Comparison Encyclopedia
How comparisons are made
Every comparison starts from Micah Blumberg’s dated record and tests a later work against it, idea by idea.
Ideas, not authors
Each theory is broken into atoms: single operations, mechanisms or claims. Each atom in a later work is compared with every dated stage of Micah Blumberg’s work, from the 2010–2012 posts and the 2017 recordings to the 2022 notes, the 2024 book and the 2025–2026 papers. A paper can share some atoms and not others, and each shared atom is recorded on its own.
Four lenses
A later atom matches when any one of three lenses finds the same idea:
- Equivalence. The same operation, mechanism or mathematics, tested after both are translated into plain operations, with category-theory and process-calculus mappings where they help.
- Narrative. The same cluster of signature concepts in the same order of moves, even when the components or equations differ.
- Detective. Working backwards from a shared conclusion, to see whether a different-looking route arrives at the same place.
A fourth lens looks across time. The Secret Follower lens lays an author’s successive papers beside Micah Blumberg’s successive dates and asks whether the later work moved toward ideas he had already published.
Two dates
Micah Blumberg’s side of a comparison shows up to two dates: the date in the source itself, and the date an independent public record confirms, such as a Git commit, a platform’s publication date, a Zenodo record or an archive capture. The earliest recovered version and the clearest version before the later work are both kept. The dated record lists every such statement with its dates.
Earlier work by others
When another author published part of an idea first, the comparison shows that work exactly and names what SAN adds that it lacks.
Every finding is kept
A finding, once recorded, is never deleted. Later review can strengthen, qualify or rank it, but cannot erase it. Questions not yet reviewed stay visible as open, never as absence.
Plagiarism-equivalence
Where two works say the same thing in different notation, the Encyclopedia may call them plagiarism-equivalent: a short translation exists between them and their key invariants coincide. The term describes content and dates only. It is not an accusation, and it says nothing about access or intent.
Why this Encyclopedia exists → · Same mechanism, different metaphor → · Back to the Comparison Encyclopedia