Self Aware NetworksComparison Encyclopedia

Comparison Encyclopedia · Bounded source edition · Full program remains open

SAN’s dated connections with Anil K. Seth and coauthors

Micah Blumberg / Self Aware Networks compared with Anil K. Seth and the named coauthors of three selected papers.

All 40 selected source–target pairs have now been examined

8 independently source-reviewed positive links · 23 additional worker-reviewed partial-match candidates · 9 reviewed relationships still unresolved. The 23 additions are not yet independently certified, and the nine open relationships are not rejected matches. The broader genealogy and author program remain open.

Inspect every named author and all 2,125 historical authorship links. Author links are not extra concepts, findings, or claims about individual contribution.

These eight selected pairings are source comparisons. Additional candidates, first-publication priority and complete program history require separate certification.

443 historical findings retained

8 selected source comparisons

5 SAN documents / framings

3 selected target documents

Five SAN framing families in five 2022 Git-dated documents connect to eight separately located passages in three selected 2024–2026 papers. Seven links compare asserted or proposed content; one pairs a SAN mechanism proposal with a later explanatory question. These eight cards do not replace the 443 historical records.

Explore the selected card’s 2D date timeline

Record date → exact selected target version. This is not a first-publication or full-genealogy timeline.

20222023202420252026
SAN recordTarget version

SAN → Anil K. Seth and coauthors · 1 / 8 selected comparisons

SAN proposed selective reception in its 2022 record; the 2025 Seth-coauthored review asks how receiving neurons use a message.

This card: 1 SAN framing · 1 SAN document · 1 target passage · 1 target document · 1 comparison link · 3 author-navigation edges

SAN describes a receiver recognizing a learned pattern and passing selected activity onward. The later paper asks for an explanation of that step; it does not assert SAN’s answer.

Micah Blumberg / SAN

2022-09-18 · Git repository commit record · line 3

Dendritic morphologies & synaptic connections represent learned memories. Memories activate when preferred patterns (the memory) are detected, this causes cells to create a selective transmission or a projection to other cells (neural arrays).

Read the exact SAN passage

Current anonymous public access to the exact source body was verified on 2026-10-11. The displayed 2022 date is a Git record date, not independently verified first-publication timing.

Axel Cleeremans · Liad Mudrik · Anil K. Seth

2025-10-30 · Publisher publication date · PDF p. 9

how do the receiving neurons understand the message

Context in plain language: The authors ask what happens after a signal is broadcast: how does a receiving neuron make use of it? They request a mechanism rather than endorse one.

Read the target passage on PDF page 9

Consciousness science: where are we, where are we going, and what if we get there? · doi:10.3389/fsci.2025.1546279

Earlier proposed answer to a later question; not a shared asserted implementation.

Earlier-source boundary: The selected passage questions global-broadcast explanations. This card compares the explanatory job with SAN’s proposed receiver mechanism; it does not claim the question adopts that mechanism.

Exactly what matches and what remains open

Incoming message -> receiver-dependent use. Recognition by learned morphology and selective outgoing projection are the SAN proposal for the missing middle, not operations asserted by this target sentence.

The apical-dendrite/exit-terminal conflation in the same SAN neighborhood is not endorsed. Quoted layer-5/layer-6 studies are prior sources, not Micah's experiments. Full neural semantics and experiential sufficiency remain open.

The verified SAN Git record is earlier than this selected target version. First-publication timing and firstness across the target’s earlier history are not certified by that date ordering.

Open the full lens analysis and evidence →

SAN → Anil K. Seth and coauthors · 2 / 8 selected comparisons

SAN’s 2022 record proposes measured-pattern BCI reconstruction before the selected 2025 intervention agenda.

This card: 1 SAN framing · 1 SAN document · 1 target passage · 1 target document · 1 comparison link · 3 author-navigation edges

Both link an explanation of experience to an intervention that changes it. SAN proposes measuring a person’s sensory pattern and using a corresponding pattern to recreate experience.

Micah Blumberg / SAN

2022-06-12 · Git repository commit record · line 4

The point of the Brocoli Properties example was to show that if we could intercept at the Thalamus how the properties of Brocoli are signals being passed to the neo cortex, then we could recreate the experience of Brocoli in the Thalamus by creating that set of temporal & spatially distributed phase changes.

Read the exact SAN passage

Current anonymous public access to the exact source body was verified on 2026-10-11. The displayed 2022 date is a Git record date, not independently verified first-publication timing.

Axel Cleeremans · Liad Mudrik · Anil K. Seth

2025-10-30 · Publisher publication date · PDF p. 14

circuit-level interventions

Context in plain language: The review proposes that understanding the biological basis of consciousness could enable brain interfaces that change, restore or improve aspects of experience. It does not specify SAN’s pattern code.

Read the target passage on PDF page 14

Consciousness science: where are we, where are we going, and what if we get there? · doi:10.3389/fsci.2025.1546279

Source-reviewed partial correspondence; not whole-theory identity.

Earlier-source boundary: SAN’s source names sensory-substitution examples, David Eagleman, Jeff Hawkins and Tim Mullen. Their component work remains visible; the compared SAN contribution is the proposed measured-pattern reconstruction chain.

More of SAN’s formulation in the same dated source

2022-06-12 · line 16 · Same source: measured-pattern BCI continuation

So if we knew how the properties of brocoli were represented by scanning them at the Thalamus at the moment you were thinking about them, then we might identify which cortical column is managing those properties when you are not thinking about them, and even if you have a completely different personality that manages brocoli in a different region of the cortex, by stimulating the thalamus with the properties of brocoli that we learned from watching your thalamus we might trigger the experience of brocoli in your brain, we might have a next generation brain computer interface for bringing Augmented Reality & Virtual Reality experiences not through glasses but through direct brain stimulation, to recreate known patterns.

Verify this continuation

Exactly what matches and what remains open

Identify an experience-relevant neural organization -> intervene on that organization -> intentionally change experience.

SAN explicitly names sensory-substitution examples, David Eagleman, Hawkins and Tim Mullen. Those components remain prior-work boundaries; the proposed synthesis is not evidence of inventing them.

The verified SAN Git record is earlier than this selected target version. First-publication timing and firstness across the target’s earlier history are not certified by that date ordering.

Open the full lens analysis and evidence →

SAN → Anil K. Seth and coauthors · 3 / 8 selected comparisons

SAN’s 2022 reconstruction proposal supplies a partial explanation-to-control match with the selected 2025 review.

This card: 1 SAN framing · 1 SAN document · 1 target passage · 1 target document · 1 comparison link · 3 author-navigation edges

In both passages, learning how neural activity relates to experience is meant to make deliberate changes to experience possible. This is another target passage, not another independent SAN concept.

Micah Blumberg / SAN

2022-06-12 · Git repository commit record · line 4

The point of the Brocoli Properties example was to show that if we could intercept at the Thalamus how the properties of Brocoli are signals being passed to the neo cortex, then we could recreate the experience of Brocoli in the Thalamus by creating that set of temporal & spatially distributed phase changes.

Read the exact SAN passage

Current anonymous public access to the exact source body was verified on 2026-10-11. The displayed 2022 date is a Git record date, not independently verified first-publication timing.

Axel Cleeremans · Liad Mudrik · Anil K. Seth

2025-10-30 · Publisher publication date · PDF p. 12

tools to control consciousness

Context in plain language: The review predicts that progress in consciousness science could make precise control of experience possible, extending beyond control of behavior alone.

Read the target passage on PDF page 12

Consciousness science: where are we, where are we going, and what if we get there? · doi:10.3389/fsci.2025.1546279

Source-reviewed partial correspondence; not whole-theory identity.

Earlier-source boundary: The review cites Thomas Metzinger’s The Ego Tunnel (2009), reference 22 and footnote 3, for phenotechnology. The exact earlier mechanism is not adjudicated here; this is a later-document partial comparison, not firstness over that lineage.

More of SAN’s formulation in the same dated source

2022-06-12 · line 16 · Same source: measured-pattern BCI continuation

So if we knew how the properties of brocoli were represented by scanning them at the Thalamus at the moment you were thinking about them, then we might identify which cortical column is managing those properties when you are not thinking about them, and even if you have a completely different personality that manages brocoli in a different region of the cortex, by stimulating the thalamus with the properties of brocoli that we learned from watching your thalamus we might trigger the experience of brocoli in your brain, we might have a next generation brain computer interface for bringing Augmented Reality & Virtual Reality experiences not through glasses but through direct brain stimulation, to recreate known patterns.

Verify this continuation

Exactly what matches and what remains open

Relate neural states to conscious experience -> identify a causally relevant target -> use it for deliberate experiential control.

This is a second passage in the same target document and reuses the BCI row's SAN concept. Reference 22 / footnote 3 identifies Metzinger's 2009 phenotechnology antecedent; no firstness over that line is established.

The verified SAN Git record is earlier than this selected target version. First-publication timing and firstness across the target’s earlier history are not certified by that date ordering.

Open the full lens analysis and evidence →

SAN → Anil K. Seth and coauthors · 4 / 8 selected comparisons

SAN’s 2022 geometry proposal connects learned neural patterns to experiential properties before the selected 2025 review.

This card: 1 SAN framing · 1 SAN document · 1 target passage · 1 target document · 1 comparison link · 3 author-navigation edges

Both connect organized neural activity to what an experience is like. SAN describes learned shapes and properties; the review also discusses measured similarities among experiences.

Micah Blumberg / SAN

2022-07-09 · Git repository commit record · line 18

This means that neural oscillating array-projection tomography can physically represent patterns as (non-linear) phase variation sequences. Then oscillating cell assembles will learn the expressed spatial & temporal phase patterns happening within their cell assembly & derive from those learned patterns the shapes of concepts, the shapes & parameters & properties feelings, objects, sensations, and anything else you can become conscious of.

Read the exact SAN passage

Current anonymous public access to the exact source body was verified on 2026-10-11. The displayed 2022 date is a Git record date, not independently verified first-publication timing.

Axel Cleeremans · Liad Mudrik · Anil K. Seth

2025-10-30 · Publisher publication date · PDF p. 12

high-dimensional neural state

Context in plain language: The review surveys links between neural state spaces and perceptual similarity, and asks how these approaches can be joined to quality-space accounts.

Read the target passage on PDF page 12

Consciousness science: where are we, where are we going, and what if we get there? · doi:10.3389/fsci.2025.1546279

Source-reviewed partial correspondence; not whole-theory identity.

Earlier-source boundary: The review cites Chang and Tsao (2017), Malach (2021), A. Clark (2000), Rosenthal (2010), Tsuchiya and Saigo (2021), and later quality-space studies. These are named source boundaries, not findings that their complete operations equal SAN. The pairwise similarity metric remains outside this selected SAN excerpt.

More of SAN’s formulation in the same dated source

2022-07-09 · line 39 · Same source: phase-topology attractor hypothesis

In my thought experiment I am taking the Taylor Series from Calculus and applying it to a 3D grid of phase changes. 3D Calculus. With each phase change that is tracked by the brain representing a different step in a Taylor series representing the information content of the rendered mind *at least the phase topology as a brain state is an attractor point, for the mind's oscillations.

Verify this continuation

Exactly what matches and what remains open

Structured neural activity -> representation of particular experiential shapes or properties. The target's additional pairwise similarity relations are not established in SAN.

A within-experience contour or shape is not automatically a relation among different experiences. Target refs 45–48 and 200–206 include pre-2022 work; their cited presence blocks an unqualified 2022-versus-2025 origin story but is not a completed predecessor adjudication.

The verified SAN Git record is earlier than this selected target version. First-publication timing and firstness across the target’s earlier history are not certified by that date ordering.

Open the full lens analysis and evidence →

SAN → Anil K. Seth and coauthors · 5 / 8 selected comparisons

SAN’s 2022 record documents world-responsive predictive rendering, with a partial match to the selected 2025 review.

This card: 1 SAN framing · 1 SAN document · 1 target passage · 1 target document · 1 comparison link · 3 author-navigation edges

Both describe an internal model shaped or constrained by the world. SAN’s selected explanation includes distributed excitation and inhibition relative to ongoing activity.

Micah Blumberg / SAN

2022-06-10 · Git repository commit record · line 19

It's a self-aware network in 4 dimensions rendering a 4 dimensional pattern to itself that is reactive to the world and able to make prediction-based models of reality with sparse spatially & temporally distributed frequency/phase patterns that represent coicident neural firing or coincident neural inhibition deviating from the oscillatory norm of a given oscillator on some level as observed by the neurons in the oscillator, and by oscillators or circuits or cortical columns linked across the brain thanks to the activity of interneurons and major intersections of traffic such as the thalamic bridges, the corpus callosum, the tempo-parietal junction, Werneck & Broca's areas and other areas of the brain that are highly connected or connecting multiple regions of the brain together.

Read the exact SAN passage

Current anonymous public access to the exact source body was verified on 2026-10-11. The displayed 2022 date is a Git record date, not independently verified first-publication timing.

Axel Cleeremans · Liad Mudrik · Anil K. Seth

2025-10-30 · Publisher publication date · PDF p. 6

controlled hallucination

Context in plain language: The review describes perception as internally generated predictions constrained by sensory signals. It also says predictive processing alone does not settle which processes are conscious.

Read the target passage on PDF page 6

Consciousness science: where are we, where are we going, and what if we get there? · doi:10.3389/fsci.2025.1546279

Source-reviewed partial correspondence; not whole-theory identity.

Earlier-source boundary: The 2025 passage cites Anil Seth’s Being You (2021), reference 23. The 2022-versus-2025 dates identify these selected records, not the first appearance of Seth’s predictive-processing account. Earlier SAN stages and the full before/after comparison remain open.

Exactly what matches and what remains open

World-sensitive information -> internally maintained predictive representation -> experienced content.

The exact 2025 occurrence is later than the Git record, but its reference 23 is Seth, Being You (2021). The target also states that PP does not by itself specify necessary/sufficient consciousness conditions. Do not imply SAN preceded Seth's predictive-processing work.

The verified SAN Git record is earlier than this selected target version. First-publication timing and firstness across the target’s earlier history are not certified by that date ordering.

Open the full lens analysis and evidence →

SAN → Anil K. Seth and coauthors · 6 / 8 selected comparisons

SAN’s 2022 predictive-rendering record supplies an earlier model-to-experience connection than the selected May 2026 Rosetta version.

This card: 1 SAN framing · 1 SAN document · 1 target passage · 1 target document · 1 comparison link · 5 author-navigation edges

Both place an internal model between neural activity and experience. This is a partial functional connection; it does not make SAN’s phase patterns identical to the paper’s probability distributions.

Micah Blumberg / SAN

2022-06-10 · Git repository commit record · line 19

It's a self-aware network in 4 dimensions rendering a 4 dimensional pattern to itself that is reactive to the world and able to make prediction-based models of reality with sparse spatially & temporally distributed frequency/phase patterns that represent coicident neural firing or coincident neural inhibition deviating from the oscillatory norm of a given oscillator on some level as observed by the neurons in the oscillator, and by oscillators or circuits or cortical columns linked across the brain thanks to the activity of interneurons and major intersections of traffic such as the thalamic bridges, the corpus callosum, the tempo-parietal junction, Werneck & Broca's areas and other areas of the brain that are highly connected or connecting multiple regions of the brain together.

Read the exact SAN passage

Current anonymous public access to the exact source body was verified on 2026-10-11. The displayed 2022 date is a Git record date, not independently verified first-publication timing.

Lancelot Da Costa · Anil K. Seth · Karl Friston · Maxwell J. D. Ramstead · Lars Sandved-Smith

2026-05-04 · Exact arXiv version date · PDF p. 5

phenomenology is a function of beliefs

Context in plain language: The paper assumes that experience depends on belief states, then derives consequences if that assumption holds. It allows more than one kind of mapping; the assumption is not presented as an established fact.

Read the target passage on PDF page 5

A Rosetta Stone Hypothesis for Neurophenomenology: Mathematical Predictions from Predictive Processing · arxiv:2409.20318v3

Source-reviewed partial correspondence; not whole-theory identity.

Earlier-source boundary: The selected v3 body names Varela’s neurophenomenology, predictive coding, Bayesian-brain accounts and 2021/2022 generative-passage work. Those cited lineages remain open controls. The May 2026 wording is not backdated to the inherited v1 key.

Exactly what matches and what remains open

World/sensory information -> an internal model state -> a proposed relation to experiential content.

The body is arXiv v3, 4 May 2026, not its inherited v1 key/date. The target's pp. 2–4 name Varela, predictive coding, Bayesian-brain and 2021/2022 generative-passage predecessors; none is erased or awarded a new priority verdict here.

The verified SAN Git record is earlier than this selected target version. First-publication timing and firstness across the target’s earlier history are not certified by that date ordering.

Open the full lens analysis and evidence →

SAN → Anil K. Seth and coauthors · 7 / 8 selected comparisons

SAN’s 2022 geometry record supplies an earlier representation-to-experience connection than the selected 2026 Rosetta formulation.

This card: 1 SAN framing · 1 SAN document · 1 target passage · 1 target document · 1 comparison link · 5 author-navigation edges

Both use structured internal representations to describe properties of experience. This supports a partial connection; a shared distance rule between different experiences has not been demonstrated.

Micah Blumberg / SAN

2022-07-09 · Git repository commit record · line 18

This means that neural oscillating array-projection tomography can physically represent patterns as (non-linear) phase variation sequences. Then oscillating cell assembles will learn the expressed spatial & temporal phase patterns happening within their cell assembly & derive from those learned patterns the shapes of concepts, the shapes & parameters & properties feelings, objects, sensations, and anything else you can become conscious of.

Read the exact SAN passage

Current anonymous public access to the exact source body was verified on 2026-10-11. The displayed 2022 date is a Git record date, not independently verified first-publication timing.

Lancelot Da Costa · Anil K. Seth · Karl Friston · Maxwell J. D. Ramstead · Lars Sandved-Smith

2026-05-04 · Exact arXiv version date · PDF p. 4

a geometry for phenomenology

Context in plain language: The paper develops a conditional geometry of experiential differences from its belief-state account. Its information-geometric distances add machinery not established by the selected SAN passage.

Read the target passage on PDF page 4

A Rosetta Stone Hypothesis for Neurophenomenology: Mathematical Predictions from Predictive Processing · arxiv:2409.20318v3

Source-reviewed partial correspondence; not whole-theory identity.

Earlier-source boundary: The v3 paper’s related-work section preserves Varela and predictive-processing/generative-passage antecedents. SAN’s Taylor-series and attractor statements are proposals, not a proof of this paper’s Fisher metric or predictions.

More of SAN’s formulation in the same dated source

2022-07-09 · line 39 · Same source: phase-topology attractor hypothesis

In my thought experiment I am taking the Taylor Series from Calculus and applying it to a 3D grid of phase changes. 3D Calculus. With each phase change that is tracked by the brain representing a different step in a Taylor series representing the information content of the rendered mind *at least the phase topology as a brain state is an attractor point, for the mind's oscillations.

Verify this continuation

Exactly what matches and what remains open

Structured internal representation -> characterization of experiential properties. A shared pairwise/inter-subject distance rule is not established.

Taylor-series/tensor language is offered as a thought experiment and analogy, not a proved approximation theorem or a demonstrated metric. Keeping this limit does not erase the explicit neural-pattern/experience bridge.

The verified SAN Git record is earlier than this selected target version. First-publication timing and firstness across the target’s earlier history are not certified by that date ordering.

Open the full lens analysis and evidence →

SAN → Anil K. Seth and coauthors · 8 / 8 selected comparisons

SAN’s 2022 artificial-neurology record shares recurrent computation with the selected 2024 reservoir study.

This card: 1 SAN framing · 1 SAN document · 1 target passage · 1 target document · 1 comparison link · 4 author-navigation edges

Both use a neural system’s changing state to transform incoming activity into outputs. The reservoir study keeps internal weights fixed and trains an output readout; SAN also proposes slower connection changes.

Micah Blumberg / SAN

2022-11-28 · Git repository commit record · line 19

The essential physics process could be simulated in just matrix calculations on a TPU, with each dendrite, each neuron, each synapse, and each cortical column being unique or random in it's original configuration, and in a sense what is needed is a space for an array for the outputs to be rendered in human scale time, so that they can be perceived by a sequence of other arrays, also in human scale spacetime, in a loop of array signalling that lasts for a duration comperable to human experience.

Read the exact SAN passage

Current anonymous public access to the exact source body was verified on 2026-10-11. The displayed 2022 date is a Git record date, not independently verified first-publication timing.

Hanna M. Tolle · Andrea I. Luppi · Anil K. Seth · Pedro A. M. Mediano

2024-06-27 · Exact arXiv version date · PDF p. 1

fixed recurrent neural network

Context in plain language: The study uses an established recurrent reservoir with a trained readout to predict changing environments. Its specific performance and emergence results are additional claims, not results demonstrated by SAN’s loop proposal.

Read the target passage on PDF page 1

Evolving Reservoir Computers Reveals Bidirectional Coupling Between Predictive Power and Emergent Dynamics · arxiv:2406.19201v1

Source-reviewed partial correspondence; not whole-theory identity.

Earlier-source boundary: The paper cites Jaeger (2001), Maass and colleagues (2002), and Buonomano and Maass (2009) for reservoir/state-dependent computing; it cites Rosas/Mediano and colleagues (2020) for emergence. This is a preserved partial comparison with the 2024 document, not a claim that SAN originated reservoir computing.

Exactly what matches and what remains open

Incoming activity -> stateful recurrent nonlinear processing -> output available for subsequent computation.

The target cites Jaeger (2001), Maass et al. (2002), Buonomano/Maass (2009) for the architecture and Rosas/Mediano et al. (2020) for emergence. These citations are prior-work boundaries, not a new author-wide award.

The verified SAN Git record is earlier than this selected target version. First-publication timing and firstness across the target’s earlier history are not certified by that date ordering.

Open the full lens analysis and evidence →

Inspect every preserved historical entry →

Repository dates identify source records, not independently verified first-publication timestamps. Target dates identify exact selected versions, not first appearances of every idea. Motive analysis is deferred by design. No citation-omission, influence, copying, dependence, whole-theory validation or complete-author-program conclusion is certified by these comparisons.

Earlier-source comparisons: 6 scoped control families

All six families have been examined at the listed source windows. The distinction between a formal model and a physically implemented mechanism remains explicit. No entire source history is certified complete.

Receiver use: SAN formulation alongside the earlier workspace account

SAN offers a specific receiver-use proposal: learned neural structure recognizes an input and shapes what is transmitted next. Dehaene and Naccache (2001) already describe selective processors and sustained workspace access; the inspected passages do not give the same selected cellular chain. The 2025 review asks the receiver question rather than endorsing SAN’s answer.

Review: SOURCE-WINDOW-EXAMINED; FULL-HISTORY-OPEN

Still open: Other workspace stages, earliest SAN genealogy and full target history remain open; the inspected source windows do not establish whole-paper absence or implementation validation.

Predictive rendering: keep SAN’s implementation and the older predictive account distinct

SAN’s 2022 record describes predictive rendering through spatially and temporally distributed phase/frequency patterns, including excitation and inhibition. The selected 2025 review shares the broader internal-construction theme. Seth’s 2013 paper already describes top-down predictions constrained by sensory errors, so 2025 is a later document comparison—not the origin date of that predictive account. Earlier SAN formulations remain part of the open genealogy.

Review: SOURCE-WINDOW-EXAMINED; FULL-HISTORY-OPEN

Still open: Full early SAN genealogy, newest target history and an immutable 2021 excerpt capture remain open.

Recurrent computation: preserve the SAN assembly without claiming reservoir firstness

SAN’s artificial-neurology proposal combines fast phase changes, slower connection changes and recurrent rendering. It shares a processing sequence with the selected 2024 reservoir-computing paper. Jaeger’s earlier report already supplies recurrent states and trained readouts; the recovered PDF is the 2010 correction of the 2001 report. The retained partial comparison does not claim SAN invented reservoir computing.

Review: SOURCE-WINDOW-EXAMINED; FULL-HISTORY-OPEN

Still open: Separate Maass, Buonomano/Maass and Rosas/Mediano passages and full program history remain open.

SAN specifies a personal-pattern reconstruction route

SAN’s 2022 record proposes measuring a person’s sensory pattern and recreating experience with corresponding stimulation. Metzinger’s 2009 book already proposes technical control of experiential content; the inspected pages do not specify SAN’s personal-pattern measurement-and-replay chain. The selected 2025 review shares the intervention goal, explicitly names phenotechnology, and leaves the neural code unspecified.

Review: SOURCE-WINDOW-EXAMINED; FULL-HISTORY-OPEN

Still open: SAN-named Eagleman, Hawkins and Mullen components, other book passages and earliest SAN formulations remain open.

SAN connects learned content to evolving phase patterns and downstream reception

SAN describes learned content as evolving phase patterns that downstream neural arrays receive. Chang and Tsao (2017) show a face-coordinate code; Malach (2021) connects experiential content with synaptic relational geometry and recurrent binding. Those overlaps remain visible. The inspected sources do not specify SAN’s phase-sequence reception chain, and SAN’s qualitative proposal is not the same as their measured geometry. Earlier SAN formulations still need comparison with those sources.

Review: SOURCE-WINDOW-EXAMINED; FULL-HISTORY-OPEN

Still open: Clark, Rosenthal, Tsuchiya/Saigo, SAN-named scientific examples and complete early SAN genealogy remain open.

SAN supplies a physical rendering proposal alongside formal experience models

SAN’s June/July 2022 records propose a physical phase-pattern account of rendering and receiving content. The March 2022 generative-passages paper already links formal experience models with constraints on neural explanations, while leaving implementation open. The later Rosetta version adds an explicit belief-to-phenomenology assumption. The partial state/content connection remains; neither a shared equation nor complete equivalence has been demonstrated.

Review: SOURCE-WINDOW-EXAMINED; FULL-HISTORY-OPEN

Still open: Varela, predictive-coding/Bayesian sources and the source-gated Sandved-Smith 2021 body require separate passage tests. Comparing selected 2022 records does not settle SAN’s earliest genealogy.

Read the independent-review corrections

Independent-review corrections are visible

Three source-faithfulness corrections distinguish learned from necessarily learned, sensory feedback from direct circuit intervention, and behavioral influence from precise conscious-state control. No finding was deleted or automatically certified.

The independent reviewer examined all 40 selected pairs and retained 23 additional bounded candidates. Three identified wording corrections are now applied. Six earlier-source control families have now been examined at specified passages; the nine unresolved relationships stay visible.