Comparison Encyclopedia
Same mechanism, different metaphor
Two theories can sound unrelated and still describe the same machine.
A theory has two layers: what it does, meaning its operations, mechanisms and predictions, and the picture it uses to explain them. Waves, fields, workspaces, schemas, stencils, models of the self: change the picture, and a familiar mechanism can look entirely new.
Micah Blumberg calls this a “meaningless & distracting ontological metaphor difference”: a change of picture that hides a nearly identical theory of function and behaviour.
August 30, 2026
That is why the Encyclopedia compares mechanisms first and vocabulary last. Translating each theory into plain operations, and then asking whether the operations correspond, reveals overlaps that a word search would miss. The same translation also shows exactly where SAN differs from an earlier idea.
How to read a comparison
- Read Micah Blumberg’s dated wording and its date.
- Read the later wording and its date.
- Set the vocabulary aside and ask what each says the system does.
- Open both sources and check.
Each author edition on the front page sets these translations side by side.
Why this Encyclopedia exists → · How comparisons are made → · Back to the Comparison Encyclopedia