Self Aware NetworksComparison Encyclopedia

SAN’s earlier self-modelling formulations

In 2022, Blumberg explicitly described a neural cell learning and predicting its own responses. The 2024 preprint and 2026 published version by Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors implement prediction of internal network activity. These cards show the shared roles, the dated wording, and the limits of each partial comparison.

32 comparison links ·4 SAN source versions ·3 source notes ·2 target versions. 224 author-navigation edges, not additional findings. Download the exact selected records.

Source-review edition: These qualified partial comparisons were checked through an independent AI-assisted source review. They do not establish whole-theory equivalence, first-publication priority or influence.

Card 1 of 32

SAN proposes learning and predicting the cell’s own responses

Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-09-18) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2024-07-14). The shared role is learning a model of the neural system’s own activity, stated explicitly in the 2022 source before the 2024/2026 papers.

moderate role-level partial

Micah Blumberg / SAN

2022-09-18 · historical Git wording record

My intuition is that the apical is learning its own cell's response, and through feedback loops, with itself and with other pyramidal neurons the cell is going to make predictions about its own patterns of causation, what patterns it responds & how it reacts or responds. With the Apical Dendrite perhaps symbolizing a more complex response that is connected to more complex learning. (compared to other types of neurons)

Exact source, line 51

The source says "My intuition" and describes feedback-linked cell responses. Anatomical speculation is not stripped from the source context.

Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors

2024-07-14 · arXiv v1 submission

In addition to performing a primary task, the networks were responsible for predicting the values of subsets of their own hidden activations.

The network predicts subsets of its own hidden activations.

Unexpected Benefits of Self-Modeling in Neural Systems

PDF pages 1-2; extracted lines 63-71 and 123-128

What is shared

own-neural-activity prediction role.

Where the comparison stops

A qualitative neural self-model is not the target’s numerical prediction of selected current hidden activations in one forward pass. This does not establish the complete estimator, future-state semantics or consciousness.

The source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.

Inspect the full comparison lenses, dates and source checks →

Card footprint: 1 SAN formulation · 1 target-version claim · 1 comparison link · 7 author-navigation edges.