Self Aware NetworksComparison Encyclopedia

Self Aware Networks · Comparison Encyclopedia · Selected source edition

Micah Blumberg · Self Aware Networks (SAN)

MICAH / SAN earlier -> Earl K. Miller and coauthors later: four partial mappings to the 2022–2023 documents.

Two documented SAN formulations are compared with two later papers, through four graded partial mappings. Open each card’s evidence record to see the exact scope and differences.

Earlier than the selected 2022–2023 documents does not mean earlier than every version of the target theory. Its January 2021 preprint is included in the chronology below.

4 target-formulation occurrences2 SAN framings1 archived SAN document2 later target documents4 partial mappings18 coauthor links

SAN compared with Earl K. Miller and coauthors · 1 / 4

Thoughts have a pattern of activity and inhibition

SAN’s recorded thought-pattern account precedes this 2022 document.

Micah Blumberg / SAN

Exact wording preserved by 19 September 2021

So that the shape of our thoughts, in tempo-spatial patterns is represented not only by what is excited in our brains but also by what is inhibited in our brains.

Read the archived article · paragraph d2a1

Buschman & Miller

1 December 2022 — Crossref publication record

Control comes from where in network space a stimulus representation is currently expressed.

Working Memory Is Complex and Dynamic, Like Your Thoughts

Read the target source · PDF page 5 (printed page 21), Top–Down Control by Spatial Computing

Partial operational match: SAN describes thought patterns using both active and inhibited regions. The later documents describe a changing spatial pattern that permits some memory-related activity and suppresses other activity.

What differs: SAN's passage concerns the proposed spatial shape of thoughts. The target describes working-memory control with specified frequency bands and separates coarse control from fine-grained item coding. Those additional claims are not contained in this SAN sentence.

Chronology boundary: the January 2021 target preprint already has the spatial-gating operation. This card establishes the direction of these two document dates, not firstness over that earlier version.

Open the full source-and-method review →

SAN compared with Earl K. Miller and coauthors · 2 / 4

Selection changes what the network can express

SAN’s recorded attention-selection account precedes this 2022 document.

Micah Blumberg / SAN

Exact wording preserved by 19 September 2021

the parts of you that are paying attention to something you are looking at become excited and that means they exhibit more activity […] The inhibited parts of the brain should feature the unconscious material.

Read the archived article · paragraph f236

Buschman & Miller

1 December 2022 — Crossref publication record

Alpha/beta inhibits gamma wherever they “collide” in cortex.

Working Memory Is Complex and Dynamic, Like Your Thoughts

Read the target source · PDF page 4 (printed page 20), control by oscillatory dynamics

Partial operational match: SAN links attention to increased activity in selected regions and suppression elsewhere. The later accounts use inhibitory rhythms to regulate access to memory content.

What differs: The shared operation is selective expression through excitation and inhibition. SAN's speculation about whole-brain electrical equilibrium and conscious/unconscious content is not established by the target experiments, and is not the target's stated explanation.

Chronology boundary: the January 2021 target preprint already has the spatial-gating operation. This card establishes the direction of these two document dates, not firstness over that earlier version.

Open the full source-and-method review →

SAN compared with Earl K. Miller and coauthors · 3 / 4

Thoughts have a pattern of activity and inhibition

SAN’s recorded thought-pattern account precedes this 2023 document.

Micah Blumberg / SAN

Exact wording preserved by 19 September 2021

So that the shape of our thoughts, in tempo-spatial patterns is represented not only by what is excited in our brains but also by what is inhibited in our brains.

Read the archived article · paragraph d2a1

Lundqvist, Miller & coauthors

14 March 2023 — journal publication

The manifestation is a dynamic patchwork of beta and gamma bursts.

Working memory control dynamics follow principles of spatial computing

Read the target source · Discussion, opening paragraph; XML paragraph 33

Partial operational match: SAN describes thought patterns using both active and inhibited regions. The later documents describe a changing spatial pattern that permits some memory-related activity and suppresses other activity.

What differs: SAN's passage concerns the proposed spatial shape of thoughts. The target describes working-memory control with specified frequency bands and separates coarse control from fine-grained item coding. Those additional claims are not contained in this SAN sentence.

Chronology boundary: the January 2021 target preprint already has the spatial-gating operation. This card establishes the direction of these two document dates, not firstness over that earlier version.

Open the full source-and-method review →

SAN compared with Earl K. Miller and coauthors · 4 / 4

Selection changes what the network can express

SAN’s recorded attention-selection account precedes this 2023 document.

Micah Blumberg / SAN

Exact wording preserved by 19 September 2021

the parts of you that are paying attention to something you are looking at become excited and that means they exhibit more activity […] The inhibited parts of the brain should feature the unconscious material.

Read the archived article · paragraph f236

Lundqvist, Miller & coauthors

14 March 2023 — journal publication

Beta bursts act as the control signal.

Working memory control dynamics follow principles of spatial computing

Read the target source · Introduction, second paragraph; XML paragraph 6

Partial operational match: SAN links attention to increased activity in selected regions and suppression elsewhere. The later accounts use inhibitory rhythms to regulate access to memory content.

What differs: The shared operation is selective expression through excitation and inhibition. SAN's speculation about whole-brain electrical equilibrium and conscious/unconscious content is not established by the target experiments, and is not the target's stated explanation.

Chronology boundary: the January 2021 target preprint already has the spatial-gating operation. This card establishes the direction of these two document dates, not firstness over that earlier version.

Open the full source-and-method review →

Earlier anchors and later, more mature formulations

Dates describe different kinds of evidence. Repository dates are not silently treated as historical public availability.

  1. 2017-06-30 · Article publication metadata

    Earliest article-level anchor; not independently verified sentence-level wording at that date.

  2. 2018-08-14 · Article modification metadata

    The archive reports a modification; exact differences from the 2017 version remain open.

  3. 2021-01-01 · Target-family preprint

    Hot-Coal already describes beta-gated spatial activation maps; must remain visible when reading the later comparisons.

    Open source
  4. 2021-09-19 · Public SAN wording capture

    Independent archive preserves both quoted Mind Code formulations.

  5. 2022-06-11 · Later SAN repository formulation

    Neural Array-Projection Tomography develops learned phase receptivity, excitation/inhibition and representation across locations. Commit date is not independently verified historical public availability.

    Open source
  6. 2022-11-28 · Later SAN repository formulation

    NAPOT revision 5 explicitly includes excitatory and inhibitory phase-wave differentials and altered neural routes. No backdating of this mature wording into the earlier article.

    Open source