{
  "schema": "reviewed-public-timeline-v1",
  "selection_date": "2026-11-08",
  "counts": {
    "records": 86,
    "exact_excerpt_sets": 42,
    "source_wording_stages": 15,
    "target_document_versions": 9,
    "program_labels": 4,
    "listed_author_labels": 30,
    "author_navigation_edges": 418,
    "source_release_pass_rows": 82,
    "miller_current_recheck_exception_rows": 4
  },
  "scope": "86 selected document-relative comparison links across six source editions, not a complete author, field or theory census. Exact same-excerpt grouping and shared source documents are navigation, not new equivalence verdicts between target authors.",
  "policy": "Motive analysis is deferred by product design. Lines connect reviewed comparisons; they do not assert influence, copying or whole-theory identity.",
  "date_policy": "SAN dates keep their original custody type. Git wording records are not independently dated first-publication events. An attributed recording date is not used to backdate the transcript. Target dates identify the selected publication/version, not the first appearance of every claim.",
  "release_boundary": "The86 selected records retain their six bounded source-edition scopes. The paired-passage additions preserve the original findings and limits. Source qualification, combined projection review, full-site integration and exact upload approval are separate gates. This is not whole-programme certification or proof of influence.",
  "rows": [
    {
      "id": "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUNSC-MCH-A12",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUNSC-MCH-A12",
      "edition_id": "bach-initial",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-EEF56EA73B51A254A9B8",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:93DBDD3104CD751CC72448B0C4DC44730FB54996BFD90E5BB0E1E544E55B9DAF",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
      "title": "A self arises through communicating cells",
      "conclusion": "Micah / SAN’s dated record precedes this selected later document on the mapped partial correspondence.",
      "shared": "Distributed signals -> local inter-unit communication and organization -> a represented agent able to coordinate interactions.",
      "relation": "functional/operational-subchain",
      "residual": "The June source does not state the later Genesis hypothesis that consciousness is the simplest developmental prerequisite for intelligence, or a global coherence objective. The developmental Genesis hypothesis and consciousness-as-coherence operator are additional commitments.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial-equivalent",
          "level": "functional/operational-subchain",
          "mapping": "Communicating units organize a larger system associated with self-directed behavior.",
          "source_locators": [
            2,
            5,
            19,
            23,
            25
          ],
          "target_locators": [
            18,
            19,
            21
          ],
          "mathematical_relation": "not-proved; no numerical equivalence percentage assigned"
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-shared-causal-prefix",
          "source_chain": [
            "incoming patterns",
            "cells receive, predict, emit and adapt communication paths",
            "distributed learned organization participating in the deciding self"
          ],
          "target_role": "Communicating cells are proposed to organize coherent models and agentic control.",
          "cluster_role": "self/world organization",
          "boundary": "A shared part of the narrative architecture is preserved; complete architecture identity and historical acquisition are not inferred."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "micah-earlier-on-bounded-document-relative-delta",
          "chronology": "The frozen 2022 Git-recorded SAN text precedes the specified 2026 target version.",
          "translation_test": "Compare operations after replacing neural rendering and pattern vocabulary with target representation and processing vocabulary; do not require the same nouns.",
          "falsification_attempt": "The June source does not state the later Genesis hypothesis that consciousness is the simplest developmental prerequisite for intelligence, or a global coherence objective. The developmental Genesis hypothesis and consciousness-as-coherence operator are additional commitments.",
          "alternate_routes": "Shared background in computational representation, learning, feedback and control remains a possible route. The targets explicitly reference earlier approaches. This review does not establish access, dependence or author-wide firstness.",
          "earlier_target_boundary": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-grounded partial process/functional correspondence, not a constructed functor, proven isomorphism or bisimulation.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-adjudicated-in-this-release-cohort",
      "program_history": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Self-communication and learned neural paths",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/37da575ba33f85cef4239295be161066d8d39f4c/a0090z%20ctpr.txt",
        "sha256": "93DBDD3104CD751CC72448B0C4DC44730FB54996BFD90E5BB0E1E544E55B9DAF",
        "date": "2022-06-08",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "the point is that we are establishing a self communication mechanism, they listen to each other, and to any other available incoming signals"
        ],
        "locators": [
          2,
          5,
          19,
          23,
          25
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcHypothesis.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "date": "2026-01-15",
        "date_type": "Revised January 15, 2026; document first dated September 15, 2025",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "communicating brain cells",
        "summary": "Communicating cells are proposed to organize coherent models and agentic control.",
        "locators": {
          "pages": [
            18,
            19,
            21
          ],
          "locator": "PDF physical pages 18, 19, 21"
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUNSC-MCH-A12",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/0",
      "source_file_sha256": "D8407737E600EECB00DBB960B385027EE50F7B86D7FD5BBDE9B641575FD46DC0",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUNSC-CIMC-A12",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUNSC-CIMC-A12",
      "edition_id": "bach-initial",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-EEF56EA73B51A254A9B8",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:93DBDD3104CD751CC72448B0C4DC44730FB54996BFD90E5BB0E1E544E55B9DAF",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
      "title": "A self arises through communicating cells",
      "conclusion": "Micah / SAN’s dated record precedes this selected later document on the mapped partial correspondence.",
      "shared": "Local units exchange information and update -> higher-order organization forms -> that organization is proposed to support agentic models.",
      "relation": "functional/operational-subchain",
      "residual": "The June source does not state the later Genesis hypothesis that consciousness is the simplest developmental prerequisite for intelligence, or a global coherence objective. Same-level metarepresentation and transparency are additional representational constraints.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial-equivalent",
          "level": "functional/operational-subchain",
          "mapping": "Communicating units organize a larger system associated with self-directed behavior.",
          "source_locators": [
            2,
            5,
            19,
            23,
            25
          ],
          "target_locators": [
            10,
            11,
            12,
            13,
            18,
            19
          ],
          "mathematical_relation": "not-proved; no numerical equivalence percentage assigned"
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-shared-causal-prefix",
          "source_chain": [
            "incoming patterns",
            "cells receive, predict, emit and adapt communication paths",
            "distributed learned organization participating in the deciding self"
          ],
          "target_role": "Self-organized perception is proposed to monitor and regulate coherent internal models.",
          "cluster_role": "self/world organization",
          "boundary": "A shared part of the narrative architecture is preserved; complete architecture identity and historical acquisition are not inferred."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "micah-earlier-on-bounded-document-relative-delta",
          "chronology": "The frozen 2022 Git-recorded SAN text precedes the specified 2026 target version.",
          "translation_test": "Compare operations after replacing neural rendering and pattern vocabulary with target representation and processing vocabulary; do not require the same nouns.",
          "falsification_attempt": "The June source does not state the later Genesis hypothesis that consciousness is the simplest developmental prerequisite for intelligence, or a global coherence objective. Same-level metarepresentation and transparency are additional representational constraints.",
          "alternate_routes": "Shared background in computational representation, learning, feedback and control remains a possible route. The targets explicitly reference earlier approaches. This review does not establish access, dependence or author-wide firstness.",
          "earlier_target_boundary": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-grounded partial process/functional correspondence, not a constructed functor, proven isomorphism or bisimulation.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-adjudicated-in-this-release-cohort",
      "program_history": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Self-communication and learned neural paths",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/37da575ba33f85cef4239295be161066d8d39f4c/a0090z%20ctpr.txt",
        "sha256": "93DBDD3104CD751CC72448B0C4DC44730FB54996BFD90E5BB0E1E544E55B9DAF",
        "date": "2022-06-08",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "the point is that we are establishing a self communication mechanism, they listen to each other, and to any other available incoming signals"
        ],
        "locators": [
          2,
          5,
          19,
          23,
          25
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "CIMC Research Program Whitepaper",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen",
          "Franz Hildebrandt-Harangozó",
          "Lou de Kerhuelvez",
          "Jim Rutt"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcWhitepaper.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
        "date": "2026-04-27",
        "date_type": "Version 2, April 27, 2026",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "second-order perception",
        "summary": "Self-organized perception is proposed to monitor and regulate coherent internal models.",
        "locators": {
          "pages": [
            10,
            11,
            12,
            13,
            18,
            19
          ],
          "locator": "PDF physical pages 10, 11, 12, 13, 18, 19"
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUNSC-CIMC-A12",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/1",
      "source_file_sha256": "D8407737E600EECB00DBB960B385027EE50F7B86D7FD5BBDE9B641575FD46DC0",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUNSC-MCH-A13",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUNSC-MCH-A13",
      "edition_id": "bach-initial",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-BE821138C84E5F7AE230",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:93DBDD3104CD751CC72448B0C4DC44730FB54996BFD90E5BB0E1E544E55B9DAF",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
      "title": "Prediction guides what happens next",
      "conclusion": "Micah / SAN’s dated record precedes this selected later document on the mapped partial correspondence.",
      "shared": "Received information -> internally conditioned state/response organization -> contribution to a system's choices.",
      "relation": "conceptual/process-prefix",
      "residual": "The June source gives a cellular next-response example. It does not yet spell out the later goal-and-preference definition of organism-level agency; the November source supplies the stronger action-planning bridge. This is not an experimentally demonstrated cellular action-selection algorithm.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial-equivalent",
          "level": "conceptual/process-prefix",
          "mapping": "An internal representation contributes to selection of a future response.",
          "source_locators": [
            2,
            19,
            21,
            41
          ],
          "target_locators": [
            17,
            20,
            21
          ],
          "mathematical_relation": "not-proved; no numerical equivalence percentage assigned"
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-shared-causal-prefix",
          "source_chain": [
            "signals from other cells",
            "receiver recognizes a pattern and predicts its next response",
            "next firing or waiting step in the sequence"
          ],
          "target_role": "Conscious model-building is connected to planning and control of action.",
          "cluster_role": "prediction and action",
          "boundary": "A shared part of the narrative architecture is preserved; complete architecture identity and historical acquisition are not inferred."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "micah-earlier-on-bounded-document-relative-delta",
          "chronology": "The frozen 2022 Git-recorded SAN text precedes the specified 2026 target version.",
          "translation_test": "Compare operations after replacing neural rendering and pattern vocabulary with target representation and processing vocabulary; do not require the same nouns.",
          "falsification_attempt": "The June source gives a cellular next-response example. It does not yet spell out the later goal-and-preference definition of organism-level agency; the November source supplies the stronger action-planning bridge. This is not an experimentally demonstrated cellular action-selection algorithm.",
          "alternate_routes": "Shared background in computational representation, learning, feedback and control remains a possible route. The targets explicitly reference earlier approaches. This review does not establish access, dependence or author-wide firstness.",
          "earlier_target_boundary": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-grounded partial process/functional correspondence, not a constructed functor, proven isomorphism or bisimulation.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-adjudicated-in-this-release-cohort",
      "program_history": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Self-communication and learned neural paths",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/37da575ba33f85cef4239295be161066d8d39f4c/a0090z%20ctpr.txt",
        "sha256": "93DBDD3104CD751CC72448B0C4DC44730FB54996BFD90E5BB0E1E544E55B9DAF",
        "date": "2022-06-08",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "Dendrites have to recognize this hertz in order for another part of the sequence to know what it means, and another part of the sequence to predict what comes next."
        ],
        "locators": [
          2,
          19,
          21,
          41
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcHypothesis.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "date": "2026-01-15",
        "date_type": "Revised January 15, 2026; document first dated September 15, 2025",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "planning",
        "summary": "Conscious model-building is connected to planning and control of action.",
        "locators": {
          "pages": [
            17,
            20,
            21
          ],
          "locator": "PDF physical pages 17, 20, 21"
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUNSC-MCH-A13",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/2",
      "source_file_sha256": "D8407737E600EECB00DBB960B385027EE50F7B86D7FD5BBDE9B641575FD46DC0",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUNSC-CIMC-A13",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUNSC-CIMC-A13",
      "edition_id": "bach-initial",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-BE821138C84E5F7AE230",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:93DBDD3104CD751CC72448B0C4DC44730FB54996BFD90E5BB0E1E544E55B9DAF",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
      "title": "Prediction guides what happens next",
      "conclusion": "Micah / SAN’s dated record precedes this selected later document on the mapped partial correspondence.",
      "shared": "Available internal information -> selection among possible subsequent responses -> influence on a future state.",
      "relation": "conceptual/process-prefix",
      "residual": "The June source gives a cellular next-response example. It does not yet spell out the later goal-and-preference definition of organism-level agency; the November source supplies the stronger action-planning bridge. Agency and consciousness are explicitly distinguished, so this match concerns an adjacent functional component.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial-equivalent",
          "level": "conceptual/process-prefix",
          "mapping": "An internal representation contributes to selection of a future response.",
          "source_locators": [
            2,
            19,
            21,
            41
          ],
          "target_locators": [
            12
          ],
          "mathematical_relation": "not-proved; no numerical equivalence percentage assigned"
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-shared-causal-prefix",
          "source_chain": [
            "signals from other cells",
            "receiver recognizes a pattern and predicts its next response",
            "next firing or waiting step in the sequence"
          ],
          "target_role": "Agency selects actions using internal goals and representations.",
          "cluster_role": "prediction and action",
          "boundary": "A shared part of the narrative architecture is preserved; complete architecture identity and historical acquisition are not inferred."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "micah-earlier-on-bounded-document-relative-delta",
          "chronology": "The frozen 2022 Git-recorded SAN text precedes the specified 2026 target version.",
          "translation_test": "Compare operations after replacing neural rendering and pattern vocabulary with target representation and processing vocabulary; do not require the same nouns.",
          "falsification_attempt": "The June source gives a cellular next-response example. It does not yet spell out the later goal-and-preference definition of organism-level agency; the November source supplies the stronger action-planning bridge. Agency and consciousness are explicitly distinguished, so this match concerns an adjacent functional component.",
          "alternate_routes": "Shared background in computational representation, learning, feedback and control remains a possible route. The targets explicitly reference earlier approaches. This review does not establish access, dependence or author-wide firstness.",
          "earlier_target_boundary": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-grounded partial process/functional correspondence, not a constructed functor, proven isomorphism or bisimulation.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-adjudicated-in-this-release-cohort",
      "program_history": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Self-communication and learned neural paths",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/37da575ba33f85cef4239295be161066d8d39f4c/a0090z%20ctpr.txt",
        "sha256": "93DBDD3104CD751CC72448B0C4DC44730FB54996BFD90E5BB0E1E544E55B9DAF",
        "date": "2022-06-08",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "Dendrites have to recognize this hertz in order for another part of the sequence to know what it means, and another part of the sequence to predict what comes next."
        ],
        "locators": [
          2,
          19,
          21,
          41
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "CIMC Research Program Whitepaper",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen",
          "Franz Hildebrandt-Harangozó",
          "Lou de Kerhuelvez",
          "Jim Rutt"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcWhitepaper.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
        "date": "2026-04-27",
        "date_type": "Version 2, April 27, 2026",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "future states",
        "summary": "Agency selects actions using internal goals and representations.",
        "locators": {
          "pages": [
            12
          ],
          "locator": "PDF physical pages 12"
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUNSC-CIMC-A13",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/3",
      "source_file_sha256": "D8407737E600EECB00DBB960B385027EE50F7B86D7FD5BBDE9B641575FD46DC0",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUNSC-MCH-A15",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUNSC-MCH-A15",
      "edition_id": "bach-initial",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-2D22791B1235FC1F3942",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:93DBDD3104CD751CC72448B0C4DC44730FB54996BFD90E5BB0E1E544E55B9DAF",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
      "title": "One unit receives what another unit produces",
      "conclusion": "Micah / SAN’s dated record precedes this selected later document on the mapped partial correspondence.",
      "shared": "Pattern arrives -> a receiving mechanism interprets/transforms it -> another pattern becomes input to the next mechanism.",
      "relation": "functional/operational-subchain",
      "residual": "The cellular learning account is not a specification of every later conditional operator or request/confirmation protocol. The shared receive-update-output chain remains visible. The paper does not specify every operator as a SAN phase-wave mechanism.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial-equivalent",
          "level": "functional/operational-subchain",
          "mapping": "Local interpretation and updates connect processing units into a causal information-processing network.",
          "source_locators": [
            5,
            19,
            23,
            25,
            41
          ],
          "target_locators": [
            16
          ],
          "mathematical_relation": "not-proved; no numerical equivalence percentage assigned"
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-shared-causal-prefix",
          "source_chain": [
            "received pattern",
            "local interpretation, emission and learned path change",
            "another receiver processes the emitted pattern"
          ],
          "target_role": "Representations propagate and transform through a causal processing network.",
          "cluster_role": "distributed transformations",
          "boundary": "A shared part of the narrative architecture is preserved; complete architecture identity and historical acquisition are not inferred."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "micah-earlier-on-bounded-document-relative-delta",
          "chronology": "The frozen 2022 Git-recorded SAN text precedes the specified 2026 target version.",
          "translation_test": "Compare operations after replacing neural rendering and pattern vocabulary with target representation and processing vocabulary; do not require the same nouns.",
          "falsification_attempt": "The cellular learning account is not a specification of every later conditional operator or request/confirmation protocol. The shared receive-update-output chain remains visible. The paper does not specify every operator as a SAN phase-wave mechanism.",
          "alternate_routes": "Shared background in computational representation, learning, feedback and control remains a possible route. The targets explicitly reference earlier approaches. This review does not establish access, dependence or author-wide firstness.",
          "earlier_target_boundary": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-grounded partial process/functional correspondence, not a constructed functor, proven isomorphism or bisimulation.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-adjudicated-in-this-release-cohort",
      "program_history": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Self-communication and learned neural paths",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/37da575ba33f85cef4239295be161066d8d39f4c/a0090z%20ctpr.txt",
        "sha256": "93DBDD3104CD751CC72448B0C4DC44730FB54996BFD90E5BB0E1E544E55B9DAF",
        "date": "2022-06-08",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "critically what they are learning they are rendering materially because their connections reshape themselves to create paths that represent learned patterns as paths, synaptic communication paths between cells, a short term memory mechanism."
        ],
        "locators": [
          5,
          19,
          23,
          25,
          41
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcHypothesis.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "date": "2026-01-15",
        "date_type": "Revised January 15, 2026; document first dated September 15, 2025",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "conditional operators",
        "summary": "Representations propagate and transform through a causal processing network.",
        "locators": {
          "pages": [
            16
          ],
          "locator": "PDF physical pages 16"
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUNSC-MCH-A15",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/4",
      "source_file_sha256": "D8407737E600EECB00DBB960B385027EE50F7B86D7FD5BBDE9B641575FD46DC0",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUNSC-CIMC-A15",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUNSC-CIMC-A15",
      "edition_id": "bach-initial",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-2D22791B1235FC1F3942",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:93DBDD3104CD751CC72448B0C4DC44730FB54996BFD90E5BB0E1E544E55B9DAF",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
      "title": "One unit receives what another unit produces",
      "conclusion": "Micah / SAN’s dated record precedes this selected later document on the mapped partial correspondence.",
      "shared": "Local state and received signals -> local update and outgoing exchange -> repeated interactions shaping global organization.",
      "relation": "functional/operational-subchain",
      "residual": "The cellular learning account is not a specification of every later conditional operator or request/confirmation protocol. The shared receive-update-output chain remains visible. Neural cellular automata and request-confirmation networks are research directions, not demonstrated conscious systems.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial-equivalent",
          "level": "functional/operational-subchain",
          "mapping": "Local interpretation and updates connect processing units into a causal information-processing network.",
          "source_locators": [
            5,
            19,
            23,
            25,
            41
          ],
          "target_locators": [
            18,
            19
          ],
          "mathematical_relation": "not-proved; no numerical equivalence percentage assigned"
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-shared-causal-prefix",
          "source_chain": [
            "received pattern",
            "local interpretation, emission and learned path change",
            "another receiver processes the emitted pattern"
          ],
          "target_role": "Local updates and exchanges are proposed to organize mutually consistent representations.",
          "cluster_role": "distributed transformations",
          "boundary": "A shared part of the narrative architecture is preserved; complete architecture identity and historical acquisition are not inferred."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "micah-earlier-on-bounded-document-relative-delta",
          "chronology": "The frozen 2022 Git-recorded SAN text precedes the specified 2026 target version.",
          "translation_test": "Compare operations after replacing neural rendering and pattern vocabulary with target representation and processing vocabulary; do not require the same nouns.",
          "falsification_attempt": "The cellular learning account is not a specification of every later conditional operator or request/confirmation protocol. The shared receive-update-output chain remains visible. Neural cellular automata and request-confirmation networks are research directions, not demonstrated conscious systems.",
          "alternate_routes": "Shared background in computational representation, learning, feedback and control remains a possible route. The targets explicitly reference earlier approaches. This review does not establish access, dependence or author-wide firstness.",
          "earlier_target_boundary": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-grounded partial process/functional correspondence, not a constructed functor, proven isomorphism or bisimulation.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-adjudicated-in-this-release-cohort",
      "program_history": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Self-communication and learned neural paths",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/37da575ba33f85cef4239295be161066d8d39f4c/a0090z%20ctpr.txt",
        "sha256": "93DBDD3104CD751CC72448B0C4DC44730FB54996BFD90E5BB0E1E544E55B9DAF",
        "date": "2022-06-08",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "critically what they are learning they are rendering materially because their connections reshape themselves to create paths that represent learned patterns as paths, synaptic communication paths between cells, a short term memory mechanism."
        ],
        "locators": [
          5,
          19,
          23,
          25,
          41
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "CIMC Research Program Whitepaper",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen",
          "Franz Hildebrandt-Harangozó",
          "Lou de Kerhuelvez",
          "Jim Rutt"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcWhitepaper.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
        "date": "2026-04-27",
        "date_type": "Version 2, April 27, 2026",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "message-passing",
        "summary": "Local updates and exchanges are proposed to organize mutually consistent representations.",
        "locators": {
          "pages": [
            18,
            19
          ],
          "locator": "PDF physical pages 18, 19"
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUNSC-CIMC-A15",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/5",
      "source_file_sha256": "D8407737E600EECB00DBB960B385027EE50F7B86D7FD5BBDE9B641575FD46DC0",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-MCH-A11",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-MCH-A11",
      "edition_id": "bach-initial",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-8D523E2C6BD7E6D63465",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
      "title": "Experience is a constructed information pattern",
      "conclusion": "Micah / SAN’s dated record precedes this selected later document on the mapped partial correspondence.",
      "shared": "Substrate-supported pattern -> computation/interpretation -> functionally identifiable represented information through processing.",
      "relation": "functional/operational-subchain",
      "residual": "The shared computational-pattern account is not a formal proof of identical semantics or of sufficient conditions for consciousness. Structural invariances characterize representations; this is not a theorem that all transformations preserve them.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial-equivalent",
          "level": "functional/operational-subchain",
          "mapping": "A representation is an implemented pattern used by a computational process, not a separate observer outside that process.",
          "source_locators": [
            93,
            95,
            97,
            100,
            102,
            108
          ],
          "target_locators": [
            16
          ],
          "mathematical_relation": "not-proved; no numerical equivalence percentage assigned"
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-shared-causal-prefix",
          "source_chain": [
            "information-bearing activity",
            "computable processing and recurrent re-rendering",
            "a represented pattern available inside the system"
          ],
          "target_role": "A representation is an implemented pattern interpreted through a suitable mechanism.",
          "cluster_role": "implemented representation",
          "boundary": "A shared part of the narrative architecture is preserved; complete architecture identity and historical acquisition are not inferred."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "micah-earlier-on-bounded-document-relative-delta",
          "chronology": "The frozen 2022 Git-recorded SAN text precedes the specified 2026 target version.",
          "translation_test": "Compare operations after replacing neural rendering and pattern vocabulary with target representation and processing vocabulary; do not require the same nouns.",
          "falsification_attempt": "The shared computational-pattern account is not a formal proof of identical semantics or of sufficient conditions for consciousness. Structural invariances characterize representations; this is not a theorem that all transformations preserve them.",
          "alternate_routes": "Shared background in computational representation, learning, feedback and control remains a possible route. The targets explicitly reference earlier approaches. This review does not establish access, dependence or author-wide firstness.",
          "earlier_target_boundary": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-grounded partial process/functional correspondence, not a constructed functor, proven isomorphism or bisimulation.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-adjudicated-in-this-release-cohort",
      "program_history": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Computational Phenomenological Consciousness",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0319z.md",
        "sha256": "FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "A rendering is a substantial pattern that is the output of some computable process."
        ],
        "locators": [
          93,
          95,
          97,
          100,
          102,
          108
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcHypothesis.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "date": "2026-01-15",
        "date_type": "Revised January 15, 2026; document first dated September 15, 2025",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "pattern within a substrate",
        "summary": "A representation is an implemented pattern interpreted through a suitable mechanism.",
        "locators": {
          "pages": [
            16
          ],
          "locator": "PDF physical pages 16"
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-MCH-A11",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/6",
      "source_file_sha256": "D8407737E600EECB00DBB960B385027EE50F7B86D7FD5BBDE9B641575FD46DC0",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-CIMC-A11",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-CIMC-A11",
      "edition_id": "bach-initial",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-8D523E2C6BD7E6D63465",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
      "title": "Experience is a constructed information pattern",
      "conclusion": "Micah / SAN’s dated record precedes this selected later document on the mapped partial correspondence.",
      "shared": "Computable activity -> structured internal representations -> organization interpretable in terms of conscious function.",
      "relation": "functional/operational-subchain",
      "residual": "The shared computational-pattern account is not a formal proof of identical semantics or of sufficient conditions for consciousness. Interpretive validation is proposed; conscious implementation is not demonstrated.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial-equivalent",
          "level": "functional/operational-subchain",
          "mapping": "A representation is an implemented pattern used by a computational process, not a separate observer outside that process.",
          "source_locators": [
            93,
            95,
            97,
            100,
            102,
            108
          ],
          "target_locators": [
            10,
            17,
            18
          ],
          "mathematical_relation": "not-proved; no numerical equivalence percentage assigned"
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-shared-causal-prefix",
          "source_chain": [
            "information-bearing activity",
            "computable processing and recurrent re-rendering",
            "a represented pattern available inside the system"
          ],
          "target_role": "The proposed conscious organization is computational and open to implementation tests.",
          "cluster_role": "implemented representation",
          "boundary": "A shared part of the narrative architecture is preserved; complete architecture identity and historical acquisition are not inferred."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "micah-earlier-on-bounded-document-relative-delta",
          "chronology": "The frozen 2022 Git-recorded SAN text precedes the specified 2026 target version.",
          "translation_test": "Compare operations after replacing neural rendering and pattern vocabulary with target representation and processing vocabulary; do not require the same nouns.",
          "falsification_attempt": "The shared computational-pattern account is not a formal proof of identical semantics or of sufficient conditions for consciousness. Interpretive validation is proposed; conscious implementation is not demonstrated.",
          "alternate_routes": "Shared background in computational representation, learning, feedback and control remains a possible route. The targets explicitly reference earlier approaches. This review does not establish access, dependence or author-wide firstness.",
          "earlier_target_boundary": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-grounded partial process/functional correspondence, not a constructed functor, proven isomorphism or bisimulation.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-adjudicated-in-this-release-cohort",
      "program_history": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Computational Phenomenological Consciousness",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0319z.md",
        "sha256": "FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "A rendering is a substantial pattern that is the output of some computable process."
        ],
        "locators": [
          93,
          95,
          97,
          100,
          102,
          108
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "CIMC Research Program Whitepaper",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen",
          "Franz Hildebrandt-Harangozó",
          "Lou de Kerhuelvez",
          "Jim Rutt"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcWhitepaper.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
        "date": "2026-04-27",
        "date_type": "Version 2, April 27, 2026",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "computational regime",
        "summary": "The proposed conscious organization is computational and open to implementation tests.",
        "locators": {
          "pages": [
            10,
            17,
            18
          ],
          "locator": "PDF physical pages 10, 17, 18"
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-CIMC-A11",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/7",
      "source_file_sha256": "D8407737E600EECB00DBB960B385027EE50F7B86D7FD5BBDE9B641575FD46DC0",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-MCH-A12",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-MCH-A12",
      "edition_id": "bach-initial",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-8FD2FED8A41DC59750DC",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
      "title": "The self is represented inside its own loop",
      "conclusion": "Micah / SAN’s dated record precedes this selected later document on the mapped partial correspondence.",
      "shared": "Distributed information processing -> construction of internally represented self/world structure -> organization of an agent's interaction.",
      "relation": "functional/operational-subchain",
      "residual": "SAN specifies oscillatory rendering and reception; the targets add particular metarepresentational and developmental conditions. These additions qualify whole-theory identity, not the shared subchain. The developmental Genesis hypothesis and consciousness-as-coherence operator are additional commitments.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial-equivalent",
          "level": "functional/operational-subchain",
          "mapping": "The self/world organization is constructed inside a recurring representational process.",
          "source_locators": [
            11,
            21,
            25,
            27,
            65,
            91,
            102,
            108
          ],
          "target_locators": [
            18,
            19,
            21
          ],
          "mathematical_relation": "not-proved; no numerical equivalence percentage assigned"
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-shared-causal-prefix",
          "source_chain": [
            "distributed sensory and internal representations",
            "recurrent rendering, detection and coordination",
            "a self represented in relation to a world and capable of coordinated action"
          ],
          "target_role": "Communicating cells are proposed to organize coherent models and agentic control.",
          "cluster_role": "self/world organization",
          "boundary": "A shared part of the narrative architecture is preserved; complete architecture identity and historical acquisition are not inferred."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "micah-earlier-on-bounded-document-relative-delta",
          "chronology": "The frozen 2022 Git-recorded SAN text precedes the specified 2026 target version.",
          "translation_test": "Compare operations after replacing neural rendering and pattern vocabulary with target representation and processing vocabulary; do not require the same nouns.",
          "falsification_attempt": "SAN specifies oscillatory rendering and reception; the targets add particular metarepresentational and developmental conditions. These additions qualify whole-theory identity, not the shared subchain. The developmental Genesis hypothesis and consciousness-as-coherence operator are additional commitments.",
          "alternate_routes": "Shared background in computational representation, learning, feedback and control remains a possible route. The targets explicitly reference earlier approaches. This review does not establish access, dependence or author-wide firstness.",
          "earlier_target_boundary": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-grounded partial process/functional correspondence, not a constructed functor, proven isomorphism or bisimulation.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-adjudicated-in-this-release-cohort",
      "program_history": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Computational Phenomenological Consciousness",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0319z.md",
        "sha256": "FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "conciousness is context referencing context, self referencing self, where self is a rendered pattern that is a distinct information/energy configuration, that oscillates inside a feedback loop that is made up of brain state elements that alternately render & detect renderings,"
        ],
        "locators": [
          11,
          21,
          25,
          27,
          65,
          91,
          102,
          108
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcHypothesis.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "date": "2026-01-15",
        "date_type": "Revised January 15, 2026; document first dated September 15, 2025",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "communicating brain cells",
        "summary": "Communicating cells are proposed to organize coherent models and agentic control.",
        "locators": {
          "pages": [
            18,
            19,
            21
          ],
          "locator": "PDF physical pages 18, 19, 21"
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-MCH-A12",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/8",
      "source_file_sha256": "D8407737E600EECB00DBB960B385027EE50F7B86D7FD5BBDE9B641575FD46DC0",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-CIMC-A12",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-CIMC-A12",
      "edition_id": "bach-initial",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-8FD2FED8A41DC59750DC",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
      "title": "The self is represented inside its own loop",
      "conclusion": "Micah / SAN’s dated record precedes this selected later document on the mapped partial correspondence.",
      "shared": "Representations constructed within a distributed system -> internal monitoring/regulation -> organized self/world modeling in service of agency.",
      "relation": "functional/operational-subchain",
      "residual": "SAN specifies oscillatory rendering and reception; the targets add particular metarepresentational and developmental conditions. These additions qualify whole-theory identity, not the shared subchain. Same-level metarepresentation and transparency are additional representational constraints.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial-equivalent",
          "level": "functional/operational-subchain",
          "mapping": "The self/world organization is constructed inside a recurring representational process.",
          "source_locators": [
            11,
            21,
            25,
            27,
            65,
            91,
            102,
            108
          ],
          "target_locators": [
            10,
            11,
            12,
            13,
            18,
            19
          ],
          "mathematical_relation": "not-proved; no numerical equivalence percentage assigned"
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-shared-causal-prefix",
          "source_chain": [
            "distributed sensory and internal representations",
            "recurrent rendering, detection and coordination",
            "a self represented in relation to a world and capable of coordinated action"
          ],
          "target_role": "Self-organized perception is proposed to monitor and regulate coherent internal models.",
          "cluster_role": "self/world organization",
          "boundary": "A shared part of the narrative architecture is preserved; complete architecture identity and historical acquisition are not inferred."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "micah-earlier-on-bounded-document-relative-delta",
          "chronology": "The frozen 2022 Git-recorded SAN text precedes the specified 2026 target version.",
          "translation_test": "Compare operations after replacing neural rendering and pattern vocabulary with target representation and processing vocabulary; do not require the same nouns.",
          "falsification_attempt": "SAN specifies oscillatory rendering and reception; the targets add particular metarepresentational and developmental conditions. These additions qualify whole-theory identity, not the shared subchain. Same-level metarepresentation and transparency are additional representational constraints.",
          "alternate_routes": "Shared background in computational representation, learning, feedback and control remains a possible route. The targets explicitly reference earlier approaches. This review does not establish access, dependence or author-wide firstness.",
          "earlier_target_boundary": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-grounded partial process/functional correspondence, not a constructed functor, proven isomorphism or bisimulation.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-adjudicated-in-this-release-cohort",
      "program_history": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Computational Phenomenological Consciousness",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0319z.md",
        "sha256": "FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "conciousness is context referencing context, self referencing self, where self is a rendered pattern that is a distinct information/energy configuration, that oscillates inside a feedback loop that is made up of brain state elements that alternately render & detect renderings,"
        ],
        "locators": [
          11,
          21,
          25,
          27,
          65,
          91,
          102,
          108
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "CIMC Research Program Whitepaper",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen",
          "Franz Hildebrandt-Harangozó",
          "Lou de Kerhuelvez",
          "Jim Rutt"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcWhitepaper.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
        "date": "2026-04-27",
        "date_type": "Version 2, April 27, 2026",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "second-order perception",
        "summary": "Self-organized perception is proposed to monitor and regulate coherent internal models.",
        "locators": {
          "pages": [
            10,
            11,
            12,
            13,
            18,
            19
          ],
          "locator": "PDF physical pages 10, 11, 12, 13, 18, 19"
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-CIMC-A12",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/9",
      "source_file_sha256": "D8407737E600EECB00DBB960B385027EE50F7B86D7FD5BBDE9B641575FD46DC0",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-MCH-A13",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-MCH-A13",
      "edition_id": "bach-initial",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-213BA6A4BC764F850CB6",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
      "title": "Imagined futures organize action",
      "conclusion": "Micah / SAN’s dated record precedes this selected later document on the mapped partial correspondence.",
      "shared": "Internal representations of a situation/possibilities -> planning and decision organization -> coordinated action in the world.",
      "relation": "functional/operational-subchain",
      "residual": "The November source gives a proposed oscillatory motor-coordination route. The target passages do not supply that same motor implementation or prove the two accounts mathematically equivalent. This is not an experimentally demonstrated cellular action-selection algorithm.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial-equivalent",
          "level": "functional/operational-subchain",
          "mapping": "Internal models of possible outcomes participate in selecting and coordinating action.",
          "source_locators": [
            29,
            39,
            65,
            71,
            73
          ],
          "target_locators": [
            17,
            20,
            21
          ],
          "mathematical_relation": "not-proved; no numerical equivalence percentage assigned"
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-shared-causal-prefix",
          "source_chain": [
            "mental imagery and predicted consequences",
            "selection and coordination of distributed action patterns",
            "movement, speech, writing and planning"
          ],
          "target_role": "Conscious model-building is connected to planning and control of action.",
          "cluster_role": "prediction and action",
          "boundary": "A shared part of the narrative architecture is preserved; complete architecture identity and historical acquisition are not inferred."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "micah-earlier-on-bounded-document-relative-delta",
          "chronology": "The frozen 2022 Git-recorded SAN text precedes the specified 2026 target version.",
          "translation_test": "Compare operations after replacing neural rendering and pattern vocabulary with target representation and processing vocabulary; do not require the same nouns.",
          "falsification_attempt": "The November source gives a proposed oscillatory motor-coordination route. The target passages do not supply that same motor implementation or prove the two accounts mathematically equivalent. This is not an experimentally demonstrated cellular action-selection algorithm.",
          "alternate_routes": "Shared background in computational representation, learning, feedback and control remains a possible route. The targets explicitly reference earlier approaches. This review does not establish access, dependence or author-wide firstness.",
          "earlier_target_boundary": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-grounded partial process/functional correspondence, not a constructed functor, proven isomorphism or bisimulation.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-adjudicated-in-this-release-cohort",
      "program_history": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Computational Phenomenological Consciousness",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0319z.md",
        "sha256": "FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "Our decisions that arise from mental imagery, from our predictions of consequences, our predictions of possible futures, result in sparse distributed muscle coordination actions sequences"
        ],
        "locators": [
          29,
          39,
          65,
          71,
          73
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcHypothesis.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "date": "2026-01-15",
        "date_type": "Revised January 15, 2026; document first dated September 15, 2025",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "planning",
        "summary": "Conscious model-building is connected to planning and control of action.",
        "locators": {
          "pages": [
            17,
            20,
            21
          ],
          "locator": "PDF physical pages 17, 20, 21"
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-MCH-A13",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/10",
      "source_file_sha256": "D8407737E600EECB00DBB960B385027EE50F7B86D7FD5BBDE9B641575FD46DC0",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-CIMC-A13",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-CIMC-A13",
      "edition_id": "bach-initial",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-213BA6A4BC764F850CB6",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
      "title": "Imagined futures organize action",
      "conclusion": "Micah / SAN’s dated record precedes this selected later document on the mapped partial correspondence.",
      "shared": "Internally represented possible outcomes and criteria -> selection of action -> influence on future states.",
      "relation": "functional/operational-subchain",
      "residual": "The November source gives a proposed oscillatory motor-coordination route. The target passages do not supply that same motor implementation or prove the two accounts mathematically equivalent. Agency and consciousness are explicitly distinguished, so this match concerns an adjacent functional component.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial-equivalent",
          "level": "functional/operational-subchain",
          "mapping": "Internal models of possible outcomes participate in selecting and coordinating action.",
          "source_locators": [
            29,
            39,
            65,
            71,
            73
          ],
          "target_locators": [
            12
          ],
          "mathematical_relation": "not-proved; no numerical equivalence percentage assigned"
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-shared-causal-prefix",
          "source_chain": [
            "mental imagery and predicted consequences",
            "selection and coordination of distributed action patterns",
            "movement, speech, writing and planning"
          ],
          "target_role": "Agency selects actions using internal goals and representations.",
          "cluster_role": "prediction and action",
          "boundary": "A shared part of the narrative architecture is preserved; complete architecture identity and historical acquisition are not inferred."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "micah-earlier-on-bounded-document-relative-delta",
          "chronology": "The frozen 2022 Git-recorded SAN text precedes the specified 2026 target version.",
          "translation_test": "Compare operations after replacing neural rendering and pattern vocabulary with target representation and processing vocabulary; do not require the same nouns.",
          "falsification_attempt": "The November source gives a proposed oscillatory motor-coordination route. The target passages do not supply that same motor implementation or prove the two accounts mathematically equivalent. Agency and consciousness are explicitly distinguished, so this match concerns an adjacent functional component.",
          "alternate_routes": "Shared background in computational representation, learning, feedback and control remains a possible route. The targets explicitly reference earlier approaches. This review does not establish access, dependence or author-wide firstness.",
          "earlier_target_boundary": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-grounded partial process/functional correspondence, not a constructed functor, proven isomorphism or bisimulation.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-adjudicated-in-this-release-cohort",
      "program_history": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Computational Phenomenological Consciousness",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0319z.md",
        "sha256": "FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "Our decisions that arise from mental imagery, from our predictions of consequences, our predictions of possible futures, result in sparse distributed muscle coordination actions sequences"
        ],
        "locators": [
          29,
          39,
          65,
          71,
          73
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "CIMC Research Program Whitepaper",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen",
          "Franz Hildebrandt-Harangozó",
          "Lou de Kerhuelvez",
          "Jim Rutt"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcWhitepaper.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
        "date": "2026-04-27",
        "date_type": "Version 2, April 27, 2026",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "future states",
        "summary": "Agency selects actions using internal goals and representations.",
        "locators": {
          "pages": [
            12
          ],
          "locator": "PDF physical pages 12"
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-CIMC-A13",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/11",
      "source_file_sha256": "D8407737E600EECB00DBB960B385027EE50F7B86D7FD5BBDE9B641575FD46DC0",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-MCH-A14",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-MCH-A14",
      "edition_id": "bach-initial",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-2447999B36FEFCC4AA65",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
      "title": "A current experience is a maintained pattern",
      "conclusion": "Micah / SAN’s dated record precedes this selected later document on the mapped partial correspondence.",
      "shared": "Sensory/object-related information -> an internal represented percept -> that content is present to awareness and can vary in experienced/objective fidelity.",
      "relation": "conceptual/process-prefix",
      "residual": "This is a bounded conceptual/process-prefix match. Tonic-baseline discrimination is not identical to the target definition of realness, and it does not establish the targets' minimal-content phenomenology. Realness is a representational feature, not a tonic-baseline measurement.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial-equivalent",
          "level": "conceptual/process-prefix",
          "mapping": "Present experience is treated as an internally represented and presently available condition.",
          "source_locators": [
            15,
            25,
            35,
            37,
            69,
            75,
            77,
            87,
            89,
            95
          ],
          "target_locators": [
            15,
            16
          ],
          "mathematical_relation": "not-proved; no numerical equivalence percentage assigned"
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-shared-causal-prefix",
          "source_chain": [
            "changing sensory and internal activity",
            "repeated construction and detection of a persistent representation",
            "currently available conscious content"
          ],
          "target_role": "Present experience includes represented content and a sense of its current occurrence.",
          "cluster_role": "maintained current content",
          "boundary": "A shared part of the narrative architecture is preserved; complete architecture identity and historical acquisition are not inferred."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "micah-earlier-on-bounded-document-relative-delta",
          "chronology": "The frozen 2022 Git-recorded SAN text precedes the specified 2026 target version.",
          "translation_test": "Compare operations after replacing neural rendering and pattern vocabulary with target representation and processing vocabulary; do not require the same nouns.",
          "falsification_attempt": "This is a bounded conceptual/process-prefix match. Tonic-baseline discrimination is not identical to the target definition of realness, and it does not establish the targets' minimal-content phenomenology. Realness is a representational feature, not a tonic-baseline measurement.",
          "alternate_routes": "Shared background in computational representation, learning, feedback and control remains a possible route. The targets explicitly reference earlier approaches. This review does not establish access, dependence or author-wide firstness.",
          "earlier_target_boundary": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-grounded partial process/functional correspondence, not a constructed functor, proven isomorphism or bisimulation.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-adjudicated-in-this-release-cohort",
      "program_history": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Computational Phenomenological Consciousness",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0319z.md",
        "sha256": "FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "the rendering in the mind is a persistent pattern that is detected by the mind the same way a rock in the world is a persistent pattern that is detectable by a computer with a neural network with a semantic segmentation program"
        ],
        "locators": [
          15,
          25,
          35,
          37,
          69,
          75,
          77,
          87,
          89,
          95
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcHypothesis.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "date": "2026-01-15",
        "date_type": "Revised January 15, 2026; document first dated September 15, 2025",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "Realness",
        "summary": "Present experience includes represented content and a sense of its current occurrence.",
        "locators": {
          "pages": [
            15,
            16
          ],
          "locator": "PDF physical pages 15, 16"
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-MCH-A14",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/12",
      "source_file_sha256": "D8407737E600EECB00DBB960B385027EE50F7B86D7FD5BBDE9B641575FD46DC0",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-CIMC-A14",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-CIMC-A14",
      "edition_id": "bach-initial",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-2447999B36FEFCC4AA65",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
      "title": "A current experience is a maintained pattern",
      "conclusion": "Micah / SAN’s dated record precedes this selected later document on the mapped partial correspondence.",
      "shared": "Ongoing representational activity -> sustained perceptual organization -> availability of that ongoing content/process within awareness.",
      "relation": "conceptual/process-prefix",
      "residual": "This is a bounded conceptual/process-prefix match. Tonic-baseline discrimination is not identical to the target definition of realness, and it does not establish the targets' minimal-content phenomenology. Minimal experience without a specified object is not identical to SAN's maintained object pattern.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial-equivalent",
          "level": "conceptual/process-prefix",
          "mapping": "Present experience is treated as an internally represented and presently available condition.",
          "source_locators": [
            15,
            25,
            35,
            37,
            69,
            75,
            77,
            87,
            89,
            95
          ],
          "target_locators": [
            11,
            12,
            13
          ],
          "mathematical_relation": "not-proved; no numerical equivalence percentage assigned"
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-shared-causal-prefix",
          "source_chain": [
            "changing sensory and internal activity",
            "repeated construction and detection of a persistent representation",
            "currently available conscious content"
          ],
          "target_role": "Conscious experience includes present registration within an internally constructed perceptual field.",
          "cluster_role": "maintained current content",
          "boundary": "A shared part of the narrative architecture is preserved; complete architecture identity and historical acquisition are not inferred."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "micah-earlier-on-bounded-document-relative-delta",
          "chronology": "The frozen 2022 Git-recorded SAN text precedes the specified 2026 target version.",
          "translation_test": "Compare operations after replacing neural rendering and pattern vocabulary with target representation and processing vocabulary; do not require the same nouns.",
          "falsification_attempt": "This is a bounded conceptual/process-prefix match. Tonic-baseline discrimination is not identical to the target definition of realness, and it does not establish the targets' minimal-content phenomenology. Minimal experience without a specified object is not identical to SAN's maintained object pattern.",
          "alternate_routes": "Shared background in computational representation, learning, feedback and control remains a possible route. The targets explicitly reference earlier approaches. This review does not establish access, dependence or author-wide firstness.",
          "earlier_target_boundary": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-grounded partial process/functional correspondence, not a constructed functor, proven isomorphism or bisimulation.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-adjudicated-in-this-release-cohort",
      "program_history": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Computational Phenomenological Consciousness",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0319z.md",
        "sha256": "FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "the rendering in the mind is a persistent pattern that is detected by the mind the same way a rock in the world is a persistent pattern that is detectable by a computer with a neural network with a semantic segmentation program"
        ],
        "locators": [
          15,
          25,
          35,
          37,
          69,
          75,
          77,
          87,
          89,
          95
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "CIMC Research Program Whitepaper",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen",
          "Franz Hildebrandt-Harangozó",
          "Lou de Kerhuelvez",
          "Jim Rutt"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcWhitepaper.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
        "date": "2026-04-27",
        "date_type": "Version 2, April 27, 2026",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "bare registration",
        "summary": "Conscious experience includes present registration within an internally constructed perceptual field.",
        "locators": {
          "pages": [
            11,
            12,
            13
          ],
          "locator": "PDF physical pages 11, 12, 13"
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-CIMC-A14",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/13",
      "source_file_sha256": "D8407737E600EECB00DBB960B385027EE50F7B86D7FD5BBDE9B641575FD46DC0",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-MCH-A15",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-MCH-A15",
      "edition_id": "bach-initial",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-9B5372898C3426C4FDA4",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
      "title": "Rendering is distributed across the network",
      "conclusion": "Micah / SAN’s dated record precedes this selected later document on the mapped partial correspondence.",
      "shared": "Represented input -> a local interpreting/transforming operation -> represented output that another operation receives.",
      "relation": "functional/operational-subchain",
      "residual": "No full operator-by-operator translation has been proved. Neither the SAN analogy nor the MCH text proves that every transformation preserves every structural invariant. The paper does not specify every operator as a SAN phase-wave mechanism.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial-equivalent",
          "level": "functional/operational-subchain",
          "mapping": "Representations participate in a network of local transformations rather than waiting for an external inner reader.",
          "source_locators": [
            21,
            23,
            25,
            27,
            33,
            35,
            100,
            102
          ],
          "target_locators": [
            16
          ],
          "mathematical_relation": "not-proved; no numerical equivalence percentage assigned"
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-shared-causal-prefix",
          "source_chain": [
            "a local representation",
            "distributed transformation and reception by another processing unit",
            "a further representation used in subsequent processing"
          ],
          "target_role": "Representations propagate and transform through a causal processing network.",
          "cluster_role": "distributed transformations",
          "boundary": "A shared part of the narrative architecture is preserved; complete architecture identity and historical acquisition are not inferred."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "micah-earlier-on-bounded-document-relative-delta",
          "chronology": "The frozen 2022 Git-recorded SAN text precedes the specified 2026 target version.",
          "translation_test": "Compare operations after replacing neural rendering and pattern vocabulary with target representation and processing vocabulary; do not require the same nouns.",
          "falsification_attempt": "No full operator-by-operator translation has been proved. Neither the SAN analogy nor the MCH text proves that every transformation preserves every structural invariant. The paper does not specify every operator as a SAN phase-wave mechanism.",
          "alternate_routes": "Shared background in computational representation, learning, feedback and control remains a possible route. The targets explicitly reference earlier approaches. This review does not establish access, dependence or author-wide firstness.",
          "earlier_target_boundary": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-grounded partial process/functional correspondence, not a constructed functor, proven isomorphism or bisimulation.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-adjudicated-in-this-release-cohort",
      "program_history": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Computational Phenomenological Consciousness",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0319z.md",
        "sha256": "FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "Metaphorically you can imagine that there is no central canvas, no computer screen where all the renderings show up, because the rendered outputs are distributed all over the place, and absorbed by the brain for the next iteration of the rendering."
        ],
        "locators": [
          21,
          23,
          25,
          27,
          33,
          35,
          100,
          102
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcHypothesis.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "date": "2026-01-15",
        "date_type": "Revised January 15, 2026; document first dated September 15, 2025",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "conditional operators",
        "summary": "Representations propagate and transform through a causal processing network.",
        "locators": {
          "pages": [
            16
          ],
          "locator": "PDF physical pages 16"
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-MCH-A15",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/14",
      "source_file_sha256": "D8407737E600EECB00DBB960B385027EE50F7B86D7FD5BBDE9B641575FD46DC0",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-CIMC-A15",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-CIMC-A15",
      "edition_id": "bach-initial",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-9B5372898C3426C4FDA4",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
      "title": "Rendering is distributed across the network",
      "conclusion": "Micah / SAN’s dated record precedes this selected later document on the mapped partial correspondence.",
      "shared": "Distributed representations -> local state updates and exchanged signals -> repeated cross-unit organization of represented state.",
      "relation": "functional/operational-subchain",
      "residual": "No full operator-by-operator translation has been proved. Neither the SAN analogy nor the MCH text proves that every transformation preserves every structural invariant. Neural cellular automata and request-confirmation networks are research directions, not demonstrated conscious systems.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial-equivalent",
          "level": "functional/operational-subchain",
          "mapping": "Representations participate in a network of local transformations rather than waiting for an external inner reader.",
          "source_locators": [
            21,
            23,
            25,
            27,
            33,
            35,
            100,
            102
          ],
          "target_locators": [
            18,
            19
          ],
          "mathematical_relation": "not-proved; no numerical equivalence percentage assigned"
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-shared-causal-prefix",
          "source_chain": [
            "a local representation",
            "distributed transformation and reception by another processing unit",
            "a further representation used in subsequent processing"
          ],
          "target_role": "Local updates and exchanges are proposed to organize mutually consistent representations.",
          "cluster_role": "distributed transformations",
          "boundary": "A shared part of the narrative architecture is preserved; complete architecture identity and historical acquisition are not inferred."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "micah-earlier-on-bounded-document-relative-delta",
          "chronology": "The frozen 2022 Git-recorded SAN text precedes the specified 2026 target version.",
          "translation_test": "Compare operations after replacing neural rendering and pattern vocabulary with target representation and processing vocabulary; do not require the same nouns.",
          "falsification_attempt": "No full operator-by-operator translation has been proved. Neither the SAN analogy nor the MCH text proves that every transformation preserves every structural invariant. Neural cellular automata and request-confirmation networks are research directions, not demonstrated conscious systems.",
          "alternate_routes": "Shared background in computational representation, learning, feedback and control remains a possible route. The targets explicitly reference earlier approaches. This review does not establish access, dependence or author-wide firstness.",
          "earlier_target_boundary": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-grounded partial process/functional correspondence, not a constructed functor, proven isomorphism or bisimulation.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-adjudicated-in-this-release-cohort",
      "program_history": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Computational Phenomenological Consciousness",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0319z.md",
        "sha256": "FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "Metaphorically you can imagine that there is no central canvas, no computer screen where all the renderings show up, because the rendered outputs are distributed all over the place, and absorbed by the brain for the next iteration of the rendering."
        ],
        "locators": [
          21,
          23,
          25,
          27,
          33,
          35,
          100,
          102
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "CIMC Research Program Whitepaper",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen",
          "Franz Hildebrandt-Harangozó",
          "Lou de Kerhuelvez",
          "Jim Rutt"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcWhitepaper.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
        "date": "2026-04-27",
        "date_type": "Version 2, April 27, 2026",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "message-passing",
        "summary": "Local updates and exchanges are proposed to organize mutually consistent representations.",
        "locators": {
          "pages": [
            18,
            19
          ],
          "locator": "PDF physical pages 18, 19"
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-CIMC-A15",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/15",
      "source_file_sha256": "D8407737E600EECB00DBB960B385027EE50F7B86D7FD5BBDE9B641575FD46DC0",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-MCH-A16",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-MCH-A16",
      "edition_id": "bach-initial",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-E580A4401673FC52723F",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
      "title": "The proposed organization can inform artificial minds",
      "conclusion": "Micah / SAN’s dated record precedes this selected later document on the mapped partial correspondence.",
      "shared": "Similar representational/control tasks -> recurring useful functional organization -> possible recreation on an artificial substrate.",
      "relation": "functional/operational-subchain",
      "residual": "SAN proposes an oscillatory route. The targets explore self-organization and convergence without establishing that the same oscillatory implementation is necessary or that any implementation is conscious. Pages 22 and 24 explicitly leave successful artificial reproduction and consciousness uncertain.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial-equivalent",
          "level": "functional/operational-subchain",
          "mapping": "Biological organization motivates an artificial implementation rather than making the biological material the only possible carrier.",
          "source_locators": [
            73,
            83,
            85,
            87,
            95,
            102,
            108
          ],
          "target_locators": [
            19,
            21,
            22,
            24
          ],
          "mathematical_relation": "not-proved; no numerical equivalence percentage assigned"
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-shared-causal-prefix",
          "source_chain": [
            "an identified organization in biological processing",
            "reproduce the relevant organization in an artificial system",
            "test a functionally corresponding artificial mind"
          ],
          "target_role": "Artificial self-organizing systems are proposed as tests of biological consciousness hypotheses.",
          "cluster_role": "artificial implementation",
          "boundary": "A shared part of the narrative architecture is preserved; complete architecture identity and historical acquisition are not inferred."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "micah-earlier-on-bounded-document-relative-delta",
          "chronology": "The frozen 2022 Git-recorded SAN text precedes the specified 2026 target version.",
          "translation_test": "Compare operations after replacing neural rendering and pattern vocabulary with target representation and processing vocabulary; do not require the same nouns.",
          "falsification_attempt": "SAN proposes an oscillatory route. The targets explore self-organization and convergence without establishing that the same oscillatory implementation is necessary or that any implementation is conscious. Pages 22 and 24 explicitly leave successful artificial reproduction and consciousness uncertain.",
          "alternate_routes": "Shared background in computational representation, learning, feedback and control remains a possible route. The targets explicitly reference earlier approaches. This review does not establish access, dependence or author-wide firstness.",
          "earlier_target_boundary": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-grounded partial process/functional correspondence, not a constructed functor, proven isomorphism or bisimulation.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-adjudicated-in-this-release-cohort",
      "program_history": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Computational Phenomenological Consciousness",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0319z.md",
        "sha256": "FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "Beyond the electro-chemical dynamics, oscillatory physics is what binds our minds together, and the simulation of oscillatory physics is what can bind artificial minds together."
        ],
        "locators": [
          73,
          83,
          85,
          87,
          95,
          102,
          108
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcHypothesis.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "date": "2026-01-15",
        "date_type": "Revised January 15, 2026; document first dated September 15, 2025",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "self-organizing information processing",
        "summary": "Artificial self-organizing systems are proposed as tests of biological consciousness hypotheses.",
        "locators": {
          "pages": [
            19,
            21,
            22,
            24
          ],
          "locator": "PDF physical pages 19, 21, 22, 24"
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-MCH-A16",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/16",
      "source_file_sha256": "D8407737E600EECB00DBB960B385027EE50F7B86D7FD5BBDE9B641575FD46DC0",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-CIMC-A16",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-CIMC-A16",
      "edition_id": "bach-initial",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-E580A4401673FC52723F",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
      "title": "The proposed organization can inform artificial minds",
      "conclusion": "Micah / SAN’s dated record precedes this selected later document on the mapped partial correspondence.",
      "shared": "Analogous representational/control problem -> similar useful internal information organization -> hypothesized biological/artificial functional correspondence.",
      "relation": "functional/operational-subchain",
      "residual": "SAN proposes an oscillatory route. The targets explore self-organization and convergence without establishing that the same oscillatory implementation is necessary or that any implementation is conscious. Convergence toward consciousness is a hypothesis, not a finding that consciousness has been reproduced.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial-equivalent",
          "level": "functional/operational-subchain",
          "mapping": "Biological organization motivates an artificial implementation rather than making the biological material the only possible carrier.",
          "source_locators": [
            73,
            83,
            85,
            87,
            95,
            102,
            108
          ],
          "target_locators": [
            10,
            17
          ],
          "mathematical_relation": "not-proved; no numerical equivalence percentage assigned"
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-shared-causal-prefix",
          "source_chain": [
            "an identified organization in biological processing",
            "reproduce the relevant organization in an artificial system",
            "test a functionally corresponding artificial mind"
          ],
          "target_role": "Different implementations may converge on corresponding solutions to a shared control problem.",
          "cluster_role": "artificial implementation",
          "boundary": "A shared part of the narrative architecture is preserved; complete architecture identity and historical acquisition are not inferred."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "micah-earlier-on-bounded-document-relative-delta",
          "chronology": "The frozen 2022 Git-recorded SAN text precedes the specified 2026 target version.",
          "translation_test": "Compare operations after replacing neural rendering and pattern vocabulary with target representation and processing vocabulary; do not require the same nouns.",
          "falsification_attempt": "SAN proposes an oscillatory route. The targets explore self-organization and convergence without establishing that the same oscillatory implementation is necessary or that any implementation is conscious. Convergence toward consciousness is a hypothesis, not a finding that consciousness has been reproduced.",
          "alternate_routes": "Shared background in computational representation, learning, feedback and control remains a possible route. The targets explicitly reference earlier approaches. This review does not establish access, dependence or author-wide firstness.",
          "earlier_target_boundary": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-grounded partial process/functional correspondence, not a constructed functor, proven isomorphism or bisimulation.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-adjudicated-in-this-release-cohort",
      "program_history": "The earlier Bach program remains separately open; no absence is inferred from these two later documents.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Computational Phenomenological Consciousness",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0319z.md",
        "sha256": "FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "Beyond the electro-chemical dynamics, oscillatory physics is what binds our minds together, and the simulation of oscillatory physics is what can bind artificial minds together."
        ],
        "locators": [
          73,
          83,
          85,
          87,
          95,
          102,
          108
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "CIMC Research Program Whitepaper",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen",
          "Franz Hildebrandt-Harangozó",
          "Lou de Kerhuelvez",
          "Jim Rutt"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcWhitepaper.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
        "date": "2026-04-27",
        "date_type": "Version 2, April 27, 2026",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "similar solutions",
        "summary": "Different implementations may converge on corresponding solutions to a shared control problem.",
        "locators": {
          "pages": [
            10,
            17
          ],
          "locator": "PDF physical pages 10, 17"
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-CIMC-A16",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/17",
      "source_file_sha256": "D8407737E600EECB00DBB960B385027EE50F7B86D7FD5BBDE9B641575FD46DC0",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUN-MCH-A04",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUN-MCH-A04",
      "edition_id": "bach-extension",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-021AD52A222A9612CF2C",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:6E88E2AC7571791EFCD03D4AB35FD7D724BFA0E388821BF51F2BD72610DD5BBF",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
      "title": "Keep information distinct while joining it together",
      "conclusion": "Micah's June 2022 Git-recorded note separates binding from the distinctions needed for information. Bach and Sorensen's reviewed MCH version likewise coordinates differentiated models and builds represented structure through contrast; the shared function does not equate physical synchrony with model consistency.",
      "shared": "Keep distinguishable patterns available within coordinated activity; compare or select contributions rather than erase all differences through undifferentiated binding.",
      "relation": "inherited source-reviewed partial",
      "residual": "No June definition of semantic constraint violation or MCH implementation of this oscillator mechanism; no identity between physical coherence and representational consistency. Neither document proves the neuroscience.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_FUNCTIONAL_OR_OPERATIONAL_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "Partial at the functional level: June separates coupling from distinction and gives the oscillator a reference against which incoming deviations are measured (36); MCH adjusts the contributions of distinct partial models (17-18), while its contrast operation creates a dimension of difference (20). Physical phase synchronization is not constraint satisfaction.",
          "formal_ceiling": "No proved mathematical isomorphism, bisimulation, functor or implementation equivalence; theoretical correspondence is not experimental validation."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_CAUSAL_OR_NARRATIVE_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "June's coupling-without-distinction objection -> differential reference -> knowledge/pattern selection aligns with the coordination-plus-differentiation problem. MCH supplies an explicit conflict -> attentional intervention -> coherent-scene architecture absent as a joined operation in this June note."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "BOUNDED_REVERSE_RECONSTRUCTION_WITH_ALTERNATIVES_OPEN",
          "reasoning": "Reverse from a coherent but differentiated scene: distinctions and selective coordination are required. June supplies these constituents, not a unique derivation of MCH's conductor or its constraint-minimization criterion.",
          "chronological_constraint": "Only this exact 2022-06-08T18:32:00-07:00 Git-record-dated formulation is compared against the selected 2026-01-15 target version. Earlier source and target routes remain open; no unique derivation, independent first-publication proof, whole-program firstness or influence follows."
        }
      },
      "formal": null,
      "citation_boundary": "Citation/omission, access and dependence are not adjudicated by this bounded review.",
      "program_history": "Whole-program before/after history remains separate from this selected document comparison.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Keep information distinct while joining it together",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/37da575ba33f85cef4239295be161066d8d39f4c/a0142z%20ctpr.txt",
        "sha256": "6E88E2AC7571791EFCD03D4AB35FD7D724BFA0E388821BF51F2BD72610DD5BBF",
        "date": "2022-06-08",
        "date_type": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "date_boundary": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "the problem is that synchronization or coherence is non-informative, its a solution for binding, for convergence, coupling of patterns, but not for distinction making, decoherence, deconvergence, decoupling of of ideas & concepts"
        ],
        "locators": [
          9,
          11,
          19,
          24,
          34,
          36,
          38,
          40
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcHypothesis.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "date": "2026-01-15",
        "date_type": "Selected document-version date, not proof this wording appeared in the initial publication",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": null,
        "summary": "The later paper coordinates different models and uses contrast to build represented structure. This shares the need for both coordination and differences.",
        "locators": {
          "physical_pages": [
            17,
            18,
            20
          ],
          "printed_pages": [
            16,
            17,
            19
          ],
          "sections": [
            "The operation of consciousness",
            "Genesis: How consciousness creates the world and the self in the mind"
          ]
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUN-MCH-A04",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/0",
      "source_file_sha256": "3A6EDA4752A6283D386F130F28EE5C4CC1B6FCF15DBB36C2509BE1F8301C11B1",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUN-CIMC-A04",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUN-CIMC-A04",
      "edition_id": "bach-extension",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-021AD52A222A9612CF2C",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:6E88E2AC7571791EFCD03D4AB35FD7D724BFA0E388821BF51F2BD72610DD5BBF",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
      "title": "Keep information distinct while joining it together",
      "conclusion": "Micah's June 2022 Git-recorded note argues that coordination must still permit distinctions. CIMC's reviewed 2026 whitepaper coordinates distinct partial models through conflict-sensitive adjustment. This is a partial functional correspondence, not identity of physical and representational coherence.",
      "shared": "Coordinate differentiated components while retaining information-bearing distinctions, using selective interaction rather than merely pooling signals.",
      "relation": "inherited source-reviewed partial",
      "residual": "Physical synchrony, oscillator baseline and semantic model consistency remain different variables. No demonstrated equivalence between June phase deviations and requests/confirmations or constraint reduction.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_FUNCTIONAL_OR_OPERATIONAL_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "Partial coordination/differentiation function: June's receiver-relative deviations and pattern selection map to preserving multiple representations and selectively adjusting or suppressing them (CIMC11); local exchange at19 is a possible implementation-level comparison, not the same oscillatory mechanism.",
          "formal_ceiling": "No proved mathematical isomorphism, bisimulation, functor or implementation equivalence; theoretical correspondence is not experimental validation."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_CAUSAL_OR_NARRATIVE_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "June rejects binding alone as an explanation of distinction. CIMC's many partial models -> detected conflicts -> adjustment or below-awareness suppression is more specified; both require organized interaction of non-identical contributors."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "BOUNDED_REVERSE_RECONSTRUCTION_WITH_ALTERNATIVES_OPEN",
          "reasoning": "Reverse from a globally coherent interpretation with multiple modalities: differentiated inputs and selective coordination are necessary. June is an antecedent for this bounded problem/operation, not a demonstrated solution to CIMC's complete self-organized second-order-perception criterion.",
          "chronological_constraint": "Only this exact 2022-06-08T18:32:00-07:00 Git-record-dated formulation is compared against the selected 2026-04-27 target version. Earlier source and target routes remain open; no unique derivation, independent first-publication proof, whole-program firstness or influence follows."
        }
      },
      "formal": null,
      "citation_boundary": "Citation/omission, access and dependence are not adjudicated by this bounded review.",
      "program_history": "Whole-program before/after history remains separate from this selected document comparison.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Keep information distinct while joining it together",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/37da575ba33f85cef4239295be161066d8d39f4c/a0142z%20ctpr.txt",
        "sha256": "6E88E2AC7571791EFCD03D4AB35FD7D724BFA0E388821BF51F2BD72610DD5BBF",
        "date": "2022-06-08",
        "date_type": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "date_boundary": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "the problem is that synchronization or coherence is non-informative, its a solution for binding, for convergence, coupling of patterns, but not for distinction making, decoherence, deconvergence, decoupling of of ideas & concepts"
        ],
        "locators": [
          9,
          11,
          19,
          24,
          34,
          36,
          38,
          40
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Consciousness Is Model Coherence",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen",
          "Franz Hildebrandt-Harangozó",
          "Lou de Kerhuelvez",
          "Jim Rutt"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcWhitepaper.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
        "date": "2026-04-27",
        "date_type": "Selected document-version date, not proof this wording appeared in the initial publication",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": null,
        "summary": "The later whitepaper coordinates distinct models and adjusts their contributions when they conflict. The shared function is selective coordination without losing distinctions.",
        "locators": {
          "physical_pages": [
            11,
            13,
            18,
            19
          ],
          "printed_pages": [
            10,
            12,
            17,
            18
          ],
          "sections": [
            "Coherence",
            "An Operational Definition of Consciousness",
            "Research Directions"
          ]
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUN-CIMC-A04",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/1",
      "source_file_sha256": "3A6EDA4752A6283D386F130F28EE5C4CC1B6FCF15DBB36C2509BE1F8301C11B1",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUL-MCH-A05",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUL-MCH-A05",
      "edition_id": "bach-extension",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-6E739C144FF6999D8EC0",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:D6C617135E5838F0DF7B99FBEDFE3941F743A59FFFEE59A0F294C5EF7012F53A",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
      "title": "Check the brain’s own representations for disagreement",
      "conclusion": "Micah's July 2022 Git-recorded discussion proposes checking internal representations by sampling and cross-referencing them to notice inconsistency. MCH's reviewed version likewise makes conflicts between partial models a focus of conscious attention; the common subchain is comparison and discrepancy detection, not an equation of rarity with contradiction.",
      "shared": "Maintain or obtain multiple representations -> compare/cross-reference them -> notice inconsistent content -> bring the discrepancy into a process that organizes the represented scene.",
      "relation": "inherited source-reviewed partial",
      "residual": "Rarity != inconsistency; noisy deviations may fail the recognition threshold. July does not provide MCH's explicit global constraint objective, conductor architecture or specific repair algorithm.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_FUNCTIONAL_OR_OPERATIONAL_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "Supported partial operational chain from July159-179, not from rarity alone: sample and cross-reference represented results, detect contradiction, cross a recognition threshold. MCH detects conflict between concurrent partial models and directs attention to it; its subsequent model adjustment is more explicit.",
          "formal_ceiling": "No proved mathematical isomorphism, bisimulation, functor or implementation equivalence; theoretical correspondence is not experimental validation."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_CAUSAL_OR_NARRATIVE_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "July connects multimodal coincidence (136-140), checking representation accuracy (151-171), and recognition of a constructed reality (175-179). This aligns with MCH's partial models -> disharmony -> directed attention -> organized perceptual scene through the comparison/detection portion."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "BOUNDED_REVERSE_RECONSTRUCTION_WITH_ALTERNATIVES_OPEN",
          "reasoning": "Reverse from a coherent reconstruction of a scene: a system must distinguish conflicting representations from a jointly supported account. July's checking narrative supports this antecedent; rarity in Shannon's sense does not by itself derive semantic contradiction.",
          "chronological_constraint": "Only this exact 2022-07-06T20:15:38-07:00 Git-record-dated formulation is compared against the selected 2026-01-15 target version. Earlier source and target routes remain open; no unique derivation, independent first-publication proof, whole-program firstness or influence follows."
        }
      },
      "formal": null,
      "citation_boundary": "Citation/omission, access and dependence are not adjudicated by this bounded review.",
      "program_history": "Whole-program before/after history remains separate from this selected document comparison.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Check the brain’s own representations for disagreement",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/6ab9773f25d460c305d1d2de9a8ee5e0ca03ee4a/b0038y.md",
        "sha256": "D6C617135E5838F0DF7B99FBEDFE3941F743A59FFFEE59A0F294C5EF7012F53A",
        "date": "2022-07-06",
        "date_type": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "date_boundary": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "Is there a way for a natural brain to check its own results, to check for pattern representation accuracy. one way to do that would be to sort of do to take multiple samples like sort of like with with and cross reference them, it's like, okay well I'm gonna attack multiple times and if something is true then it's gonna be true."
        ],
        "locators": [
          5,
          7,
          9,
          31,
          136,
          140,
          151,
          155,
          159,
          163,
          167,
          171,
          175,
          179
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcHypothesis.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "date": "2026-01-15",
        "date_type": "Selected document-version date, not proof this wording appeared in the initial publication",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": null,
        "summary": "The later paper directs attention toward conflicts between partial models. The shared operation is comparing representations and detecting disagreement.",
        "locators": {
          "physical_pages": [
            17,
            18
          ],
          "printed_pages": [
            16,
            17
          ],
          "sections": [
            "The operation of consciousness"
          ]
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUL-MCH-A05",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/2",
      "source_file_sha256": "3A6EDA4752A6283D386F130F28EE5C4CC1B6FCF15DBB36C2509BE1F8301C11B1",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUL-CIMC-A05",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUL-CIMC-A05",
      "edition_id": "bach-extension",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-6E739C144FF6999D8EC0",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:D6C617135E5838F0DF7B99FBEDFE3941F743A59FFFEE59A0F294C5EF7012F53A",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
      "title": "Check the brain’s own representations for disagreement",
      "conclusion": "Micah's July 2022 Git-recorded proposal cross-checks representations and notices inconsistency. CIMC's reviewed 2026 whitepaper likewise detects conflicts among partial models before coordinating them. The shared checking operation survives different implementations; rarity alone is not the match.",
      "shared": "Compare information from multiple representations/modalities -> detect disagreement -> recognize the discrepancy as relevant to the system's constructed account.",
      "relation": "inherited source-reviewed partial",
      "residual": "Global optimization, simultaneous model constraints, suppression of unresolved content and distributed negotiation are target-specific elaborations not recovered as a single July algorithm.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_FUNCTIONAL_OR_OPERATIONAL_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "July159-179 explicitly supplies cross-referencing, inconsistency detection and recognition thresholds; CIMC11 supplies comparison/conflict detection and attention. CIMC19 adds iterative requests/confirmations, which is not established in July.",
          "formal_ceiling": "No proved mathematical isomorphism, bisimulation, functor or implementation equivalence; theoretical correspondence is not experimental validation."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_CAUSAL_OR_NARRATIVE_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "July's multimodal associations -> accuracy check -> contradiction recognition -> constructed reality shares a causal prefix with CIMC's competing models -> conflict detection -> coordinated revision. Repeated sampling is not automatically the same as simultaneously active partial models."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "BOUNDED_REVERSE_RECONSTRUCTION_WITH_ALTERNATIVES_OPEN",
          "reasoning": "Reverse from consistent multi-model organization: a discrepancy-sensitive cross-check is a plausible necessary component. July supplies that component without licensing an identity between rare neural variations and constraint violations or the entire CIMC solution.",
          "chronological_constraint": "Only this exact 2022-07-06T20:15:38-07:00 Git-record-dated formulation is compared against the selected 2026-04-27 target version. Earlier source and target routes remain open; no unique derivation, independent first-publication proof, whole-program firstness or influence follows."
        }
      },
      "formal": null,
      "citation_boundary": "Citation/omission, access and dependence are not adjudicated by this bounded review.",
      "program_history": "Whole-program before/after history remains separate from this selected document comparison.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Check the brain’s own representations for disagreement",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/6ab9773f25d460c305d1d2de9a8ee5e0ca03ee4a/b0038y.md",
        "sha256": "D6C617135E5838F0DF7B99FBEDFE3941F743A59FFFEE59A0F294C5EF7012F53A",
        "date": "2022-07-06",
        "date_type": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "date_boundary": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "Is there a way for a natural brain to check its own results, to check for pattern representation accuracy. one way to do that would be to sort of do to take multiple samples like sort of like with with and cross reference them, it's like, okay well I'm gonna attack multiple times and if something is true then it's gonna be true."
        ],
        "locators": [
          5,
          7,
          9,
          31,
          136,
          140,
          151,
          155,
          159,
          163,
          167,
          171,
          175,
          179
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Consciousness Is Model Coherence",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen",
          "Franz Hildebrandt-Harangozó",
          "Lou de Kerhuelvez",
          "Jim Rutt"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcWhitepaper.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
        "date": "2026-04-27",
        "date_type": "Selected document-version date, not proof this wording appeared in the initial publication",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": null,
        "summary": "The later whitepaper detects conflicts between partial models before coordinating them. The match is the checking step, not an identical correction algorithm.",
        "locators": {
          "physical_pages": [
            11,
            18,
            19
          ],
          "printed_pages": [
            10,
            17,
            18
          ],
          "sections": [
            "Coherence",
            "Interpretive Validation",
            "Research Directions"
          ]
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUL-CIMC-A05",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/3",
      "source_file_sha256": "3A6EDA4752A6283D386F130F28EE5C4CC1B6FCF15DBB36C2509BE1F8301C11B1",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022SEP-MCH-A06",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022SEP-MCH-A06",
      "edition_id": "bach-extension",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-D55A1FE63EF767A869A8",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:66642AF5B4CC43F0CE252FAEF42970A6EEC57D0BAFE214A682E10E564D5CDC9E",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
      "title": "Build an internal world, then register it again",
      "conclusion": "Micah's September 2022 Git-recorded account builds experienced self and world from contrasts in a continuing field and makes rendered patterns available to the brain again. MCH's reviewed Genesis passage also builds represented space, objects and self through differences, alongside reflexive perception. This supports a shared construction narrative, not the same neural mechanism.",
      "shared": "An initially undifferentiated representational field/substrate gains contrasts -> those distinctions organize an internally constructed world and self -> the system registers its own represented/perceptual activity.",
      "relation": "inherited source-reviewed partial",
      "residual": "No target endorsement of specific tonic frequencies, anatomical assignments, phase-wave tomography or excitatory/inhibitory implementation. Re-reading outputs alone is not proof of MCH's synchronous second-order phenomenology, and the sources remain hypotheses.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_FUNCTIONAL_OR_OPERATIONAL_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "A substantial bounded functional correspondence: September18 differentiates raw awareness into self/world by contrast, and24 makes output available to renewed internal perception; MCH20 creates difference dimensions, space, objects and self, while15-16 supplies reflexive perceptual registration. MCH does not supply tonic neural implementation.",
          "formal_ceiling": "No proved mathematical isomorphism, bisimulation, functor or implementation equivalence; theoretical correspondence is not experimental validation."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_CAUSAL_OR_NARRATIVE_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "The contrast -> organized experiential world -> represented self narrative is directly present on both sides, not merely inferred from the word rendering. September additionally specifies recurrent cellular rendering; MCH's Genesis claim makes consciousness an early organizing prerequisite, not simply a mature output."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "BOUNDED_REVERSE_RECONSTRUCTION_WITH_ALTERNATIVES_OPEN",
          "reasoning": "Reverse from an internally constructed self-in-world: a differentiable medium, organization of relations and perceptual availability are required. September explicitly supplies this chain. The reverse mapping cannot recover all of MCH's developmental priority claims or its conductor operation.",
          "chronological_constraint": "Only this exact 2022-09-17T23:23:08-07:00 Git-record-dated formulation is compared against the selected 2026-01-15 target version. Earlier source and target routes remain open; no unique derivation, independent first-publication proof, whole-program firstness or influence follows."
        }
      },
      "formal": null,
      "citation_boundary": "Citation/omission, access and dependence are not adjudicated by this bounded review.",
      "program_history": "Whole-program before/after history remains separate from this selected document comparison.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Build an internal world, then register it again",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/7129fcf82a9d42665a1372ecdc803e912bc81b6a/a0310zNAPOT5.md",
        "sha256": "66642AF5B4CC43F0CE252FAEF42970A6EEC57D0BAFE214A682E10E564D5CDC9E",
        "date": "2022-09-17",
        "date_type": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "date_boundary": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "The brain is effectively doing computational rendering & then reading it’s own output pattern, from neuronal outputs, as that pattern is looped or played back to the neural network of the brain which detects it, with neuronal inputs, and re-renders (outputs it again) with new sensor input data."
        ],
        "locators": [
          14,
          18,
          20,
          22,
          24,
          30,
          34,
          36,
          56,
          60,
          89,
          91,
          93,
          99
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcHypothesis.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "date": "2026-01-15",
        "date_type": "Selected document-version date, not proof this wording appeared in the initial publication",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": null,
        "summary": "The later Genesis account builds represented space, objects and self through differences. Elsewhere the paper makes perception itself available to perception.",
        "locators": {
          "physical_pages": [
            15,
            16,
            18,
            19,
            20,
            21
          ],
          "printed_pages": [
            14,
            15,
            17,
            18,
            19,
            20
          ],
          "sections": [
            "The phenomenology of consciousness",
            "The Genesis Hypothesis",
            "Genesis: How consciousness creates the world and the self in the mind",
            "The Human Consciousness Hypothesis"
          ]
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022SEP-MCH-A06",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/4",
      "source_file_sha256": "3A6EDA4752A6283D386F130F28EE5C4CC1B6FCF15DBB36C2509BE1F8301C11B1",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022SEP-CIMC-A06",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022SEP-CIMC-A06",
      "edition_id": "bach-extension",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-D55A1FE63EF767A869A8",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:66642AF5B4CC43F0CE252FAEF42970A6EEC57D0BAFE214A682E10E564D5CDC9E",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
      "title": "Build an internal world, then register it again",
      "conclusion": "Micah's September 2022 Git-recorded account has neural activity render self/world patterns and receive its own output again. CIMC's reviewed whitepaper similarly proposes self-organization of the substrate's own activity and reflexive perceptual representation. The common subchain is internal construction and re-entry, with its stricter perceptual constraints left separate.",
      "shared": "Operate on the substrate's own activity -> organize differentiated representations of self/world -> make the perceptual process internally available -> iteratively maintain organized experience.",
      "relation": "inherited source-reviewed partial",
      "residual": "No whitepaper-specific Genesis contrast-to-space narrative equivalent to MCH20, and no stated tonic baseline/burst/inhibition mechanism. Perceptual same-level encoding and epistemic transparency stay unproved in this SAN passage.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_FUNCTIONAL_OR_OPERATIONAL_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "Partial re-entrant organization: September24 renders, receives its own output and re-renders with input; CIMC11 iteratively organizes its own activity patterns and11-13 makes the perceptual process present in its represented field. This is stronger than shared rendering vocabulary but not a matched neural algorithm.",
          "formal_ceiling": "No proved mathematical isomorphism, bisimulation, functor or implementation equivalence; theoretical correspondence is not experimental validation."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_CAUSAL_OR_NARRATIVE_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "September's differentiated activity -> represented self/world -> recurrent observation shares a causal subchain with CIMC's self-organizing activity -> coherent representational structures -> reflexive perception. September's tonic contrast account is not explicitly repeated in this target."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "BOUNDED_REVERSE_RECONSTRUCTION_WITH_ALTERNATIVES_OPEN",
          "reasoning": "Reverse from an internally available constructed experiential world: representation formation and access to one's own activity are plausible prerequisites. September supplies them. Same-level encoding, transparency and global coherence are additional CIMC constraints not derived solely from recurrent output.",
          "chronological_constraint": "Only this exact 2022-09-17T23:23:08-07:00 Git-record-dated formulation is compared against the selected 2026-04-27 target version. Earlier source and target routes remain open; no unique derivation, independent first-publication proof, whole-program firstness or influence follows."
        }
      },
      "formal": null,
      "citation_boundary": "Citation/omission, access and dependence are not adjudicated by this bounded review.",
      "program_history": "Whole-program before/after history remains separate from this selected document comparison.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Build an internal world, then register it again",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/7129fcf82a9d42665a1372ecdc803e912bc81b6a/a0310zNAPOT5.md",
        "sha256": "66642AF5B4CC43F0CE252FAEF42970A6EEC57D0BAFE214A682E10E564D5CDC9E",
        "date": "2022-09-17",
        "date_type": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "date_boundary": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "The brain is effectively doing computational rendering & then reading it’s own output pattern, from neuronal outputs, as that pattern is looped or played back to the neural network of the brain which detects it, with neuronal inputs, and re-renders (outputs it again) with new sensor input data."
        ],
        "locators": [
          14,
          18,
          20,
          22,
          24,
          30,
          34,
          36,
          56,
          60,
          89,
          91,
          93,
          99
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Consciousness Is Model Coherence",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen",
          "Franz Hildebrandt-Harangozó",
          "Lou de Kerhuelvez",
          "Jim Rutt"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcWhitepaper.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
        "date": "2026-04-27",
        "date_type": "Selected document-version date, not proof this wording appeared in the initial publication",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": null,
        "summary": "The later whitepaper proposes organizing the system’s own activity into representations and making perception internally available. This shares internal construction and re-entry, while adding further conditions.",
        "locators": {
          "physical_pages": [
            10,
            11,
            12,
            13,
            18,
            19
          ],
          "printed_pages": [
            9,
            10,
            11,
            12,
            17,
            18
          ],
          "sections": [
            "A Hypothesis on Consciousness",
            "Genesis",
            "Second-order perception",
            "An Operational Definition of Consciousness",
            "Research Directions"
          ]
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022SEP-CIMC-A06",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/5",
      "source_file_sha256": "3A6EDA4752A6283D386F130F28EE5C4CC1B6FCF15DBB36C2509BE1F8301C11B1",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-MCH-A07",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-MCH-A07",
      "edition_id": "bach-extension",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-FE0AEFC9EE0EFEF388C7",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:D6C617135E5838F0DF7B99FBEDFE3941F743A59FFFEE59A0F294C5EF7012F53A",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
      "title": "Look inside an artificial mind, not only at its answers",
      "conclusion": "Micah's July 2022 Git-recorded discussion calls for criteria grounded in what artificial neural networks do internally, distinct from intelligence alone. MCH's reviewed version also makes internal organization central to consciousness testing. Its stronger argument against a behavior-only test is not established by this July passage.",
      "shared": "Use a theory of internal organization to identify candidate artificial consciousness, distinguish it from intelligent output alone, and guide what is constructed or assessed.",
      "relation": "inherited source-reviewed partial",
      "residual": "No validated July consciousness diagnostic, no complete necessary-and-sufficient test, no demonstrated exclusion of all behavior-only methods; MCH also frames its tests as a research program with failure possibilities.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_FUNCTIONAL_OR_OPERATIONAL_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "A methodological/functional partial: July23/29/31/203/207/223 ties proposed criteria to neural representations and mechanisms; MCH23 requires internal structure rather than performance alone, and24 proposes theory-guided developmental construction.",
          "formal_ceiling": "No proved mathematical isomorphism, bisimulation, functor or implementation equivalence; theoretical correspondence is not experimental validation."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_CAUSAL_OR_NARRATIVE_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "July mechanism account -> recognition criteria -> artificial-network assessment -> ethical concern shares the construction/assessment portion of MCH's hypothesis -> simulation -> structure-sensitive test. July is not an argued behavior-only impossibility theorem."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "BOUNDED_REVERSE_RECONSTRUCTION_WITH_ALTERNATIVES_OPEN",
          "reasoning": "Reverse from knowing whether an artificial system is conscious: a criterion tied to what the system does internally is needed under both accounts. July offers that research demand, not MCH's logical argument that behavior alone cannot settle the question.",
          "chronological_constraint": "Only this exact 2022-07-06T20:15:38-07:00 Git-record-dated formulation is compared against the selected 2026-01-15 target version. Earlier source and target routes remain open; no unique derivation, independent first-publication proof, whole-program firstness or influence follows."
        }
      },
      "formal": null,
      "citation_boundary": "Citation/omission, access and dependence are not adjudicated by this bounded review.",
      "program_history": "Whole-program before/after history remains separate from this selected document comparison.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Look inside an artificial mind, not only at its answers",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/6ab9773f25d460c305d1d2de9a8ee5e0ca03ee4a/b0038y.md",
        "sha256": "D6C617135E5838F0DF7B99FBEDFE3941F743A59FFFEE59A0F294C5EF7012F53A",
        "date": "2022-07-06",
        "date_type": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "date_boundary": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "We need a guidebook for when an artificial neural network becomes conscious."
        ],
        "locators": [
          23,
          29,
          31,
          114,
          136,
          140,
          159,
          195,
          199,
          203,
          207,
          211,
          223,
          253
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcHypothesis.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "date": "2026-01-15",
        "date_type": "Selected document-version date, not proof this wording appeared in the initial publication",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": null,
        "summary": "The later paper makes internal organization important to testing consciousness. It also develops a stronger argument against relying on behavior alone.",
        "locators": {
          "physical_pages": [
            21,
            22,
            23,
            24
          ],
          "printed_pages": [
            20,
            21,
            22,
            23
          ],
          "sections": [
            "Testing the Machine Consciousness Hypothesis",
            "Why there can be no Turing Test for consciousness",
            "Universality"
          ]
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-MCH-A07",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/6",
      "source_file_sha256": "3A6EDA4752A6283D386F130F28EE5C4CC1B6FCF15DBB36C2509BE1F8301C11B1",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-CIMC-A07",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-CIMC-A07",
      "edition_id": "bach-extension",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-FE0AEFC9EE0EFEF388C7",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:D6C617135E5838F0DF7B99FBEDFE3941F743A59FFFEE59A0F294C5EF7012F53A",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
      "title": "Look inside an artificial mind, not only at its answers",
      "conclusion": "Micah's July 2022 Git-recorded proposal connects artificial-consciousness criteria to internal neural operations and ethical treatment. CIMC's reviewed whitepaper also couples construction with analysis of internal organization and alternative explanations. The shared research method does not establish a validated test.",
      "shared": "Ground artificial-consciousness criteria in a proposed internal mechanism -> examine candidate networks or construct test systems -> assess implications for their treatment.",
      "relation": "inherited source-reviewed partial",
      "residual": "No tested discriminator, converged definition of consciousness or validated internal signature in July. CIMC itself says neither behavioral performance nor weights alone can directly identify consciousness.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_FUNCTIONAL_OR_OPERATIONAL_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "July's mechanism-linked criteria and distinction from intelligence partially correspond to CIMC6/17/18's construction plus interpretive analysis of internal organization. This is a methodological operation, not a demonstrated equivalence of classifiers.",
          "formal_ceiling": "No proved mathematical isomorphism, bisimulation, functor or implementation equivalence; theoretical correspondence is not experimental validation."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_CAUSAL_OR_NARRATIVE_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "July actual neural operations -> criteria for consciousness -> understanding networks/ethical risk aligns with CIMC theory -> designed systems -> internal/behavioral evidence -> alternatives -> responsibility. Explicit comparison with alternative explanations is more developed in CIMC."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "BOUNDED_REVERSE_RECONSTRUCTION_WITH_ALTERNATIVES_OPEN",
          "reasoning": "Reverse from responsible identification of candidate conscious systems: explain what internally realizes the hypothesized capacity, not merely whether it performs impressively. July supplies this bounded antecedent without furnishing CIMC's full inference-to-best-explanation procedure.",
          "chronological_constraint": "Only this exact 2022-07-06T20:15:38-07:00 Git-record-dated formulation is compared against the selected 2026-04-27 target version. Earlier source and target routes remain open; no unique derivation, independent first-publication proof, whole-program firstness or influence follows."
        }
      },
      "formal": null,
      "citation_boundary": "Citation/omission, access and dependence are not adjudicated by this bounded review.",
      "program_history": "Whole-program before/after history remains separate from this selected document comparison.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Look inside an artificial mind, not only at its answers",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/6ab9773f25d460c305d1d2de9a8ee5e0ca03ee4a/b0038y.md",
        "sha256": "D6C617135E5838F0DF7B99FBEDFE3941F743A59FFFEE59A0F294C5EF7012F53A",
        "date": "2022-07-06",
        "date_type": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "date_boundary": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "We need a guidebook for when an artificial neural network becomes conscious."
        ],
        "locators": [
          23,
          29,
          31,
          114,
          136,
          140,
          159,
          195,
          199,
          203,
          207,
          211,
          223,
          253
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Consciousness Is Model Coherence",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen",
          "Franz Hildebrandt-Harangozó",
          "Lou de Kerhuelvez",
          "Jim Rutt"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcWhitepaper.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
        "date": "2026-04-27",
        "date_type": "Selected document-version date, not proof this wording appeared in the initial publication",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": null,
        "summary": "The later whitepaper pairs building artificial systems with examining their internal organization and alternative explanations. Both make this a research method, not a finished consciousness test.",
        "locators": {
          "physical_pages": [
            6,
            17,
            18,
            19
          ],
          "printed_pages": [
            5,
            16,
            17,
            18
          ],
          "sections": [
            "Research program introduction",
            "From Theory to Construction",
            "Interpretive Validation",
            "Ethical Considerations"
          ]
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-CIMC-A07",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/7",
      "source_file_sha256": "3A6EDA4752A6283D386F130F28EE5C4CC1B6FCF15DBB36C2509BE1F8301C11B1",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-MCH-A08",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-MCH-A08",
      "edition_id": "bach-extension",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-8DA5EC3F35F784C69F8A",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:D73632B6DF40CD48127C28B76B8B7965E22E4271BEA54F906E606F97D4E944C8",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
      "title": "An artificial mind develops; it is not just a snapshot",
      "conclusion": "Micah's November 2022 Git-recorded proposal distinguishes immediate experiential states from longer structural stages and applies both to artificial minds. MCH's reviewed Genesis account likewise makes developmental organization important to constructing self/world models. The shared developmental framing does not equate their mechanisms.",
      "shared": "Treat an artificial mind as something whose internal organization develops over time, not solely as a snapshot of present performance; design learning conditions that can alter that organization.",
      "relation": "inherited source-reviewed partial",
      "residual": "States/stages is explicitly attributed to AQAL or Spiral Dynamics (11). Synaptic phase, growth/decay thresholds and implementation hardware are not MCH's developmental mechanism; no backdating this mature wording to June or to an older heading.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_FUNCTIONAL_OR_OPERATIONAL_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "Partial developmental-design operation: November5/9/13/19 links short-lived states to longer structural changes and proposes simulating both; MCH19/21/24 studies development that constructs self/world organization. Target does not operationalize the same fast/slow synaptic split.",
          "formal_ceiling": "No proved mathematical isomorphism, bisimulation, functor or implementation equivalence; theoretical correspondence is not experimental validation."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_CAUSAL_OR_NARRATIVE_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "November experiences plus accumulated connection changes -> threshold changes in perspective -> developing robot mind aligns with MCH's learning trajectory -> organized self/world model. MCH's consciousness-before-complex-cognition claim is not supplied by that states/stages contrast."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "BOUNDED_REVERSE_RECONSTRUCTION_WITH_ALTERNATIVES_OPEN",
          "reasoning": "Reverse from a developed artificial mind: inspect or simulate its path of organization, rather than only a present state. November is a dated developmental antecedent; it does not derive Genesis as a universal biological learning algorithm.",
          "chronological_constraint": "Only this exact 2022-11-28T18:09:11-08:00 Git-record-dated formulation is compared against the selected 2026-01-15 target version. Earlier source and target routes remain open; no unique derivation, independent first-publication proof, whole-program firstness or influence follows."
        }
      },
      "formal": null,
      "citation_boundary": "Citation/omission, access and dependence are not adjudicated by this bounded review.",
      "program_history": "Whole-program before/after history remains separate from this selected document comparison.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "An artificial mind develops; it is not just a snapshot",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0320z.md",
        "sha256": "D73632B6DF40CD48127C28B76B8B7965E22E4271BEA54F906E606F97D4E944C8",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "date_boundary": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "It's a concept that means we, as robots, can have computed short term state experiences, with synaptic phase changes, and long term stage changes, with (real or simulated) synaptic growth or decay which takes longer to happen."
        ],
        "locators": [
          3,
          5,
          7,
          9,
          11,
          13,
          15,
          17,
          19
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcHypothesis.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "date": "2026-01-15",
        "date_type": "Selected document-version date, not proof this wording appeared in the initial publication",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": null,
        "summary": "The later Genesis account makes development important to constructing a self and world model. The shared developmental direction does not require identical learning mechanisms.",
        "locators": {
          "physical_pages": [
            19,
            21,
            24
          ],
          "printed_pages": [
            18,
            20,
            23
          ],
          "sections": [
            "The Genesis Hypothesis",
            "The Human Consciousness Hypothesis",
            "Universality"
          ]
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-MCH-A08",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/8",
      "source_file_sha256": "3A6EDA4752A6283D386F130F28EE5C4CC1B6FCF15DBB36C2509BE1F8301C11B1",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-CIMC-A08",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-CIMC-A08",
      "edition_id": "bach-extension",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-9703F49EDC8DFFE970D1",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:D73632B6DF40CD48127C28B76B8B7965E22E4271BEA54F906E606F97D4E944C8",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
      "title": "An artificial mind develops; it is not just a snapshot",
      "conclusion": "Micah's November 2022 Git-recorded proposal connects long-term neural changes to threshold-like developmental stages in artificial minds. CIMC's reviewed whitepaper asks whether developmental trajectories show predicted transitions alongside new internal organization. This is a shared developmental test direction, not an equation of synaptic phase with developmental phase transitions.",
      "shared": "Observe an artificial system's developmental trajectory for changes in internal organization, including threshold-like transitions associated with new capacities.",
      "relation": "inherited source-reviewed partial",
      "residual": "CIMC's phase transitions are not specified as synaptic phase shifts or LTP/LTD, and November does not establish the target's coherence-plus-metarepresentation transition. General states/stages is acknowledged background from AQAL/Spiral Dynamics.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_FUNCTIONAL_OR_OPERATIONAL_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "Supported partial transition/assessment mapping: November9 explicitly proposes threshold changes in stages from accumulated growth/decay; CIMC18 asks whether developmental trajectories show predicted phase transitions and links marked cross-modal improvement to emergent internal structures.",
          "formal_ceiling": "No proved mathematical isomorphism, bisimulation, functor or implementation equivalence; theoretical correspondence is not experimental validation."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_CAUSAL_OR_NARRATIVE_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "November ongoing experience and slow connection change -> qualitative stage -> mature artificial mind corresponds to CIMC self-organization/developmental pressure -> emergent organization and improved integration -> evidence to evaluate. Different causes remain visible."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "BOUNDED_REVERSE_RECONSTRUCTION_WITH_ALTERNATIVES_OPEN",
          "reasoning": "Reverse from a newly organized artificial cognitive capacity: developmental evidence and qualitative changes matter. November supplies a threshold-stage antecedent; frequency phase and dynamical developmental phase transition are not interchangeable.",
          "chronological_constraint": "Only this exact 2022-11-28T18:09:11-08:00 Git-record-dated formulation is compared against the selected 2026-04-27 target version. Earlier source and target routes remain open; no unique derivation, independent first-publication proof, whole-program firstness or influence follows."
        }
      },
      "formal": null,
      "citation_boundary": "Citation/omission, access and dependence are not adjudicated by this bounded review.",
      "program_history": "Whole-program before/after history remains separate from this selected document comparison.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "An artificial mind develops; it is not just a snapshot",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0320z.md",
        "sha256": "D73632B6DF40CD48127C28B76B8B7965E22E4271BEA54F906E606F97D4E944C8",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "date_boundary": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "Imagine that Synaptic Connections via Growth LTP & Decay LTD, over a long term, results in eventual threshold changes that we can identify as Stages, or major changes in live perspective that only happen after a very long time, or only happen after a very big life event."
        ],
        "locators": [
          3,
          5,
          7,
          9,
          11,
          13,
          15,
          17,
          19
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Consciousness Is Model Coherence",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen",
          "Franz Hildebrandt-Harangozó",
          "Lou de Kerhuelvez",
          "Jim Rutt"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcWhitepaper.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
        "date": "2026-04-27",
        "date_type": "Selected document-version date, not proof this wording appeared in the initial publication",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": null,
        "summary": "The later whitepaper asks whether a developing system shows transitions alongside new internal organization. SAN’s earlier threshold-stage proposal supports this particular comparison.",
        "locators": {
          "physical_pages": [
            10,
            11,
            18
          ],
          "printed_pages": [
            9,
            10,
            17
          ],
          "sections": [
            "A Hypothesis on Consciousness",
            "Genesis",
            "Interpretive Validation"
          ]
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-CIMC-A08",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/9",
      "source_file_sha256": "3A6EDA4752A6283D386F130F28EE5C4CC1B6FCF15DBB36C2509BE1F8301C11B1",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-MCH-A09",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-MCH-A09",
      "edition_id": "bach-extension",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-DA13A8659C13071165F6",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:D6C617135E5838F0DF7B99FBEDFE3941F743A59FFFEE59A0F294C5EF7012F53A",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
      "title": "Perception can include the act of perceiving",
      "conclusion": "Micah's July 2022 Git-recorded discussion explicitly locates perceiving perception in neural operations, alongside internally rendered patterns received again. MCH's reviewed version also characterizes consciousness through perception that perception occurs. The partial reflexive correspondence does not establish identical timing or representational structure.",
      "shared": "A neural/computational process registers its own perceptual activity, with internal representations available to further perception rather than an unexplained outside viewer.",
      "relation": "inherited source-reviewed partial",
      "residual": "A following receiver alone could process content without representing that perception occurs. July does not establish MCH's immediate non-inferential synchronous form, and its self-as-direction (187) is not MCH's full observing-self model.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_FUNCTIONAL_OR_OPERATIONAL_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "July195 explicitly characterizes a neural mechanism as perceiving perception;31 supplies neural-array output received by another array and159 checking one's own results. MCH15 explicitly perceives that perception is occurring. This supports a partial reflexive function beyond a generic feed-forward receiver.",
          "formal_ceiling": "No proved mathematical isomorphism, bisimulation, functor or implementation equivalence; theoretical correspondence is not experimental validation."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_CAUSAL_OR_NARRATIVE_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "July rendered multimodal pattern -> subsequent reception/checking -> acknowledgment/perceiving perception aligns with MCH structured percept -> contemporaneous registration of observing. The source's ordered next-array story is not proof of subjective simultaneity."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "BOUNDED_REVERSE_RECONSTRUCTION_WITH_ALTERNATIVES_OPEN",
          "reasoning": "Reverse from awareness of perceiving: the system must make its own perceptual activity available to a perceptual process. July supplies that stated objective and candidate operation, not the complete sufficient conditions for second-order phenomenology.",
          "chronological_constraint": "Only this exact 2022-07-06T20:15:38-07:00 Git-record-dated formulation is compared against the selected 2026-01-15 target version. Earlier source and target routes remain open; no unique derivation, independent first-publication proof, whole-program firstness or influence follows."
        }
      },
      "formal": null,
      "citation_boundary": "Citation/omission, access and dependence are not adjudicated by this bounded review.",
      "program_history": "Whole-program before/after history remains separate from this selected document comparison.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Perception can include the act of perceiving",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/6ab9773f25d460c305d1d2de9a8ee5e0ca03ee4a/b0038y.md",
        "sha256": "D6C617135E5838F0DF7B99FBEDFE3941F743A59FFFEE59A0F294C5EF7012F53A",
        "date": "2022-07-06",
        "date_type": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "date_boundary": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "the one process in the machine is always seeking to know, it's always seeking to know is perceiving perception."
        ],
        "locators": [
          31,
          136,
          140,
          159,
          175,
          179,
          187,
          191,
          195,
          199
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcHypothesis.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "date": "2026-01-15",
        "date_type": "Selected document-version date, not proof this wording appeared in the initial publication",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": null,
        "summary": "The later paper also describes perception that perception is occurring. The shared reflexive function does not establish identical timing or structure.",
        "locators": {
          "physical_pages": [
            15,
            16,
            19
          ],
          "printed_pages": [
            14,
            15,
            18
          ],
          "sections": [
            "The phenomenology of consciousness",
            "Reflexive conductor question"
          ]
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-MCH-A09",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/10",
      "source_file_sha256": "3A6EDA4752A6283D386F130F28EE5C4CC1B6FCF15DBB36C2509BE1F8301C11B1",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-CIMC-A09",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-CIMC-A09",
      "edition_id": "bach-extension",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-DA13A8659C13071165F6",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:D6C617135E5838F0DF7B99FBEDFE3941F743A59FFFEE59A0F294C5EF7012F53A",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
      "title": "Perception can include the act of perceiving",
      "conclusion": "Micah's July 2022 Git-recorded proposal explicitly treats perceiving perception as neural activity. CIMC's reviewed whitepaper likewise makes reflexive perception central, while adding same-level encoding and transparency constraints not established by the July receiver description.",
      "shared": "The perceptual process becomes internally available as part of what the system registers; perception of perception is proposed as a function of the substrate's own activity.",
      "relation": "inherited source-reviewed partial",
      "residual": "Same-level metarepresentation, non-inferential synchrony, epistemic transparency and global-coherence linkage remain unresolved. The target itself says its precise format and constraints are still under development.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_FUNCTIONAL_OR_OPERATIONAL_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "July195 states the reflexive operation and31/159 supplies candidate re-reception and checking. CIMC11-13 explicitly requires perception of perception. Shared function is supported; same-level encoding and transparent representational format are extra target constraints.",
          "formal_ceiling": "No proved mathematical isomorphism, bisimulation, functor or implementation equivalence; theoretical correspondence is not experimental validation."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_CAUSAL_OR_NARRATIVE_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "July multimodal rendering -> re-reception/checking -> perceiving perception shares a subchain with CIMC organized perceptual field -> inclusion of its occurrence -> global coherence operator. It does not establish the last coherence-specific coupling as a joined mechanism."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "BOUNDED_REVERSE_RECONSTRUCTION_WITH_ALTERNATIVES_OPEN",
          "reasoning": "Reverse from second-order perceptual presence: one's own perceptual occurrence must be represented, not just outputs forwarded. July's explicit195 supports the proposed reflexive requirement; the next-array mechanism alone cannot decide whether target13's same-level and transparency conditions hold.",
          "chronological_constraint": "Only this exact 2022-07-06T20:15:38-07:00 Git-record-dated formulation is compared against the selected 2026-04-27 target version. Earlier source and target routes remain open; no unique derivation, independent first-publication proof, whole-program firstness or influence follows."
        }
      },
      "formal": null,
      "citation_boundary": "Citation/omission, access and dependence are not adjudicated by this bounded review.",
      "program_history": "Whole-program before/after history remains separate from this selected document comparison.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Perception can include the act of perceiving",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/6ab9773f25d460c305d1d2de9a8ee5e0ca03ee4a/b0038y.md",
        "sha256": "D6C617135E5838F0DF7B99FBEDFE3941F743A59FFFEE59A0F294C5EF7012F53A",
        "date": "2022-07-06",
        "date_type": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "date_boundary": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "the one process in the machine is always seeking to know, it's always seeking to know is perceiving perception."
        ],
        "locators": [
          31,
          136,
          140,
          159,
          175,
          179,
          187,
          191,
          195,
          199
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Consciousness Is Model Coherence",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen",
          "Franz Hildebrandt-Harangozó",
          "Lou de Kerhuelvez",
          "Jim Rutt"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcWhitepaper.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
        "date": "2026-04-27",
        "date_type": "Selected document-version date, not proof this wording appeared in the initial publication",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": null,
        "summary": "The later whitepaper likewise makes perception of perception central. It adds same-level representation and transparency conditions that need separate comparison.",
        "locators": {
          "physical_pages": [
            11,
            12,
            13
          ],
          "printed_pages": [
            10,
            11,
            12
          ],
          "sections": [
            "Second-order perception",
            "Consciousness Distinguished from Concomitants",
            "An Operational Definition of Consciousness"
          ]
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-CIMC-A09",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/11",
      "source_file_sha256": "3A6EDA4752A6283D386F130F28EE5C4CC1B6FCF15DBB36C2509BE1F8301C11B1",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-MCH-A10",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-MCH-A10",
      "edition_id": "bach-extension",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-0E29192A2E5FEE5BC6D6",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:D73632B6DF40CD48127C28B76B8B7965E22E4271BEA54F906E606F97D4E944C8",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
      "title": "Choose the detail a simulation needs to preserve",
      "conclusion": "Micah's November 2022 Git-recorded implementation proposal models individual dendrites, synapses and their changing dynamics. MCH's reviewed version likewise raises the possibility that simulating consciousness needs more cellular detail than simplified neuron-to-neuron messages. Neither establishes the required resolution experimentally.",
      "shared": "A simulation meant to realize consciousness may need to retain computational detail below a simplified whole-neuron unit; preserve relevant component organization rather than assume a coarse network is sufficient.",
      "relation": "inherited source-reviewed partial",
      "residual": "Dendrites and synapses are sub-neural structures, not evidence that every intracellular biochemical process must be simulated. MCH makes a possibility statement, not a proven requirement; neither side demonstrates sufficiency or feasibility.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_FUNCTIONAL_OR_OPERATIONAL_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "Bounded implementation-granularity match: November19 explicitly models individual dendrites and synapses with spatial/temporal response and fast/slow changes; MCH22 questions sparse inter-neuron messages and asks whether complex cellular machinery must also be simulated.",
          "formal_ceiling": "No proved mathematical isomorphism, bisimulation, functor or implementation equivalence; theoretical correspondence is not experimental validation."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_CAUSAL_OR_NARRATIVE_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "November computational account -> choose substrate -> model sub-neural and network dynamics -> rendered activity corresponds to MCH hypothesized functionality -> test simulation sufficiency -> possibly increase cellular resolution. Both are proposed requirements, not successful implementations."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "BOUNDED_REVERSE_RECONSTRUCTION_WITH_ALTERNATIVES_OPEN",
          "reasoning": "Reverse from a simulation preserving consciousness-relevant functions: test which intra-cellular/sub-neural details a coarse abstraction omits. November supplies concrete dendritic/synaptic candidates; MCH's broader machinery question does not identify the same minimal sufficient set.",
          "chronological_constraint": "Only this exact 2022-11-28T18:09:11-08:00 Git-record-dated formulation is compared against the selected 2026-01-15 target version. Earlier source and target routes remain open; no unique derivation, independent first-publication proof, whole-program firstness or influence follows."
        }
      },
      "formal": null,
      "citation_boundary": "Citation/omission, access and dependence are not adjudicated by this bounded review.",
      "program_history": "Whole-program before/after history remains separate from this selected document comparison.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Choose the detail a simulation needs to preserve",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0320z.md",
        "sha256": "D73632B6DF40CD48127C28B76B8B7965E22E4271BEA54F906E606F97D4E944C8",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "date_boundary": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "The essential physics process could be simulated in just matrix calculations on a TPU, with each dendrite, each neuron, each synapse, and each cortical column being unique or random in it's original configuration"
        ],
        "locators": [
          3,
          7,
          9,
          13,
          15,
          17,
          19,
          21
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcHypothesis.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "date": "2026-01-15",
        "date_type": "Selected document-version date, not proof this wording appeared in the initial publication",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": null,
        "summary": "The later paper raises the possibility that simplified messages between neurons may omit important cellular machinery. Both question what detail a simulation needs.",
        "locators": {
          "physical_pages": [
            21,
            22
          ],
          "printed_pages": [
            20,
            21
          ],
          "sections": [
            "The extended Machine Consciousness Hypothesis"
          ]
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-MCH-A10",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/12",
      "source_file_sha256": "3A6EDA4752A6283D386F130F28EE5C4CC1B6FCF15DBB36C2509BE1F8301C11B1",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-CIMC-A10",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-CIMC-A10",
      "edition_id": "bach-extension",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-0E29192A2E5FEE5BC6D6",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:D73632B6DF40CD48127C28B76B8B7965E22E4271BEA54F906E606F97D4E944C8",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
      "title": "Local interactions can build higher-order organization",
      "conclusion": "Micah's November 2022 Git-recorded proposal links context-sensitive local neural components and larger assemblies in a simulated mind. CIMC's reviewed whitepaper also studies how local interactions produce higher-order organization. Its cited pages do not establish the stronger claim that simulation must extend inside neurons.",
      "shared": "Local interacting computational units, arranged across scales, can be studied or simulated as the basis for higher-order organization.",
      "relation": "inherited source-reviewed partial",
      "residual": "CIMC18-19 neither requires nor explicitly proposes simulating inside a neuron. Processing units, biological cells and agent communities are comparison scales, not evidence of subcellular fidelity. Retain the stronger route open, not established.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_FUNCTIONAL_OR_OPERATIONAL_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "A weaker but genuine multiscale/local-interaction partial: November19 discusses neurons, arrays, edge communities, columns and synchronous groups with context-sensitive responses; CIMC18 studies local units, cells and communities generating global structures, and19 uses distributed messages.",
          "formal_ceiling": "No proved mathematical isomorphism, bisimulation, functor or implementation equivalence; theoretical correspondence is not experimental validation."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_CAUSAL_OR_NARRATIVE_CORRESPONDENCE",
          "reasoning": "November local spatial/temporal interactions -> assemblies -> rendered system activity shares a local-to-global architecture with CIMC local update rules -> organized dynamics. CIMC's NCA/requests-confirmations implementation does not instantiate November's sub-neural simulation details."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "BOUNDED_REVERSE_RECONSTRUCTION_WITH_ALTERNATIVES_OPEN",
          "reasoning": "Reverse from higher-order organized dynamics: some local interaction rules and component organization must be implemented. November provides a candidate hierarchy; the target output does not force an intra-cellular simulation requirement.",
          "chronological_constraint": "Only this exact 2022-11-28T18:09:11-08:00 Git-record-dated formulation is compared against the selected 2026-04-27 target version. Earlier source and target routes remain open; no unique derivation, independent first-publication proof, whole-program firstness or influence follows."
        }
      },
      "formal": null,
      "citation_boundary": "Citation/omission, access and dependence are not adjudicated by this bounded review.",
      "program_history": "Whole-program before/after history remains separate from this selected document comparison.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Local interactions can build higher-order organization",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0320z.md",
        "sha256": "D73632B6DF40CD48127C28B76B8B7965E22E4271BEA54F906E606F97D4E944C8",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "date_boundary": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "The essential physics process could be simulated in just matrix calculations on a TPU, with each dendrite, each neuron, each synapse, and each cortical column being unique or random in it's original configuration"
        ],
        "locators": [
          3,
          13,
          15,
          17,
          19,
          21
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Consciousness Is Model Coherence",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen",
          "Franz Hildebrandt-Harangozó",
          "Lou de Kerhuelvez",
          "Jim Rutt"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcWhitepaper.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
        "date": "2026-04-27",
        "date_type": "Selected document-version date, not proof this wording appeared in the initial publication",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": null,
        "summary": "The later whitepaper studies how local interactions create higher-order organization. That supports a local-to-global match, not a claim that this whitepaper requires simulating inside neurons.",
        "locators": {
          "physical_pages": [
            18,
            19
          ],
          "printed_pages": [
            17,
            18
          ],
          "sections": [
            "Self-organization and multi-agent systems",
            "Cognitive architectures"
          ]
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-CIMC-A10",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/2022-source-extension/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/13",
      "source_file_sha256": "3A6EDA4752A6283D386F130F28EE5C4CC1B6FCF15DBB36C2509BE1F8301C11B1",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-neural-lace:BACH-DOCWIN-2017-MCH-A03",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2017-MCH-A03",
      "edition_id": "bach-neural-lace",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-9D867D97BDDD91B25558",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
      "title": "Building objects inside a spatial representation",
      "conclusion": "Blumberg's earlier source record already joins spatial features, object categories and predicted movement; Bach and Sorensen's later text also builds and tracks objects within a represented world.",
      "shared": "Both descriptions organize perceptual features into represented objects and use more than a bare label: the SAN passage predicts movement; the later passage identifies and tracks individuals in an internally constructed space.",
      "relation": "partial",
      "residual": "The SAN passage does not here present MCH's second-order-perception genesis mechanism. MCH does not here give SAN's joint external-scene/neural-measurement BCI procedure. Shared categorization alone is historically broad.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial",
          "analysis": "Partial conceptual and operational correspondence: spatial features become individuated/categorized objects within a model. Tracking and motion prediction are related temporal operations, not identical algorithms."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-subchain-correspondence",
          "analysis": "Common ordered subchain: organize spatial distinctions -> construct object representations -> maintain or predict an object over change. SAN links it to paired brain/computer measurement; MCH embeds it in a genesis story."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "COMPATIBLE-RECONSTRUCTION-NOT-UNIQUE",
          "constrained_conclusion": "The target output is categorized objects whose individual identity can be tracked over change, not just a list of object names.",
          "required_operations": "There must be an operation relating perceptual distinctions to an object representation, and some way to preserve or update object identity across changing observations.",
          "alternative_routes": "A feed-forward classifier with a separate tracker, a recurrent scene model, and predictive object tracking can satisfy parts of that requirement without the same genesis or consciousness mechanism.",
          "source_test": "SAN lines 71–79 explicitly group lines into a car and predict its motion; lines 169–189 describe a spatial representation changing over time. This supplies the object-building and temporal-relation subset.",
          "remaining_indeterminacy": "The backward test supports a partial object-processing relation. It does not force MCH to use SAN’s BCI measurement procedure or prove identical tracking and prediction algorithms.",
          "analysis": "Work backward from recognizing the same moving individual: the system must retain discriminative features and link observations across change; grouped object representations are a compatible route. Output does not determine a unique representation, consciousness mechanism, thalamic code, or influence.",
          "constrained_target_output": "Named/categorized individuals remain identifiable as their positions or appearances change."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Qualitative partial trace: features -> object-in-space -> temporal object relation. No equality of update functions, full simulation, functor or bisimulation is proved.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The 21-occurrence program history remains open. This is document-relative source-record chronology, not author-wide firstness or a completed before/after migration finding.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Neural Lace monologue · Building objects inside a spatial representation",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/214c640ba35e81350eaef71635a255f00d18ad75/nlp1.md",
        "sha256": "A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
        "date": "2025-06-21",
        "date_type": "Git wording record; first public release not independently dated",
        "date_boundary": "Source labels OpenAI Whisper transcription; audio accuracy not independently checked here",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": "April 2017 (attributed; original audio/upload not verified)",
        "quotes": [
          "And we're going to call this the concept of a car.",
          "And not only do we have this concept of a car, which is all these lines, but we can also predict which way the car is moving."
        ],
        "locators": [
          [
            61,
            81
          ],
          [
            151,
            189
          ]
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcHypothesis.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "date": "2026-01-15",
        "date_type": "Selected PDF version date, not initial article date",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "Consciousness sorts things and animals into different kinds, identifies and tracks individuals, and gives each their names.",
        "summary": "Both descriptions organize perceptual features into represented objects and use more than a bare label: the SAN passage predicts movement; the later passage identifies and tracks individuals in an internally constructed space.",
        "locators": {
          "page": 20
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2017-MCH-A03",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/0",
      "source_file_sha256": "C25D68ED7FCF82D91028B5C1A7A332978B639B5E410A91CDAD3226EED03DD14C",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-neural-lace:BACH-DOCWIN-2017-CIMC-A03",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2017-CIMC-A03",
      "edition_id": "bach-neural-lace",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-0A04381C2FE72327FD2B",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
      "title": "Combining partial information into an experienced world",
      "conclusion": "Blumberg's earlier source record explains experience as sparse sensory input completed by internal concepts; the later CIMC text likewise builds a perceptual world from partial models.",
      "shared": "Both make the experienced world depend on the combination of partial internal representations, not on simply copying the incoming sensory stream.",
      "relation": "partial",
      "residual": "Sensory completion using supporting concepts does not by itself specify CIMC's contradiction detection, attention allocation or suppression rule. Those differences limit this pair, without removing its shared integration operation.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial",
          "analysis": "Partial representational assembly: limited sensory information and supporting concepts contribute to a complete experienced scene; concurrent partial models contribute to a consistent perceptual world."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-subchain-correspondence",
          "analysis": "Shared subchain: partial contributions -> integration in an internal representational system -> experienced world. Conflict detection and its resolution are explicit in CIMC and are not silently read into this SAN sentence."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "COMMON-INTEGRATION-REQUIREMENT-WITH-REPAIR-RESIDUAL",
          "constrained_conclusion": "The target constructs a perceptual world from simultaneously maintained partial models, despite their incompleteness and potential conflict.",
          "required_operations": "Contributions from more than one partial representation must affect an organized output; the target additionally requires a way to reduce inconsistency between those contributions.",
          "alternative_routes": "Completion from stored expectations, a feed-forward integrator, and iterative constraint repair are possible routes. A shared completed-world output alone cannot select which repair rule is used.",
          "source_test": "SAN lines 107–131 explicitly combine limited sensory input with internally supplied supporting concepts into complete experience. That satisfies the multi-contribution completion subset rather than merely mentioning perception.",
          "remaining_indeterminacy": "The source passage does not specify the target’s constraint-minimization operator. The assembly subset remains supported while that additional operator stays open for other genealogy rows.",
          "analysis": "Work backward from a stable scene built from partial, potentially incompatible models: contributions must be represented and their conflicts must be handled by reconciliation, weighting, exclusion or suppression. The monologue's internally supplied context and converging senses support the integration portion, but do not specify that conflict-handling operation. Sensory completion and alternative model-selection schemes could yield the bounded perceptual output; neither the output nor the source fixes CIMC's attention/repair implementation.",
          "constrained_target_output": "A stable perceptual world is sustained from simultaneous partial models, including potentially conflicting contributions."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Partial input/transform/output alignment of sensory-and-internal contributions -> integration -> scene; no proof that the two integration operators implement the same optimization.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The 21-occurrence program history remains open. This is document-relative source-record chronology, not author-wide firstness or a completed before/after migration finding.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Neural Lace monologue · Combining partial information into an experienced world",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/214c640ba35e81350eaef71635a255f00d18ad75/nlp1.md",
        "sha256": "A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
        "date": "2025-06-21",
        "date_type": "Git wording record; first public release not independently dated",
        "date_boundary": "Source labels OpenAI Whisper transcription; audio accuracy not independently checked here",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": "April 2017 (attributed; original audio/upload not verified)",
        "quotes": [
          "These are all, um, supporting concepts that are taking a little bit of information coming from your senses and bolstering that into your complete experience."
        ],
        "locators": [
          [
            103,
            131
          ],
          [
            151,
            189
          ]
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "CIMC Research Program for Machine Consciousness, Whitepaper v2",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen",
          "Franz Hildebrandt-Harangozó",
          "Lou de Kerhuelvez",
          "Jim Rutt"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcWhitepaper.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
        "date": "2026-04-27",
        "date_type": "Selected PDF version date, not initial article date",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "they minimize constraint violations between partial models of reality maintained in parallel.",
        "summary": "Both make the experienced world depend on the combination of partial internal representations, not on simply copying the incoming sensory stream.",
        "locators": {
          "page": 11
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2017-CIMC-A03",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/1",
      "source_file_sha256": "C25D68ED7FCF82D91028B5C1A7A332978B639B5E410A91CDAD3226EED03DD14C",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-neural-lace:BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-MCH-A13",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-MCH-A13",
      "edition_id": "bach-neural-lace",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-BC830DE62BEC176601DB",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
      "title": "Representations participate in changing mental states",
      "conclusion": "Blumberg's earlier record proposes an operation that changes an ongoing neural experience; the later MCH text also treats mental states as causally transformable. The common state-transition principle is partial, not an identical controller.",
      "shared": "Both proposals give represented mental state a causal role in a transition to another mental state, rather than treating it as an inert report.",
      "relation": "weak-partial",
      "residual": "MCH does not specify a current/desired difference or an external BCI channel in this passage. SAN's difference-write proposal is not a demonstration of consciousness's own control process.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "weak-partial",
          "analysis": "Partial process correspondence at the state-transition level. SAN specifies a current/desired comparison and proposed external write-in; MCH characterizes internally conscious operation by its effects on mental state."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-subchain-correspondence",
          "analysis": "Shared narrow subchain: a represented mental state -> an operation on that state -> changed mental content. The controller and cause of the operation differ, so this is not a match of the whole control architecture."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "UNDERDETERMINED-STATE-CHANGE-RECONSTRUCTION",
          "constrained_conclusion": "The target treats conscious operation as capable of changing a mental state.",
          "required_operations": "At minimum, there must be distinguishable before/after mental states and an effective transformation between them. This alone does not require an explicitly represented goal or a difference message.",
          "alternative_routes": "Externally induced change, autonomous control, and spontaneous internal state evolution can instantiate state transitions; only further constraints distinguish those causes.",
          "source_test": "SAN lines 497–507 provide a concrete proposed transformation: compare the current pattern with an intended one, then transmit a change that alters experienced content.",
          "remaining_indeterminacy": "This is a broad partial state-transition framing, not identity between an external BCI operator and conscious agency. No target-specific controller can be reconstructed from this shared endpoint alone.",
          "analysis": "Given a changed mental state, some effective transition must have occurred; that observation alone neither entails a desired-state comparator nor a difference-coded signal. MCH's more constrained coherent output is compatible with many repair operations. A full delta-controller cannot be reverse-inferred.",
          "constrained_target_output": "Conscious operation changes mental states; the surrounding target account associates the change with increased coherence."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Abstract partial transition correspondence s -> operation -> s′. The SAN transition carries a specified desired state and difference message; those labels have no exact mapped MCH operator here.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The 21-occurrence program history remains open. This is document-relative source-record chronology, not author-wide firstness or a completed before/after migration finding.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Neural Lace monologue · Representations participate in changing mental states",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/214c640ba35e81350eaef71635a255f00d18ad75/nlp1.md",
        "sha256": "A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
        "date": "2025-06-21",
        "date_type": "Git wording record; first public release not independently dated",
        "date_boundary": "Source labels OpenAI Whisper transcription; audio accuracy not independently checked here",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": "April 2017 (attributed; original audio/upload not verified)",
        "quotes": [
          "But what you would do then is figure out the difference between the pattern that's there and the pattern that should be there if steak was there.",
          "And then you send the difference between those two patterns so that the pattern that received just allows you to have steak into your reality where there was none before."
        ],
        "locators": [
          [
            491,
            519
          ]
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcHypothesis.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "date": "2026-01-15",
        "date_type": "Selected PDF version date, not initial article date",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "By characterizing consciousness as an operator on mental states, we can approach its functionality by observing how mental states change as a result of conscious operation.",
        "summary": "Both proposals give represented mental state a causal role in a transition to another mental state, rather than treating it as an inert report.",
        "locators": {
          "page": 17
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-MCH-A13",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/2",
      "source_file_sha256": "C25D68ED7FCF82D91028B5C1A7A332978B639B5E410A91CDAD3226EED03DD14C",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-neural-lace:BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-CIMC-A13",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-CIMC-A13",
      "edition_id": "bach-neural-lace",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-BC830DE62BEC176601DB",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
      "title": "Using a represented goal to select a state change",
      "conclusion": "Blumberg's earlier record computes a neural update from a represented desired state; the later CIMC definition also makes represented goals guide control over future states.",
      "shared": "Both use a represented intended state to guide a change, rather than applying an unrelated fixed signal.",
      "relation": "partial",
      "residual": "CIMC's definition does not mandate a neural pattern difference, receiver-specific write-in or external interface. The correspondence is one subchain of goal-directed control, not proof of the complete SAN architecture.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial",
          "analysis": "Partial operational correspondence: represent a goal or desired pattern -> choose the change relative to it -> influence a subsequent state. SAN supplies a particular difference-write procedure; CIMC supplies an abstract agency definition."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-subchain-correspondence",
          "analysis": "Shared control subchain: represented future condition -> selection of action/update -> changed state. It bridges BCI and agency contexts without claiming that the external BCI controller is the target's self-organizing agent."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "GOAL-SENSITIVE-CONTROL-RECONSTRUCTION-NOT-DELTA-IDENTITY",
          "constrained_conclusion": "The target selects actions on the basis of represented goals in order to control future states.",
          "required_operations": "A represented preference or intended condition must influence which action is selected, and that action must be capable of changing a subsequent state.",
          "alternative_routes": "A learned policy, model-predictive control, and a direct state-difference update can meet that goal-sensitive control requirement. The abstract definition does not require subtraction of neural patterns.",
          "source_test": "SAN lines 501–507 represent the desired perceptual pattern, compare it with the ongoing pattern and choose the transmitted update accordingly. The source therefore meets the goal-conditioned update subset.",
          "remaining_indeterminacy": "BCI versus autonomous agency is an implementation/context residual, not a veto on the shared control subchain. Matching objectives, policies and the complete agent remain unproved.",
          "analysis": "Work backward from selective control toward a represented goal: the selected intervention must be sensitive to an evaluative criterion and capable of affecting the outcome. This permits delta control, planning, policy selection or other strategies; it does not require the source's difference-signal protocol.",
          "constrained_target_output": "A system selects among possible actions using represented goals/preferences and thereby controls future states."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Partial control schema: (current state, represented goal) -> selected action/update -> subsequent state. Identical objectives, transition kernels and goal evaluation are not proved.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The 21-occurrence program history remains open. This is document-relative source-record chronology, not author-wide firstness or a completed before/after migration finding.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Neural Lace monologue · Using a represented goal to select a state change",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/214c640ba35e81350eaef71635a255f00d18ad75/nlp1.md",
        "sha256": "A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
        "date": "2025-06-21",
        "date_type": "Git wording record; first public release not independently dated",
        "date_boundary": "Source labels OpenAI Whisper transcription; audio accuracy not independently checked here",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": "April 2017 (attributed; original audio/upload not verified)",
        "quotes": [
          "But what you would do then is figure out the difference between the pattern that's there and the pattern that should be there if steak was there.",
          "And then you send the difference between those two patterns so that the pattern that received just allows you to have steak into your reality where there was none before."
        ],
        "locators": [
          [
            491,
            519
          ]
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "CIMC Research Program for Machine Consciousness, Whitepaper v2",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen",
          "Franz Hildebrandt-Harangozó",
          "Lou de Kerhuelvez",
          "Jim Rutt"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcWhitepaper.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
        "date": "2026-04-27",
        "date_type": "Selected PDF version date, not initial article date",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "the capacity of a system to exert control over future states, that is, to select among possible actions on the basis of internal representations of goals, preferences, or evaluative criteria.",
        "summary": "Both use a represented intended state to guide a change, rather than applying an unrelated fixed signal.",
        "locators": {
          "page": 12
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-CIMC-A13",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/3",
      "source_file_sha256": "C25D68ED7FCF82D91028B5C1A7A332978B639B5E410A91CDAD3226EED03DD14C",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-neural-lace:BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-MCH-A14",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-MCH-A14",
      "edition_id": "bach-neural-lace",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-47F1940534AF8F975047",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
      "title": "Experienced content need not reproduce the outside scene",
      "conclusion": "Blumberg's earlier record explicitly separates an experienced object from its external presence; Bach and Sorensen later also distinguish conscious content from its real or imaginary character.",
      "shared": "Both distinguish the content of experience from whether the corresponding object is physically present outside the subject.",
      "relation": "partial-conceptual",
      "residual": "The target's claim concerns the representational character of experience, not this specific neural intervention. An induced percept, imagined content and an experience of factuality must not be conflated.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial-conceptual",
          "analysis": "Partial conceptual/output correspondence: an internal representational state can contain an object without that object being present in the external environment. The target separately describes a variable realness dimension."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-subchain-correspondence",
          "analysis": "SAN: state-dependent neural intervention -> added experienced object. MCH: representational content -> real/imaginary character. The shared endpoint is represented experience rather than necessary external presence; the causal routes are not fully aligned."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "INTERNAL-CONTENT-RECONSTRUCTION-NOT-WRITE-PROTOCOL",
          "constrained_conclusion": "The target distinguishes experienced content from its real or imaginary character.",
          "required_operations": "Content must be represented in a way that does not simply equate its occurrence in experience with the external presence of the represented object.",
          "alternative_routes": "Imagining an object, an induced percept and assigning a realness property can all dissociate content from external presence, but they need not use the same process.",
          "source_test": "SAN lines 505–519 propose changing neural content so an object not externally present enters experienced reality. That is an explicit instance of the representational distinction.",
          "remaining_indeterminacy": "The backward inference preserves the partial output/conceptual match. It does not establish that induced experience, imagination and MCH’s realness dimension are identical.",
          "analysis": "Work backward from experiencing an externally absent object: an internal content-carrying process must support that appearance independently of that object's present sensory cause. Dreams, hallucinations, imagery or intervention could do so; no specific pattern-difference input or realness variable is forced.",
          "constrained_target_output": "Conscious content can be imagined or experienced as factual even when an external object does not warrant that appearance."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Partial output relation between internally represented object and external-object presence; no equivalence of hallucination, imagination or realness-detection operators.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The 21-occurrence program history remains open. This is document-relative source-record chronology, not author-wide firstness or a completed before/after migration finding.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Neural Lace monologue · Experienced content need not reproduce the outside scene",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/214c640ba35e81350eaef71635a255f00d18ad75/nlp1.md",
        "sha256": "A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
        "date": "2025-06-21",
        "date_type": "Git wording record; first public release not independently dated",
        "date_boundary": "Source labels OpenAI Whisper transcription; audio accuracy not independently checked here",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": "April 2017 (attributed; original audio/upload not verified)",
        "quotes": [
          "And then you send the difference between those two patterns so that the pattern that received just allows you to have steak into your reality where there was none before.",
          "So once we can do that, that means that you're going to have things in your reality that are not actually there"
        ],
        "locators": [
          [
            497,
            519
          ]
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcHypothesis.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "date": "2026-01-15",
        "date_type": "Selected PDF version date, not initial article date",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "The contents of consciousness may be experienced as real or imaginary",
        "summary": "Both distinguish the content of experience from whether the corresponding object is physically present outside the subject.",
        "locators": {
          "page": 16
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-MCH-A14",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/4",
      "source_file_sha256": "C25D68ED7FCF82D91028B5C1A7A332978B639B5E410A91CDAD3226EED03DD14C",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-neural-lace:BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-CIMC-A14",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-CIMC-A14",
      "edition_id": "bach-neural-lace",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-77883A03590C93103733",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
      "title": "The experienced world is an internally maintained representation",
      "conclusion": "Blumberg's earlier record treats the experienced world as internally constructed and alterable; the later CIMC text likewise names maintenance of a perceptual world. This is a broad partial correspondence.",
      "shared": "Both place the experienced world in an ongoing internal representational process, which can be maintained or changed rather than merely received as a complete external picture.",
      "relation": "weak-partial-conceptual",
      "residual": "This pair is broad and weak by itself. It does not establish identical maintenance, minimal experience, self-registration or coherence optimization. Stronger operations require additional source-specific rows, not expansion of this quotation.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "weak-partial-conceptual",
          "analysis": "Weak partial conceptual correspondence in the maintained representational output. SAN describes internal completion and a proposed intervention; CIMC describes stable world maintenance as an operation of consciousness."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-subchain-correspondence",
          "analysis": "Both connect organized internal content to experienced-world availability. The evidence does not align the full repair mechanism: SAN's controlled write-in and CIMC's conflict resolution remain different specified procedures."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "WORLD-MAINTENANCE-RECONSTRUCTION-WRITABILITY-NOT-ENTAILED",
          "constrained_conclusion": "The target includes maintaining a stable perceptual world among the functions to be explained.",
          "required_operations": "Some organized representation of a world must be available across the relevant processing interval; the endpoint alone does not uniquely specify its maintenance mechanism.",
          "alternative_routes": "Reconstruction at successive moments, recurrent stabilization and conflict-driven repair are alternative ways to preserve an organized output. This broad result does not discriminate between them.",
          "source_test": "SAN lines 107–131 describe internally supported construction of experience, and lines 497–519 make that experience an alterable ongoing state. This supports the internal-world framing.",
          "remaining_indeterminacy": "The pair remains a weak partial conceptual relation. The specified stable-maintenance or self-registration mechanism cannot be inferred from the shared output class and stays open.",
          "analysis": "Work backward from a stable perceptual world despite partial inputs: internal representations must be maintained and integrated. That output can arise without any external write channel or capacity to insert nonexistent objects; the target does not select the source's intervention route.",
          "constrained_target_output": "Conscious operations sustain a stable perceptual world by coordinating partial representations."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Qualitative common output class: an internally constructed perceptual world. No implementation-level or mathematical equivalence is established by this pair.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The 21-occurrence program history remains open. This is document-relative source-record chronology, not author-wide firstness or a completed before/after migration finding.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Neural Lace monologue · The experienced world is an internally maintained representation",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/214c640ba35e81350eaef71635a255f00d18ad75/nlp1.md",
        "sha256": "A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
        "date": "2025-06-21",
        "date_type": "Git wording record; first public release not independently dated",
        "date_boundary": "Source labels OpenAI Whisper transcription; audio accuracy not independently checked here",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": "April 2017 (attributed; original audio/upload not verified)",
        "quotes": [
          "These are all, um, supporting concepts that are taking a little bit of information coming from your senses and bolstering that into your complete experience.",
          "And then you send the difference between those two patterns so that the pattern that received just allows you to have steak into your reality where there was none before."
        ],
        "locators": [
          [
            103,
            131
          ],
          [
            497,
            519
          ]
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "CIMC Research Program for Machine Consciousness, Whitepaper v2",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen",
          "Franz Hildebrandt-Harangozó",
          "Lou de Kerhuelvez",
          "Jim Rutt"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcWhitepaper.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
        "date": "2026-04-27",
        "date_type": "Selected PDF version date, not initial article date",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "the maintenance of a stable perceptual world",
        "summary": "Both place the experienced world in an ongoing internal representational process, which can be maintained or changed rather than merely received as a complete external picture.",
        "locators": {
          "page": 11
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-CIMC-A14",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/5",
      "source_file_sha256": "C25D68ED7FCF82D91028B5C1A7A332978B639B5E410A91CDAD3226EED03DD14C",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-neural-lace:BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-MCH-A15",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-MCH-A15",
      "edition_id": "bach-neural-lace",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-BC830DE62BEC176601DB",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
      "title": "Patterns change what the receiving system represents",
      "conclusion": "Blumberg's earlier record gives a receiver-dependent way to transform a neural representation; the later MCH account also describes patterns transformed through conditional processing.",
      "shared": "Both use transmitted patterns to produce a further representation through a receiving process. SAN specifies the current receiver state and a difference message; MCH describes the general conditional transformation network.",
      "relation": "partial",
      "residual": "The target paragraph does not specify transmission of only a difference, feedback verification or an identical receiver-state equation. Those remain unmatched SAN specifics within this pair.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial",
          "analysis": "Partial operational subchain: incoming pattern -> receiving transformation -> changed representation. SAN's state-dependent delta is more specific than the target's general conditional operator here."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-subchain-correspondence",
          "analysis": "The matched architecture is representational transformation along a causal path, not just shared neural vocabulary. Different implementations remain: an external BCI update versus a general processing network."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "CAUSAL-TRANSFORM-RECONSTRUCTION-OPERATOR-UNDERDETERMINED",
          "constrained_conclusion": "The target propagates patterns through conditional operators that transform representations into further representations.",
          "required_operations": "Patterns must enter a causally effective receiving process, whose operation determines the resulting representation; a bare transmitted label is not a complete transformation account.",
          "alternative_routes": "A fixed conditional rule, a learned state-sensitive transformation and an explicit difference update can produce representational transitions. The target paragraph does not choose SAN’s update formula.",
          "source_test": "SAN lines 497–507 reject blind addition of a complete pattern and select a message relative to the receiving state. This is an explicit state-sensitive instance of the broader transformation class.",
          "remaining_indeterminacy": "The bounded example-to-class relation survives the change of context. Exact difference transmission, acknowledgement and an identical receiver-state equation are not entailed by the target.",
          "analysis": "Work backward from a reproducibly changed representation: there must be a substrate-sensitive causal mapping from some prior/input pattern to the new one. Conditional network propagation is compatible; so are diverse encodings and operators. Difference coding and electromagnetic dominoes are not forced.",
          "constrained_target_output": "Patterns in a processing network are causally transformed into further representations."
        }
      },
      "formal": "A bounded example-to-general-process relation: U(s,message) -> represented s′. Not a proof that the target conditional operator is the SAN delta operator.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The 21-occurrence program history remains open. This is document-relative source-record chronology, not author-wide firstness or a completed before/after migration finding.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Neural Lace monologue · Patterns change what the receiving system represents",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/214c640ba35e81350eaef71635a255f00d18ad75/nlp1.md",
        "sha256": "A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
        "date": "2025-06-21",
        "date_type": "Git wording record; first public release not independently dated",
        "date_boundary": "Source labels OpenAI Whisper transcription; audio accuracy not independently checked here",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": "April 2017 (attributed; original audio/upload not verified)",
        "quotes": [
          "But what you would do then is figure out the difference between the pattern that's there and the pattern that should be there if steak was there.",
          "And then you send the difference between those two patterns so that the pattern that received just allows you to have steak into your reality where there was none before."
        ],
        "locators": [
          [
            491,
            511
          ]
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcHypothesis.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "date": "2026-01-15",
        "date_type": "Selected PDF version date, not initial article date",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "Representations are transformed into other representations, each characterized by their structural invariances and their place in the processing network, which can be seen as a causal network that propagates patterns via conditional operators.",
        "summary": "Both use transmitted patterns to produce a further representation through a receiving process. SAN specifies the current receiver state and a difference message; MCH describes the general conditional transformation network.",
        "locators": {
          "page": 16
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-MCH-A15",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/6",
      "source_file_sha256": "C25D68ED7FCF82D91028B5C1A7A332978B639B5E410A91CDAD3226EED03DD14C",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-neural-lace:BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-CIMC-A15",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-CIMC-A15",
      "edition_id": "bach-neural-lace",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-07AB827DEC5D5348F7C4",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
      "title": "Feedback and confirmation in distributed communication",
      "conclusion": "Blumberg's earlier record proposes feedback and verified neural communication; the later CIMC program also uses requests and confirmations between processing units.",
      "shared": "Both describe neural or computational communication using reciprocal exchange and confirmation, not only one-way transmission.",
      "relation": "partial",
      "residual": "TCP-style delivery confirmation is not itself semantic agreement. SAN here does not supply CIMC's Request Confirmation Network implementation; CIMC here does not specify the SAN perceptual difference-write operation.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial",
          "analysis": "Partial communication pattern: send -> returned check/confirmation -> continued organized communication. SAN uses a TCP analogy and a conscious/unconscious proposal; CIMC proposes Request Confirmation Networks for mutual consistency."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-subchain-correspondence",
          "analysis": "Shared feedback architecture joins local communications through returned information. Reliable delivery in the SAN analogy and semantic consistency in CIMC are not identical goals, but the reciprocal-check subchain is supported."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "CONFIRMATION-RECONSTRUCTION-NOT-PROTOCOL-IDENTITY",
          "constrained_conclusion": "The target seeks mutual consistency through iterative requests and confirmations between processing units without a central controller.",
          "required_operations": "Units must exchange messages in both directions, interpret returned checks, and use them in further processing. Mutual consistency also needs agreement semantics beyond delivery alone.",
          "alternative_routes": "Delivery acknowledgements, constraint negotiation and other decentralized feedback protocols share reciprocal traces but differ in what a confirmation means.",
          "source_test": "SAN lines 285–303 explicitly connect a feedback loop with verifying a sent message; lines 335–379 apply the analogy hypothetically to conscious brain communication.",
          "remaining_indeterminacy": "The reciprocal-check trace is supported. TCP-style delivery cannot by itself supply CIMC’s semantic agreement or convergence rule, and neither theory is treated as an implemented proof here.",
          "analysis": "Work backward from mutually confirmed coordination: receiving units must affect the subsequent exchange, and a returned signal must bear on whether a proposed communication or state is accepted. The monologue supplies a compatible return-check motif. Its delivery acknowledgement alone cannot establish consistency of represented contents; acknowledgements, negotiation, consensus and other feedback protocols can differ in what they certify. Neither TCP nor an identical consciousness/RCN mechanism is forced.",
          "constrained_target_output": "Processing units use iterative requests and confirmations to negotiate mutually consistent information."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Partial protocol trace: message -> receiver -> return check. No equality of acknowledgement semantics, convergence conditions or network implementation is proved.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The 21-occurrence program history remains open. This is document-relative source-record chronology, not author-wide firstness or a completed before/after migration finding.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Neural Lace monologue · Feedback and confirmation in distributed communication",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/214c640ba35e81350eaef71635a255f00d18ad75/nlp1.md",
        "sha256": "A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
        "date": "2025-06-21",
        "date_type": "Git wording record; first public release not independently dated",
        "date_boundary": "Source labels OpenAI Whisper transcription; audio accuracy not independently checked here",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": "April 2017 (attributed; original audio/upload not verified)",
        "quotes": [
          "because the connection means there's, there's actually a feedback loop of information.",
          "you're able to send a whole and complete message and you're able to verify that it was sent"
        ],
        "locators": [
          [
            277,
            305
          ],
          [
            335,
            379
          ],
          [
            491,
            507
          ]
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "CIMC Research Program for Machine Consciousness, Whitepaper v2",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen",
          "Franz Hildebrandt-Harangozó",
          "Lou de Kerhuelvez",
          "Jim Rutt"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcWhitepaper.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
        "date": "2026-04-27",
        "date_type": "Selected PDF version date, not initial article date",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "processing units negotiate mutual consistency through iterative exchange of requests and confirmations rather than by centralized control.",
        "summary": "Both describe neural or computational communication using reciprocal exchange and confirmation, not only one-way transmission.",
        "locators": {
          "page": 19
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-CIMC-A15",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/7",
      "source_file_sha256": "C25D68ED7FCF82D91028B5C1A7A332978B639B5E410A91CDAD3226EED03DD14C",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-neural-lace:BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-MCH-A16",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-MCH-A16",
      "edition_id": "bach-neural-lace",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-E9C6DDFC5573F3250A57",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
      "title": "From understanding biological operations to artificial implementations",
      "conclusion": "Blumberg's earlier Neural Lace program explicitly continues into artificial neocortices and brains; Bach and Sorensen later also propose recreating biological information processing computationally.",
      "shared": "Both research programs connect understanding biological information processing with constructing an artificial implementation.",
      "relation": "partial-conceptual",
      "residual": "The source does not here state MCH's evolutionary-search or second-order-learning algorithm. Artificial brain construction was a broad pre-existing research aim; this pair is not a worldwide firstness finding.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial-conceptual",
          "analysis": "Partial research-operation correspondence: identify biological information-processing requirements -> seek an artificial realization. SAN links interface understanding to artificial neocortices/brains; MCH specifies a search for a self-organizing learning algorithm."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-subchain-correspondence",
          "analysis": "Shared investigation-to-construction sequence rather than shared terminology alone. SAN's preceding brain/computer representation bridge supplies an operational link; the later target makes biological-to-digital realization explicit."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "FUNCTIONAL-REALIZATION-RECONSTRUCTION-SPECIFIC-LEARNING-ROUTE-OPEN",
          "constrained_conclusion": "The target proposes searching for a biological information-processing algorithm by constructing analogous self-organizing conditions on digital hardware.",
          "required_operations": "A biological function must be identified, translated into candidate construction requirements, and used to guide an artificial implementation or test.",
          "alternative_routes": "Biomimetic simulation, abstract functional modeling and developmental learning are possible research routes; building an artificial brain does not uniquely identify one algorithm.",
          "source_test": "SAN lines 61–81 connect brain and computer representations, lines 491–507 propose their operational interface, and lines 523–527 explicitly continue the program into artificial neocortices and brains.",
          "remaining_indeterminacy": "The investigation-to-construction sequence is a partial research-program correspondence. Neither successful construction, a shared self-organizing algorithm nor worldwide novelty of artificial brains follows.",
          "analysis": "Work backward from an artificial realization of the target's biological learning role: the artificial system must support the relevant representations, causal operations and learning conditions, not merely reproduce a human-looking output. The monologue's human/computer spatial bridge and artificial-brain roadmap support the broad realization direction. They do not specify self-organization, the hypothesized consciousness-producing algorithm or sufficient developmental conditions; engineered perception could supply the source's demonstrated analogy without the target's full hypothesis.",
          "constrained_target_output": "An artificial system instantiates relevant biological learning/agency functions under analogous self-organizing conditions."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Partial design-program relation from biological operation study to artificial realization, not a proof of functional equivalence of any constructed systems.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The 21-occurrence program history remains open. This is document-relative source-record chronology, not author-wide firstness or a completed before/after migration finding.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Neural Lace monologue · From understanding biological operations to artificial implementations",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/214c640ba35e81350eaef71635a255f00d18ad75/nlp1.md",
        "sha256": "A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
        "date": "2025-06-21",
        "date_type": "Git wording record; first public release not independently dated",
        "date_boundary": "Source labels OpenAI Whisper transcription; audio accuracy not independently checked here",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": "April 2017 (attributed; original audio/upload not verified)",
        "quotes": [
          "But after we build neural lace, the idea is to, um, uh, build artificial neocortex and then artificial brains."
        ],
        "locators": [
          [
            61,
            81
          ],
          [
            491,
            527
          ]
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcHypothesis.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "date": "2026-01-15",
        "date_type": "Selected PDF version date, not initial article date",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "it is possible to search for this algorithm by recreating analogous conditions of self-organizing information processing on digital computer hardware, while posing suitable tasks that require intelligent agency.",
        "summary": "Both research programs connect understanding biological information processing with constructing an artificial implementation.",
        "locators": {
          "page": 21
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-MCH-A16",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/8",
      "source_file_sha256": "C25D68ED7FCF82D91028B5C1A7A332978B639B5E410A91CDAD3226EED03DD14C",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "bach-neural-lace:BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-CIMC-A16",
      "original_id": "BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-CIMC-A16",
      "edition_id": "bach-neural-lace",
      "program": "Bach",
      "passage_id": "passage-0B193AFFEA6224D652F7",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
      "title": "Related functions across biological and artificial systems",
      "conclusion": "Blumberg’s earlier source record explicitly compares human and artificial visual grouping and prediction; the later CIMC discussion likewise connects artificial visual representations with animal visual cortex.",
      "shared": "Both compare visual representation across brains and artificial systems. SAN explains grouping lines and edges into objects and predicting movement; CIMC discusses related features learned by artificial vision systems.",
      "relation": "partial-conceptual",
      "residual": "The target cites Olah et al. (2020) for experimental AI representation comparisons and adds a consciousness-convergence conjecture. The earlier SAN passage supplies a cross-substrate perceptual-function bridge, not those experiments, a universality theorem or equal consciousness.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "partial-conceptual",
          "analysis": "Partial cross-substrate perceptual-function correspondence: both relate biological and artificial visual representation. The selected 2026 target cites comparative AI evidence from 2020; the SAN passage provides a functional example, not that experiment."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "bounded-subchain-correspondence",
          "analysis": "Shared reasoning chain: visual task -> internally organized visual representation -> a bridge between biological and artificial systems. The target then extends a convergence conjecture to consciousness; that extra arrow is not imported into SAN’s car example."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "TASK-CONSTRAINED-REPRESENTATION-RECONSTRUCTION-CONSCIOUSNESS-RESIDUAL",
          "constrained_conclusion": "The selected target passage compares visual representations in artificial recognition systems with the organization of animal visual cortex.",
          "required_operations": "A comparison must relate represented visual structure or perceptual functions across biological and artificial systems rather than treating their different substrates as sufficient to end the comparison.",
          "alternative_routes": "Systems can solve the same task with different internal algorithms. Shared visual function or some shared features does not by itself force a universal architecture or consciousness.",
          "source_test": "SAN lines 71–79 explicitly compare human and self-driving-car grouping of lines and edges into an object concept and prediction of its motion. The later artificial-brain proposal supplies a continuation, not a completed implementation.",
          "remaining_indeterminacy": "The cross-substrate perceptual-function bridge is supported. The cited AI convergence experiments and the target’s subsequent consciousness conjecture are distinct claims not established by this earlier source.",
          "analysis": "Work backward first from the target's visual-recognition example: a successful biological or artificial system needs task-suitable discriminative representations, making the monologue's shared object-grouping/prediction role a compatible antecedent. Similar output does not uniquely determine internal geometry or establish empirical feature convergence. Work backward separately from the target's conditional consciousness extension: coherent world/self modeling under agentic and self-organizing constraints is additionally required by that hypothesis. Those conditions are not supplied by the monologue's car example or its artificial-brain intention.",
          "constrained_target_output": "In the target's vision example, different implementations solve recognition tasks with related representations; its further consciousness extension is conditional on coherent agentic control in self-organizing substrates."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Cross-substrate partial functional analogy, not proof of universal convergence, identical algorithms or consciousness equivalence.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The 21-occurrence program history remains open. This is document-relative source-record chronology, not author-wide firstness or a completed before/after migration finding.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Neural Lace monologue · Related functions across biological and artificial systems",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/214c640ba35e81350eaef71635a255f00d18ad75/nlp1.md",
        "sha256": "A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
        "date": "2025-06-21",
        "date_type": "Git wording record; first public release not independently dated",
        "date_boundary": "Source labels OpenAI Whisper transcription; audio accuracy not independently checked here",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": "April 2017 (attributed; original audio/upload not verified)",
        "quotes": [
          "And the self-driving car is doing the same thing.",
          "It's predicting there is a concept, which is a unification of a bunch of lines and edges and spatial computing and cars doing it and humans are doing it."
        ],
        "locators": [
          [
            61,
            81
          ],
          [
            491,
            527
          ]
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "CIMC Research Program for Machine Consciousness, Whitepaper v2",
        "authors": [
          "Joscha Bach",
          "Hikari Sorensen",
          "Franz Hildebrandt-Harangozó",
          "Lou de Kerhuelvez",
          "Jim Rutt"
        ],
        "url": "https://cimc.ai/cimcWhitepaper.pdf",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D",
        "date": "2026-04-27",
        "date_type": "Selected PDF version date, not initial article date",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "These representations closely matched the known organization of the animal visual cortex, despite the artificial systems having no biological constraints.",
        "summary": "Both compare visual representation across brains and artificial systems. SAN explains grouping lines and edges into objects and predicting movement; CIMC discusses related features learned by artificial vision systems.",
        "locators": {
          "page": 17
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/evidence.html#BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-CIMC-A16",
      "deck_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/index.html",
      "data_href": "../joscha-bach/neural-lace-source-comparisons/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/9",
      "source_file_sha256": "C25D68ED7FCF82D91028B5C1A7A332978B639B5E410A91CDAD3226EED03DD14C",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "miller-spatial:MIL-PUB-SHAPE-2022",
      "original_id": "MIL-PUB-SHAPE-2022",
      "edition_id": "miller-spatial",
      "program": "Miller",
      "passage_id": "passage-1C294299F5AAE5418FB7",
      "source_work_id": "miller-spatial:source-url:https://web.archive.org/web/20210919213836/https://medium.com/silicon-valley-global-news/the-game-of-go-speculation-about-the-code-of-our-minds-in-our-brains-5a39d7cb6366",
      "target_work_id": "miller-spatial:document:REVIEW",
      "title": "Thoughts have a pattern of activity and inhibition",
      "conclusion": "Micah / SAN’s dated record precedes this selected later document on the mapped partial correspondence.",
      "shared": "selection or task context → spatially differentiated excitation/inhibition → selective expression or access to neural content",
      "relation": "PARTIAL_OPERATIONAL_AND_CAUSAL_MATCH",
      "residual": "SAN's passage concerns the proposed spatial shape of thoughts. The target describes working-memory control with specified frequency bands and separates coarse control from fine-grained item coding. Those additional claims are not contained in this SAN sentence.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "function": "d2a1 describes the spatial form of thoughts using excitation and inhibition. The selection function is supplied by f236 in the same article, not inferred from d2a1 alone. The target instead specifies spatial control of memory expression. The shared operation is partial.",
          "behavior": "Both describe simultaneous higher activity in selected regions and inhibited activity elsewhere. The target adds specific task-dependent readout and control behavior.",
          "operation": "Spatially organized excitation/inhibition changes which neural content is expressed. The target assigns distinct roles to beta, gamma, spiking and item location; the SAN source does not specify that entire implementation.",
          "math": "No equation-to-equation equivalence is demonstrated in these passages. No formal numerical score or isomorphism proof is assigned.",
          "program": "An informal selection/gating subroutine can be translated between the descriptions. There is no executable implementation or verified program equivalence here.",
          "form": "A spatially and temporally differentiated neural pattern is shared; SAN thought-shape and target control-pattern are not treated as identical representational levels."
        },
        "L2": {
          "matched_subchain": [
            "selection or task context",
            "spatially differentiated excitation/inhibition",
            "selective expression or access to neural content"
          ],
          "degree": "PARTIAL CAUSAL-ARCHITECTURE MATCH",
          "boundary": "The SAN causal selection step is explicitly bound to neighboring article paragraph f236; d2a1 alone is representational. Together they support spatial excitation/inhibition -> selected content expression. This does not equate thought content itself with the target's coarse control map."
        },
        "L3": {
          "strongest_supported_reading": "The SAN source independently documents the two compared formulations before the selected 2022 and 2023 publication records. Different vocabulary does not erase the shared gating operation.",
          "antecedent_control": "The target-family January 2021 Hot-Coal preprint already presents spatial activation maps and beta gating (P5–P8), before the September 2021 SAN archive capture. Earlier SAN article metadata remains visible but is not sufficient to date each sentence.",
          "residual": "This comparison alone does not establish SAN-before-target-family priority. Older component literature and earlier SAN wording custody remain open; no adverse conclusion or favorable ledger deletion follows.",
          "dependence_score": "NOT ESTIMATED: no access model, background-rate model, or independent coding calibration",
          "motive_policy": "Motive analysis is deferred by product design."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Gorla-style operational preservation, Baez-style structural comparison and Chiribella-style operational comparisons are prompts for testing structure, not executed mathematical proofs in this packet. No formal theorem, numerical percent equivalence, five-sigma result, copying, legal violation, or whole-theory experimental validation is claimed.",
      "citation_boundary": "Not adjudicated by this selected projection.",
      "program_history": "The target-family January 2021 Hot-Coal preprint already presents spatial activation maps and beta gating (P5–P8), before the September 2021 SAN archive capture. Earlier SAN article metadata remains visible but is not sufficient to date each sentence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Mind Code // Brain Code: Go (Ancient Game) and Alpha Go",
        "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20210919213836/https://medium.com/silicon-valley-global-news/the-game-of-go-speculation-about-the-code-of-our-minds-in-our-brains-5a39d7cb6366",
        "sha256": null,
        "date": "2021-09-19",
        "date_type": "Exact wording preserved by 19 September 2021",
        "date_boundary": "Article metadata says published 30 June 2017 and modified 14 August 2018. The captured text is not individually backdated to either metadata date.",
        "public_wording_by": "2021-09-19",
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "So that the shape of our thoughts, in tempo-spatial patterns is represented not only by what is excited in our brains but also by what is inhibited in our brains."
        ],
        "locators": [
          "d2a1",
          "f236"
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Working Memory Is Complex and Dynamic, Like Your Thoughts",
        "authors": [
          "Timothy J. Buschman",
          "Earl K. Miller"
        ],
        "url": "https://doi.org/10.1162/jocn_a_01940",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": null,
        "date": "2022-12-01",
        "date_type": "1 December 2022 — Crossref publication record",
        "date_boundary": "Crossref records 1 December 2022; journal volume 35 issue 1 is 2023. DOI creation on 2 November 2022 is not a publication date. The 2021 SAN archive predates either 2022 date.",
        "quote": "Control comes from where in network space a stimulus representation is currently expressed.",
        "summary": "Pages 4–5 describe broad alpha/beta-versus-gamma patterns controlling the expression of finer-grained neural representations. Their location changes with task demands.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "PDF page 5 (printed page 21), Top–Down Control by Spatial Computing",
          "quote": "Control comes from where in network space a stimulus representation is currently expressed.",
          "context": "Pages 4–5 describe broad alpha/beta-versus-gamma patterns controlling the expression of finer-grained neural representations. Their location changes with task demands.",
          "source": "REVIEW",
          "page": 5
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../miller-spatial-computing/evidence.html#MIL-PUB-SHAPE-2022",
      "deck_href": "../miller-spatial-computing/index.html",
      "data_href": "../miller-spatial-computing/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/0",
      "source_file_sha256": "AC0BEEABCCC29ED2E494AC8FA0936516FC94E57566C1C6B77E58F01A656FDD1A",
      "release_state": "historical-source-release-current-global-recheck-exception"
    },
    {
      "id": "miller-spatial:MIL-PUB-MASK-2022",
      "original_id": "MIL-PUB-MASK-2022",
      "edition_id": "miller-spatial",
      "program": "Miller",
      "passage_id": "passage-648B00F6E6DC98CC3291",
      "source_work_id": "miller-spatial:source-url:https://web.archive.org/web/20210919213836/https://medium.com/silicon-valley-global-news/the-game-of-go-speculation-about-the-code-of-our-minds-in-our-brains-5a39d7cb6366",
      "target_work_id": "miller-spatial:document:REVIEW",
      "title": "Selection changes what the network can express",
      "conclusion": "Micah / SAN’s dated record precedes this selected later document on the mapped partial correspondence.",
      "shared": "selection or task context → spatially differentiated excitation/inhibition → selective expression or access to neural content",
      "relation": "PARTIAL_OPERATIONAL_AND_CAUSAL_MATCH",
      "residual": "The shared operation is selective expression through excitation and inhibition. SAN's speculation about whole-brain electrical equilibrium and conscious/unconscious content is not established by the target experiments, and is not the target's stated explanation.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "function": "Both connect selective neural expression with the content that is currently available. This is a partial functional match, not equivalence of complete theories.",
          "behavior": "Both describe simultaneous higher activity in selected regions and inhibited activity elsewhere. The target adds specific task-dependent readout and control behavior.",
          "operation": "Spatially organized excitation/inhibition changes which neural content is expressed. The target assigns distinct roles to beta, gamma, spiking and item location; the SAN source does not specify that entire implementation.",
          "math": "No equation-to-equation equivalence is demonstrated in these passages. No formal numerical score or isomorphism proof is assigned.",
          "program": "An informal selection/gating subroutine can be translated between the descriptions. There is no executable implementation or verified program equivalence here.",
          "form": "A spatially and temporally differentiated neural pattern is shared; SAN thought-shape and target control-pattern are not treated as identical representational levels."
        },
        "L2": {
          "matched_subchain": [
            "selection or task context",
            "spatially differentiated excitation/inhibition",
            "selective expression or access to neural content"
          ],
          "degree": "PARTIAL CAUSAL-ARCHITECTURE MATCH",
          "boundary": "Three matched roles do not establish identical full narrative architecture. The target's item/control scale separation, order coding and generalization claims exceed the archived SAN excerpts."
        },
        "L3": {
          "strongest_supported_reading": "The SAN source independently documents the two compared formulations before the selected 2022 and 2023 publication records. Different vocabulary does not erase the shared gating operation.",
          "antecedent_control": "The target-family January 2021 Hot-Coal preprint already presents spatial activation maps and beta gating (P5–P8), before the September 2021 SAN archive capture. Earlier SAN article metadata remains visible but is not sufficient to date each sentence.",
          "residual": "This comparison alone does not establish SAN-before-target-family priority. Older component literature and earlier SAN wording custody remain open; no adverse conclusion or favorable ledger deletion follows.",
          "dependence_score": "NOT ESTIMATED: no access model, background-rate model, or independent coding calibration",
          "motive_policy": "Motive analysis is deferred by product design."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Gorla-style operational preservation, Baez-style structural comparison and Chiribella-style operational comparisons are prompts for testing structure, not executed mathematical proofs in this packet. No formal theorem, numerical percent equivalence, five-sigma result, copying, legal violation, or whole-theory experimental validation is claimed.",
      "citation_boundary": "Not adjudicated by this selected projection.",
      "program_history": "The target-family January 2021 Hot-Coal preprint already presents spatial activation maps and beta gating (P5–P8), before the September 2021 SAN archive capture. Earlier SAN article metadata remains visible but is not sufficient to date each sentence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Mind Code // Brain Code: Go (Ancient Game) and Alpha Go",
        "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20210919213836/https://medium.com/silicon-valley-global-news/the-game-of-go-speculation-about-the-code-of-our-minds-in-our-brains-5a39d7cb6366",
        "sha256": null,
        "date": "2021-09-19",
        "date_type": "Exact wording preserved by 19 September 2021",
        "date_boundary": "Article metadata says published 30 June 2017 and modified 14 August 2018. The captured text is not individually backdated to either metadata date.",
        "public_wording_by": "2021-09-19",
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "The inhibited parts of the brain should feature the unconscious material.",
          "the parts of you that are paying attention to something you are looking at become excited and that means they exhibit more activity"
        ],
        "locators": [
          "f236"
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Working Memory Is Complex and Dynamic, Like Your Thoughts",
        "authors": [
          "Timothy J. Buschman",
          "Earl K. Miller"
        ],
        "url": "https://doi.org/10.1162/jocn_a_01940",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": null,
        "date": "2022-12-01",
        "date_type": "1 December 2022 — Crossref publication record",
        "date_boundary": "Crossref records 1 December 2022; journal volume 35 issue 1 is 2023. DOI creation on 2 November 2022 is not a publication date. The 2021 SAN archive predates either 2022 date.",
        "quote": "Alpha/beta inhibits gamma wherever they “collide” in cortex.",
        "summary": "The surrounding paragraphs describe reduction of deep-layer alpha/beta allowing superficial recurrent excitation, gamma bursting and memory readout; increasing beta suppresses this activity.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "PDF page 4 (printed page 20), control by oscillatory dynamics",
          "quote": "Alpha/beta inhibits gamma wherever they “collide” in cortex.",
          "context": "The surrounding paragraphs describe reduction of deep-layer alpha/beta allowing superficial recurrent excitation, gamma bursting and memory readout; increasing beta suppresses this activity.",
          "source": "REVIEW",
          "page": 4
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../miller-spatial-computing/evidence.html#MIL-PUB-MASK-2022",
      "deck_href": "../miller-spatial-computing/index.html",
      "data_href": "../miller-spatial-computing/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/1",
      "source_file_sha256": "AC0BEEABCCC29ED2E494AC8FA0936516FC94E57566C1C6B77E58F01A656FDD1A",
      "release_state": "historical-source-release-current-global-recheck-exception"
    },
    {
      "id": "miller-spatial:MIL-PUB-SHAPE-2023",
      "original_id": "MIL-PUB-SHAPE-2023",
      "edition_id": "miller-spatial",
      "program": "Miller",
      "passage_id": "passage-1C294299F5AAE5418FB7",
      "source_work_id": "miller-spatial:source-url:https://web.archive.org/web/20210919213836/https://medium.com/silicon-valley-global-news/the-game-of-go-speculation-about-the-code-of-our-minds-in-our-brains-5a39d7cb6366",
      "target_work_id": "miller-spatial:document:JOURNAL",
      "title": "Thoughts have a pattern of activity and inhibition",
      "conclusion": "Micah / SAN’s dated record precedes this selected later document on the mapped partial correspondence.",
      "shared": "selection or task context → spatially differentiated excitation/inhibition → selective expression or access to neural content",
      "relation": "PARTIAL_OPERATIONAL_AND_CAUSAL_MATCH",
      "residual": "SAN's passage concerns the proposed spatial shape of thoughts. The target describes working-memory control with specified frequency bands and separates coarse control from fine-grained item coding. Those additional claims are not contained in this SAN sentence.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "function": "d2a1 describes the spatial form of thoughts using excitation and inhibition. The selection function is supplied by f236 in the same article, not inferred from d2a1 alone. The target instead specifies spatial control of memory expression. The shared operation is partial.",
          "behavior": "Both describe simultaneous higher activity in selected regions and inhibited activity elsewhere. The target adds specific task-dependent readout and control behavior.",
          "operation": "Spatially organized excitation/inhibition changes which neural content is expressed. The target assigns distinct roles to beta, gamma, spiking and item location; the SAN source does not specify that entire implementation.",
          "math": "No equation-to-equation equivalence is demonstrated in these passages. No formal numerical score or isomorphism proof is assigned.",
          "program": "An informal selection/gating subroutine can be translated between the descriptions. There is no executable implementation or verified program equivalence here.",
          "form": "A spatially and temporally differentiated neural pattern is shared; SAN thought-shape and target control-pattern are not treated as identical representational levels."
        },
        "L2": {
          "matched_subchain": [
            "selection or task context",
            "spatially differentiated excitation/inhibition",
            "selective expression or access to neural content"
          ],
          "degree": "PARTIAL CAUSAL-ARCHITECTURE MATCH",
          "boundary": "The SAN causal selection step is explicitly bound to neighboring article paragraph f236; d2a1 alone is representational. Together they support spatial excitation/inhibition -> selected content expression. This does not equate thought content itself with the target's coarse control map."
        },
        "L3": {
          "strongest_supported_reading": "The SAN source independently documents the two compared formulations before the selected 2022 and 2023 publication records. Different vocabulary does not erase the shared gating operation.",
          "antecedent_control": "The target-family January 2021 Hot-Coal preprint already presents spatial activation maps and beta gating (P5–P8), before the September 2021 SAN archive capture. Earlier SAN article metadata remains visible but is not sufficient to date each sentence.",
          "residual": "This comparison alone does not establish SAN-before-target-family priority. Older component literature and earlier SAN wording custody remain open; no adverse conclusion or favorable ledger deletion follows.",
          "dependence_score": "NOT ESTIMATED: no access model, background-rate model, or independent coding calibration",
          "motive_policy": "Motive analysis is deferred by product design."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Gorla-style operational preservation, Baez-style structural comparison and Chiribella-style operational comparisons are prompts for testing structure, not executed mathematical proofs in this packet. No formal theorem, numerical percent equivalence, five-sigma result, copying, legal violation, or whole-theory experimental validation is claimed.",
      "citation_boundary": "Not adjudicated by this selected projection.",
      "program_history": "The target-family January 2021 Hot-Coal preprint already presents spatial activation maps and beta gating (P5–P8), before the September 2021 SAN archive capture. Earlier SAN article metadata remains visible but is not sufficient to date each sentence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Mind Code // Brain Code: Go (Ancient Game) and Alpha Go",
        "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20210919213836/https://medium.com/silicon-valley-global-news/the-game-of-go-speculation-about-the-code-of-our-minds-in-our-brains-5a39d7cb6366",
        "sha256": null,
        "date": "2021-09-19",
        "date_type": "Exact wording preserved by 19 September 2021",
        "date_boundary": "Article metadata says published 30 June 2017 and modified 14 August 2018. The captured text is not individually backdated to either metadata date.",
        "public_wording_by": "2021-09-19",
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "So that the shape of our thoughts, in tempo-spatial patterns is represented not only by what is excited in our brains but also by what is inhibited in our brains."
        ],
        "locators": [
          "d2a1",
          "f236"
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Working memory control dynamics follow principles of spatial computing",
        "authors": [
          "Mikael Lundqvist",
          "Scott L. Brincat",
          "Jonas Rose",
          "Melissa R. Warden",
          "Timothy J. Buschman",
          "Earl K. Miller",
          "Pawel Herman"
        ],
        "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-36555-4",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": null,
        "date": "2023-03-14",
        "date_type": "14 March 2023 — journal publication",
        "date_boundary": "Received 16 March 2022; accepted 7 February 2023. The January 2021 preprint already contains the target family's spatial-gating proposal.",
        "quote": "The manifestation is a dynamic patchwork of beta and gamma bursts.",
        "summary": "The paragraph assigns control information to network space, distributing memory items across locations for independent manipulation, with beta inhibiting gamma/spiking where beta is high.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "Discussion, opening paragraph; XML paragraph 33",
          "quote": "The manifestation is a dynamic patchwork of beta and gamma bursts.",
          "context": "The paragraph assigns control information to network space, distributing memory items across locations for independent manipulation, with beta inhibiting gamma/spiking where beta is high.",
          "source": "JOURNAL",
          "paragraph": 33
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../miller-spatial-computing/evidence.html#MIL-PUB-SHAPE-2023",
      "deck_href": "../miller-spatial-computing/index.html",
      "data_href": "../miller-spatial-computing/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/2",
      "source_file_sha256": "AC0BEEABCCC29ED2E494AC8FA0936516FC94E57566C1C6B77E58F01A656FDD1A",
      "release_state": "historical-source-release-current-global-recheck-exception"
    },
    {
      "id": "miller-spatial:MIL-PUB-MASK-2023",
      "original_id": "MIL-PUB-MASK-2023",
      "edition_id": "miller-spatial",
      "program": "Miller",
      "passage_id": "passage-648B00F6E6DC98CC3291",
      "source_work_id": "miller-spatial:source-url:https://web.archive.org/web/20210919213836/https://medium.com/silicon-valley-global-news/the-game-of-go-speculation-about-the-code-of-our-minds-in-our-brains-5a39d7cb6366",
      "target_work_id": "miller-spatial:document:JOURNAL",
      "title": "Selection changes what the network can express",
      "conclusion": "Micah / SAN’s dated record precedes this selected later document on the mapped partial correspondence.",
      "shared": "selection or task context → spatially differentiated excitation/inhibition → selective expression or access to neural content",
      "relation": "PARTIAL_OPERATIONAL_AND_CAUSAL_MATCH",
      "residual": "The shared operation is selective expression through excitation and inhibition. SAN's speculation about whole-brain electrical equilibrium and conscious/unconscious content is not established by the target experiments, and is not the target's stated explanation.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "function": "Both connect selective neural expression with the content that is currently available. This is a partial functional match, not equivalence of complete theories.",
          "behavior": "Both describe simultaneous higher activity in selected regions and inhibited activity elsewhere. The target adds specific task-dependent readout and control behavior.",
          "operation": "Spatially organized excitation/inhibition changes which neural content is expressed. The target assigns distinct roles to beta, gamma, spiking and item location; the SAN source does not specify that entire implementation.",
          "math": "No equation-to-equation equivalence is demonstrated in these passages. No formal numerical score or isomorphism proof is assigned.",
          "program": "An informal selection/gating subroutine can be translated between the descriptions. There is no executable implementation or verified program equivalence here.",
          "form": "A spatially and temporally differentiated neural pattern is shared; SAN thought-shape and target control-pattern are not treated as identical representational levels."
        },
        "L2": {
          "matched_subchain": [
            "selection or task context",
            "spatially differentiated excitation/inhibition",
            "selective expression or access to neural content"
          ],
          "degree": "PARTIAL CAUSAL-ARCHITECTURE MATCH",
          "boundary": "Three matched roles do not establish identical full narrative architecture. The target's item/control scale separation, order coding and generalization claims exceed the archived SAN excerpts."
        },
        "L3": {
          "strongest_supported_reading": "The SAN source independently documents the two compared formulations before the selected 2022 and 2023 publication records. Different vocabulary does not erase the shared gating operation.",
          "antecedent_control": "The target-family January 2021 Hot-Coal preprint already presents spatial activation maps and beta gating (P5–P8), before the September 2021 SAN archive capture. Earlier SAN article metadata remains visible but is not sufficient to date each sentence.",
          "residual": "This comparison alone does not establish SAN-before-target-family priority. Older component literature and earlier SAN wording custody remain open; no adverse conclusion or favorable ledger deletion follows.",
          "dependence_score": "NOT ESTIMATED: no access model, background-rate model, or independent coding calibration",
          "motive_policy": "Motive analysis is deferred by product design."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Gorla-style operational preservation, Baez-style structural comparison and Chiribella-style operational comparisons are prompts for testing structure, not executed mathematical proofs in this packet. No formal theorem, numerical percent equivalence, five-sigma result, copying, legal violation, or whole-theory experimental validation is claimed.",
      "citation_boundary": "Not adjudicated by this selected projection.",
      "program_history": "The target-family January 2021 Hot-Coal preprint already presents spatial activation maps and beta gating (P5–P8), before the September 2021 SAN archive capture. Earlier SAN article metadata remains visible but is not sufficient to date each sentence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Mind Code // Brain Code: Go (Ancient Game) and Alpha Go",
        "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20210919213836/https://medium.com/silicon-valley-global-news/the-game-of-go-speculation-about-the-code-of-our-minds-in-our-brains-5a39d7cb6366",
        "sha256": null,
        "date": "2021-09-19",
        "date_type": "Exact wording preserved by 19 September 2021",
        "date_boundary": "Article metadata says published 30 June 2017 and modified 14 August 2018. The captured text is not individually backdated to either metadata date.",
        "public_wording_by": "2021-09-19",
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "The inhibited parts of the brain should feature the unconscious material.",
          "the parts of you that are paying attention to something you are looking at become excited and that means they exhibit more activity"
        ],
        "locators": [
          "f236"
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Working memory control dynamics follow principles of spatial computing",
        "authors": [
          "Mikael Lundqvist",
          "Scott L. Brincat",
          "Jonas Rose",
          "Melissa R. Warden",
          "Timothy J. Buschman",
          "Earl K. Miller",
          "Pawel Herman"
        ],
        "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-36555-4",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": null,
        "date": "2023-03-14",
        "date_type": "14 March 2023 — journal publication",
        "date_boundary": "Received 16 March 2022; accepted 7 February 2023. The January 2021 preprint already contains the target family's spatial-gating proposal.",
        "quote": "Beta bursts act as the control signal.",
        "summary": "The paragraph links beta to inhibition of gamma/spiking and thereby access to working-memory content. The next paragraphs explain how spatial control addresses individual items.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "Introduction, second paragraph; XML paragraph 6",
          "quote": "Beta bursts act as the control signal.",
          "context": "The paragraph links beta to inhibition of gamma/spiking and thereby access to working-memory content. The next paragraphs explain how spatial control addresses individual items.",
          "source": "JOURNAL",
          "paragraph": 6
        },
        "speech_act": null
      },
      "evidence_href": "../miller-spatial-computing/evidence.html#MIL-PUB-MASK-2023",
      "deck_href": "../miller-spatial-computing/index.html",
      "data_href": "../miller-spatial-computing/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/3",
      "source_file_sha256": "AC0BEEABCCC29ED2E494AC8FA0936516FC94E57566C1C6B77E58F01A656FDD1A",
      "release_state": "historical-source-release-current-global-recheck-exception"
    },
    {
      "id": "seth-selected:S-PUB-RECEIVER",
      "original_id": "S-PUB-RECEIVER",
      "edition_id": "seth-selected",
      "program": "Seth and coauthors",
      "passage_id": "passage-2FC545FCC7A3DD08C715",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:824A074A17729942D83FEBA0E9BA3297EEC4F287F9C46FE956B890273FBC4B50",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:0C3C16675F4FCE48FBFBBE74FFCF7B8D9A1BBD2F5249978DA8CDE2E6B63B69BA",
      "title": "SAN proposed selective reception in its 2022 record; the 2025 Seth-coauthored review asks how receiving neurons use a message.",
      "conclusion": "SAN proposed selective reception in its 2022 record; the 2025 Seth-coauthored review asks how receiving neurons use a message.",
      "shared": "Incoming message -> receiver-dependent use. Recognition by learned morphology and selective outgoing projection are the SAN proposal for the missing middle, not operations asserted by this target sentence.",
      "relation": "earlier-mechanism-to-later-explanatory-demand",
      "residual": "The apical-dendrite/exit-terminal conflation in the same SAN neighborhood is not endorsed. Quoted layer-5/layer-6 studies are prior sources, not Micah's experiments. Full neural semantics and experiential sufficiency remain open.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_FUNCTIONAL_PROBLEM_FIT",
          "reason": "SAN states a selective input-recognition-to-output operation. The target constrains the explanatory job at the receiver. This is a supported answer-to-question pairing, not implementation equivalence."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_ARCHITECTURAL_LOCATION",
          "reason": "Both place the explanatory burden after signal arrival and before useful downstream processing. Only SAN joins learned receptive structure, recognition and projection in a proposed causal chain."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "SUPPORTED_CONSTRAINED_OUTPUT_RECONSTRUCTION_WITH_NONUNIQUE_SOLUTION",
          "reason": "Constrained result: A broadcast carries information that downstream neural processing can use. Required operation: There must be a physically implemented dependence of receiver processing on relevant message differences; arrival alone does not explain use. Source test: Line 3 supplies learned selectivity followed by transmission; lines 49–61 elaborate input-sensitive response learning. Alternatives: Learned receptive selectivity; Fixed feature-sensitive circuitry; Population decoding or predictive message passing. Remaining uncertainty: The question neither selects this mechanism nor proves the claimed receiver operation explains consciousness."
        }
      },
      "formal": {
        "category_theory": "Partial role/subchain translation only. No object-and-morphism construction or proof of functoriality is supplied.",
        "process": "The common input/transform/output dependencies are stated explicitly; no transition-system bisimulation or process-calculus equivalence is proved.",
        "quantitative_grade": "Not calibrated; no invented percentage or sigma."
      },
      "citation_boundary": "Not adjudicated by this selected projection.",
      "program_history": "The selected passage questions global-broadcast explanations. This card compares the explanatory job with SAN’s proposed receiver mechanism; it does not claim the question adopts that mechanism.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN proposed selective reception in its 2022 record; the 2025 Seth-coauthored review asks how receiving neurons use a message.",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/894b4d4ea3f23d4d1d526e123b5744283ff9cd5d/a0007z.md#L3",
        "sha256": "824A074A17729942D83FEBA0E9BA3297EEC4F287F9C46FE956B890273FBC4B50",
        "date": "2022-09-18",
        "date_type": "Git repository commit record",
        "date_boundary": "Current anonymous public access to the exact source body was verified on 2026-10-11. The displayed 2022 date is a Git record date, not independently verified first-publication timing.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "Dendritic morphologies & synaptic connections represent learned memories. Memories activate when preferred patterns (the memory) are detected, this causes cells to create a selective transmission or a projection to other cells (neural arrays)."
        ],
        "locators": {
          "line": 3,
          "other_passages": []
        }
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Consciousness science: where are we, where are we going, and what if we get there?",
        "authors": [
          "Axel Cleeremans",
          "Liad Mudrik",
          "Anil K. Seth"
        ],
        "url": "https://doi.org/10.3389/fsci.2025.1546279",
        "pdf_url": "https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/science/articles/10.3389/fsci.2025.1546279/pdf#page=9",
        "sha256": "0C3C16675F4FCE48FBFBBE74FFCF7B8D9A1BBD2F5249978DA8CDE2E6B63B69BA",
        "date": "2025-10-30",
        "date_type": "Publisher publication date",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "how do the receiving neurons understand the message",
        "summary": "The authors ask what happens after a signal is broadcast: how does a receiving neuron make use of it? They request a mechanism rather than endorse one.",
        "locators": {
          "page": 9,
          "text_lines": [
            758,
            758
          ],
          "section": "From correlates to testable theories; opening paragraph continued from p. 7"
        },
        "speech_act": "The authors request a mechanistic explanation of a global broadcast's reception; they do not endorse an implementation."
      },
      "evidence_href": "../anil-seth/source-comparisons/evidence.html#S-PUB-RECEIVER",
      "deck_href": "../anil-seth/source-comparisons/index.html",
      "data_href": "../anil-seth/source-comparisons/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/display_rows/0",
      "source_file_sha256": "48142DB5C9D9C7307BE5A7B6DF8388118924A3DBD9C553B054EF0349BC93F6D5",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "seth-selected:S-PUB-BCI",
      "original_id": "S-PUB-BCI",
      "edition_id": "seth-selected",
      "program": "Seth and coauthors",
      "passage_id": "passage-70D087CDF66C2841BE24",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:9560B7C53AA44B83D0D1AF409B0890754B40418B282AC13A24FFC3AF8D08E9DE",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:0C3C16675F4FCE48FBFBBE74FFCF7B8D9A1BBD2F5249978DA8CDE2E6B63B69BA",
      "title": "SAN’s 2022 record proposes measured-pattern BCI reconstruction before the selected 2025 intervention agenda.",
      "conclusion": "SAN’s 2022 record proposes measured-pattern BCI reconstruction before the selected 2025 intervention agenda.",
      "shared": "Identify an experience-relevant neural organization -> intervene on that organization -> intentionally change experience.",
      "relation": "partial-operation",
      "residual": "SAN explicitly names sensory-substitution examples, David Eagleman, Hawkins and Tim Mullen. Those components remain prior-work boundaries; the proposed synthesis is not evidence of inventing them.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_OPERATION",
          "reason": "Both propose a causal intervention on neural mechanisms to affect experience. SAN specifies reproducing a learned distributed pattern; the target specifies neither that code nor faithful replay of a particular sensory episode."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_CAUSAL_SUBCHAIN",
          "reason": "Neural account -> intervention target -> altered experience is common. SAN adds measurement of personal sensory patterns and proposed thalamic stimulation; target purposes include remediation and enhancement rather than only recreation."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "SUPPORTED_CONSTRAINED_OUTPUT_RECONSTRUCTION_WITH_NONUNIQUE_SOLUTION",
          "reason": "Constrained result: A circuit intervention intentionally remediates or enhances a conscious experience. Required operation: The manipulated circuit variable must causally affect the experiential feature, with sufficient targeting to separate it from a merely behavioral effect. Source test: Lines 4 and 16 propose measuring a sensory pattern and stimulating the thalamus with a corresponding pattern to trigger experience. Alternatives: Electrical activity-pattern stimulation; Neurochemical modulation; Other content-relevant neural codes. Remaining uncertainty: The target does not require SAN's code, anatomical location, replay fidelity or proposed BCI. Neither text demonstrates this SAN procedure."
        }
      },
      "formal": {
        "category_theory": "Partial role/subchain translation only. No object-and-morphism construction or proof of functoriality is supplied.",
        "process": "The common input/transform/output dependencies are stated explicitly; no transition-system bisimulation or process-calculus equivalence is proved.",
        "quantitative_grade": "Not calibrated; no invented percentage or sigma."
      },
      "citation_boundary": "Not adjudicated by this selected projection.",
      "program_history": "SAN’s source names sensory-substitution examples, David Eagleman, Jeff Hawkins and Tim Mullen. Their component work remains visible; the compared SAN contribution is the proposed measured-pattern reconstruction chain.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN’s 2022 record proposes measured-pattern BCI reconstruction before the selected 2025 intervention agenda.",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/81210149c4fbf14575ee6c6b56c05daa34a92273/a0306z.md#L4",
        "sha256": "9560B7C53AA44B83D0D1AF409B0890754B40418B282AC13A24FFC3AF8D08E9DE",
        "date": "2022-06-12",
        "date_type": "Git repository commit record",
        "date_boundary": "Current anonymous public access to the exact source body was verified on 2026-10-11. The displayed 2022 date is a Git record date, not independently verified first-publication timing.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "The point of the Brocoli Properties example was to show that if we could intercept at the Thalamus how the properties of Brocoli are signals being passed to the neo cortex, then we could recreate the experience of Brocoli in the Thalamus by creating that set of temporal & spatially distributed phase changes."
        ],
        "locators": {
          "line": 4,
          "other_passages": [
            {
              "line": 16,
              "text": "So if we knew how the properties of brocoli were represented by scanning them at the Thalamus at the moment you were thinking about them, then we might identify which cortical column is managing those properties when you are not thinking about them, and even if you have a completely different personality that manages brocoli in a different region of the cortex, by stimulating the thalamus with the properties of brocoli that we learned from watching your thalamus we might trigger the experience of brocoli in your brain, we might have a next generation brain computer interface for bringing Augmented Reality & Virtual Reality experiences not through glasses but through direct brain stimulation, to recreate known patterns.",
              "label": "Same source: measured-pattern BCI continuation",
              "record_date": "2022-06-12",
              "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/81210149c4fbf14575ee6c6b56c05daa34a92273/a0306z.md#L16"
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Consciousness science: where are we, where are we going, and what if we get there?",
        "authors": [
          "Axel Cleeremans",
          "Liad Mudrik",
          "Anil K. Seth"
        ],
        "url": "https://doi.org/10.3389/fsci.2025.1546279",
        "pdf_url": "https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/science/articles/10.3389/fsci.2025.1546279/pdf#page=14",
        "sha256": "0C3C16675F4FCE48FBFBBE74FFCF7B8D9A1BBD2F5249978DA8CDE2E6B63B69BA",
        "date": "2025-10-30",
        "date_type": "Publisher publication date",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "circuit-level interventions",
        "summary": "The review proposes that understanding the biological basis of consciousness could enable brain interfaces that change, restore or improve aspects of experience. It does not specify SAN’s pattern code.",
        "locators": {
          "page": 14,
          "text_lines": [
            1170,
            1174
          ],
          "section": "Clinical implications / mental health, final paragraph before Ethical implications"
        },
        "speech_act": "Conditional future intervention agenda: better biological understanding should enable circuit-level interventions, including BCIs, that affect experience."
      },
      "evidence_href": "../anil-seth/source-comparisons/evidence.html#S-PUB-BCI",
      "deck_href": "../anil-seth/source-comparisons/index.html",
      "data_href": "../anil-seth/source-comparisons/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/display_rows/1",
      "source_file_sha256": "48142DB5C9D9C7307BE5A7B6DF8388118924A3DBD9C553B054EF0349BC93F6D5",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "seth-selected:S-PUB-CONTROL",
      "original_id": "S-PUB-CONTROL",
      "edition_id": "seth-selected",
      "program": "Seth and coauthors",
      "passage_id": "passage-70D087CDF66C2841BE24",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:9560B7C53AA44B83D0D1AF409B0890754B40418B282AC13A24FFC3AF8D08E9DE",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:0C3C16675F4FCE48FBFBBE74FFCF7B8D9A1BBD2F5249978DA8CDE2E6B63B69BA",
      "title": "SAN’s 2022 reconstruction proposal supplies a partial explanation-to-control match with the selected 2025 review.",
      "conclusion": "SAN’s 2022 reconstruction proposal supplies a partial explanation-to-control match with the selected 2025 review.",
      "shared": "Relate neural states to conscious experience -> identify a causally relevant target -> use it for deliberate experiential control.",
      "relation": "partial-operation",
      "residual": "This is a second passage in the same target document and reuses the BCI row's SAN concept. Reference 22 / footnote 3 identifies Metzinger's 2009 phenotechnology antecedent; no firstness over that line is established.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_FUNCTION_AND_OPERATION",
          "reason": "The target's prospective ability to control experience contains the goal served by SAN's proposed sensory-pattern recreation. SAN does not supply all conscious-state identification or arbitrary precise control."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_CAUSAL_SUBCHAIN",
          "reason": "Understanding the neural basis is meant to make intervention possible in both. The target includes distinguishing conscious from nonconscious states, which SAN's broccoli example does not establish."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "SUPPORTED_CONSTRAINED_OUTPUT_RECONSTRUCTION_WITH_NONUNIQUE_SOLUTION",
          "reason": "Constrained result: A tool controls consciousness as precisely as tools aim to control behavior. Required operation: Identify manipulable neural variables with reliable experiential consequences; behavioral control alone is insufficient. Source test: SAN line 4 proposes a causal replay mechanism and line 16 adds individual-pattern measurement and direct stimulation. Alternatives: Pattern-specific stimulation; State-level neuromodulation; Other experimentally calibrated neural interventions. Remaining uncertainty: Recreating one proposed content does not derive a general test for consciousness or the target's precision of control."
        }
      },
      "formal": {
        "category_theory": "Partial role/subchain translation only. No object-and-morphism construction or proof of functoriality is supplied.",
        "process": "The common input/transform/output dependencies are stated explicitly; no transition-system bisimulation or process-calculus equivalence is proved.",
        "quantitative_grade": "Not calibrated; no invented percentage or sigma."
      },
      "citation_boundary": "Not adjudicated by this selected projection.",
      "program_history": "The review cites Thomas Metzinger’s The Ego Tunnel (2009), reference 22 and footnote 3, for phenotechnology. The exact earlier mechanism is not adjudicated here; this is a later-document partial comparison, not firstness over that lineage.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN’s 2022 reconstruction proposal supplies a partial explanation-to-control match with the selected 2025 review.",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/81210149c4fbf14575ee6c6b56c05daa34a92273/a0306z.md#L4",
        "sha256": "9560B7C53AA44B83D0D1AF409B0890754B40418B282AC13A24FFC3AF8D08E9DE",
        "date": "2022-06-12",
        "date_type": "Git repository commit record",
        "date_boundary": "Current anonymous public access to the exact source body was verified on 2026-10-11. The displayed 2022 date is a Git record date, not independently verified first-publication timing.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "The point of the Brocoli Properties example was to show that if we could intercept at the Thalamus how the properties of Brocoli are signals being passed to the neo cortex, then we could recreate the experience of Brocoli in the Thalamus by creating that set of temporal & spatially distributed phase changes."
        ],
        "locators": {
          "line": 4,
          "other_passages": [
            {
              "line": 16,
              "text": "So if we knew how the properties of brocoli were represented by scanning them at the Thalamus at the moment you were thinking about them, then we might identify which cortical column is managing those properties when you are not thinking about them, and even if you have a completely different personality that manages brocoli in a different region of the cortex, by stimulating the thalamus with the properties of brocoli that we learned from watching your thalamus we might trigger the experience of brocoli in your brain, we might have a next generation brain computer interface for bringing Augmented Reality & Virtual Reality experiences not through glasses but through direct brain stimulation, to recreate known patterns.",
              "label": "Same source: measured-pattern BCI continuation",
              "record_date": "2022-06-12",
              "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/81210149c4fbf14575ee6c6b56c05daa34a92273/a0306z.md#L16"
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Consciousness science: where are we, where are we going, and what if we get there?",
        "authors": [
          "Axel Cleeremans",
          "Liad Mudrik",
          "Anil K. Seth"
        ],
        "url": "https://doi.org/10.3389/fsci.2025.1546279",
        "pdf_url": "https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/science/articles/10.3389/fsci.2025.1546279/pdf#page=12",
        "sha256": "0C3C16675F4FCE48FBFBBE74FFCF7B8D9A1BBD2F5249978DA8CDE2E6B63B69BA",
        "date": "2025-10-30",
        "date_type": "Publisher publication date",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "tools to control consciousness",
        "summary": "The review predicts that progress in consciousness science could make precise control of experience possible, extending beyond control of behavior alone.",
        "locators": {
          "page": 12,
          "text_lines": [
            1067,
            1077
          ],
          "section": "What if we succeed? / Scientific implications; footnote 3"
        },
        "speech_act": "A forward-looking consequence of success in consciousness science, with phenotechnology explicitly cited to Metzinger."
      },
      "evidence_href": "../anil-seth/source-comparisons/evidence.html#S-PUB-CONTROL",
      "deck_href": "../anil-seth/source-comparisons/index.html",
      "data_href": "../anil-seth/source-comparisons/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/display_rows/2",
      "source_file_sha256": "48142DB5C9D9C7307BE5A7B6DF8388118924A3DBD9C553B054EF0349BC93F6D5",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "seth-selected:S-PUB-QUALITY-SPACE",
      "original_id": "S-PUB-QUALITY-SPACE",
      "edition_id": "seth-selected",
      "program": "Seth and coauthors",
      "passage_id": "passage-906D20718C015F724ABE",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:F54159599C6799F6E798D3EDE95F7D3020C513EF826AD5BB7A6D771A485722DE",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:0C3C16675F4FCE48FBFBBE74FFCF7B8D9A1BBD2F5249978DA8CDE2E6B63B69BA",
      "title": "SAN’s 2022 geometry proposal connects learned neural patterns to experiential properties before the selected 2025 review.",
      "conclusion": "SAN’s 2022 geometry proposal connects learned neural patterns to experiential properties before the selected 2025 review.",
      "shared": "Structured neural activity -> representation of particular experiential shapes or properties. The target's additional pairwise similarity relations are not established in SAN.",
      "relation": "partial-representation-role",
      "residual": "A within-experience contour or shape is not automatically a relation among different experiences. Target refs 45–48 and 200–206 include pre-2022 work; their cited presence blocks an unqualified 2022-versus-2025 origin story but is not a completed predecessor adjudication.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_REPRESENTATIONAL_FUNCTION",
          "reason": "SAN ties learned spatial-temporal phase patterns to shapes and properties of experience; the target ties neural state-space organization to visual experience. This is more specific than the word 'geometry', but not the same metric or data analysis."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_CAUSAL_BRIDGE_WITH_RELATIONAL_RESIDUAL",
          "reason": "Neural organization is used to explain experiential content in both. SAN's constructive learning account does not itself derive relational similarity across experiences or subjects, the target's distinctive explanatory step."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "SUPPORTED_CONSTRAINED_OUTPUT_RECONSTRUCTION_WITH_NONUNIQUE_SOLUTION",
          "reason": "Constrained result: Neural similarities systematically correspond to similarities among experiences. Required operation: A representation and comparison rule must retain the distinctions and relations used in perceptual judgments. Source test: Lines 16–18 provide structured learned patterns and experiential properties; line 39 additionally calls phase topology a brain-state attractor. No pairwise similarity rule is supplied. Alternatives: Population-rate geometry; Learned temporal-pattern geometry; Other representational spaces with a separately tested neural-to-perceptual map. Remaining uncertainty: The attractor remark strengthens a state/experience bridge, not evidence for a metric, similarity judgment model or empirical validation."
        }
      },
      "formal": {
        "category_theory": "Partial role/subchain translation only. No object-and-morphism construction or proof of functoriality is supplied.",
        "process": "The common input/transform/output dependencies are stated explicitly; no transition-system bisimulation or process-calculus equivalence is proved.",
        "quantitative_grade": "Not calibrated; no invented percentage or sigma."
      },
      "citation_boundary": "Not adjudicated by this selected projection.",
      "program_history": "The review cites Chang and Tsao (2017), Malach (2021), A. Clark (2000), Rosenthal (2010), Tsuchiya and Saigo (2021), and later quality-space studies. These are named source boundaries, not findings that their complete operations equal SAN. The pairwise similarity metric remains outside this selected SAN excerpt.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN’s 2022 geometry proposal connects learned neural patterns to experiential properties before the selected 2025 review.",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/c1ab1deeed9531a3a35134fc6b6efe8ffeef1392/a0149z.md#L18",
        "sha256": "F54159599C6799F6E798D3EDE95F7D3020C513EF826AD5BB7A6D771A485722DE",
        "date": "2022-07-09",
        "date_type": "Git repository commit record",
        "date_boundary": "Current anonymous public access to the exact source body was verified on 2026-10-11. The displayed 2022 date is a Git record date, not independently verified first-publication timing.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "This means that neural oscillating array-projection tomography can physically represent patterns as (non-linear) phase variation sequences. Then oscillating cell assembles will learn the expressed spatial & temporal phase patterns happening within their cell assembly & derive from those learned patterns the shapes of concepts, the shapes & parameters & properties feelings, objects, sensations, and anything else you can become conscious of."
        ],
        "locators": {
          "line": 18,
          "other_passages": [
            {
              "line": 39,
              "text": "In my thought experiment I am taking the Taylor Series from Calculus and applying it to a 3D grid of phase changes. 3D Calculus. With each phase change that is tracked by the brain representing a different step in a Taylor series representing the information content of the rendered mind *at least the phase topology as a brain state is an attractor point, for the mind's oscillations. ",
              "label": "Same source: phase-topology attractor hypothesis",
              "record_date": "2022-07-09",
              "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/c1ab1deeed9531a3a35134fc6b6efe8ffeef1392/a0149z.md#L39"
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Consciousness science: where are we, where are we going, and what if we get there?",
        "authors": [
          "Axel Cleeremans",
          "Liad Mudrik",
          "Anil K. Seth"
        ],
        "url": "https://doi.org/10.3389/fsci.2025.1546279",
        "pdf_url": "https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/science/articles/10.3389/fsci.2025.1546279/pdf#page=12",
        "sha256": "0C3C16675F4FCE48FBFBBE74FFCF7B8D9A1BBD2F5249978DA8CDE2E6B63B69BA",
        "date": "2025-10-30",
        "date_type": "Publisher publication date",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "high-dimensional neural state",
        "summary": "The review surveys links between neural state spaces and perceptual similarity, and asks how these approaches can be joined to quality-space accounts.",
        "locators": {
          "page": 12,
          "text_lines": [
            976,
            995
          ],
          "section": "New methods / first paragraph on phenomenological similarity structures"
        },
        "speech_act": "Synthesis of empirical neural/perceptual similarity studies and a philosophical quality-space hypothesis, followed by an open integration question."
      },
      "evidence_href": "../anil-seth/source-comparisons/evidence.html#S-PUB-QUALITY-SPACE",
      "deck_href": "../anil-seth/source-comparisons/index.html",
      "data_href": "../anil-seth/source-comparisons/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/display_rows/3",
      "source_file_sha256": "48142DB5C9D9C7307BE5A7B6DF8388118924A3DBD9C553B054EF0349BC93F6D5",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "seth-selected:S-PUB-PREDICTIVE-RENDERING",
      "original_id": "S-PUB-PREDICTIVE-RENDERING",
      "edition_id": "seth-selected",
      "program": "Seth and coauthors",
      "passage_id": "passage-31EDA9274920A7131A39",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:E97073DD551D3A78E10E8D85C7559947F20AA75D7E658081CE4DE37F2C3F944E",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:0C3C16675F4FCE48FBFBBE74FFCF7B8D9A1BBD2F5249978DA8CDE2E6B63B69BA",
      "title": "SAN’s 2022 record documents world-responsive predictive rendering, with a partial match to the selected 2025 review.",
      "conclusion": "SAN’s 2022 record documents world-responsive predictive rendering, with a partial match to the selected 2025 review.",
      "shared": "World-sensitive information -> internally maintained predictive representation -> experienced content.",
      "relation": "partial-operation",
      "residual": "The exact 2025 occurrence is later than the Git record, but its reference 23 is Seth, Being You (2021). The target also states that PP does not by itself specify necessary/sufficient consciousness conditions. Do not imply SAN preceded Seth's predictive-processing work.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_OPERATION",
          "reason": "SAN explicitly combines predictive modeling, world reactivity and internally read patterns. The target makes the sharper claim that top-down predictions provide content and sensory signals constrain them."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_GENERATION_AND_CONSTRAINT_ARCHITECTURE",
          "reason": "Internal modeling coupled to environmental information is shared. SAN's sparse excitation/inhibition departures and downstream receivers are not the target's stated Bayesian prediction-error algorithm."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "SUPPORTED_CONSTRAINED_OUTPUT_RECONSTRUCTION_WITH_NONUNIQUE_SOLUTION",
          "reason": "Constrained result: An internally generated percept is controlled by the world rather than unconstrained hallucination. Required operation: An external-sensitive route must constrain or update the represented content. Source test: Line 19 explicitly supplies world-reactive predictive patterns, and line 21 links sensory interactions to successive receiving arrays. Alternatives: Prediction-error minimization; Other recurrent estimators; World-sensitive selection or correction of internal patterns. Remaining uncertainty: World reactivity does not uniquely imply Bayesian error minimization or a particular top-down hierarchy; no conscious/unconscious discriminator follows."
        }
      },
      "formal": {
        "category_theory": "Partial role/subchain translation only. No object-and-morphism construction or proof of functoriality is supplied.",
        "process": "The common input/transform/output dependencies are stated explicitly; no transition-system bisimulation or process-calculus equivalence is proved.",
        "quantitative_grade": "Not calibrated; no invented percentage or sigma."
      },
      "citation_boundary": "Not adjudicated by this selected projection.",
      "program_history": "The 2025 passage cites Anil Seth’s Being You (2021), reference 23. The 2022-versus-2025 dates identify these selected records, not the first appearance of Seth’s predictive-processing account. Earlier SAN stages and the full before/after comparison remain open.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN’s 2022 record documents world-responsive predictive rendering, with a partial match to the selected 2025 review.",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/f219cf478aeacbe903467a3ca274b00e2e2de085/a0079z.md#L19",
        "sha256": "E97073DD551D3A78E10E8D85C7559947F20AA75D7E658081CE4DE37F2C3F944E",
        "date": "2022-06-10",
        "date_type": "Git repository commit record",
        "date_boundary": "Current anonymous public access to the exact source body was verified on 2026-10-11. The displayed 2022 date is a Git record date, not independently verified first-publication timing.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "It's a self-aware network in 4 dimensions rendering a 4 dimensional pattern to itself that is reactive to the world and able to make prediction-based models of reality with sparse spatially & temporally distributed frequency/phase patterns that represent coicident neural firing or coincident neural inhibition deviating from the oscillatory norm of a given oscillator on some level as observed by the neurons in the oscillator, and by oscillators or circuits or cortical columns linked across the brain thanks to the activity of interneurons and major intersections of traffic such as the thalamic bridges, the corpus callosum, the tempo-parietal junction, Werneck & Broca's areas and other areas of the brain that are highly connected or connecting multiple regions of the brain together."
        ],
        "locators": {
          "line": 19,
          "other_passages": []
        }
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Consciousness science: where are we, where are we going, and what if we get there?",
        "authors": [
          "Axel Cleeremans",
          "Liad Mudrik",
          "Anil K. Seth"
        ],
        "url": "https://doi.org/10.3389/fsci.2025.1546279",
        "pdf_url": "https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/science/articles/10.3389/fsci.2025.1546279/pdf#page=6",
        "sha256": "0C3C16675F4FCE48FBFBBE74FFCF7B8D9A1BBD2F5249978DA8CDE2E6B63B69BA",
        "date": "2025-10-30",
        "date_type": "Publisher publication date",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "controlled hallucination",
        "summary": "The review describes perception as internally generated predictions constrained by sensory signals. It also says predictive processing alone does not settle which processes are conscious.",
        "locators": {
          "page": 6,
          "text_lines": [
            578,
            587
          ],
          "section": "Predictive (and recurrent) processing theory; qualification continues p. 7"
        },
        "speech_act": "Review of predictive-processing theories and the controlled-hallucination formulation, expressly citing Seth's 2021 book."
      },
      "evidence_href": "../anil-seth/source-comparisons/evidence.html#S-PUB-PREDICTIVE-RENDERING",
      "deck_href": "../anil-seth/source-comparisons/index.html",
      "data_href": "../anil-seth/source-comparisons/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/display_rows/4",
      "source_file_sha256": "48142DB5C9D9C7307BE5A7B6DF8388118924A3DBD9C553B054EF0349BC93F6D5",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "seth-selected:S-PUB-ROSETTA",
      "original_id": "S-PUB-ROSETTA",
      "edition_id": "seth-selected",
      "program": "Seth and coauthors",
      "passage_id": "passage-31EDA9274920A7131A39",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:E97073DD551D3A78E10E8D85C7559947F20AA75D7E658081CE4DE37F2C3F944E",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:D2B009D43C7838DBDED0F61E532A167E632DC18610B968709FF9919BC2580880",
      "title": "SAN’s 2022 predictive-rendering record supplies an earlier model-to-experience connection than the selected May 2026 Rosetta version.",
      "conclusion": "SAN’s 2022 predictive-rendering record supplies an earlier model-to-experience connection than the selected May 2026 Rosetta version.",
      "shared": "World/sensory information -> an internal model state -> a proposed relation to experiential content.",
      "relation": "partial-function",
      "residual": "The body is arXiv v3, 4 May 2026, not its inherited v1 key/date. The target's pp. 2–4 name Varela, predictive coding, Bayesian-brain and 2021/2022 generative-passage predecessors; none is erased or awarded a new priority verdict here.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_FUNCTIONAL_BRIDGE",
          "reason": "SAN's internally rendered predictive model and the target's belief-to-phenomenology mapping occupy a related explanatory role. SAN does not define approximate posterior distributions or the map phi."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_MODEL_MEDIATED_ARCHITECTURE",
          "reason": "Both use an internal representation between neural dynamics and experience. The target makes beliefs a common formal currency linking multiple observables, whereas SAN proposes a physical receiver/dynamics realization."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "SUPPORTED_CONSTRAINED_OUTPUT_RECONSTRUCTION_WITH_NONUNIQUE_SOLUTION",
          "reason": "Constrained result: Phenomenological content is determined by the modeled belief state. Required operation: Under that assumption, the belief state and mapping must retain distinctions sufficient to determine experiential content; identical modeled beliefs cannot map to different content without added variables. Source test: SAN lines 17–21 connect temporally distributed representations with consciousness and receiving arrays; they do not establish a probability space or sufficiency of beliefs alone. Alternatives: Identity mapping; Marginalization onto a subset; Pushforward/coarse-graining; Other deterministic, potentially many-to-one mapping. Remaining uncertainty: The reverse argument tests compatibility with a stated assumption. It does not prove the assumption or uniquely identify SAN as its implementation."
        }
      },
      "formal": {
        "category_theory": "Partial role/subchain translation only. No object-and-morphism construction or proof of functoriality is supplied.",
        "process": "The common input/transform/output dependencies are stated explicitly; no transition-system bisimulation or process-calculus equivalence is proved.",
        "quantitative_grade": "Not calibrated; no invented percentage or sigma."
      },
      "citation_boundary": "Not adjudicated by this selected projection.",
      "program_history": "The selected v3 body names Varela’s neurophenomenology, predictive coding, Bayesian-brain accounts and 2021/2022 generative-passage work. Those cited lineages remain open controls. The May 2026 wording is not backdated to the inherited v1 key.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN’s 2022 predictive-rendering record supplies an earlier model-to-experience connection than the selected May 2026 Rosetta version.",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/f219cf478aeacbe903467a3ca274b00e2e2de085/a0079z.md#L19",
        "sha256": "E97073DD551D3A78E10E8D85C7559947F20AA75D7E658081CE4DE37F2C3F944E",
        "date": "2022-06-10",
        "date_type": "Git repository commit record",
        "date_boundary": "Current anonymous public access to the exact source body was verified on 2026-10-11. The displayed 2022 date is a Git record date, not independently verified first-publication timing.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "It's a self-aware network in 4 dimensions rendering a 4 dimensional pattern to itself that is reactive to the world and able to make prediction-based models of reality with sparse spatially & temporally distributed frequency/phase patterns that represent coicident neural firing or coincident neural inhibition deviating from the oscillatory norm of a given oscillator on some level as observed by the neurons in the oscillator, and by oscillators or circuits or cortical columns linked across the brain thanks to the activity of interneurons and major intersections of traffic such as the thalamic bridges, the corpus callosum, the tempo-parietal junction, Werneck & Broca's areas and other areas of the brain that are highly connected or connecting multiple regions of the brain together."
        ],
        "locators": {
          "line": 19,
          "other_passages": []
        }
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "A Rosetta Stone Hypothesis for Neurophenomenology: Mathematical Predictions from Predictive Processing",
        "authors": [
          "Lancelot Da Costa",
          "Anil K. Seth",
          "Karl Friston",
          "Maxwell J. D. Ramstead",
          "Lars Sandved-Smith"
        ],
        "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2409.20318v3",
        "pdf_url": "https://arxiv.org/pdf/2409.20318v3#page=5",
        "sha256": "D2B009D43C7838DBDED0F61E532A167E632DC18610B968709FF9919BC2580880",
        "date": "2026-05-04",
        "date_type": "Exact arXiv version date",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "phenomenology is a function of beliefs",
        "summary": "The paper assumes that experience depends on belief states, then derives consequences if that assumption holds. It allows more than one kind of mapping; the assumption is not presented as an established fact.",
        "locators": {
          "page": 5,
          "text_lines": [
            198,
            203
          ],
          "section": "Section 2, Assumption 2.1; abstract p. 1 and sections 1.2–1.4 pp. 2–4"
        },
        "speech_act": "An explicitly conditional technical assumption, followed by predictions; not a proved fact or a full theory deciding where consciousness exists."
      },
      "evidence_href": "../anil-seth/source-comparisons/evidence.html#S-PUB-ROSETTA",
      "deck_href": "../anil-seth/source-comparisons/index.html",
      "data_href": "../anil-seth/source-comparisons/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/display_rows/5",
      "source_file_sha256": "48142DB5C9D9C7307BE5A7B6DF8388118924A3DBD9C553B054EF0349BC93F6D5",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "seth-selected:S-PUB-ROSETTA-GEOMETRY",
      "original_id": "S-PUB-ROSETTA-GEOMETRY",
      "edition_id": "seth-selected",
      "program": "Seth and coauthors",
      "passage_id": "passage-906D20718C015F724ABE",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:F54159599C6799F6E798D3EDE95F7D3020C513EF826AD5BB7A6D771A485722DE",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:D2B009D43C7838DBDED0F61E532A167E632DC18610B968709FF9919BC2580880",
      "title": "SAN’s 2022 geometry record supplies an earlier representation-to-experience connection than the selected 2026 Rosetta formulation.",
      "conclusion": "SAN’s 2022 geometry record supplies an earlier representation-to-experience connection than the selected 2026 Rosetta formulation.",
      "shared": "Structured internal representation -> characterization of experiential properties. A shared pairwise/inter-subject distance rule is not established.",
      "relation": "partial-representation-role",
      "residual": "Taylor-series/tensor language is offered as a thought experiment and analogy, not a proved approximation theorem or a demonstrated metric. Keeping this limit does not erase the explicit neural-pattern/experience bridge.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_REPRESENTATIONAL_ROLE_ONLY",
          "reason": "SAN gives a physically learned pattern-to-experiential-shape proposal. The target characterizes differences in probability-distribution content and conditionally induces phenomenological geometry. That role-level subset survives, not the metric."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_BRIDGE_NOT_SHARED_RELATIONAL_DERIVATION",
          "reason": "The common prefix is representational structure informing experience. Worker L2's 'relations among experiences' goes beyond SAN's shown intra-experience shapes/properties. The target adds an explicit belief-to-phenomenology map and information-geometric distances."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "SUPPORTED_CONSTRAINED_OUTPUT_RECONSTRUCTION_WITH_NONUNIQUE_SOLUTION",
          "reason": "Constrained result: A geometry can characterize experiential differences across subjects or moments. Required operation: Specify a state space, a discrepancy/metric, and a justified relation between that discrepancy and experiential difference. Source test: SAN lines 6, 16–18 and 39 describe changing structured neural patterns and experiential properties, but supply neither a probability-distribution metric nor an inter-subject comparison map. Alternatives: Fisher information distance under the target's conditions; Other divergences or metrics explicitly allowed by the target; A neural-pattern geometry with an independently supplied experiential comparison map. Remaining uncertainty: Different neural patterns can support different experiential properties without fixing their distances. SAN does not derive Fisher geometry, confidence effects or the paper's predictions."
        }
      },
      "formal": {
        "category_theory": "Partial role/subchain translation only. No object-and-morphism construction or proof of functoriality is supplied.",
        "process": "The common input/transform/output dependencies are stated explicitly; no transition-system bisimulation or process-calculus equivalence is proved.",
        "quantitative_grade": "Not calibrated; no invented percentage or sigma."
      },
      "citation_boundary": "Not adjudicated by this selected projection.",
      "program_history": "The v3 paper’s related-work section preserves Varela and predictive-processing/generative-passage antecedents. SAN’s Taylor-series and attractor statements are proposals, not a proof of this paper’s Fisher metric or predictions.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN’s 2022 geometry record supplies an earlier representation-to-experience connection than the selected 2026 Rosetta formulation.",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/c1ab1deeed9531a3a35134fc6b6efe8ffeef1392/a0149z.md#L18",
        "sha256": "F54159599C6799F6E798D3EDE95F7D3020C513EF826AD5BB7A6D771A485722DE",
        "date": "2022-07-09",
        "date_type": "Git repository commit record",
        "date_boundary": "Current anonymous public access to the exact source body was verified on 2026-10-11. The displayed 2022 date is a Git record date, not independently verified first-publication timing.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "This means that neural oscillating array-projection tomography can physically represent patterns as (non-linear) phase variation sequences. Then oscillating cell assembles will learn the expressed spatial & temporal phase patterns happening within their cell assembly & derive from those learned patterns the shapes of concepts, the shapes & parameters & properties feelings, objects, sensations, and anything else you can become conscious of."
        ],
        "locators": {
          "line": 18,
          "other_passages": [
            {
              "line": 39,
              "text": "In my thought experiment I am taking the Taylor Series from Calculus and applying it to a 3D grid of phase changes. 3D Calculus. With each phase change that is tracked by the brain representing a different step in a Taylor series representing the information content of the rendered mind *at least the phase topology as a brain state is an attractor point, for the mind's oscillations. ",
              "label": "Same source: phase-topology attractor hypothesis",
              "record_date": "2022-07-09",
              "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/c1ab1deeed9531a3a35134fc6b6efe8ffeef1392/a0149z.md#L39"
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "A Rosetta Stone Hypothesis for Neurophenomenology: Mathematical Predictions from Predictive Processing",
        "authors": [
          "Lancelot Da Costa",
          "Anil K. Seth",
          "Karl Friston",
          "Maxwell J. D. Ramstead",
          "Lars Sandved-Smith"
        ],
        "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2409.20318v3",
        "pdf_url": "https://arxiv.org/pdf/2409.20318v3#page=4",
        "sha256": "D2B009D43C7838DBDED0F61E532A167E632DC18610B968709FF9919BC2580880",
        "date": "2026-05-04",
        "date_type": "Exact arXiv version date",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "a geometry for phenomenology",
        "summary": "The paper develops a conditional geometry of experiential differences from its belief-state account. Its information-geometric distances add machinery not established by the selected SAN passage.",
        "locators": {
          "page": 4,
          "text_lines": [
            155,
            158
          ],
          "section": "Scope/contribution p. 4; section 3.1.1 pp. 6–7; Assumption 2.1 p. 5"
        },
        "speech_act": "The authors derive a conditional information-geometric framework; their Fisher metric is a natural choice, not uniquely mandated."
      },
      "evidence_href": "../anil-seth/source-comparisons/evidence.html#S-PUB-ROSETTA-GEOMETRY",
      "deck_href": "../anil-seth/source-comparisons/index.html",
      "data_href": "../anil-seth/source-comparisons/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/display_rows/6",
      "source_file_sha256": "48142DB5C9D9C7307BE5A7B6DF8388118924A3DBD9C553B054EF0349BC93F6D5",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "seth-selected:S-PUB-RECURRENT-COMPUTING",
      "original_id": "S-PUB-RECURRENT-COMPUTING",
      "edition_id": "seth-selected",
      "program": "Seth and coauthors",
      "passage_id": "passage-4625CD8B95472AF9388D",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:D73632B6DF40CD48127C28B76B8B7965E22E4271BEA54F906E606F97D4E944C8",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:CEBE6F9B6798C5E122802FA216E96A7AC1577BE64B31851378A97A52F1F7E1ED",
      "title": "SAN’s 2022 artificial-neurology record shares recurrent computation with the selected 2024 reservoir study.",
      "conclusion": "SAN’s 2022 artificial-neurology record shares recurrent computation with the selected 2024 reservoir study.",
      "shared": "Incoming activity -> stateful recurrent nonlinear processing -> output available for subsequent computation.",
      "relation": "partial-operation",
      "residual": "The target cites Jaeger (2001), Maass et al. (2002), Buonomano/Maass (2009) for the architecture and Rosas/Mediano et al. (2020) for emergence. These citations are prior-work boundaries, not a new author-wide award.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_OPERATION",
          "reason": "Both descriptions use recurrent neural dynamics over time with downstream outputs. SAN additionally proposes changing connections and experience; the target fixes reservoir weights and trains a linear readout."
        },
        "L2": {
          "result": "PARTIAL_CAUSAL_ARCHITECTURE",
          "reason": "The shared input/state/output dependency is real and survives implementation differences. A loop alone does not establish reservoir training, a task loss, or the target's bidirectional performance/emergence result."
        },
        "L3": {
          "result": "SUPPORTED_CONSTRAINED_OUTPUT_RECONSTRUCTION_WITH_NONUNIQUE_SOLUTION",
          "reason": "Constrained result: Forecast temporal trajectories from the observed input history; the selected paper realizes this goal with a reservoir and learned readout. Required operation: Encode task-relevant input/history in usable state distinctions and map those distinctions to predictions. Source test: SAN line 19 provides time-extended signaling loops, nonlinear spatial-temporal responses and subsequent arrays. It does not specify a fixed reservoir or readout-only optimization. Alternatives: Reservoir recurrence plus trained readout; Other recurrent state models; History windows or delay-line features in nonrecurrent predictors. Remaining uncertainty: SAN's loop is a plausible architectural ingredient, not a derivation of the target equations, optimization or PID emergence measure."
        }
      },
      "formal": {
        "category_theory": "Partial role/subchain translation only. No object-and-morphism construction or proof of functoriality is supplied.",
        "process": "The common input/transform/output dependencies are stated explicitly; no transition-system bisimulation or process-calculus equivalence is proved.",
        "quantitative_grade": "Not calibrated; no invented percentage or sigma."
      },
      "citation_boundary": "Not adjudicated by this selected projection.",
      "program_history": "The paper cites Jaeger (2001), Maass and colleagues (2002), and Buonomano and Maass (2009) for reservoir/state-dependent computing; it cites Rosas/Mediano and colleagues (2020) for emergence. This is a preserved partial comparison with the 2024 document, not a claim that SAN originated reservoir computing.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN’s 2022 artificial-neurology record shares recurrent computation with the selected 2024 reservoir study.",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0320z.md#L19",
        "sha256": "D73632B6DF40CD48127C28B76B8B7965E22E4271BEA54F906E606F97D4E944C8",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "Git repository commit record",
        "date_boundary": "Current anonymous public access to the exact source body was verified on 2026-10-11. The displayed 2022 date is a Git record date, not independently verified first-publication timing.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "The essential physics process could be simulated in just matrix calculations on a TPU, with each dendrite, each neuron, each synapse, and each cortical column being unique or random in it's original configuration, and in a sense what is needed is a space for an array for the outputs to be rendered in human scale time, so that they can be perceived by a sequence of other arrays, also in human scale spacetime, in a loop of array signalling that lasts for a duration comperable to human experience."
        ],
        "locators": {
          "line": 19,
          "other_passages": []
        }
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Evolving Reservoir Computers Reveals Bidirectional Coupling Between Predictive Power and Emergent Dynamics",
        "authors": [
          "Hanna M. Tolle",
          "Andrea I. Luppi",
          "Anil K. Seth",
          "Pedro A. M. Mediano"
        ],
        "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19201v1",
        "pdf_url": "https://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19201v1#page=1",
        "sha256": "CEBE6F9B6798C5E122802FA216E96A7AC1577BE64B31851378A97A52F1F7E1ED",
        "date": "2024-06-27",
        "date_type": "Exact arXiv version date",
        "date_boundary": null,
        "quote": "fixed recurrent neural network",
        "summary": "The study uses an established recurrent reservoir with a trained readout to predict changing environments. Its specific performance and emergence results are additional claims, not results demonstrated by SAN’s loop proposal.",
        "locators": {
          "page": 1,
          "text_lines": [
            48,
            61
          ],
          "section": "Introduction, reservoir architecture paragraph; Fig. 1A caption p. 2"
        },
        "speech_act": "Description of an established reservoir-computing architecture used in the authors' prediction/emergence study; not a claim to invent recurrence."
      },
      "evidence_href": "../anil-seth/source-comparisons/evidence.html#S-PUB-RECURRENT-COMPUTING",
      "deck_href": "../anil-seth/source-comparisons/index.html",
      "data_href": "../anil-seth/source-comparisons/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/display_rows/7",
      "source_file_sha256": "48142DB5C9D9C7307BE5A7B6DF8388118924A3DBD9C553B054EF0349BC93F6D5",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-91B5B26D598E22D0B644",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-91B5B26D598E22D0B644",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-B83B1C2A6D1193509C49",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:824A074A17729942D83FEBA0E9BA3297EEC4F287F9C46FE956B890273FBC4B50",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
      "title": "SAN proposes learning and predicting the cell’s own responses",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-09-18) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2024-07-14). The shared role is learning a model of the neural system’s own activity, stated explicitly in the 2022 source before the 2024/2026 papers.",
      "shared": "The shared role is learning a model of the neural system’s own activity, stated explicitly in the 2022 source before the 2024/2026 papers.",
      "relation": "own-neural-activity prediction role · moderate role-level partial",
      "residual": "A qualitative neural self-model is not the target’s numerical prediction of selected current hidden activations in one forward pass. This does not establish the complete estimator, future-state semantics or consciousness.\n\nThe source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.\n\nPredicts current selected hidden activations, not automatically a future biological firing or conscious experience.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "own-neural-activity prediction role",
          "favorable": "The shared role is learning a model of the neural system’s own activity, stated explicitly in the 2022 source before the 2024/2026 papers.",
          "residual": "A qualitative neural self-model is not the target’s numerical prediction of selected current hidden activations in one forward pass. This does not establish the complete estimator, future-state semantics or consciousness."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "The cell is proposed to learn and predict its own response patterns through feedback.",
          "target_roles": "The network predicts subsets of its own hidden activations.",
          "shared_role": "own-neural-activity prediction role",
          "scope_limit": "The source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To reach the reported own-activation prediction, the target must retain an internal activity value and estimate it. Recover the source’s explicit own-activity modelling role, while retaining the missing numerical/state-coordinate implementation.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0007z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/894b4d4ea3f23d4d1d526e123b5744283ff9cd5d/a0007z.md",
        "sha256": "824A074A17729942D83FEBA0E9BA3297EEC4F287F9C46FE956B890273FBC4B50",
        "date": "2022-09-18",
        "date_type": "Historical Git author/commit record; original public availability is not independently certified.",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "My intuition is that the apical is learning its own cell's response, and through feedback loops, with itself and with other pyramidal neurons the cell is going to make predictions about its own patterns of causation, what patterns it responds & how it reacts or responds. With the Apical Dendrite perhaps symbolizing a more complex response that is connected to more complex learning. (compared to other types of neurons)"
        ],
        "locators": [
          51
        ],
        "speech_act": "The source says \"My intuition\" and describes feedback-linked cell responses. Anatomical speculation is not stripped from the source context."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected Benefits of Self-Modeling in Neural Systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram N. Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.10188v1",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "date": "2024-07-14",
        "date_type": "arXiv v1 submission date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies held PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "In addition to performing a primary task, the networks were responsible for predicting the values of subsets of their own hidden activations.",
        "summary": "The network predicts subsets of its own hidden activations.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "PDF pages 1-2; extracted lines 63-71 and 123-128",
          "quote_normalization": "Verbatim wording checked against the2024PDF page2; line-break hyphens and whitespace joined for readability."
        },
        "speech_act": "Predicts current selected hidden activations, not automatically a future biological firing or conscious experience.",
        "hash_kind": "held PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-91B5B26D598E22D0B644",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-91B5B26D598E22D0B644",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/0",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-F6DC84F405510C785476",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-F6DC84F405510C785476",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-39CEEAD5343139662A07",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:BAE95CC2D214077ABCE720EEA26177DADC1301FB3DC0946C93A3B85D1D4F88F9",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
      "title": "SAN proposes learning and predicting the cell’s own responses",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-08-30) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2024-07-14). The shared role is learning a model of the neural system’s own activity, stated explicitly in the 2022 source before the 2024/2026 papers.",
      "shared": "The shared role is learning a model of the neural system’s own activity, stated explicitly in the 2022 source before the 2024/2026 papers.",
      "relation": "own-neural-activity prediction role · moderate role-level partial",
      "residual": "A qualitative neural self-model is not the target’s numerical prediction of selected current hidden activations in one forward pass. This does not establish the complete estimator, future-state semantics or consciousness.\n\nThe source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.\n\nPredicts current selected hidden activations, not automatically a future biological firing or conscious experience.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "own-neural-activity prediction role",
          "favorable": "The shared role is learning a model of the neural system’s own activity, stated explicitly in the 2022 source before the 2024/2026 papers.",
          "residual": "A qualitative neural self-model is not the target’s numerical prediction of selected current hidden activations in one forward pass. This does not establish the complete estimator, future-state semantics or consciousness."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "The cell is proposed to learn and predict its own response patterns through feedback.",
          "target_roles": "The network predicts subsets of its own hidden activations.",
          "shared_role": "own-neural-activity prediction role",
          "scope_limit": "The source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To reach the reported own-activation prediction, the target must retain an internal activity value and estimate it. Recover the source’s explicit own-activity modelling role, while retaining the missing numerical/state-coordinate implementation.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0007z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/86ca59559908f6cad3f9f3314f3d651c3e0c6ea1/a0007z.md",
        "sha256": "BAE95CC2D214077ABCE720EEA26177DADC1301FB3DC0946C93A3B85D1D4F88F9",
        "date": "2022-08-30",
        "date_type": "Historical Git author/commit record; original public availability is not independently certified.",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "My intuition is that the apical is learning it's responds, and through feedback loops, with itself and with other pyramidal neurons the cell is going to make predictions about it's own patterns of causation, what patterns it responds & how it reacts or responds. With the Apical Dendrite perhaps symbolizing a more complex response that is connected to more complex learning. (compared to other types of neurons)"
        ],
        "locators": [
          39
        ],
        "speech_act": "Tentative basal/apical/exit-terminal account. This is learning a response mapping, not an explicit classification-plus-regression objective."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected Benefits of Self-Modeling in Neural Systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram N. Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.10188v1",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "date": "2024-07-14",
        "date_type": "arXiv v1 submission date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies held PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "In addition to performing a primary task, the networks were responsible for predicting the values of subsets of their own hidden activations.",
        "summary": "The network predicts subsets of its own hidden activations.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "PDF pages 1-2; extracted lines 63-71 and 123-128",
          "quote_normalization": "Verbatim wording checked against the2024PDF page2; line-break hyphens and whitespace joined for readability."
        },
        "speech_act": "Predicts current selected hidden activations, not automatically a future biological firing or conscious experience.",
        "hash_kind": "held PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-F6DC84F405510C785476",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-F6DC84F405510C785476",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/1",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-D7E1433EC8FC2F035F0341",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-D7E1433EC8FC2F035F0341",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-1EE166CBB8943AF4C5A0",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:835009EAE0FA62D471E5368131806D08C22549AE7C590DDFBA70187FAFE221D8",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
      "title": "SAN: a neural pattern represents its own activity",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-06-12) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2024-07-14). The note models the system’s own thought activity; the later network predicts its own internal activations.",
      "shared": "The note models the system’s own thought activity; the later network predicts its own internal activations.",
      "relation": "partial own-activity representation · weak-to-moderate conceptual partial",
      "residual": "A qualitative neural self-model is not the target’s numerical prediction of selected current hidden activations in one forward pass. This does not establish the complete estimator, future-state semantics or consciousness.\n\nThe owner-reported 2012 header is separate from the 2022 wording record.\n\nPredicts current selected hidden activations, not automatically a future biological firing or conscious experience.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "partial own-activity representation",
          "favorable": "The note models the system’s own thought activity; the later network predicts its own internal activations.",
          "residual": "A qualitative neural self-model is not the target’s numerical prediction of selected current hidden activations in one forward pass. This does not establish the complete estimator, future-state semantics or consciousness."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "A neural thought pattern represents its own activity within sensing and action.",
          "target_roles": "The network predicts subsets of its own hidden activations.",
          "shared_role": "partial own-activity representation",
          "scope_limit": "The owner-reported 2012 header is separate from the 2022 wording record.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To reach the reported own-activation prediction, the target must retain an internal activity value and estimate it. Recover the source’s explicit own-activity modelling role, while retaining the missing numerical/state-coordinate implementation.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0339z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4245ac674ea89dbf2b832f14a256a4d30937f13a/a0339z.md",
        "sha256": "835009EAE0FA62D471E5368131806D08C22549AE7C590DDFBA70187FAFE221D8",
        "date": "2022-06-12",
        "date_type": "Historical Git record; original first public release not independently authenticated",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release. This note reports 2012-09-07 separately; that is not an authenticated first-publication date.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": "2012-09-07",
        "quotes": [
          "the observer is the thought pattern making a thought pattern of the thought pattern"
        ],
        "locators": [
          8
        ],
        "speech_act": "The2012header is owner-reported, not independently authenticated publication. The2022Git object fixes this wording. Metaphysical, meditation and machine-consciousness assertions elsewhere in the note are not adopted as findings. The Numenta reference remains visible."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected Benefits of Self-Modeling in Neural Systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram N. Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.10188v1",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "date": "2024-07-14",
        "date_type": "arXiv v1 submission date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies held PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "In addition to performing a primary task, the networks were responsible for predicting the values of subsets of their own hidden activations.",
        "summary": "The network predicts subsets of its own hidden activations.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "PDF pages 1-2; extracted lines 63-71 and 123-128",
          "quote_normalization": "Verbatim wording checked against the2024PDF page2; line-break hyphens and whitespace joined for readability."
        },
        "speech_act": "Predicts current selected hidden activations, not automatically a future biological firing or conscious experience.",
        "hash_kind": "held PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-D7E1433EC8FC2F035F0341",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-D7E1433EC8FC2F035F0341",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/2",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-819E34C670A929D915DAF3",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-819E34C670A929D915DAF3",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-E352849CB7F0C159E646",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:C4538E29BCC1B8B3584334047A95CB1DE0E3B2C1A359F496643225C33939E120",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
      "title": "SAN: a learning loop receives its own activity",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-06-08) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2024-07-14). Self-generated activity returns to the neural system; the target predicts selected internally generated activations.",
      "shared": "Self-generated activity returns to the neural system; the target predicts selected internally generated activations.",
      "relation": "own-activity learning causal prefix · weak-to-moderate partial",
      "residual": "A qualitative neural self-model is not the target’s numerical prediction of selected current hidden activations in one forward pass. This does not establish the complete estimator, future-state semantics or consciousness.\n\nThe owner-reported 2012 header is separate from the 2022 wording record.\n\nPredicts current selected hidden activations, not automatically a future biological firing or conscious experience.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "own-activity learning causal prefix",
          "favorable": "Self-generated activity returns to the neural system; the target predicts selected internally generated activations.",
          "residual": "A qualitative neural self-model is not the target’s numerical prediction of selected current hidden activations in one forward pass. This does not establish the complete estimator, future-state semantics or consciousness."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "The neurons producing a pattern also receive it, within a feedback loop that learns.",
          "target_roles": "The network predicts subsets of its own hidden activations.",
          "shared_role": "own-activity learning causal prefix",
          "scope_limit": "The owner-reported 2012 header is separate from the 2022 wording record.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To reach the reported own-activation prediction, the target must retain an internal activity value and estimate it. Recover the source’s explicit own-activity modelling role, while retaining the missing numerical/state-coordinate implementation.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0632z ctpr.txt",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/5360f6414909a2474129b2140ee0dc3112c93b6b/a0632z%20ctpr.txt",
        "sha256": "C4538E29BCC1B8B3584334047A95CB1DE0E3B2C1A359F496643225C33939E120",
        "date": "2022-06-08",
        "date_type": "Historical Git record; original first public release not independently authenticated",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release. This note reports 2012-04-19 separately; that is not an authenticated first-publication date.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": "2012-04-19",
        "quotes": [
          "Who listens to the song and understands the meaning? the song is a loop, the neurons that play it also listen to it"
        ],
        "locators": [
          49
        ],
        "speech_act": "The2012header is owner-reported. The2022retrospective rendering comment at line3 is not backdated into2012. Hawkins is explicitly recommended and the Pinker quotation is separately attributed. The instrument/song description is an analogy, not proof that every neuron hears a literal sound or of the source's other numerical/physical claims."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected Benefits of Self-Modeling in Neural Systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram N. Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.10188v1",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "date": "2024-07-14",
        "date_type": "arXiv v1 submission date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies held PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "In addition to performing a primary task, the networks were responsible for predicting the values of subsets of their own hidden activations.",
        "summary": "The network predicts subsets of its own hidden activations.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "PDF pages 1-2; extracted lines 63-71 and 123-128",
          "quote_normalization": "Verbatim wording checked against the2024PDF page2; line-break hyphens and whitespace joined for readability."
        },
        "speech_act": "Predicts current selected hidden activations, not automatically a future biological firing or conscious experience.",
        "hash_kind": "held PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-819E34C670A929D915DAF3",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-819E34C670A929D915DAF3",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/3",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-SOURCE-EDITION-EC8331FB96F4AB07565AF8",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-SOURCE-EDITION-EC8331FB96F4AB07565AF8",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-652B718D9B12CE563750",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:824A074A17729942D83FEBA0E9BA3297EEC4F287F9C46FE956B890273FBC4B50",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
      "title": "SAN proposes learning from the cell’s own activity",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-09-18) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2024-07-14). Learning about internally generated activity accompanies ordinary signal processing; the target implements this additional focus as an auxiliary task.",
      "shared": "Learning about internally generated activity accompanies ordinary signal processing; the target implements this additional focus as an auxiliary task.",
      "relation": "additional internal-learning role · weak-to-moderate component partial",
      "residual": "Reading or learning from internal activity is not an explicitly specified additional output head, numerical auxiliary regression loss or training schedule. The shared role is preserved without identifying the full implementation.\n\nThe source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.\n\nA numerical auxiliary regression output is more specific than merely reading an internal representation.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "additional internal-learning role",
          "favorable": "Learning about internally generated activity accompanies ordinary signal processing; the target implements this additional focus as an auxiliary task.",
          "residual": "Reading or learning from internal activity is not an explicitly specified additional output head, numerical auxiliary regression loss or training schedule. The shared role is preserved without identifying the full implementation."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "The proposed apical learning process receives external sensory input and the cell’s own somatic burst patterns.",
          "target_roles": "Self-modeling is implemented as an auxiliary regression task.",
          "shared_role": "additional internal-learning role",
          "scope_limit": "The source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To add self-modelling beside the main task, the target must expose internal activity to an additional learned prediction role. Compare that role to internal readout/own-response learning, not merely to the word self.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0007z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/894b4d4ea3f23d4d1d526e123b5744283ff9cd5d/a0007z.md",
        "sha256": "824A074A17729942D83FEBA0E9BA3297EEC4F287F9C46FE956B890273FBC4B50",
        "date": "2022-09-18",
        "date_type": "Historical Git author/commit record; original public availability is not independently certified.",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "An interesting thought about the cyclic nature of Layer 5 pyramidal cells, is the idea that the process of the dendrite being a sensor, like an eyeball or an ear appears to apply to both sides of the neuron, on the way in, and on the way out. So the Apical dendrite, as a neural network, is learning from incoming sensory stimulus, but the Soma burst is one of the incoming sensory stimuli, with models of soma burst waveforms becoming part of what the Apical Dendrite has to contend with."
        ],
        "locators": [
          47
        ],
        "speech_act": "The source says \"My intuition\" and describes feedback-linked cell responses. Anatomical speculation is not stripped from the source context."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected Benefits of Self-Modeling in Neural Systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram N. Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.10188v1",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "date": "2024-07-14",
        "date_type": "arXiv v1 submission date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies held PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "we augmented the output layer to predict both the class probabilities and the activations of specific target layers within the network.",
        "summary": "Self-modeling is implemented as an auxiliary regression task.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "PDF page 2; extracted lines 113-128",
          "quote_normalization": "Verbatim wording checked against the2024PDF page2; line-break hyphens and whitespace joined for readability."
        },
        "speech_act": "A numerical auxiliary regression output is more specific than merely reading an internal representation.",
        "hash_kind": "held PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-SOURCE-EDITION-EC8331FB96F4AB07565AF8",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-SOURCE-EDITION-EC8331FB96F4AB07565AF8",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/4",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-7CB5D4FA11FA0C429AE3",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-7CB5D4FA11FA0C429AE3",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-A95BFA23D8A9633FA010",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:BAE95CC2D214077ABCE720EEA26177DADC1301FB3DC0946C93A3B85D1D4F88F9",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
      "title": "SAN proposes learning from the cell’s own activity",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-08-30) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2024-07-14). Learning about internally generated activity accompanies ordinary signal processing; the target implements this additional focus as an auxiliary task.",
      "shared": "Learning about internally generated activity accompanies ordinary signal processing; the target implements this additional focus as an auxiliary task.",
      "relation": "additional internal-learning role · weak-to-moderate component partial",
      "residual": "Reading or learning from internal activity is not an explicitly specified additional output head, numerical auxiliary regression loss or training schedule. The shared role is preserved without identifying the full implementation.\n\nThe source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.\n\nA numerical auxiliary regression output is more specific than merely reading an internal representation.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "additional internal-learning role",
          "favorable": "Learning about internally generated activity accompanies ordinary signal processing; the target implements this additional focus as an auxiliary task.",
          "residual": "Reading or learning from internal activity is not an explicitly specified additional output head, numerical auxiliary regression loss or training schedule. The shared role is preserved without identifying the full implementation."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "The proposed apical learning process receives external sensory input and the cell’s own somatic burst patterns.",
          "target_roles": "Self-modeling is implemented as an auxiliary regression task.",
          "shared_role": "additional internal-learning role",
          "scope_limit": "The source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To add self-modelling beside the main task, the target must expose internal activity to an additional learned prediction role. Compare that role to internal readout/own-response learning, not merely to the word self.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0007z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/86ca59559908f6cad3f9f3314f3d651c3e0c6ea1/a0007z.md",
        "sha256": "BAE95CC2D214077ABCE720EEA26177DADC1301FB3DC0946C93A3B85D1D4F88F9",
        "date": "2022-08-30",
        "date_type": "Historical Git author/commit record; original public availability is not independently certified.",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "An interesting thought about the cyclic nature of Layer 5 pyramidal cells, is the idea that the process of the dendrite being a sensor, like an eyeball or an ear appears to apply to both sides of the neuron, on the way in, and on the way out. So the Apical dendrite, as a neural network, is learning from incoming sensor stimulus, but the Soma burst is one of the incoming sensor stimulai, with models of soma burst waveforms becoming part of what the Apical Dendrite has to contend with."
        ],
        "locators": [
          35
        ],
        "speech_act": "Tentative basal/apical/exit-terminal account. This is learning a response mapping, not an explicit classification-plus-regression objective."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected Benefits of Self-Modeling in Neural Systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram N. Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.10188v1",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "date": "2024-07-14",
        "date_type": "arXiv v1 submission date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies held PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "we augmented the output layer to predict both the class probabilities and the activations of specific target layers within the network.",
        "summary": "Self-modeling is implemented as an auxiliary regression task.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "PDF page 2; extracted lines 113-128",
          "quote_normalization": "Verbatim wording checked against the2024PDF page2; line-break hyphens and whitespace joined for readability."
        },
        "speech_act": "A numerical auxiliary regression output is more specific than merely reading an internal representation.",
        "hash_kind": "held PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-7CB5D4FA11FA0C429AE3",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-7CB5D4FA11FA0C429AE3",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/5",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-2531A0FE58C3F12156E32F",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-2531A0FE58C3F12156E32F",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-1EE166CBB8943AF4C5A0",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:835009EAE0FA62D471E5368131806D08C22549AE7C590DDFBA70187FAFE221D8",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
      "title": "SAN: self-representation within sensing and action",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-06-12) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2024-07-14). Both accounts include an internally directed modelling role inside the functioning network.",
      "shared": "Both accounts include an internally directed modelling role inside the functioning network.",
      "relation": "internal-modelling architecture component · weak conceptual/architecture partial",
      "residual": "Reading or learning from internal activity is not an explicitly specified additional output head, numerical auxiliary regression loss or training schedule. The shared role is preserved without identifying the full implementation.\n\nThe owner-reported 2012 header is separate from the 2022 wording record.\n\nA numerical auxiliary regression output is more specific than merely reading an internal representation.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "internal-modelling architecture component",
          "favorable": "Both accounts include an internally directed modelling role inside the functioning network.",
          "residual": "Reading or learning from internal activity is not an explicitly specified additional output head, numerical auxiliary regression loss or training schedule. The shared role is preserved without identifying the full implementation."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "A representation of the system’s own thought activity is included within ongoing neural sensing and action.",
          "target_roles": "Self-modeling is implemented as an auxiliary regression task.",
          "shared_role": "internal-modelling architecture component",
          "scope_limit": "The owner-reported 2012 header is separate from the 2022 wording record.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To add self-modelling beside the main task, the target must expose internal activity to an additional learned prediction role. Compare that role to internal readout/own-response learning, not merely to the word self.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0339z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4245ac674ea89dbf2b832f14a256a4d30937f13a/a0339z.md",
        "sha256": "835009EAE0FA62D471E5368131806D08C22549AE7C590DDFBA70187FAFE221D8",
        "date": "2022-06-12",
        "date_type": "Historical Git record; original first public release not independently authenticated",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release. This note reports 2012-09-07 separately; that is not an authenticated first-publication date.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": "2012-09-07",
        "quotes": [
          "the observer is the thought pattern making a thought pattern of the thought pattern"
        ],
        "locators": [
          8
        ],
        "speech_act": "The2012header is owner-reported, not independently authenticated publication. The2022Git object fixes this wording. Metaphysical, meditation and machine-consciousness assertions elsewhere in the note are not adopted as findings. The Numenta reference remains visible."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected Benefits of Self-Modeling in Neural Systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram N. Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.10188v1",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "date": "2024-07-14",
        "date_type": "arXiv v1 submission date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies held PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "we augmented the output layer to predict both the class probabilities and the activations of specific target layers within the network.",
        "summary": "Self-modeling is implemented as an auxiliary regression task.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "PDF page 2; extracted lines 113-128",
          "quote_normalization": "Verbatim wording checked against the2024PDF page2; line-break hyphens and whitespace joined for readability."
        },
        "speech_act": "A numerical auxiliary regression output is more specific than merely reading an internal representation.",
        "hash_kind": "held PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-2531A0FE58C3F12156E32F",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-2531A0FE58C3F12156E32F",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/6",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-2159ABF1CD53AA0526009A",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-2159ABF1CD53AA0526009A",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-23DB15524725B85231AF",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:C4538E29BCC1B8B3584334047A95CB1DE0E3B2C1A359F496643225C33939E120",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
      "title": "SAN: a neural representation is read by another layer",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-06-08) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2024-07-14). An internal representation becomes input to further neural processing; the target adds a specific internal regression task.",
      "shared": "An internal representation becomes input to further neural processing; the target adds a specific internal regression task.",
      "relation": "internal neural readout component · weak component partial",
      "residual": "Reading or learning from internal activity is not an explicitly specified additional output head, numerical auxiliary regression loss or training schedule. The shared role is preserved without identifying the full implementation.\n\nLine 3 is a retrospective comment fixed in 2022, not a verified 2012 statement.\n\nA numerical auxiliary regression output is more specific than merely reading an internal representation.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "internal neural readout component",
          "favorable": "An internal representation becomes input to further neural processing; the target adds a specific internal regression task.",
          "residual": "Reading or learning from internal activity is not an explicitly specified additional output head, numerical auxiliary regression loss or training schedule. The shared role is preserved without identifying the full implementation."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "A 2022-recorded retrospective comment describes a rendering that a subsequent neural array or layer reads and interprets.",
          "target_roles": "Self-modeling is implemented as an auxiliary regression task.",
          "shared_role": "internal neural readout component",
          "scope_limit": "Line 3 is a retrospective comment fixed in 2022, not a verified 2012 statement.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To add self-modelling beside the main task, the target must expose internal activity to an additional learned prediction role. Compare that role to internal readout/own-response learning, not merely to the word self.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0632z ctpr.txt",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/5360f6414909a2474129b2140ee0dc3112c93b6b/a0632z%20ctpr.txt",
        "sha256": "C4538E29BCC1B8B3584334047A95CB1DE0E3B2C1A359F496643225C33939E120",
        "date": "2022-06-08",
        "date_type": "Historical Git record; original first public release not independently authenticated",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release. This note reports 2012-04-19 separately; that is not an authenticated first-publication date.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": "2012-04-19",
        "quotes": [
          "Comment on the note: What I think I was missing at this point in time (2012) was the part about how a memory-prediction was actually a rendering that a subsequent array or layer of nerve cells would read & interpret."
        ],
        "locators": [
          3
        ],
        "speech_act": "The2012header is owner-reported. The2022retrospective rendering comment at line3 is not backdated into2012. Hawkins is explicitly recommended and the Pinker quotation is separately attributed. The instrument/song description is an analogy, not proof that every neuron hears a literal sound or of the source's other numerical/physical claims."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected Benefits of Self-Modeling in Neural Systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram N. Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.10188v1",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "date": "2024-07-14",
        "date_type": "arXiv v1 submission date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies held PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "we augmented the output layer to predict both the class probabilities and the activations of specific target layers within the network.",
        "summary": "Self-modeling is implemented as an auxiliary regression task.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "PDF page 2; extracted lines 113-128",
          "quote_normalization": "Verbatim wording checked against the2024PDF page2; line-break hyphens and whitespace joined for readability."
        },
        "speech_act": "A numerical auxiliary regression output is more specific than merely reading an internal representation.",
        "hash_kind": "held PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-2159ABF1CD53AA0526009A",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-2159ABF1CD53AA0526009A",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/7",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-5928D99804B56C410D88",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-5928D99804B56C410D88",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-B83B1C2A6D1193509C49",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:824A074A17729942D83FEBA0E9BA3297EEC4F287F9C46FE956B890273FBC4B50",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
      "title": "SAN links response learning with learning about responses",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-09-18) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2024-07-14). The earlier source joins two learning roles; the later system trains a primary task and an internal-prediction task together.",
      "shared": "The earlier source joins two learning roles; the later system trains a primary task and an internal-prediction task together.",
      "relation": "coupled learning-role architecture · weak-to-moderate architecture partial",
      "residual": "The source does not specify the target’s weighted cross-entropy-plus-regression objective, optimizer, targets or gradient computation. Coupled learning roles are not mathematical identity of the loss.\n\nThe source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.\n\nSAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "coupled learning-role architecture",
          "favorable": "The earlier source joins two learning roles; the later system trains a primary task and an internal-prediction task together.",
          "residual": "The source does not specify the target’s weighted cross-entropy-plus-regression objective, optimizer, targets or gradient computation. Coupled learning roles are not mathematical identity of the loss."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "Response learning and learning the cell’s own responses are coupled through recurring feedback.",
          "target_roles": "The two tasks are classification and prediction of the network's own selected hidden activations. The paper uses additive weighted classification and regression losses.",
          "shared_role": "coupled learning-role architecture",
          "scope_limit": "The source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To train the two tasks jointly, the target must combine task-specific error signals. The sources support joined learning roles at most; no additive numerical loss is inferred from feedback language.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0007z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/894b4d4ea3f23d4d1d526e123b5744283ff9cd5d/a0007z.md",
        "sha256": "824A074A17729942D83FEBA0E9BA3297EEC4F287F9C46FE956B890273FBC4B50",
        "date": "2022-09-18",
        "date_type": "Historical Git author/commit record; original public availability is not independently certified.",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "My intuition is that the apical is learning its own cell's response, and through feedback loops, with itself and with other pyramidal neurons the cell is going to make predictions about its own patterns of causation, what patterns it responds & how it reacts or responds. With the Apical Dendrite perhaps symbolizing a more complex response that is connected to more complex learning. (compared to other types of neurons)"
        ],
        "locators": [
          51
        ],
        "speech_act": "The source says \"My intuition\" and describes feedback-linked cell responses. Anatomical speculation is not stripped from the source context."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected Benefits of Self-Modeling in Neural Systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram N. Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.10188v1",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "date": "2024-07-14",
        "date_type": "arXiv v1 submission date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies held PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "The predictions and targets were passed to their respective loss functions and models were trained jointly on these two tasks.",
        "summary": "The two tasks are classification and prediction of the network's own selected hidden activations. The paper uses additive weighted classification and regression losses.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "PDF page 3, left column",
          "quote_normalization": "Readable wording verified against the held PDF page3image; extraction had collapsed spaces."
        },
        "speech_act": "SAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
        "hash_kind": "held PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-5928D99804B56C410D88",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-5928D99804B56C410D88",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/8",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-A32132257E5EDD8C9245",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-A32132257E5EDD8C9245",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-39CEEAD5343139662A07",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:BAE95CC2D214077ABCE720EEA26177DADC1301FB3DC0946C93A3B85D1D4F88F9",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
      "title": "SAN links response learning with learning about responses",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-08-30) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2024-07-14). The earlier source joins two learning roles; the later system trains a primary task and an internal-prediction task together.",
      "shared": "The earlier source joins two learning roles; the later system trains a primary task and an internal-prediction task together.",
      "relation": "coupled learning-role architecture · weak-to-moderate architecture partial",
      "residual": "The source does not specify the target’s weighted cross-entropy-plus-regression objective, optimizer, targets or gradient computation. Coupled learning roles are not mathematical identity of the loss.\n\nThe source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.\n\nSAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "coupled learning-role architecture",
          "favorable": "The earlier source joins two learning roles; the later system trains a primary task and an internal-prediction task together.",
          "residual": "The source does not specify the target’s weighted cross-entropy-plus-regression objective, optimizer, targets or gradient computation. Coupled learning roles are not mathematical identity of the loss."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "Response learning and learning the cell’s own responses are coupled through recurring feedback.",
          "target_roles": "The two tasks are classification and prediction of the network's own selected hidden activations. The paper uses additive weighted classification and regression losses.",
          "shared_role": "coupled learning-role architecture",
          "scope_limit": "The source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To train the two tasks jointly, the target must combine task-specific error signals. The sources support joined learning roles at most; no additive numerical loss is inferred from feedback language.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0007z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/86ca59559908f6cad3f9f3314f3d651c3e0c6ea1/a0007z.md",
        "sha256": "BAE95CC2D214077ABCE720EEA26177DADC1301FB3DC0946C93A3B85D1D4F88F9",
        "date": "2022-08-30",
        "date_type": "Historical Git author/commit record; original public availability is not independently certified.",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "My intuition is that the apical is learning it's responds, and through feedback loops, with itself and with other pyramidal neurons the cell is going to make predictions about it's own patterns of causation, what patterns it responds & how it reacts or responds. With the Apical Dendrite perhaps symbolizing a more complex response that is connected to more complex learning. (compared to other types of neurons)"
        ],
        "locators": [
          39
        ],
        "speech_act": "Tentative basal/apical/exit-terminal account. This is learning a response mapping, not an explicit classification-plus-regression objective."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected Benefits of Self-Modeling in Neural Systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram N. Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.10188v1",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "date": "2024-07-14",
        "date_type": "arXiv v1 submission date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies held PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "The predictions and targets were passed to their respective loss functions and models were trained jointly on these two tasks.",
        "summary": "The two tasks are classification and prediction of the network's own selected hidden activations. The paper uses additive weighted classification and regression losses.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "PDF page 3, left column",
          "quote_normalization": "Readable wording verified against the held PDF page3image; extraction had collapsed spaces."
        },
        "speech_act": "SAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
        "hash_kind": "held PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-A32132257E5EDD8C9245",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-A32132257E5EDD8C9245",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/9",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-7DA4CA25A387A68325DDAF",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-7DA4CA25A387A68325DDAF",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-1EE166CBB8943AF4C5A0",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:835009EAE0FA62D471E5368131806D08C22549AE7C590DDFBA70187FAFE221D8",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
      "title": "SAN: self-representation alongside sensing and action",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-06-12) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2024-07-14). Primary engagement and internal self-representation coexist in one system; the target implements an explicit paired learning objective.",
      "shared": "Primary engagement and internal self-representation coexist in one system; the target implements an explicit paired learning objective.",
      "relation": "paired-role architecture component · weak architecture partial",
      "residual": "The source does not specify the target’s weighted cross-entropy-plus-regression objective, optimizer, targets or gradient computation. Coupled learning roles are not mathematical identity of the loss.\n\nThe owner-reported 2012 header is separate from the 2022 wording record.\n\nSAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "paired-role architecture component",
          "favorable": "Primary engagement and internal self-representation coexist in one system; the target implements an explicit paired learning objective.",
          "residual": "The source does not specify the target’s weighted cross-entropy-plus-regression objective, optimizer, targets or gradient computation. Coupled learning roles are not mathematical identity of the loss."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "The note joins sensing and action with a recursively developing representation of the system’s own activity.",
          "target_roles": "The two tasks are classification and prediction of the network's own selected hidden activations. The paper uses additive weighted classification and regression losses.",
          "shared_role": "paired-role architecture component",
          "scope_limit": "The owner-reported 2012 header is separate from the 2022 wording record.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To train the two tasks jointly, the target must combine task-specific error signals. The sources support joined learning roles at most; no additive numerical loss is inferred from feedback language.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0339z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4245ac674ea89dbf2b832f14a256a4d30937f13a/a0339z.md",
        "sha256": "835009EAE0FA62D471E5368131806D08C22549AE7C590DDFBA70187FAFE221D8",
        "date": "2022-06-12",
        "date_type": "Historical Git record; original first public release not independently authenticated",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release. This note reports 2012-09-07 separately; that is not an authenticated first-publication date.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": "2012-09-07",
        "quotes": [
          "the observer is the thought pattern making a thought pattern of the thought pattern"
        ],
        "locators": [
          8
        ],
        "speech_act": "The2012header is owner-reported, not independently authenticated publication. The2022Git object fixes this wording. Metaphysical, meditation and machine-consciousness assertions elsewhere in the note are not adopted as findings. The Numenta reference remains visible."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected Benefits of Self-Modeling in Neural Systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram N. Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.10188v1",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "date": "2024-07-14",
        "date_type": "arXiv v1 submission date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies held PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "The predictions and targets were passed to their respective loss functions and models were trained jointly on these two tasks.",
        "summary": "The two tasks are classification and prediction of the network's own selected hidden activations. The paper uses additive weighted classification and regression losses.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "PDF page 3, left column",
          "quote_normalization": "Readable wording verified against the held PDF page3image; extraction had collapsed spaces."
        },
        "speech_act": "SAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
        "hash_kind": "held PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-7DA4CA25A387A68325DDAF",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-7DA4CA25A387A68325DDAF",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/10",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-68D7605C981D48B35EA68D",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-68D7605C981D48B35EA68D",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-7E85AA36802C889CD645",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:C4538E29BCC1B8B3584334047A95CB1DE0E3B2C1A359F496643225C33939E120",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
      "title": "SAN: self-generated activity feeds a learning loop",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-06-08) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2024-07-14). The internally generated activity participates in learning alongside the system’s other activity; the target implements primary and self-modelling losses together.",
      "shared": "The internally generated activity participates in learning alongside the system’s other activity; the target implements primary and self-modelling losses together.",
      "relation": "internally returned learning component · weak architecture partial",
      "residual": "The source does not specify the target’s weighted cross-entropy-plus-regression objective, optimizer, targets or gradient computation. Coupled learning roles are not mathematical identity of the loss.\n\nThe owner-reported 2012 header is separate from the 2022 wording record.\n\nSAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "internally returned learning component",
          "favorable": "The internally generated activity participates in learning alongside the system’s other activity; the target implements primary and self-modelling losses together.",
          "residual": "The source does not specify the target’s weighted cross-entropy-plus-regression objective, optimizer, targets or gradient computation. Coupled learning roles are not mathematical identity of the loss."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "A neural system produces and receives its own patterns within a feedback loop that learns.",
          "target_roles": "The two tasks are classification and prediction of the network's own selected hidden activations. The paper uses additive weighted classification and regression losses.",
          "shared_role": "internally returned learning component",
          "scope_limit": "The owner-reported 2012 header is separate from the 2022 wording record.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To train the two tasks jointly, the target must combine task-specific error signals. The sources support joined learning roles at most; no additive numerical loss is inferred from feedback language.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0632z ctpr.txt",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/5360f6414909a2474129b2140ee0dc3112c93b6b/a0632z%20ctpr.txt",
        "sha256": "C4538E29BCC1B8B3584334047A95CB1DE0E3B2C1A359F496643225C33939E120",
        "date": "2022-06-08",
        "date_type": "Historical Git record; original first public release not independently authenticated",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release. This note reports 2012-04-19 separately; that is not an authenticated first-publication date.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": "2012-04-19",
        "quotes": [
          "Being is a learning loop, like a feedback loop that learns"
        ],
        "locators": [
          44
        ],
        "speech_act": "The2012header is owner-reported. The2022retrospective rendering comment at line3 is not backdated into2012. Hawkins is explicitly recommended and the Pinker quotation is separately attributed. The instrument/song description is an analogy, not proof that every neuron hears a literal sound or of the source's other numerical/physical claims."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected Benefits of Self-Modeling in Neural Systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram N. Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.10188v1",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "date": "2024-07-14",
        "date_type": "arXiv v1 submission date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies held PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "The predictions and targets were passed to their respective loss functions and models were trained jointly on these two tasks.",
        "summary": "The two tasks are classification and prediction of the network's own selected hidden activations. The paper uses additive weighted classification and regression losses.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "PDF page 3, left column",
          "quote_normalization": "Readable wording verified against the held PDF page3image; extraction had collapsed spaces."
        },
        "speech_act": "SAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
        "hash_kind": "held PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-68D7605C981D48B35EA68D",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-68D7605C981D48B35EA68D",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/11",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-OP-02AE465E84391429B764CC",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-OP-02AE465E84391429B764CC",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-B83B1C2A6D1193509C49",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:824A074A17729942D83FEBA0E9BA3297EEC4F287F9C46FE956B890273FBC4B50",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
      "title": "SAN proposes two adaptive learning roles",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-09-18) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2024-07-14). The source gives both response generation and self-response prediction adaptive roles; the target makes both actual and predicted internal activations trainable.",
      "shared": "The source gives both response generation and self-response prediction adaptive roles; the target makes both actual and predicted internal activations trainable.",
      "relation": "two adaptive roles / causal-prefix mapping · moderate role-level partial",
      "residual": "The target lets both actual and predicted hidden activations vary under its joint loss. The source supplies only the stated adaptive component or qualitative coupled-role account, not the same shared-parameter optimization or measured complexity reduction.\n\nThe source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.\n\nSAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "two adaptive roles / causal-prefix mapping",
          "favorable": "The source gives both response generation and self-response prediction adaptive roles; the target makes both actual and predicted internal activations trainable.",
          "residual": "The target lets both actual and predicted hidden activations vary under its joint loss. The source supplies only the stated adaptive component or qualitative coupled-role account, not the same shared-parameter optimization or measured complexity reduction."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "The response mapping and the model of the cell’s responses are both described as learned.",
          "target_roles": "Here “the two” refers to the predicted activations and the actual hidden activations. Both depend on trainable model weights; the target activity is not held permanently fixed. This explanation is a paraphrase, not an alteration of the quotation.",
          "shared_role": "two adaptive roles / causal-prefix mapping",
          "scope_limit": "The source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To make both sides trainable, the target requires adaptable predicted and actual activations. Test each source for predictor adaptation and response-generation adaptation separately. A one-sided supported component remains partial and does not establish the two-sided conjunction.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0007z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/894b4d4ea3f23d4d1d526e123b5744283ff9cd5d/a0007z.md",
        "sha256": "824A074A17729942D83FEBA0E9BA3297EEC4F287F9C46FE956B890273FBC4B50",
        "date": "2022-09-18",
        "date_type": "Historical Git author/commit record; original public availability is not independently certified.",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "My intuition is that the apical is learning its own cell's response, and through feedback loops, with itself and with other pyramidal neurons the cell is going to make predictions about its own patterns of causation, what patterns it responds & how it reacts or responds. With the Apical Dendrite perhaps symbolizing a more complex response that is connected to more complex learning. (compared to other types of neurons)"
        ],
        "locators": [
          51
        ],
        "speech_act": "The source says \"My intuition\" and describes feedback-linked cell responses. Anatomical speculation is not stripped from the source context."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected Benefits of Self-Modeling in Neural Systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram N. Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.10188v1",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "date": "2024-07-14",
        "date_type": "arXiv v1 submission date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies held PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "During training, the two could both be varied to find the best critical points under the joint loss function.",
        "summary": "Here “the two” refers to the predicted activations and the actual hidden activations. Both depend on trainable model weights; the target activity is not held permanently fixed. This explanation is a paraphrase, not an alteration of the quotation.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "PDF page 3, left column",
          "quote_normalization": "Readable wording verified against the held PDF page3image; extraction had collapsed spaces."
        },
        "speech_act": "SAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
        "hash_kind": "held PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-OP-02AE465E84391429B764CC",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-OP-02AE465E84391429B764CC",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/12",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-OP-5F41654BAC7D61117420DD",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-OP-5F41654BAC7D61117420DD",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-39CEEAD5343139662A07",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:BAE95CC2D214077ABCE720EEA26177DADC1301FB3DC0946C93A3B85D1D4F88F9",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
      "title": "SAN proposes two adaptive learning roles",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-08-30) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2024-07-14). The source gives both response generation and self-response prediction adaptive roles; the target makes both actual and predicted internal activations trainable.",
      "shared": "The source gives both response generation and self-response prediction adaptive roles; the target makes both actual and predicted internal activations trainable.",
      "relation": "two adaptive roles / causal-prefix mapping · moderate role-level partial",
      "residual": "The target lets both actual and predicted hidden activations vary under its joint loss. The source supplies only the stated adaptive component or qualitative coupled-role account, not the same shared-parameter optimization or measured complexity reduction.\n\nThe source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.\n\nSAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "two adaptive roles / causal-prefix mapping",
          "favorable": "The source gives both response generation and self-response prediction adaptive roles; the target makes both actual and predicted internal activations trainable.",
          "residual": "The target lets both actual and predicted hidden activations vary under its joint loss. The source supplies only the stated adaptive component or qualitative coupled-role account, not the same shared-parameter optimization or measured complexity reduction."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "The response mapping and the model of the cell’s responses are both described as learned.",
          "target_roles": "Here “the two” refers to the predicted activations and the actual hidden activations. Both depend on trainable model weights; the target activity is not held permanently fixed. This explanation is a paraphrase, not an alteration of the quotation.",
          "shared_role": "two adaptive roles / causal-prefix mapping",
          "scope_limit": "The source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To make both sides trainable, the target requires adaptable predicted and actual activations. Test each source for predictor adaptation and response-generation adaptation separately. A one-sided supported component remains partial and does not establish the two-sided conjunction.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0007z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/86ca59559908f6cad3f9f3314f3d651c3e0c6ea1/a0007z.md",
        "sha256": "BAE95CC2D214077ABCE720EEA26177DADC1301FB3DC0946C93A3B85D1D4F88F9",
        "date": "2022-08-30",
        "date_type": "Historical Git author/commit record; original public availability is not independently certified.",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "My intuition is that the apical is learning it's responds, and through feedback loops, with itself and with other pyramidal neurons the cell is going to make predictions about it's own patterns of causation, what patterns it responds & how it reacts or responds. With the Apical Dendrite perhaps symbolizing a more complex response that is connected to more complex learning. (compared to other types of neurons)"
        ],
        "locators": [
          39
        ],
        "speech_act": "Tentative basal/apical/exit-terminal account. This is learning a response mapping, not an explicit classification-plus-regression objective."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected Benefits of Self-Modeling in Neural Systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram N. Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.10188v1",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "date": "2024-07-14",
        "date_type": "arXiv v1 submission date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies held PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "During training, the two could both be varied to find the best critical points under the joint loss function.",
        "summary": "Here “the two” refers to the predicted activations and the actual hidden activations. Both depend on trainable model weights; the target activity is not held permanently fixed. This explanation is a paraphrase, not an alteration of the quotation.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "PDF page 3, left column",
          "quote_normalization": "Readable wording verified against the held PDF page3image; extraction had collapsed spaces."
        },
        "speech_act": "SAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
        "hash_kind": "held PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-OP-5F41654BAC7D61117420DD",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-OP-5F41654BAC7D61117420DD",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/13",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-6E9082577AE83072A9BD38",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-6E9082577AE83072A9BD38",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-ACFCB26C79A1CDC4CC19",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:835009EAE0FA62D471E5368131806D08C22549AE7C590DDFBA70187FAFE221D8",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
      "title": "SAN: the self-representation develops",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-06-12) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2024-07-14). The source’s internal self-representation can develop; the target also permits its internal predictor to change during training.",
      "shared": "The source’s internal self-representation can develop; the target also permits its internal predictor to change during training.",
      "relation": "adaptive self-model component · weak conceptual partial",
      "residual": "The target lets both actual and predicted hidden activations vary under its joint loss. The source supplies only the stated adaptive component or qualitative coupled-role account, not the same shared-parameter optimization or measured complexity reduction.\n\nOnly adaptive self-representation is mapped. The source is not used to assert a separately trained generator.\n\nSAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "adaptive self-model component",
          "favorable": "The source’s internal self-representation can develop; the target also permits its internal predictor to change during training.",
          "residual": "The target lets both actual and predicted hidden activations vary under its joint loss. The source supplies only the stated adaptive component or qualitative coupled-role account, not the same shared-parameter optimization or measured complexity reduction."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "A prediction of awareness incorporates its own development and evolves through the continuing loop.",
          "target_roles": "Here “the two” refers to the predicted activations and the actual hidden activations. Both depend on trainable model weights; the target activity is not held permanently fixed. This explanation is a paraphrase, not an alteration of the quotation.",
          "shared_role": "adaptive self-model component",
          "scope_limit": "Only adaptive self-representation is mapped. The source is not used to assert a separately trained generator.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To make both sides trainable, the target requires adaptable predicted and actual activations. Test each source for predictor adaptation and response-generation adaptation separately. A one-sided supported component remains partial and does not establish the two-sided conjunction.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0339z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4245ac674ea89dbf2b832f14a256a4d30937f13a/a0339z.md",
        "sha256": "835009EAE0FA62D471E5368131806D08C22549AE7C590DDFBA70187FAFE221D8",
        "date": "2022-06-12",
        "date_type": "Historical Git record; original first public release not independently authenticated",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release. This note reports 2012-09-07 separately; that is not an authenticated first-publication date.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": "2012-09-07",
        "quotes": [
          "We have a prediction of awareness, and it seems aware because this prediction is incorporating it's own development into an even higher level of awareness about itself."
        ],
        "locators": [
          10
        ],
        "speech_act": "The2012header is owner-reported, not independently authenticated publication. The2022Git object fixes this wording. Metaphysical, meditation and machine-consciousness assertions elsewhere in the note are not adopted as findings. The Numenta reference remains visible."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected Benefits of Self-Modeling in Neural Systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram N. Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.10188v1",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "date": "2024-07-14",
        "date_type": "arXiv v1 submission date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies held PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "During training, the two could both be varied to find the best critical points under the joint loss function.",
        "summary": "Here “the two” refers to the predicted activations and the actual hidden activations. Both depend on trainable model weights; the target activity is not held permanently fixed. This explanation is a paraphrase, not an alteration of the quotation.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "PDF page 3, left column",
          "quote_normalization": "Readable wording verified against the held PDF page3image; extraction had collapsed spaces."
        },
        "speech_act": "SAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
        "hash_kind": "held PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-6E9082577AE83072A9BD38",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-6E9082577AE83072A9BD38",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/14",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-317030652681ED6980721B",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-317030652681ED6980721B",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-7B0F6012CB863CC0E802",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:C4538E29BCC1B8B3584334047A95CB1DE0E3B2C1A359F496643225C33939E120",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
      "title": "SAN: a learning loop with adaptable responses",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-06-08) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2024-07-14). The source describes adaptable response generation and a learning self-loop; the target allows both actual activations and their predictions to change.",
      "shared": "The source describes adaptable response generation and a learning self-loop; the target allows both actual activations and their predictions to change.",
      "relation": "qualitative co-adaptation causal prefix · weak-to-moderate partial",
      "residual": "The target lets both actual and predicted hidden activations vary under its joint loss. The source supplies only the stated adaptive component or qualitative coupled-role account, not the same shared-parameter optimization or measured complexity reduction.\n\nThe owner-reported 2012 header is separate from the 2022 wording record.\n\nSAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "qualitative co-adaptation causal prefix",
          "favorable": "The source describes adaptable response generation and a learning self-loop; the target allows both actual activations and their predictions to change.",
          "residual": "The target lets both actual and predicted hidden activations vary under its joint loss. The source supplies only the stated adaptive component or qualitative coupled-role account, not the same shared-parameter optimization or measured complexity reduction."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "The note joins learning from returned activity with tissue becoming prepared for later signals through experience.",
          "target_roles": "Here “the two” refers to the predicted activations and the actual hidden activations. Both depend on trainable model weights; the target activity is not held permanently fixed. This explanation is a paraphrase, not an alteration of the quotation.",
          "shared_role": "qualitative co-adaptation causal prefix",
          "scope_limit": "The owner-reported 2012 header is separate from the 2022 wording record.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To make both sides trainable, the target requires adaptable predicted and actual activations. Test each source for predictor adaptation and response-generation adaptation separately. A one-sided supported component remains partial and does not establish the two-sided conjunction.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0632z ctpr.txt",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/5360f6414909a2474129b2140ee0dc3112c93b6b/a0632z%20ctpr.txt",
        "sha256": "C4538E29BCC1B8B3584334047A95CB1DE0E3B2C1A359F496643225C33939E120",
        "date": "2022-06-08",
        "date_type": "Historical Git record; original first public release not independently authenticated",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release. This note reports 2012-04-19 separately; that is not an authenticated first-publication date.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": "2012-04-19",
        "quotes": [
          "right so as you sense something, an electric pattern is traveling up the neo cortex, and the statistically novel parts leave a bigger impact, so your memory-prediction is the learn response to that sensory-electrical impact, it's the tissue attempting to be ready for that impact the next time it comes, that's how memory-prediction works on the small scale."
        ],
        "locators": [
          31
        ],
        "speech_act": "The2012header is owner-reported. The2022retrospective rendering comment at line3 is not backdated into2012. Hawkins is explicitly recommended and the Pinker quotation is separately attributed. The instrument/song description is an analogy, not proof that every neuron hears a literal sound or of the source's other numerical/physical claims."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected Benefits of Self-Modeling in Neural Systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram N. Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.10188v1",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "date": "2024-07-14",
        "date_type": "arXiv v1 submission date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies held PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "During training, the two could both be varied to find the best critical points under the joint loss function.",
        "summary": "Here “the two” refers to the predicted activations and the actual hidden activations. Both depend on trainable model weights; the target activity is not held permanently fixed. This explanation is a paraphrase, not an alteration of the quotation.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "PDF page 3, left column",
          "quote_normalization": "Readable wording verified against the held PDF page3image; extraction had collapsed spaces."
        },
        "speech_act": "SAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
        "hash_kind": "held PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-317030652681ED6980721B",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-317030652681ED6980721B",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/15",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-B2FBA73841C57C47DD06",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-B2FBA73841C57C47DD06",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-B83B1C2A6D1193509C49",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:824A074A17729942D83FEBA0E9BA3297EEC4F287F9C46FE956B890273FBC4B50",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
      "title": "SAN proposes learning and predicting the cell’s own responses",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-09-18) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2026-05-14). The shared role is learning a model of the neural system’s own activity, stated explicitly in the 2022 source before the 2024/2026 papers.",
      "shared": "The shared role is learning a model of the neural system’s own activity, stated explicitly in the 2022 source before the 2024/2026 papers.",
      "relation": "own-neural-activity prediction role · moderate role-level partial",
      "residual": "A qualitative neural self-model is not the target’s numerical prediction of selected current hidden activations in one forward pass. This does not establish the complete estimator, future-state semantics or consciousness.\n\nThe source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.\n\nPredicts current selected hidden activations, not automatically a future biological firing or conscious experience.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "own-neural-activity prediction role",
          "favorable": "The shared role is learning a model of the neural system’s own activity, stated explicitly in the 2022 source before the 2024/2026 papers.",
          "residual": "A qualitative neural self-model is not the target’s numerical prediction of selected current hidden activations in one forward pass. This does not establish the complete estimator, future-state semantics or consciousness."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "The cell is proposed to learn and predict its own response patterns through feedback.",
          "target_roles": "An artificial network predicts its internal states.",
          "shared_role": "own-neural-activity prediction role",
          "scope_limit": "The source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To reach the reported own-activation prediction, the target must retain an internal activity value and estimate it. Recover the source’s explicit own-activity modelling role, while retaining the missing numerical/state-coordinate implementation.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0007z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/894b4d4ea3f23d4d1d526e123b5744283ff9cd5d/a0007z.md",
        "sha256": "824A074A17729942D83FEBA0E9BA3297EEC4F287F9C46FE956B890273FBC4B50",
        "date": "2022-09-18",
        "date_type": "Historical Git author/commit record; original public availability is not independently certified.",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "My intuition is that the apical is learning its own cell's response, and through feedback loops, with itself and with other pyramidal neurons the cell is going to make predictions about its own patterns of causation, what patterns it responds & how it reacts or responds. With the Apical Dendrite perhaps symbolizing a more complex response that is connected to more complex learning. (compared to other types of neurons)"
        ],
        "locators": [
          51
        ],
        "speech_act": "The source says \"My intuition\" and describes feedback-linked cell responses. Anatomical speculation is not stripped from the source context."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected benefits of self-modelling in neural systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2024.0531",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
        "date": "2026-05-14",
        "date_type": "Version-of-record publication date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "In addition to performing a primary task, the networks were responsible for predicting the values of subsets of their own hidden activations.",
        "summary": "An artificial network predicts its internal states.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "Published source capture lines 121–124",
          "quote_normalization": "Verbatim published-version source-capture wording, with line breaks joined."
        },
        "speech_act": "Predicts current selected hidden activations, not automatically a future biological firing or conscious experience.",
        "hash_kind": "numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-B2FBA73841C57C47DD06",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-B2FBA73841C57C47DD06",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/16",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-93556A53F13F0E727739",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-93556A53F13F0E727739",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-39CEEAD5343139662A07",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:BAE95CC2D214077ABCE720EEA26177DADC1301FB3DC0946C93A3B85D1D4F88F9",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
      "title": "SAN proposes learning and predicting the cell’s own responses",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-08-30) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2026-05-14). The shared role is learning a model of the neural system’s own activity, stated explicitly in the 2022 source before the 2024/2026 papers.",
      "shared": "The shared role is learning a model of the neural system’s own activity, stated explicitly in the 2022 source before the 2024/2026 papers.",
      "relation": "own-neural-activity prediction role · moderate role-level partial",
      "residual": "A qualitative neural self-model is not the target’s numerical prediction of selected current hidden activations in one forward pass. This does not establish the complete estimator, future-state semantics or consciousness.\n\nThe source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.\n\nPredicts current selected hidden activations, not automatically a future biological firing or conscious experience.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "own-neural-activity prediction role",
          "favorable": "The shared role is learning a model of the neural system’s own activity, stated explicitly in the 2022 source before the 2024/2026 papers.",
          "residual": "A qualitative neural self-model is not the target’s numerical prediction of selected current hidden activations in one forward pass. This does not establish the complete estimator, future-state semantics or consciousness."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "The cell is proposed to learn and predict its own response patterns through feedback.",
          "target_roles": "An artificial network predicts its internal states.",
          "shared_role": "own-neural-activity prediction role",
          "scope_limit": "The source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To reach the reported own-activation prediction, the target must retain an internal activity value and estimate it. Recover the source’s explicit own-activity modelling role, while retaining the missing numerical/state-coordinate implementation.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0007z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/86ca59559908f6cad3f9f3314f3d651c3e0c6ea1/a0007z.md",
        "sha256": "BAE95CC2D214077ABCE720EEA26177DADC1301FB3DC0946C93A3B85D1D4F88F9",
        "date": "2022-08-30",
        "date_type": "Historical Git author/commit record; original public availability is not independently certified.",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "My intuition is that the apical is learning it's responds, and through feedback loops, with itself and with other pyramidal neurons the cell is going to make predictions about it's own patterns of causation, what patterns it responds & how it reacts or responds. With the Apical Dendrite perhaps symbolizing a more complex response that is connected to more complex learning. (compared to other types of neurons)"
        ],
        "locators": [
          39
        ],
        "speech_act": "Tentative basal/apical/exit-terminal account. This is learning a response mapping, not an explicit classification-plus-regression objective."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected benefits of self-modelling in neural systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2024.0531",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
        "date": "2026-05-14",
        "date_type": "Version-of-record publication date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "In addition to performing a primary task, the networks were responsible for predicting the values of subsets of their own hidden activations.",
        "summary": "An artificial network predicts its internal states.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "Published source capture lines 121–124",
          "quote_normalization": "Verbatim published-version source-capture wording, with line breaks joined."
        },
        "speech_act": "Predicts current selected hidden activations, not automatically a future biological firing or conscious experience.",
        "hash_kind": "numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-93556A53F13F0E727739",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-93556A53F13F0E727739",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/17",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-3C08158497F89FC0D377DB",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-3C08158497F89FC0D377DB",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-1EE166CBB8943AF4C5A0",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:835009EAE0FA62D471E5368131806D08C22549AE7C590DDFBA70187FAFE221D8",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
      "title": "SAN: a neural pattern represents its own activity",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-06-12) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2026-05-14). The note models the system’s own thought activity; the later network predicts its own internal activations.",
      "shared": "The note models the system’s own thought activity; the later network predicts its own internal activations.",
      "relation": "partial own-activity representation · weak-to-moderate conceptual partial",
      "residual": "A qualitative neural self-model is not the target’s numerical prediction of selected current hidden activations in one forward pass. This does not establish the complete estimator, future-state semantics or consciousness.\n\nThe owner-reported 2012 header is separate from the 2022 wording record.\n\nPredicts current selected hidden activations, not automatically a future biological firing or conscious experience.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "partial own-activity representation",
          "favorable": "The note models the system’s own thought activity; the later network predicts its own internal activations.",
          "residual": "A qualitative neural self-model is not the target’s numerical prediction of selected current hidden activations in one forward pass. This does not establish the complete estimator, future-state semantics or consciousness."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "A neural thought pattern represents its own activity within sensing and action.",
          "target_roles": "An artificial network predicts its internal states.",
          "shared_role": "partial own-activity representation",
          "scope_limit": "The owner-reported 2012 header is separate from the 2022 wording record.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To reach the reported own-activation prediction, the target must retain an internal activity value and estimate it. Recover the source’s explicit own-activity modelling role, while retaining the missing numerical/state-coordinate implementation.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0339z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4245ac674ea89dbf2b832f14a256a4d30937f13a/a0339z.md",
        "sha256": "835009EAE0FA62D471E5368131806D08C22549AE7C590DDFBA70187FAFE221D8",
        "date": "2022-06-12",
        "date_type": "Historical Git record; original first public release not independently authenticated",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release. This note reports 2012-09-07 separately; that is not an authenticated first-publication date.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": "2012-09-07",
        "quotes": [
          "the observer is the thought pattern making a thought pattern of the thought pattern"
        ],
        "locators": [
          8
        ],
        "speech_act": "The2012header is owner-reported, not independently authenticated publication. The2022Git object fixes this wording. Metaphysical, meditation and machine-consciousness assertions elsewhere in the note are not adopted as findings. The Numenta reference remains visible."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected benefits of self-modelling in neural systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2024.0531",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
        "date": "2026-05-14",
        "date_type": "Version-of-record publication date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "In addition to performing a primary task, the networks were responsible for predicting the values of subsets of their own hidden activations.",
        "summary": "An artificial network predicts its internal states.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "Published source capture lines 121–124",
          "quote_normalization": "Verbatim published-version source-capture wording, with line breaks joined."
        },
        "speech_act": "Predicts current selected hidden activations, not automatically a future biological firing or conscious experience.",
        "hash_kind": "numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-3C08158497F89FC0D377DB",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-3C08158497F89FC0D377DB",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/18",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-97DD037CC2D876BC05C4B2",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-97DD037CC2D876BC05C4B2",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-E352849CB7F0C159E646",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:C4538E29BCC1B8B3584334047A95CB1DE0E3B2C1A359F496643225C33939E120",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
      "title": "SAN: a learning loop receives its own activity",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-06-08) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2026-05-14). Self-generated activity returns to the neural system; the target predicts selected internally generated activations.",
      "shared": "Self-generated activity returns to the neural system; the target predicts selected internally generated activations.",
      "relation": "own-activity learning causal prefix · weak-to-moderate partial",
      "residual": "A qualitative neural self-model is not the target’s numerical prediction of selected current hidden activations in one forward pass. This does not establish the complete estimator, future-state semantics or consciousness.\n\nThe owner-reported 2012 header is separate from the 2022 wording record.\n\nPredicts current selected hidden activations, not automatically a future biological firing or conscious experience.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "own-activity learning causal prefix",
          "favorable": "Self-generated activity returns to the neural system; the target predicts selected internally generated activations.",
          "residual": "A qualitative neural self-model is not the target’s numerical prediction of selected current hidden activations in one forward pass. This does not establish the complete estimator, future-state semantics or consciousness."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "The neurons producing a pattern also receive it, within a feedback loop that learns.",
          "target_roles": "An artificial network predicts its internal states.",
          "shared_role": "own-activity learning causal prefix",
          "scope_limit": "The owner-reported 2012 header is separate from the 2022 wording record.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To reach the reported own-activation prediction, the target must retain an internal activity value and estimate it. Recover the source’s explicit own-activity modelling role, while retaining the missing numerical/state-coordinate implementation.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0632z ctpr.txt",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/5360f6414909a2474129b2140ee0dc3112c93b6b/a0632z%20ctpr.txt",
        "sha256": "C4538E29BCC1B8B3584334047A95CB1DE0E3B2C1A359F496643225C33939E120",
        "date": "2022-06-08",
        "date_type": "Historical Git record; original first public release not independently authenticated",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release. This note reports 2012-04-19 separately; that is not an authenticated first-publication date.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": "2012-04-19",
        "quotes": [
          "Who listens to the song and understands the meaning? the song is a loop, the neurons that play it also listen to it"
        ],
        "locators": [
          49
        ],
        "speech_act": "The2012header is owner-reported. The2022retrospective rendering comment at line3 is not backdated into2012. Hawkins is explicitly recommended and the Pinker quotation is separately attributed. The instrument/song description is an analogy, not proof that every neuron hears a literal sound or of the source's other numerical/physical claims."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected benefits of self-modelling in neural systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2024.0531",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
        "date": "2026-05-14",
        "date_type": "Version-of-record publication date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "In addition to performing a primary task, the networks were responsible for predicting the values of subsets of their own hidden activations.",
        "summary": "An artificial network predicts its internal states.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "Published source capture lines 121–124",
          "quote_normalization": "Verbatim published-version source-capture wording, with line breaks joined."
        },
        "speech_act": "Predicts current selected hidden activations, not automatically a future biological firing or conscious experience.",
        "hash_kind": "numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-97DD037CC2D876BC05C4B2",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-97DD037CC2D876BC05C4B2",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/19",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-SOURCE-EDITION-942C01660790DE34D4A711",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-SOURCE-EDITION-942C01660790DE34D4A711",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-652B718D9B12CE563750",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:824A074A17729942D83FEBA0E9BA3297EEC4F287F9C46FE956B890273FBC4B50",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
      "title": "SAN proposes learning from the cell’s own activity",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-09-18) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2026-05-14). Learning about internally generated activity accompanies ordinary signal processing; the target implements this additional focus as an auxiliary task.",
      "shared": "Learning about internally generated activity accompanies ordinary signal processing; the target implements this additional focus as an auxiliary task.",
      "relation": "additional internal-learning role · weak-to-moderate component partial",
      "residual": "Reading or learning from internal activity is not an explicitly specified additional output head, numerical auxiliary regression loss or training schedule. The shared role is preserved without identifying the full implementation.\n\nThe source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.\n\nA numerical auxiliary regression output is more specific than merely reading an internal representation.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "additional internal-learning role",
          "favorable": "Learning about internally generated activity accompanies ordinary signal processing; the target implements this additional focus as an auxiliary task.",
          "residual": "Reading or learning from internal activity is not an explicitly specified additional output head, numerical auxiliary regression loss or training schedule. The shared role is preserved without identifying the full implementation."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "The proposed apical learning process receives external sensory input and the cell’s own somatic burst patterns.",
          "target_roles": "Internal-state prediction is trained as an auxiliary task.",
          "shared_role": "additional internal-learning role",
          "scope_limit": "The source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To add self-modelling beside the main task, the target must expose internal activity to an additional learned prediction role. Compare that role to internal readout/own-response learning, not merely to the word self.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0007z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/894b4d4ea3f23d4d1d526e123b5744283ff9cd5d/a0007z.md",
        "sha256": "824A074A17729942D83FEBA0E9BA3297EEC4F287F9C46FE956B890273FBC4B50",
        "date": "2022-09-18",
        "date_type": "Historical Git author/commit record; original public availability is not independently certified.",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "An interesting thought about the cyclic nature of Layer 5 pyramidal cells, is the idea that the process of the dendrite being a sensor, like an eyeball or an ear appears to apply to both sides of the neuron, on the way in, and on the way out. So the Apical dendrite, as a neural network, is learning from incoming sensory stimulus, but the Soma burst is one of the incoming sensory stimuli, with models of soma burst waveforms becoming part of what the Apical Dendrite has to contend with."
        ],
        "locators": [
          47
        ],
        "speech_act": "The source says \"My intuition\" and describes feedback-linked cell responses. Anatomical speculation is not stripped from the source context."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected benefits of self-modelling in neural systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2024.0531",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
        "date": "2026-05-14",
        "date_type": "Version-of-record publication date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "we augmented the output layer to predict both the class probabilities and the activations of specific target layers within the network.",
        "summary": "Internal-state prediction is trained as an auxiliary task.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "Published source capture lines 145–156",
          "quote_normalization": "Verbatim published-version source-capture wording, with line breaks joined."
        },
        "speech_act": "A numerical auxiliary regression output is more specific than merely reading an internal representation.",
        "hash_kind": "numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-SOURCE-EDITION-942C01660790DE34D4A711",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-SOURCE-EDITION-942C01660790DE34D4A711",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/20",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-04042FE8489D45E422D2",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-04042FE8489D45E422D2",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-A95BFA23D8A9633FA010",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:BAE95CC2D214077ABCE720EEA26177DADC1301FB3DC0946C93A3B85D1D4F88F9",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
      "title": "SAN proposes learning from the cell’s own activity",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-08-30) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2026-05-14). Learning about internally generated activity accompanies ordinary signal processing; the target implements this additional focus as an auxiliary task.",
      "shared": "Learning about internally generated activity accompanies ordinary signal processing; the target implements this additional focus as an auxiliary task.",
      "relation": "additional internal-learning role · weak-to-moderate component partial",
      "residual": "Reading or learning from internal activity is not an explicitly specified additional output head, numerical auxiliary regression loss or training schedule. The shared role is preserved without identifying the full implementation.\n\nThe source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.\n\nA numerical auxiliary regression output is more specific than merely reading an internal representation.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "additional internal-learning role",
          "favorable": "Learning about internally generated activity accompanies ordinary signal processing; the target implements this additional focus as an auxiliary task.",
          "residual": "Reading or learning from internal activity is not an explicitly specified additional output head, numerical auxiliary regression loss or training schedule. The shared role is preserved without identifying the full implementation."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "The proposed apical learning process receives external sensory input and the cell’s own somatic burst patterns.",
          "target_roles": "Internal-state prediction is trained as an auxiliary task.",
          "shared_role": "additional internal-learning role",
          "scope_limit": "The source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To add self-modelling beside the main task, the target must expose internal activity to an additional learned prediction role. Compare that role to internal readout/own-response learning, not merely to the word self.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0007z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/86ca59559908f6cad3f9f3314f3d651c3e0c6ea1/a0007z.md",
        "sha256": "BAE95CC2D214077ABCE720EEA26177DADC1301FB3DC0946C93A3B85D1D4F88F9",
        "date": "2022-08-30",
        "date_type": "Historical Git author/commit record; original public availability is not independently certified.",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "An interesting thought about the cyclic nature of Layer 5 pyramidal cells, is the idea that the process of the dendrite being a sensor, like an eyeball or an ear appears to apply to both sides of the neuron, on the way in, and on the way out. So the Apical dendrite, as a neural network, is learning from incoming sensor stimulus, but the Soma burst is one of the incoming sensor stimulai, with models of soma burst waveforms becoming part of what the Apical Dendrite has to contend with."
        ],
        "locators": [
          35
        ],
        "speech_act": "Tentative basal/apical/exit-terminal account. This is learning a response mapping, not an explicit classification-plus-regression objective."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected benefits of self-modelling in neural systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2024.0531",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
        "date": "2026-05-14",
        "date_type": "Version-of-record publication date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "we augmented the output layer to predict both the class probabilities and the activations of specific target layers within the network.",
        "summary": "Internal-state prediction is trained as an auxiliary task.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "Published source capture lines 145–156",
          "quote_normalization": "Verbatim published-version source-capture wording, with line breaks joined."
        },
        "speech_act": "A numerical auxiliary regression output is more specific than merely reading an internal representation.",
        "hash_kind": "numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-04042FE8489D45E422D2",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-04042FE8489D45E422D2",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/21",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-3AA152D7447C9192E882D6",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-3AA152D7447C9192E882D6",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-1EE166CBB8943AF4C5A0",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:835009EAE0FA62D471E5368131806D08C22549AE7C590DDFBA70187FAFE221D8",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
      "title": "SAN: self-representation within sensing and action",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-06-12) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2026-05-14). Both accounts include an internally directed modelling role inside the functioning network.",
      "shared": "Both accounts include an internally directed modelling role inside the functioning network.",
      "relation": "internal-modelling architecture component · weak conceptual/architecture partial",
      "residual": "Reading or learning from internal activity is not an explicitly specified additional output head, numerical auxiliary regression loss or training schedule. The shared role is preserved without identifying the full implementation.\n\nThe owner-reported 2012 header is separate from the 2022 wording record.\n\nA numerical auxiliary regression output is more specific than merely reading an internal representation.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "internal-modelling architecture component",
          "favorable": "Both accounts include an internally directed modelling role inside the functioning network.",
          "residual": "Reading or learning from internal activity is not an explicitly specified additional output head, numerical auxiliary regression loss or training schedule. The shared role is preserved without identifying the full implementation."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "A representation of the system’s own thought activity is included within ongoing neural sensing and action.",
          "target_roles": "Internal-state prediction is trained as an auxiliary task.",
          "shared_role": "internal-modelling architecture component",
          "scope_limit": "The owner-reported 2012 header is separate from the 2022 wording record.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To add self-modelling beside the main task, the target must expose internal activity to an additional learned prediction role. Compare that role to internal readout/own-response learning, not merely to the word self.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0339z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4245ac674ea89dbf2b832f14a256a4d30937f13a/a0339z.md",
        "sha256": "835009EAE0FA62D471E5368131806D08C22549AE7C590DDFBA70187FAFE221D8",
        "date": "2022-06-12",
        "date_type": "Historical Git record; original first public release not independently authenticated",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release. This note reports 2012-09-07 separately; that is not an authenticated first-publication date.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": "2012-09-07",
        "quotes": [
          "the observer is the thought pattern making a thought pattern of the thought pattern"
        ],
        "locators": [
          8
        ],
        "speech_act": "The2012header is owner-reported, not independently authenticated publication. The2022Git object fixes this wording. Metaphysical, meditation and machine-consciousness assertions elsewhere in the note are not adopted as findings. The Numenta reference remains visible."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected benefits of self-modelling in neural systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2024.0531",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
        "date": "2026-05-14",
        "date_type": "Version-of-record publication date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "we augmented the output layer to predict both the class probabilities and the activations of specific target layers within the network.",
        "summary": "Internal-state prediction is trained as an auxiliary task.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "Published source capture lines 145–156",
          "quote_normalization": "Verbatim published-version source-capture wording, with line breaks joined."
        },
        "speech_act": "A numerical auxiliary regression output is more specific than merely reading an internal representation.",
        "hash_kind": "numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-3AA152D7447C9192E882D6",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-3AA152D7447C9192E882D6",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/22",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-C9E2C8B4AAFC584D596DFD",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-C9E2C8B4AAFC584D596DFD",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-23DB15524725B85231AF",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:C4538E29BCC1B8B3584334047A95CB1DE0E3B2C1A359F496643225C33939E120",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
      "title": "SAN: a neural representation is read by another layer",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-06-08) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2026-05-14). An internal representation becomes input to further neural processing; the target adds a specific internal regression task.",
      "shared": "An internal representation becomes input to further neural processing; the target adds a specific internal regression task.",
      "relation": "internal neural readout component · weak component partial",
      "residual": "Reading or learning from internal activity is not an explicitly specified additional output head, numerical auxiliary regression loss or training schedule. The shared role is preserved without identifying the full implementation.\n\nLine 3 is a retrospective comment fixed in 2022, not a verified 2012 statement.\n\nA numerical auxiliary regression output is more specific than merely reading an internal representation.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "internal neural readout component",
          "favorable": "An internal representation becomes input to further neural processing; the target adds a specific internal regression task.",
          "residual": "Reading or learning from internal activity is not an explicitly specified additional output head, numerical auxiliary regression loss or training schedule. The shared role is preserved without identifying the full implementation."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "A 2022-recorded retrospective comment describes a rendering that a subsequent neural array or layer reads and interprets.",
          "target_roles": "Internal-state prediction is trained as an auxiliary task.",
          "shared_role": "internal neural readout component",
          "scope_limit": "Line 3 is a retrospective comment fixed in 2022, not a verified 2012 statement.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To add self-modelling beside the main task, the target must expose internal activity to an additional learned prediction role. Compare that role to internal readout/own-response learning, not merely to the word self.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0632z ctpr.txt",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/5360f6414909a2474129b2140ee0dc3112c93b6b/a0632z%20ctpr.txt",
        "sha256": "C4538E29BCC1B8B3584334047A95CB1DE0E3B2C1A359F496643225C33939E120",
        "date": "2022-06-08",
        "date_type": "Historical Git record; original first public release not independently authenticated",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release. This note reports 2012-04-19 separately; that is not an authenticated first-publication date.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": "2012-04-19",
        "quotes": [
          "Comment on the note: What I think I was missing at this point in time (2012) was the part about how a memory-prediction was actually a rendering that a subsequent array or layer of nerve cells would read & interpret."
        ],
        "locators": [
          3
        ],
        "speech_act": "The2012header is owner-reported. The2022retrospective rendering comment at line3 is not backdated into2012. Hawkins is explicitly recommended and the Pinker quotation is separately attributed. The instrument/song description is an analogy, not proof that every neuron hears a literal sound or of the source's other numerical/physical claims."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected benefits of self-modelling in neural systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2024.0531",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
        "date": "2026-05-14",
        "date_type": "Version-of-record publication date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "we augmented the output layer to predict both the class probabilities and the activations of specific target layers within the network.",
        "summary": "Internal-state prediction is trained as an auxiliary task.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "Published source capture lines 145–156",
          "quote_normalization": "Verbatim published-version source-capture wording, with line breaks joined."
        },
        "speech_act": "A numerical auxiliary regression output is more specific than merely reading an internal representation.",
        "hash_kind": "numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-C9E2C8B4AAFC584D596DFD",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-C9E2C8B4AAFC584D596DFD",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/23",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-OP-F42E07906D82A1736B8DA4",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-OP-F42E07906D82A1736B8DA4",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-B83B1C2A6D1193509C49",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:824A074A17729942D83FEBA0E9BA3297EEC4F287F9C46FE956B890273FBC4B50",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
      "title": "SAN links response learning with learning about responses",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-09-18) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2026-05-14). The earlier source joins two learning roles; the later system trains a primary task and an internal-prediction task together.",
      "shared": "The earlier source joins two learning roles; the later system trains a primary task and an internal-prediction task together.",
      "relation": "coupled learning-role architecture · weak-to-moderate architecture partial",
      "residual": "The source does not specify the target’s weighted cross-entropy-plus-regression objective, optimizer, targets or gradient computation. Coupled learning roles are not mathematical identity of the loss.\n\nThe source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.\n\nSAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "coupled learning-role architecture",
          "favorable": "The earlier source joins two learning roles; the later system trains a primary task and an internal-prediction task together.",
          "residual": "The source does not specify the target’s weighted cross-entropy-plus-regression objective, optimizer, targets or gradient computation. Coupled learning roles are not mathematical identity of the loss."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "Response learning and learning the cell’s own responses are coupled through recurring feedback.",
          "target_roles": "The two tasks are classification and prediction of the network's own selected hidden activations. The paper uses additive weighted classification and regression losses.",
          "shared_role": "coupled learning-role architecture",
          "scope_limit": "The source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To train the two tasks jointly, the target must combine task-specific error signals. The sources support joined learning roles at most; no additive numerical loss is inferred from feedback language.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0007z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/894b4d4ea3f23d4d1d526e123b5744283ff9cd5d/a0007z.md",
        "sha256": "824A074A17729942D83FEBA0E9BA3297EEC4F287F9C46FE956B890273FBC4B50",
        "date": "2022-09-18",
        "date_type": "Historical Git author/commit record; original public availability is not independently certified.",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "My intuition is that the apical is learning its own cell's response, and through feedback loops, with itself and with other pyramidal neurons the cell is going to make predictions about its own patterns of causation, what patterns it responds & how it reacts or responds. With the Apical Dendrite perhaps symbolizing a more complex response that is connected to more complex learning. (compared to other types of neurons)"
        ],
        "locators": [
          51
        ],
        "speech_act": "The source says \"My intuition\" and describes feedback-linked cell responses. Anatomical speculation is not stripped from the source context."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected benefits of self-modelling in neural systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2024.0531",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
        "date": "2026-05-14",
        "date_type": "Version-of-record publication date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "The predictions and targets were passed to their respective loss functions, and models were trained jointly on these two tasks.",
        "summary": "The two tasks are classification and prediction of the network's own selected hidden activations. The paper uses additive weighted classification and regression losses.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "Publisher PDF page 4, located lines 158–168",
          "quote_normalization": "Verbatim source-capture wording; line breaks collapsed to spaces."
        },
        "speech_act": "SAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
        "hash_kind": "numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-OP-F42E07906D82A1736B8DA4",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-OP-F42E07906D82A1736B8DA4",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/24",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-OP-DD5297EF633E9E990473D5",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-OP-DD5297EF633E9E990473D5",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-39CEEAD5343139662A07",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:BAE95CC2D214077ABCE720EEA26177DADC1301FB3DC0946C93A3B85D1D4F88F9",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
      "title": "SAN links response learning with learning about responses",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-08-30) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2026-05-14). The earlier source joins two learning roles; the later system trains a primary task and an internal-prediction task together.",
      "shared": "The earlier source joins two learning roles; the later system trains a primary task and an internal-prediction task together.",
      "relation": "coupled learning-role architecture · weak-to-moderate architecture partial",
      "residual": "The source does not specify the target’s weighted cross-entropy-plus-regression objective, optimizer, targets or gradient computation. Coupled learning roles are not mathematical identity of the loss.\n\nThe source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.\n\nSAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "coupled learning-role architecture",
          "favorable": "The earlier source joins two learning roles; the later system trains a primary task and an internal-prediction task together.",
          "residual": "The source does not specify the target’s weighted cross-entropy-plus-regression objective, optimizer, targets or gradient computation. Coupled learning roles are not mathematical identity of the loss."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "Response learning and learning the cell’s own responses are coupled through recurring feedback.",
          "target_roles": "The two tasks are classification and prediction of the network's own selected hidden activations. The paper uses additive weighted classification and regression losses.",
          "shared_role": "coupled learning-role architecture",
          "scope_limit": "The source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To train the two tasks jointly, the target must combine task-specific error signals. The sources support joined learning roles at most; no additive numerical loss is inferred from feedback language.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0007z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/86ca59559908f6cad3f9f3314f3d651c3e0c6ea1/a0007z.md",
        "sha256": "BAE95CC2D214077ABCE720EEA26177DADC1301FB3DC0946C93A3B85D1D4F88F9",
        "date": "2022-08-30",
        "date_type": "Historical Git author/commit record; original public availability is not independently certified.",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "My intuition is that the apical is learning it's responds, and through feedback loops, with itself and with other pyramidal neurons the cell is going to make predictions about it's own patterns of causation, what patterns it responds & how it reacts or responds. With the Apical Dendrite perhaps symbolizing a more complex response that is connected to more complex learning. (compared to other types of neurons)"
        ],
        "locators": [
          39
        ],
        "speech_act": "Tentative basal/apical/exit-terminal account. This is learning a response mapping, not an explicit classification-plus-regression objective."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected benefits of self-modelling in neural systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2024.0531",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
        "date": "2026-05-14",
        "date_type": "Version-of-record publication date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "The predictions and targets were passed to their respective loss functions, and models were trained jointly on these two tasks.",
        "summary": "The two tasks are classification and prediction of the network's own selected hidden activations. The paper uses additive weighted classification and regression losses.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "Publisher PDF page 4, located lines 158–168",
          "quote_normalization": "Verbatim source-capture wording; line breaks collapsed to spaces."
        },
        "speech_act": "SAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
        "hash_kind": "numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-OP-DD5297EF633E9E990473D5",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-OP-DD5297EF633E9E990473D5",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/25",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-A69F711711EA6D3B1CBA26",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-A69F711711EA6D3B1CBA26",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-1EE166CBB8943AF4C5A0",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:835009EAE0FA62D471E5368131806D08C22549AE7C590DDFBA70187FAFE221D8",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
      "title": "SAN: self-representation alongside sensing and action",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-06-12) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2026-05-14). Primary engagement and internal self-representation coexist in one system; the target implements an explicit paired learning objective.",
      "shared": "Primary engagement and internal self-representation coexist in one system; the target implements an explicit paired learning objective.",
      "relation": "paired-role architecture component · weak architecture partial",
      "residual": "The source does not specify the target’s weighted cross-entropy-plus-regression objective, optimizer, targets or gradient computation. Coupled learning roles are not mathematical identity of the loss.\n\nThe owner-reported 2012 header is separate from the 2022 wording record.\n\nSAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "paired-role architecture component",
          "favorable": "Primary engagement and internal self-representation coexist in one system; the target implements an explicit paired learning objective.",
          "residual": "The source does not specify the target’s weighted cross-entropy-plus-regression objective, optimizer, targets or gradient computation. Coupled learning roles are not mathematical identity of the loss."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "The note joins sensing and action with a recursively developing representation of the system’s own activity.",
          "target_roles": "The two tasks are classification and prediction of the network's own selected hidden activations. The paper uses additive weighted classification and regression losses.",
          "shared_role": "paired-role architecture component",
          "scope_limit": "The owner-reported 2012 header is separate from the 2022 wording record.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To train the two tasks jointly, the target must combine task-specific error signals. The sources support joined learning roles at most; no additive numerical loss is inferred from feedback language.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0339z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4245ac674ea89dbf2b832f14a256a4d30937f13a/a0339z.md",
        "sha256": "835009EAE0FA62D471E5368131806D08C22549AE7C590DDFBA70187FAFE221D8",
        "date": "2022-06-12",
        "date_type": "Historical Git record; original first public release not independently authenticated",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release. This note reports 2012-09-07 separately; that is not an authenticated first-publication date.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": "2012-09-07",
        "quotes": [
          "the observer is the thought pattern making a thought pattern of the thought pattern"
        ],
        "locators": [
          8
        ],
        "speech_act": "The2012header is owner-reported, not independently authenticated publication. The2022Git object fixes this wording. Metaphysical, meditation and machine-consciousness assertions elsewhere in the note are not adopted as findings. The Numenta reference remains visible."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected benefits of self-modelling in neural systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2024.0531",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
        "date": "2026-05-14",
        "date_type": "Version-of-record publication date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "The predictions and targets were passed to their respective loss functions, and models were trained jointly on these two tasks.",
        "summary": "The two tasks are classification and prediction of the network's own selected hidden activations. The paper uses additive weighted classification and regression losses.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "Publisher PDF page 4, located lines 158–168",
          "quote_normalization": "Verbatim source-capture wording; line breaks collapsed to spaces."
        },
        "speech_act": "SAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
        "hash_kind": "numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-A69F711711EA6D3B1CBA26",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-A69F711711EA6D3B1CBA26",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/26",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-F864269540C721258D2910",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-F864269540C721258D2910",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-7E85AA36802C889CD645",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:C4538E29BCC1B8B3584334047A95CB1DE0E3B2C1A359F496643225C33939E120",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
      "title": "SAN: self-generated activity feeds a learning loop",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-06-08) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2026-05-14). The internally generated activity participates in learning alongside the system’s other activity; the target implements primary and self-modelling losses together.",
      "shared": "The internally generated activity participates in learning alongside the system’s other activity; the target implements primary and self-modelling losses together.",
      "relation": "internally returned learning component · weak architecture partial",
      "residual": "The source does not specify the target’s weighted cross-entropy-plus-regression objective, optimizer, targets or gradient computation. Coupled learning roles are not mathematical identity of the loss.\n\nThe owner-reported 2012 header is separate from the 2022 wording record.\n\nSAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "internally returned learning component",
          "favorable": "The internally generated activity participates in learning alongside the system’s other activity; the target implements primary and self-modelling losses together.",
          "residual": "The source does not specify the target’s weighted cross-entropy-plus-regression objective, optimizer, targets or gradient computation. Coupled learning roles are not mathematical identity of the loss."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "A neural system produces and receives its own patterns within a feedback loop that learns.",
          "target_roles": "The two tasks are classification and prediction of the network's own selected hidden activations. The paper uses additive weighted classification and regression losses.",
          "shared_role": "internally returned learning component",
          "scope_limit": "The owner-reported 2012 header is separate from the 2022 wording record.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To train the two tasks jointly, the target must combine task-specific error signals. The sources support joined learning roles at most; no additive numerical loss is inferred from feedback language.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0632z ctpr.txt",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/5360f6414909a2474129b2140ee0dc3112c93b6b/a0632z%20ctpr.txt",
        "sha256": "C4538E29BCC1B8B3584334047A95CB1DE0E3B2C1A359F496643225C33939E120",
        "date": "2022-06-08",
        "date_type": "Historical Git record; original first public release not independently authenticated",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release. This note reports 2012-04-19 separately; that is not an authenticated first-publication date.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": "2012-04-19",
        "quotes": [
          "Being is a learning loop, like a feedback loop that learns"
        ],
        "locators": [
          44
        ],
        "speech_act": "The2012header is owner-reported. The2022retrospective rendering comment at line3 is not backdated into2012. Hawkins is explicitly recommended and the Pinker quotation is separately attributed. The instrument/song description is an analogy, not proof that every neuron hears a literal sound or of the source's other numerical/physical claims."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected benefits of self-modelling in neural systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2024.0531",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
        "date": "2026-05-14",
        "date_type": "Version-of-record publication date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "The predictions and targets were passed to their respective loss functions, and models were trained jointly on these two tasks.",
        "summary": "The two tasks are classification and prediction of the network's own selected hidden activations. The paper uses additive weighted classification and regression losses.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "Publisher PDF page 4, located lines 158–168",
          "quote_normalization": "Verbatim source-capture wording; line breaks collapsed to spaces."
        },
        "speech_act": "SAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
        "hash_kind": "numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-F864269540C721258D2910",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-F864269540C721258D2910",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/27",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-OP-F2E78CCABF9F5111CF12AF",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-OP-F2E78CCABF9F5111CF12AF",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-B83B1C2A6D1193509C49",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:824A074A17729942D83FEBA0E9BA3297EEC4F287F9C46FE956B890273FBC4B50",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
      "title": "SAN proposes two adaptive learning roles",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-09-18) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2026-05-14). The source gives both response generation and self-response prediction adaptive roles; the target makes both actual and predicted internal activations trainable.",
      "shared": "The source gives both response generation and self-response prediction adaptive roles; the target makes both actual and predicted internal activations trainable.",
      "relation": "two adaptive roles / causal-prefix mapping · moderate role-level partial",
      "residual": "The target lets both actual and predicted hidden activations vary under its joint loss. The source supplies only the stated adaptive component or qualitative coupled-role account, not the same shared-parameter optimization or measured complexity reduction.\n\nThe source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.\n\nSAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "two adaptive roles / causal-prefix mapping",
          "favorable": "The source gives both response generation and self-response prediction adaptive roles; the target makes both actual and predicted internal activations trainable.",
          "residual": "The target lets both actual and predicted hidden activations vary under its joint loss. The source supplies only the stated adaptive component or qualitative coupled-role account, not the same shared-parameter optimization or measured complexity reduction."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "The response mapping and the model of the cell’s responses are both described as learned.",
          "target_roles": "Here “the two” refers to the predicted activations and the actual hidden activations. Both depend on trainable model weights; the target activity is not held permanently fixed. This explanation is a paraphrase, not an alteration of the quotation.",
          "shared_role": "two adaptive roles / causal-prefix mapping",
          "scope_limit": "The source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To make both sides trainable, the target requires adaptable predicted and actual activations. Test each source for predictor adaptation and response-generation adaptation separately. A one-sided supported component remains partial and does not establish the two-sided conjunction.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0007z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/894b4d4ea3f23d4d1d526e123b5744283ff9cd5d/a0007z.md",
        "sha256": "824A074A17729942D83FEBA0E9BA3297EEC4F287F9C46FE956B890273FBC4B50",
        "date": "2022-09-18",
        "date_type": "Historical Git author/commit record; original public availability is not independently certified.",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "My intuition is that the apical is learning its own cell's response, and through feedback loops, with itself and with other pyramidal neurons the cell is going to make predictions about its own patterns of causation, what patterns it responds & how it reacts or responds. With the Apical Dendrite perhaps symbolizing a more complex response that is connected to more complex learning. (compared to other types of neurons)"
        ],
        "locators": [
          51
        ],
        "speech_act": "The source says \"My intuition\" and describes feedback-linked cell responses. Anatomical speculation is not stripped from the source context."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected benefits of self-modelling in neural systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2024.0531",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
        "date": "2026-05-14",
        "date_type": "Version-of-record publication date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "During training, the two could both be varied to find the best critical points under the joint loss function.",
        "summary": "Here “the two” refers to the predicted activations and the actual hidden activations. Both depend on trainable model weights; the target activity is not held permanently fixed. This explanation is a paraphrase, not an alteration of the quotation.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "Publisher PDF page 4, located lines 169–171",
          "quote_normalization": "Verbatim source-capture wording; line breaks collapsed to spaces."
        },
        "speech_act": "SAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
        "hash_kind": "numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-OP-F2E78CCABF9F5111CF12AF",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-OP-F2E78CCABF9F5111CF12AF",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/28",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-OP-B41DD2AEB8A3B0CA5D6542",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-OP-B41DD2AEB8A3B0CA5D6542",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-39CEEAD5343139662A07",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:BAE95CC2D214077ABCE720EEA26177DADC1301FB3DC0946C93A3B85D1D4F88F9",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
      "title": "SAN proposes two adaptive learning roles",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-08-30) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2026-05-14). The source gives both response generation and self-response prediction adaptive roles; the target makes both actual and predicted internal activations trainable.",
      "shared": "The source gives both response generation and self-response prediction adaptive roles; the target makes both actual and predicted internal activations trainable.",
      "relation": "two adaptive roles / causal-prefix mapping · moderate role-level partial",
      "residual": "The target lets both actual and predicted hidden activations vary under its joint loss. The source supplies only the stated adaptive component or qualitative coupled-role account, not the same shared-parameter optimization or measured complexity reduction.\n\nThe source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.\n\nSAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "two adaptive roles / causal-prefix mapping",
          "favorable": "The source gives both response generation and self-response prediction adaptive roles; the target makes both actual and predicted internal activations trainable.",
          "residual": "The target lets both actual and predicted hidden activations vary under its joint loss. The source supplies only the stated adaptive component or qualitative coupled-role account, not the same shared-parameter optimization or measured complexity reduction."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "The response mapping and the model of the cell’s responses are both described as learned.",
          "target_roles": "Here “the two” refers to the predicted activations and the actual hidden activations. Both depend on trainable model weights; the target activity is not held permanently fixed. This explanation is a paraphrase, not an alteration of the quotation.",
          "shared_role": "two adaptive roles / causal-prefix mapping",
          "scope_limit": "The source is tentative (My intuition) and mixes basal/apical/exit terminology; compare the learning role without endorsing every anatomical implementation claim.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To make both sides trainable, the target requires adaptable predicted and actual activations. Test each source for predictor adaptation and response-generation adaptation separately. A one-sided supported component remains partial and does not establish the two-sided conjunction.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0007z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/86ca59559908f6cad3f9f3314f3d651c3e0c6ea1/a0007z.md",
        "sha256": "BAE95CC2D214077ABCE720EEA26177DADC1301FB3DC0946C93A3B85D1D4F88F9",
        "date": "2022-08-30",
        "date_type": "Historical Git author/commit record; original public availability is not independently certified.",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "My intuition is that the apical is learning it's responds, and through feedback loops, with itself and with other pyramidal neurons the cell is going to make predictions about it's own patterns of causation, what patterns it responds & how it reacts or responds. With the Apical Dendrite perhaps symbolizing a more complex response that is connected to more complex learning. (compared to other types of neurons)"
        ],
        "locators": [
          39
        ],
        "speech_act": "Tentative basal/apical/exit-terminal account. This is learning a response mapping, not an explicit classification-plus-regression objective."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected benefits of self-modelling in neural systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2024.0531",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
        "date": "2026-05-14",
        "date_type": "Version-of-record publication date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "During training, the two could both be varied to find the best critical points under the joint loss function.",
        "summary": "Here “the two” refers to the predicted activations and the actual hidden activations. Both depend on trainable model weights; the target activity is not held permanently fixed. This explanation is a paraphrase, not an alteration of the quotation.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "Publisher PDF page 4, located lines 169–171",
          "quote_normalization": "Verbatim source-capture wording; line breaks collapsed to spaces."
        },
        "speech_act": "SAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
        "hash_kind": "numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-OP-B41DD2AEB8A3B0CA5D6542",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-OP-B41DD2AEB8A3B0CA5D6542",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/29",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-7BE24D6314DF7C538019C4",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-7BE24D6314DF7C538019C4",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-ACFCB26C79A1CDC4CC19",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:835009EAE0FA62D471E5368131806D08C22549AE7C590DDFBA70187FAFE221D8",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
      "title": "SAN: the self-representation develops",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-06-12) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2026-05-14). The source’s internal self-representation can develop; the target also permits its internal predictor to change during training.",
      "shared": "The source’s internal self-representation can develop; the target also permits its internal predictor to change during training.",
      "relation": "adaptive self-model component · weak conceptual partial",
      "residual": "The target lets both actual and predicted hidden activations vary under its joint loss. The source supplies only the stated adaptive component or qualitative coupled-role account, not the same shared-parameter optimization or measured complexity reduction.\n\nOnly adaptive self-representation is mapped. The source is not used to assert a separately trained generator.\n\nSAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "adaptive self-model component",
          "favorable": "The source’s internal self-representation can develop; the target also permits its internal predictor to change during training.",
          "residual": "The target lets both actual and predicted hidden activations vary under its joint loss. The source supplies only the stated adaptive component or qualitative coupled-role account, not the same shared-parameter optimization or measured complexity reduction."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "A prediction of awareness incorporates its own development and evolves through the continuing loop.",
          "target_roles": "Here “the two” refers to the predicted activations and the actual hidden activations. Both depend on trainable model weights; the target activity is not held permanently fixed. This explanation is a paraphrase, not an alteration of the quotation.",
          "shared_role": "adaptive self-model component",
          "scope_limit": "Only adaptive self-representation is mapped. The source is not used to assert a separately trained generator.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To make both sides trainable, the target requires adaptable predicted and actual activations. Test each source for predictor adaptation and response-generation adaptation separately. A one-sided supported component remains partial and does not establish the two-sided conjunction.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0339z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4245ac674ea89dbf2b832f14a256a4d30937f13a/a0339z.md",
        "sha256": "835009EAE0FA62D471E5368131806D08C22549AE7C590DDFBA70187FAFE221D8",
        "date": "2022-06-12",
        "date_type": "Historical Git record; original first public release not independently authenticated",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release. This note reports 2012-09-07 separately; that is not an authenticated first-publication date.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": "2012-09-07",
        "quotes": [
          "We have a prediction of awareness, and it seems aware because this prediction is incorporating it's own development into an even higher level of awareness about itself."
        ],
        "locators": [
          10
        ],
        "speech_act": "The2012header is owner-reported, not independently authenticated publication. The2022Git object fixes this wording. Metaphysical, meditation and machine-consciousness assertions elsewhere in the note are not adopted as findings. The Numenta reference remains visible."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected benefits of self-modelling in neural systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2024.0531",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
        "date": "2026-05-14",
        "date_type": "Version-of-record publication date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "During training, the two could both be varied to find the best critical points under the joint loss function.",
        "summary": "Here “the two” refers to the predicted activations and the actual hidden activations. Both depend on trainable model weights; the target activity is not held permanently fixed. This explanation is a paraphrase, not an alteration of the quotation.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "Publisher PDF page 4, located lines 169–171",
          "quote_normalization": "Verbatim source-capture wording; line breaks collapsed to spaces."
        },
        "speech_act": "SAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
        "hash_kind": "numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-7BE24D6314DF7C538019C4",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-7BE24D6314DF7C538019C4",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/30",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-5715974107759890106553",
      "original_id": "GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-5715974107759890106553",
      "edition_id": "graziano-self-modelling",
      "program": "Graziano",
      "passage_id": "passage-7B0F6012CB863CC0E802",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:C4538E29BCC1B8B3584334047A95CB1DE0E3B2C1A359F496643225C33939E120",
      "target_work_id": "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
      "title": "SAN: a learning loop with adaptable responses",
      "conclusion": "Micah Blumberg / SAN (2022-06-08) → Premakumar, Graziano and coauthors (2026-05-14). The source describes adaptable response generation and a learning self-loop; the target allows both actual activations and their predictions to change.",
      "shared": "The source describes adaptable response generation and a learning self-loop; the target allows both actual activations and their predictions to change.",
      "relation": "qualitative co-adaptation causal prefix · weak-to-moderate partial",
      "residual": "The target lets both actual and predicted hidden activations vary under its joint loss. The source supplies only the stated adaptive component or qualitative coupled-role account, not the same shared-parameter optimization or measured complexity reduction.\n\nThe owner-reported 2012 header is separate from the 2022 wording record.\n\nSAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
      "lenses": {
        "L1": {
          "relation": "qualitative co-adaptation causal prefix",
          "favorable": "The source describes adaptable response generation and a learning self-loop; the target allows both actual activations and their predictions to change.",
          "residual": "The target lets both actual and predicted hidden activations vary under its joint loss. The source supplies only the stated adaptive component or qualitative coupled-role account, not the same shared-parameter optimization or measured complexity reduction."
        },
        "L2": {
          "source_roles": "The note joins learning from returned activity with tissue becoming prepared for later signals through experience.",
          "target_roles": "Here “the two” refers to the predicted activations and the actual hidden activations. Both depend on trainable model weights; the target activity is not held permanently fixed. This explanation is a paraphrase, not an alteration of the quotation.",
          "shared_role": "qualitative co-adaptation causal prefix",
          "scope_limit": "The owner-reported 2012 header is separate from the 2022 wording record.",
          "full_architecture_identity": false
        },
        "L3": {
          "backward_test": "To make both sides trainable, the target requires adaptable predicted and actual activations. Test each source for predictor adaptation and response-generation adaptation separately. A one-sided supported component remains partial and does not establish the two-sided conjunction.",
          "chronology": "Selected 2022 Git record precedes exact later target version; neither worldwide-first nor earlier public-release authentication is asserted.",
          "alternative_routes": "The target places its work in attention-schema, multi-task and self-supervised-learning literature. Shared background and independent development remain live possibilities. A bounded source correspondence is not a derivation or omission verdict.",
          "prior_control_boundary": "Earlier 2011–2022 AST stages and the newestOctober 2026 self-schemas paper remain on the wider programme grid; this selection does not erase or settle them."
        }
      },
      "formal": "Source-reviewed conceptual, role or causal-prefix partial; no complete operator identity, isomorphism or bisimulation is certified.",
      "citation_boundary": "not-evaluable",
      "program_history": "The separate coverage matrix names 14 target stages, including arXiv v2 and the October 2026 self-schemas paper. Unreviewed stage/signature cells remain unknown; no before-state absence or influence conclusion follows. Selected target operators persist in both later paper versions. This does not establish a complete before/after migration, dependence, access or influence.",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0632z ctpr.txt",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/5360f6414909a2474129b2140ee0dc3112c93b6b/a0632z%20ctpr.txt",
        "sha256": "C4538E29BCC1B8B3584334047A95CB1DE0E3B2C1A359F496643225C33939E120",
        "date": "2022-06-08",
        "date_type": "Historical Git record; original first public release not independently authenticated",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release. This note reports 2012-04-19 separately; that is not an authenticated first-publication date.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": "2012-04-19",
        "quotes": [
          "right so as you sense something, an electric pattern is traveling up the neo cortex, and the statistically novel parts leave a bigger impact, so your memory-prediction is the learn response to that sensory-electrical impact, it's the tissue attempting to be ready for that impact the next time it comes, that's how memory-prediction works on the small scale."
        ],
        "locators": [
          31
        ],
        "speech_act": "The2012header is owner-reported. The2022retrospective rendering comment at line3 is not backdated into2012. Hawkins is explicitly recommended and the Pinker quotation is separately attributed. The instrument/song description is an analogy, not proof that every neuron hears a literal sound or of the source's other numerical/physical claims."
      },
      "target": {
        "title": "Unexpected benefits of self-modelling in neural systems",
        "authors": [
          "Vickram Premakumar",
          "Michael Vaiana",
          "Florin Pop",
          "Judd Rosenblatt",
          "Diogo Schwerz de Lucena",
          "Kirsten Ziman",
          "Michael S. A. Graziano"
        ],
        "url": "https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2024.0531",
        "pdf_url": null,
        "sha256": "868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43",
        "date": "2026-05-14",
        "date_type": "Version-of-record publication date",
        "date_boundary": "Selected version only, not the first appearance of every claim. Source hash identifies numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes.",
        "quote": "During training, the two could both be varied to find the best critical points under the joint loss function.",
        "summary": "Here “the two” refers to the predicted activations and the actual hidden activations. Both depend on trainable model weights; the target activity is not held permanently fixed. This explanation is a paraphrase, not an alteration of the quotation.",
        "locators": {
          "locator": "Publisher PDF page 4, located lines 169–171",
          "quote_normalization": "Verbatim source-capture wording; line breaks collapsed to spaces."
        },
        "speech_act": "SAN is not asserted to supply this specific weighted classification-plus-regression loss. Same-pass activation prediction is distinct from prediction of a future biological firing.",
        "hash_kind": "numbered source-text capture; not PDF bytes"
      },
      "evidence_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/evidence.html#GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-5715974107759890106553",
      "deck_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/index.html?card=GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-5715974107759890106553",
      "data_href": "../michael-graziano/self-modelling/comparison-data.json",
      "source_pointer": "/rows/31",
      "source_file_sha256": "643324A6BD919E630751D859D3804DE2CBA8EFC65E65015CFDD78F38D6CC7321",
      "release_state": "source-release-check-passed"
    }
  ],
  "groups": [
    {
      "id": "passage-648B00F6E6DC98CC3291",
      "title": "Selection changes what the network can express",
      "source_work_id": "miller-spatial:source-url:https://web.archive.org/web/20210919213836/https://medium.com/silicon-valley-global-news/the-game-of-go-speculation-about-the-code-of-our-minds-in-our-brains-5a39d7cb6366",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Mind Code // Brain Code: Go (Ancient Game) and Alpha Go",
        "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20210919213836/https://medium.com/silicon-valley-global-news/the-game-of-go-speculation-about-the-code-of-our-minds-in-our-brains-5a39d7cb6366",
        "sha256": null,
        "date": "2021-09-19",
        "date_type": "Exact wording preserved by 19 September 2021",
        "date_boundary": "Article metadata says published 30 June 2017 and modified 14 August 2018. The captured text is not individually backdated to either metadata date.",
        "public_wording_by": "2021-09-19",
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "The inhibited parts of the brain should feature the unconscious material.",
          "the parts of you that are paying attention to something you are looking at become excited and that means they exhibit more activity"
        ],
        "locators": [
          "f236"
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "miller-spatial:MIL-PUB-MASK-2022",
        "miller-spatial:MIL-PUB-MASK-2023"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "miller-spatial:document:REVIEW",
        "miller-spatial:document:JOURNAL"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Miller"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-1C294299F5AAE5418FB7",
      "title": "Thoughts have a pattern of activity and inhibition",
      "source_work_id": "miller-spatial:source-url:https://web.archive.org/web/20210919213836/https://medium.com/silicon-valley-global-news/the-game-of-go-speculation-about-the-code-of-our-minds-in-our-brains-5a39d7cb6366",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Mind Code // Brain Code: Go (Ancient Game) and Alpha Go",
        "url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20210919213836/https://medium.com/silicon-valley-global-news/the-game-of-go-speculation-about-the-code-of-our-minds-in-our-brains-5a39d7cb6366",
        "sha256": null,
        "date": "2021-09-19",
        "date_type": "Exact wording preserved by 19 September 2021",
        "date_boundary": "Article metadata says published 30 June 2017 and modified 14 August 2018. The captured text is not individually backdated to either metadata date.",
        "public_wording_by": "2021-09-19",
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "So that the shape of our thoughts, in tempo-spatial patterns is represented not only by what is excited in our brains but also by what is inhibited in our brains."
        ],
        "locators": [
          "d2a1",
          "f236"
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "miller-spatial:MIL-PUB-SHAPE-2022",
        "miller-spatial:MIL-PUB-SHAPE-2023"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "miller-spatial:document:REVIEW",
        "miller-spatial:document:JOURNAL"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Miller"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-EEF56EA73B51A254A9B8",
      "title": "A self arises through communicating cells",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:93DBDD3104CD751CC72448B0C4DC44730FB54996BFD90E5BB0E1E544E55B9DAF",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Self-communication and learned neural paths",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/37da575ba33f85cef4239295be161066d8d39f4c/a0090z%20ctpr.txt",
        "sha256": "93DBDD3104CD751CC72448B0C4DC44730FB54996BFD90E5BB0E1E544E55B9DAF",
        "date": "2022-06-08",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "the point is that we are establishing a self communication mechanism, they listen to each other, and to any other available incoming signals"
        ],
        "locators": [
          2,
          5,
          19,
          23,
          25
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUNSC-MCH-A12",
        "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUNSC-CIMC-A12"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Bach"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-021AD52A222A9612CF2C",
      "title": "Keep information distinct while joining it together",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:6E88E2AC7571791EFCD03D4AB35FD7D724BFA0E388821BF51F2BD72610DD5BBF",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Keep information distinct while joining it together",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/37da575ba33f85cef4239295be161066d8d39f4c/a0142z%20ctpr.txt",
        "sha256": "6E88E2AC7571791EFCD03D4AB35FD7D724BFA0E388821BF51F2BD72610DD5BBF",
        "date": "2022-06-08",
        "date_type": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "date_boundary": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "the problem is that synchronization or coherence is non-informative, its a solution for binding, for convergence, coupling of patterns, but not for distinction making, decoherence, deconvergence, decoupling of of ideas & concepts"
        ],
        "locators": [
          9,
          11,
          19,
          24,
          34,
          36,
          38,
          40
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUN-MCH-A04",
        "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUN-CIMC-A04"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Bach"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-2D22791B1235FC1F3942",
      "title": "One unit receives what another unit produces",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:93DBDD3104CD751CC72448B0C4DC44730FB54996BFD90E5BB0E1E544E55B9DAF",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Self-communication and learned neural paths",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/37da575ba33f85cef4239295be161066d8d39f4c/a0090z%20ctpr.txt",
        "sha256": "93DBDD3104CD751CC72448B0C4DC44730FB54996BFD90E5BB0E1E544E55B9DAF",
        "date": "2022-06-08",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "critically what they are learning they are rendering materially because their connections reshape themselves to create paths that represent learned patterns as paths, synaptic communication paths between cells, a short term memory mechanism."
        ],
        "locators": [
          5,
          19,
          23,
          25,
          41
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUNSC-MCH-A15",
        "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUNSC-CIMC-A15"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Bach"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-BE821138C84E5F7AE230",
      "title": "Prediction guides what happens next",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:93DBDD3104CD751CC72448B0C4DC44730FB54996BFD90E5BB0E1E544E55B9DAF",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Self-communication and learned neural paths",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/37da575ba33f85cef4239295be161066d8d39f4c/a0090z%20ctpr.txt",
        "sha256": "93DBDD3104CD751CC72448B0C4DC44730FB54996BFD90E5BB0E1E544E55B9DAF",
        "date": "2022-06-08",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "Dendrites have to recognize this hertz in order for another part of the sequence to know what it means, and another part of the sequence to predict what comes next."
        ],
        "locators": [
          2,
          19,
          21,
          41
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUNSC-MCH-A13",
        "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUNSC-CIMC-A13"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Bach"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-E352849CB7F0C159E646",
      "title": "SAN: a learning loop receives its own activity",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:C4538E29BCC1B8B3584334047A95CB1DE0E3B2C1A359F496643225C33939E120",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0632z ctpr.txt",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/5360f6414909a2474129b2140ee0dc3112c93b6b/a0632z%20ctpr.txt",
        "sha256": "C4538E29BCC1B8B3584334047A95CB1DE0E3B2C1A359F496643225C33939E120",
        "date": "2022-06-08",
        "date_type": "Historical Git record; original first public release not independently authenticated",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release. This note reports 2012-04-19 separately; that is not an authenticated first-publication date.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": "2012-04-19",
        "quotes": [
          "Who listens to the song and understands the meaning? the song is a loop, the neurons that play it also listen to it"
        ],
        "locators": [
          49
        ],
        "speech_act": "The2012header is owner-reported. The2022retrospective rendering comment at line3 is not backdated into2012. Hawkins is explicitly recommended and the Pinker quotation is separately attributed. The instrument/song description is an analogy, not proof that every neuron hears a literal sound or of the source's other numerical/physical claims."
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-819E34C670A929D915DAF3",
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-97DD037CC2D876BC05C4B2"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Graziano"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-7B0F6012CB863CC0E802",
      "title": "SAN: a learning loop with adaptable responses",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:C4538E29BCC1B8B3584334047A95CB1DE0E3B2C1A359F496643225C33939E120",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0632z ctpr.txt",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/5360f6414909a2474129b2140ee0dc3112c93b6b/a0632z%20ctpr.txt",
        "sha256": "C4538E29BCC1B8B3584334047A95CB1DE0E3B2C1A359F496643225C33939E120",
        "date": "2022-06-08",
        "date_type": "Historical Git record; original first public release not independently authenticated",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release. This note reports 2012-04-19 separately; that is not an authenticated first-publication date.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": "2012-04-19",
        "quotes": [
          "right so as you sense something, an electric pattern is traveling up the neo cortex, and the statistically novel parts leave a bigger impact, so your memory-prediction is the learn response to that sensory-electrical impact, it's the tissue attempting to be ready for that impact the next time it comes, that's how memory-prediction works on the small scale."
        ],
        "locators": [
          31
        ],
        "speech_act": "The2012header is owner-reported. The2022retrospective rendering comment at line3 is not backdated into2012. Hawkins is explicitly recommended and the Pinker quotation is separately attributed. The instrument/song description is an analogy, not proof that every neuron hears a literal sound or of the source's other numerical/physical claims."
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-317030652681ED6980721B",
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-5715974107759890106553"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Graziano"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-23DB15524725B85231AF",
      "title": "SAN: a neural representation is read by another layer",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:C4538E29BCC1B8B3584334047A95CB1DE0E3B2C1A359F496643225C33939E120",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0632z ctpr.txt",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/5360f6414909a2474129b2140ee0dc3112c93b6b/a0632z%20ctpr.txt",
        "sha256": "C4538E29BCC1B8B3584334047A95CB1DE0E3B2C1A359F496643225C33939E120",
        "date": "2022-06-08",
        "date_type": "Historical Git record; original first public release not independently authenticated",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release. This note reports 2012-04-19 separately; that is not an authenticated first-publication date.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": "2012-04-19",
        "quotes": [
          "Comment on the note: What I think I was missing at this point in time (2012) was the part about how a memory-prediction was actually a rendering that a subsequent array or layer of nerve cells would read & interpret."
        ],
        "locators": [
          3
        ],
        "speech_act": "The2012header is owner-reported. The2022retrospective rendering comment at line3 is not backdated into2012. Hawkins is explicitly recommended and the Pinker quotation is separately attributed. The instrument/song description is an analogy, not proof that every neuron hears a literal sound or of the source's other numerical/physical claims."
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-2159ABF1CD53AA0526009A",
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-C9E2C8B4AAFC584D596DFD"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Graziano"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-7E85AA36802C889CD645",
      "title": "SAN: self-generated activity feeds a learning loop",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:C4538E29BCC1B8B3584334047A95CB1DE0E3B2C1A359F496643225C33939E120",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0632z ctpr.txt",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/5360f6414909a2474129b2140ee0dc3112c93b6b/a0632z%20ctpr.txt",
        "sha256": "C4538E29BCC1B8B3584334047A95CB1DE0E3B2C1A359F496643225C33939E120",
        "date": "2022-06-08",
        "date_type": "Historical Git record; original first public release not independently authenticated",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release. This note reports 2012-04-19 separately; that is not an authenticated first-publication date.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": "2012-04-19",
        "quotes": [
          "Being is a learning loop, like a feedback loop that learns"
        ],
        "locators": [
          44
        ],
        "speech_act": "The2012header is owner-reported. The2022retrospective rendering comment at line3 is not backdated into2012. Hawkins is explicitly recommended and the Pinker quotation is separately attributed. The instrument/song description is an analogy, not proof that every neuron hears a literal sound or of the source's other numerical/physical claims."
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-68D7605C981D48B35EA68D",
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-F864269540C721258D2910"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Graziano"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-31EDA9274920A7131A39",
      "title": "SAN’s 2022 record documents world-responsive predictive rendering, with a partial match to the selected 2025 review.",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:E97073DD551D3A78E10E8D85C7559947F20AA75D7E658081CE4DE37F2C3F944E",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN’s 2022 record documents world-responsive predictive rendering, with a partial match to the selected 2025 review.",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/f219cf478aeacbe903467a3ca274b00e2e2de085/a0079z.md#L19",
        "sha256": "E97073DD551D3A78E10E8D85C7559947F20AA75D7E658081CE4DE37F2C3F944E",
        "date": "2022-06-10",
        "date_type": "Git repository commit record",
        "date_boundary": "Current anonymous public access to the exact source body was verified on 2026-10-11. The displayed 2022 date is a Git record date, not independently verified first-publication timing.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "It's a self-aware network in 4 dimensions rendering a 4 dimensional pattern to itself that is reactive to the world and able to make prediction-based models of reality with sparse spatially & temporally distributed frequency/phase patterns that represent coicident neural firing or coincident neural inhibition deviating from the oscillatory norm of a given oscillator on some level as observed by the neurons in the oscillator, and by oscillators or circuits or cortical columns linked across the brain thanks to the activity of interneurons and major intersections of traffic such as the thalamic bridges, the corpus callosum, the tempo-parietal junction, Werneck & Broca's areas and other areas of the brain that are highly connected or connecting multiple regions of the brain together."
        ],
        "locators": {
          "line": 19,
          "other_passages": []
        }
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "seth-selected:S-PUB-PREDICTIVE-RENDERING",
        "seth-selected:S-PUB-ROSETTA"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:0C3C16675F4FCE48FBFBBE74FFCF7B8D9A1BBD2F5249978DA8CDE2E6B63B69BA",
        "sha256:D2B009D43C7838DBDED0F61E532A167E632DC18610B968709FF9919BC2580880"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Seth and coauthors"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-1EE166CBB8943AF4C5A0",
      "title": "SAN: a neural pattern represents its own activity",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:835009EAE0FA62D471E5368131806D08C22549AE7C590DDFBA70187FAFE221D8",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0339z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4245ac674ea89dbf2b832f14a256a4d30937f13a/a0339z.md",
        "sha256": "835009EAE0FA62D471E5368131806D08C22549AE7C590DDFBA70187FAFE221D8",
        "date": "2022-06-12",
        "date_type": "Historical Git record; original first public release not independently authenticated",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release. This note reports 2012-09-07 separately; that is not an authenticated first-publication date.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": "2012-09-07",
        "quotes": [
          "the observer is the thought pattern making a thought pattern of the thought pattern"
        ],
        "locators": [
          8
        ],
        "speech_act": "The2012header is owner-reported, not independently authenticated publication. The2022Git object fixes this wording. Metaphysical, meditation and machine-consciousness assertions elsewhere in the note are not adopted as findings. The Numenta reference remains visible."
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-D7E1433EC8FC2F035F0341",
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-2531A0FE58C3F12156E32F",
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-7DA4CA25A387A68325DDAF",
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-3C08158497F89FC0D377DB",
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R5-3AA152D7447C9192E882D6",
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-A69F711711EA6D3B1CBA26"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Graziano"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-ACFCB26C79A1CDC4CC19",
      "title": "SAN: the self-representation develops",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:835009EAE0FA62D471E5368131806D08C22549AE7C590DDFBA70187FAFE221D8",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0339z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4245ac674ea89dbf2b832f14a256a4d30937f13a/a0339z.md",
        "sha256": "835009EAE0FA62D471E5368131806D08C22549AE7C590DDFBA70187FAFE221D8",
        "date": "2022-06-12",
        "date_type": "Historical Git record; original first public release not independently authenticated",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release. This note reports 2012-09-07 separately; that is not an authenticated first-publication date.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": "2012-09-07",
        "quotes": [
          "We have a prediction of awareness, and it seems aware because this prediction is incorporating it's own development into an even higher level of awareness about itself."
        ],
        "locators": [
          10
        ],
        "speech_act": "The2012header is owner-reported, not independently authenticated publication. The2022Git object fixes this wording. Metaphysical, meditation and machine-consciousness assertions elsewhere in the note are not adopted as findings. The Numenta reference remains visible."
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-6E9082577AE83072A9BD38",
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-GENEALOGY-R4-7BE24D6314DF7C538019C4"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Graziano"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-70D087CDF66C2841BE24",
      "title": "SAN’s 2022 record proposes measured-pattern BCI reconstruction before the selected 2025 intervention agenda.",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:9560B7C53AA44B83D0D1AF409B0890754B40418B282AC13A24FFC3AF8D08E9DE",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN’s 2022 record proposes measured-pattern BCI reconstruction before the selected 2025 intervention agenda.",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/81210149c4fbf14575ee6c6b56c05daa34a92273/a0306z.md#L4",
        "sha256": "9560B7C53AA44B83D0D1AF409B0890754B40418B282AC13A24FFC3AF8D08E9DE",
        "date": "2022-06-12",
        "date_type": "Git repository commit record",
        "date_boundary": "Current anonymous public access to the exact source body was verified on 2026-10-11. The displayed 2022 date is a Git record date, not independently verified first-publication timing.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "The point of the Brocoli Properties example was to show that if we could intercept at the Thalamus how the properties of Brocoli are signals being passed to the neo cortex, then we could recreate the experience of Brocoli in the Thalamus by creating that set of temporal & spatially distributed phase changes."
        ],
        "locators": {
          "line": 4,
          "other_passages": [
            {
              "line": 16,
              "text": "So if we knew how the properties of brocoli were represented by scanning them at the Thalamus at the moment you were thinking about them, then we might identify which cortical column is managing those properties when you are not thinking about them, and even if you have a completely different personality that manages brocoli in a different region of the cortex, by stimulating the thalamus with the properties of brocoli that we learned from watching your thalamus we might trigger the experience of brocoli in your brain, we might have a next generation brain computer interface for bringing Augmented Reality & Virtual Reality experiences not through glasses but through direct brain stimulation, to recreate known patterns.",
              "label": "Same source: measured-pattern BCI continuation",
              "record_date": "2022-06-12",
              "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/81210149c4fbf14575ee6c6b56c05daa34a92273/a0306z.md#L16"
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "seth-selected:S-PUB-BCI",
        "seth-selected:S-PUB-CONTROL"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:0C3C16675F4FCE48FBFBBE74FFCF7B8D9A1BBD2F5249978DA8CDE2E6B63B69BA"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Seth and coauthors"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-6E739C144FF6999D8EC0",
      "title": "Check the brain’s own representations for disagreement",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:D6C617135E5838F0DF7B99FBEDFE3941F743A59FFFEE59A0F294C5EF7012F53A",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Check the brain’s own representations for disagreement",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/6ab9773f25d460c305d1d2de9a8ee5e0ca03ee4a/b0038y.md",
        "sha256": "D6C617135E5838F0DF7B99FBEDFE3941F743A59FFFEE59A0F294C5EF7012F53A",
        "date": "2022-07-06",
        "date_type": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "date_boundary": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "Is there a way for a natural brain to check its own results, to check for pattern representation accuracy. one way to do that would be to sort of do to take multiple samples like sort of like with with and cross reference them, it's like, okay well I'm gonna attack multiple times and if something is true then it's gonna be true."
        ],
        "locators": [
          5,
          7,
          9,
          31,
          136,
          140,
          151,
          155,
          159,
          163,
          167,
          171,
          175,
          179
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUL-MCH-A05",
        "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUL-CIMC-A05"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Bach"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-FE0AEFC9EE0EFEF388C7",
      "title": "Look inside an artificial mind, not only at its answers",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:D6C617135E5838F0DF7B99FBEDFE3941F743A59FFFEE59A0F294C5EF7012F53A",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Look inside an artificial mind, not only at its answers",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/6ab9773f25d460c305d1d2de9a8ee5e0ca03ee4a/b0038y.md",
        "sha256": "D6C617135E5838F0DF7B99FBEDFE3941F743A59FFFEE59A0F294C5EF7012F53A",
        "date": "2022-07-06",
        "date_type": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "date_boundary": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "We need a guidebook for when an artificial neural network becomes conscious."
        ],
        "locators": [
          23,
          29,
          31,
          114,
          136,
          140,
          159,
          195,
          199,
          203,
          207,
          211,
          223,
          253
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-MCH-A07",
        "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-CIMC-A07"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Bach"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-DA13A8659C13071165F6",
      "title": "Perception can include the act of perceiving",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:D6C617135E5838F0DF7B99FBEDFE3941F743A59FFFEE59A0F294C5EF7012F53A",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Perception can include the act of perceiving",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/6ab9773f25d460c305d1d2de9a8ee5e0ca03ee4a/b0038y.md",
        "sha256": "D6C617135E5838F0DF7B99FBEDFE3941F743A59FFFEE59A0F294C5EF7012F53A",
        "date": "2022-07-06",
        "date_type": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "date_boundary": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "the one process in the machine is always seeking to know, it's always seeking to know is perceiving perception."
        ],
        "locators": [
          31,
          136,
          140,
          159,
          175,
          179,
          187,
          191,
          195,
          199
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-MCH-A09",
        "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-CIMC-A09"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Bach"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-906D20718C015F724ABE",
      "title": "SAN’s 2022 geometry proposal connects learned neural patterns to experiential properties before the selected 2025 review.",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:F54159599C6799F6E798D3EDE95F7D3020C513EF826AD5BB7A6D771A485722DE",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN’s 2022 geometry proposal connects learned neural patterns to experiential properties before the selected 2025 review.",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/c1ab1deeed9531a3a35134fc6b6efe8ffeef1392/a0149z.md#L18",
        "sha256": "F54159599C6799F6E798D3EDE95F7D3020C513EF826AD5BB7A6D771A485722DE",
        "date": "2022-07-09",
        "date_type": "Git repository commit record",
        "date_boundary": "Current anonymous public access to the exact source body was verified on 2026-10-11. The displayed 2022 date is a Git record date, not independently verified first-publication timing.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "This means that neural oscillating array-projection tomography can physically represent patterns as (non-linear) phase variation sequences. Then oscillating cell assembles will learn the expressed spatial & temporal phase patterns happening within their cell assembly & derive from those learned patterns the shapes of concepts, the shapes & parameters & properties feelings, objects, sensations, and anything else you can become conscious of."
        ],
        "locators": {
          "line": 18,
          "other_passages": [
            {
              "line": 39,
              "text": "In my thought experiment I am taking the Taylor Series from Calculus and applying it to a 3D grid of phase changes. 3D Calculus. With each phase change that is tracked by the brain representing a different step in a Taylor series representing the information content of the rendered mind *at least the phase topology as a brain state is an attractor point, for the mind's oscillations. ",
              "label": "Same source: phase-topology attractor hypothesis",
              "record_date": "2022-07-09",
              "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/c1ab1deeed9531a3a35134fc6b6efe8ffeef1392/a0149z.md#L39"
            }
          ]
        }
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "seth-selected:S-PUB-QUALITY-SPACE",
        "seth-selected:S-PUB-ROSETTA-GEOMETRY"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:0C3C16675F4FCE48FBFBBE74FFCF7B8D9A1BBD2F5249978DA8CDE2E6B63B69BA",
        "sha256:D2B009D43C7838DBDED0F61E532A167E632DC18610B968709FF9919BC2580880"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Seth and coauthors"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-39CEEAD5343139662A07",
      "title": "SAN proposes learning and predicting the cell’s own responses",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:BAE95CC2D214077ABCE720EEA26177DADC1301FB3DC0946C93A3B85D1D4F88F9",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0007z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/86ca59559908f6cad3f9f3314f3d651c3e0c6ea1/a0007z.md",
        "sha256": "BAE95CC2D214077ABCE720EEA26177DADC1301FB3DC0946C93A3B85D1D4F88F9",
        "date": "2022-08-30",
        "date_type": "Historical Git author/commit record; original public availability is not independently certified.",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "My intuition is that the apical is learning it's responds, and through feedback loops, with itself and with other pyramidal neurons the cell is going to make predictions about it's own patterns of causation, what patterns it responds & how it reacts or responds. With the Apical Dendrite perhaps symbolizing a more complex response that is connected to more complex learning. (compared to other types of neurons)"
        ],
        "locators": [
          39
        ],
        "speech_act": "Tentative basal/apical/exit-terminal account. This is learning a response mapping, not an explicit classification-plus-regression objective."
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-F6DC84F405510C785476",
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-A32132257E5EDD8C9245",
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-OP-5F41654BAC7D61117420DD",
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-93556A53F13F0E727739",
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-OP-DD5297EF633E9E990473D5",
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-OP-B41DD2AEB8A3B0CA5D6542"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Graziano"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-A95BFA23D8A9633FA010",
      "title": "SAN proposes learning from the cell’s own activity",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:BAE95CC2D214077ABCE720EEA26177DADC1301FB3DC0946C93A3B85D1D4F88F9",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0007z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/86ca59559908f6cad3f9f3314f3d651c3e0c6ea1/a0007z.md",
        "sha256": "BAE95CC2D214077ABCE720EEA26177DADC1301FB3DC0946C93A3B85D1D4F88F9",
        "date": "2022-08-30",
        "date_type": "Historical Git author/commit record; original public availability is not independently certified.",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "An interesting thought about the cyclic nature of Layer 5 pyramidal cells, is the idea that the process of the dendrite being a sensor, like an eyeball or an ear appears to apply to both sides of the neuron, on the way in, and on the way out. So the Apical dendrite, as a neural network, is learning from incoming sensor stimulus, but the Soma burst is one of the incoming sensor stimulai, with models of soma burst waveforms becoming part of what the Apical Dendrite has to contend with."
        ],
        "locators": [
          35
        ],
        "speech_act": "Tentative basal/apical/exit-terminal account. This is learning a response mapping, not an explicit classification-plus-regression objective."
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-7CB5D4FA11FA0C429AE3",
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-04042FE8489D45E422D2"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Graziano"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-D55A1FE63EF767A869A8",
      "title": "Build an internal world, then register it again",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:66642AF5B4CC43F0CE252FAEF42970A6EEC57D0BAFE214A682E10E564D5CDC9E",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Build an internal world, then register it again",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/7129fcf82a9d42665a1372ecdc803e912bc81b6a/a0310zNAPOT5.md",
        "sha256": "66642AF5B4CC43F0CE252FAEF42970A6EEC57D0BAFE214A682E10E564D5CDC9E",
        "date": "2022-09-17",
        "date_type": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "date_boundary": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "The brain is effectively doing computational rendering & then reading it’s own output pattern, from neuronal outputs, as that pattern is looped or played back to the neural network of the brain which detects it, with neuronal inputs, and re-renders (outputs it again) with new sensor input data."
        ],
        "locators": [
          14,
          18,
          20,
          22,
          24,
          30,
          34,
          36,
          56,
          60,
          89,
          91,
          93,
          99
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022SEP-MCH-A06",
        "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022SEP-CIMC-A06"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Bach"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-2FC545FCC7A3DD08C715",
      "title": "SAN proposed selective reception in its 2022 record; the 2025 Seth-coauthored review asks how receiving neurons use a message.",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:824A074A17729942D83FEBA0E9BA3297EEC4F287F9C46FE956B890273FBC4B50",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN proposed selective reception in its 2022 record; the 2025 Seth-coauthored review asks how receiving neurons use a message.",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/894b4d4ea3f23d4d1d526e123b5744283ff9cd5d/a0007z.md#L3",
        "sha256": "824A074A17729942D83FEBA0E9BA3297EEC4F287F9C46FE956B890273FBC4B50",
        "date": "2022-09-18",
        "date_type": "Git repository commit record",
        "date_boundary": "Current anonymous public access to the exact source body was verified on 2026-10-11. The displayed 2022 date is a Git record date, not independently verified first-publication timing.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "Dendritic morphologies & synaptic connections represent learned memories. Memories activate when preferred patterns (the memory) are detected, this causes cells to create a selective transmission or a projection to other cells (neural arrays)."
        ],
        "locators": {
          "line": 3,
          "other_passages": []
        }
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "seth-selected:S-PUB-RECEIVER"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:0C3C16675F4FCE48FBFBBE74FFCF7B8D9A1BBD2F5249978DA8CDE2E6B63B69BA"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Seth and coauthors"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-B83B1C2A6D1193509C49",
      "title": "SAN proposes learning and predicting the cell’s own responses",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:824A074A17729942D83FEBA0E9BA3297EEC4F287F9C46FE956B890273FBC4B50",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0007z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/894b4d4ea3f23d4d1d526e123b5744283ff9cd5d/a0007z.md",
        "sha256": "824A074A17729942D83FEBA0E9BA3297EEC4F287F9C46FE956B890273FBC4B50",
        "date": "2022-09-18",
        "date_type": "Historical Git author/commit record; original public availability is not independently certified.",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "My intuition is that the apical is learning its own cell's response, and through feedback loops, with itself and with other pyramidal neurons the cell is going to make predictions about its own patterns of causation, what patterns it responds & how it reacts or responds. With the Apical Dendrite perhaps symbolizing a more complex response that is connected to more complex learning. (compared to other types of neurons)"
        ],
        "locators": [
          51
        ],
        "speech_act": "The source says \"My intuition\" and describes feedback-linked cell responses. Anatomical speculation is not stripped from the source context."
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-91B5B26D598E22D0B644",
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-5928D99804B56C410D88",
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-OP-02AE465E84391429B764CC",
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-DOCWIN-B2FBA73841C57C47DD06",
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-OP-F42E07906D82A1736B8DA4",
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-OP-F2E78CCABF9F5111CF12AF"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Graziano"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-652B718D9B12CE563750",
      "title": "SAN proposes learning from the cell’s own activity",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:824A074A17729942D83FEBA0E9BA3297EEC4F287F9C46FE956B890273FBC4B50",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN source note a0007z.md",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/894b4d4ea3f23d4d1d526e123b5744283ff9cd5d/a0007z.md",
        "sha256": "824A074A17729942D83FEBA0E9BA3297EEC4F287F9C46FE956B890273FBC4B50",
        "date": "2022-09-18",
        "date_type": "Historical Git author/commit record; original public availability is not independently certified.",
        "date_boundary": "2022 dates are historical Git records whose exact wording matches current public bytes. Earlier 2012 headers remain reported dates, not authenticated first public release.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "reported_note_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "An interesting thought about the cyclic nature of Layer 5 pyramidal cells, is the idea that the process of the dendrite being a sensor, like an eyeball or an ear appears to apply to both sides of the neuron, on the way in, and on the way out. So the Apical dendrite, as a neural network, is learning from incoming sensory stimulus, but the Soma burst is one of the incoming sensory stimuli, with models of soma burst waveforms becoming part of what the Apical Dendrite has to contend with."
        ],
        "locators": [
          47
        ],
        "speech_act": "The source says \"My intuition\" and describes feedback-linked cell responses. Anatomical speculation is not stripped from the source context."
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-SOURCE-EDITION-EC8331FB96F4AB07565AF8",
        "graziano-self-modelling:GRAZIANO-SOURCE-EDITION-942C01660790DE34D4A711"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:B66283213B3D1E960FE73EF95CAD2AB718A58F915912A558D94D5D2826051067",
        "sha256:868442FA76856C32181E1E360D52E783FF341349670D1F1061BB210354749B43"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Graziano"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-2447999B36FEFCC4AA65",
      "title": "A current experience is a maintained pattern",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Computational Phenomenological Consciousness",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0319z.md",
        "sha256": "FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "the rendering in the mind is a persistent pattern that is detected by the mind the same way a rock in the world is a persistent pattern that is detectable by a computer with a neural network with a semantic segmentation program"
        ],
        "locators": [
          15,
          25,
          35,
          37,
          69,
          75,
          77,
          87,
          89,
          95
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-MCH-A14",
        "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-CIMC-A14"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Bach"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-8DA5EC3F35F784C69F8A",
      "title": "An artificial mind develops; it is not just a snapshot",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:D73632B6DF40CD48127C28B76B8B7965E22E4271BEA54F906E606F97D4E944C8",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "An artificial mind develops; it is not just a snapshot",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0320z.md",
        "sha256": "D73632B6DF40CD48127C28B76B8B7965E22E4271BEA54F906E606F97D4E944C8",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "date_boundary": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "It's a concept that means we, as robots, can have computed short term state experiences, with synaptic phase changes, and long term stage changes, with (real or simulated) synaptic growth or decay which takes longer to happen."
        ],
        "locators": [
          3,
          5,
          7,
          9,
          11,
          13,
          15,
          17,
          19
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-MCH-A08"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Bach"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-9703F49EDC8DFFE970D1",
      "title": "An artificial mind develops; it is not just a snapshot",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:D73632B6DF40CD48127C28B76B8B7965E22E4271BEA54F906E606F97D4E944C8",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "An artificial mind develops; it is not just a snapshot",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0320z.md",
        "sha256": "D73632B6DF40CD48127C28B76B8B7965E22E4271BEA54F906E606F97D4E944C8",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "date_boundary": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "Imagine that Synaptic Connections via Growth LTP & Decay LTD, over a long term, results in eventual threshold changes that we can identify as Stages, or major changes in live perspective that only happen after a very long time, or only happen after a very big life event."
        ],
        "locators": [
          3,
          5,
          7,
          9,
          11,
          13,
          15,
          17,
          19
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-CIMC-A08"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Bach"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-0E29192A2E5FEE5BC6D6",
      "title": "Choose the detail a simulation needs to preserve",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:D73632B6DF40CD48127C28B76B8B7965E22E4271BEA54F906E606F97D4E944C8",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Choose the detail a simulation needs to preserve",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0320z.md",
        "sha256": "D73632B6DF40CD48127C28B76B8B7965E22E4271BEA54F906E606F97D4E944C8",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "date_boundary": "Locally verified Git author and committer timestamps of byte-matching blob; not independently timestamped first-public availability",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "The essential physics process could be simulated in just matrix calculations on a TPU, with each dendrite, each neuron, each synapse, and each cortical column being unique or random in it's original configuration"
        ],
        "locators": [
          3,
          7,
          9,
          13,
          15,
          17,
          19,
          21
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-MCH-A10",
        "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-CIMC-A10"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Bach"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-8D523E2C6BD7E6D63465",
      "title": "Experience is a constructed information pattern",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Computational Phenomenological Consciousness",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0319z.md",
        "sha256": "FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "A rendering is a substantial pattern that is the output of some computable process."
        ],
        "locators": [
          93,
          95,
          97,
          100,
          102,
          108
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-MCH-A11",
        "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-CIMC-A11"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Bach"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-213BA6A4BC764F850CB6",
      "title": "Imagined futures organize action",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Computational Phenomenological Consciousness",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0319z.md",
        "sha256": "FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "Our decisions that arise from mental imagery, from our predictions of consequences, our predictions of possible futures, result in sparse distributed muscle coordination actions sequences"
        ],
        "locators": [
          29,
          39,
          65,
          71,
          73
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-MCH-A13",
        "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-CIMC-A13"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Bach"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-9B5372898C3426C4FDA4",
      "title": "Rendering is distributed across the network",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Computational Phenomenological Consciousness",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0319z.md",
        "sha256": "FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "Metaphorically you can imagine that there is no central canvas, no computer screen where all the renderings show up, because the rendered outputs are distributed all over the place, and absorbed by the brain for the next iteration of the rendering."
        ],
        "locators": [
          21,
          23,
          25,
          27,
          33,
          35,
          100,
          102
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-MCH-A15",
        "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-CIMC-A15"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Bach"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-4625CD8B95472AF9388D",
      "title": "SAN’s 2022 artificial-neurology record shares recurrent computation with the selected 2024 reservoir study.",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:D73632B6DF40CD48127C28B76B8B7965E22E4271BEA54F906E606F97D4E944C8",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "SAN’s 2022 artificial-neurology record shares recurrent computation with the selected 2024 reservoir study.",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0320z.md#L19",
        "sha256": "D73632B6DF40CD48127C28B76B8B7965E22E4271BEA54F906E606F97D4E944C8",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "Git repository commit record",
        "date_boundary": "Current anonymous public access to the exact source body was verified on 2026-10-11. The displayed 2022 date is a Git record date, not independently verified first-publication timing.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "The essential physics process could be simulated in just matrix calculations on a TPU, with each dendrite, each neuron, each synapse, and each cortical column being unique or random in it's original configuration, and in a sense what is needed is a space for an array for the outputs to be rendered in human scale time, so that they can be perceived by a sequence of other arrays, also in human scale spacetime, in a loop of array signalling that lasts for a duration comperable to human experience."
        ],
        "locators": {
          "line": 19,
          "other_passages": []
        }
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "seth-selected:S-PUB-RECURRENT-COMPUTING"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:CEBE6F9B6798C5E122802FA216E96A7AC1577BE64B31851378A97A52F1F7E1ED"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Seth and coauthors"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-E580A4401673FC52723F",
      "title": "The proposed organization can inform artificial minds",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Computational Phenomenological Consciousness",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0319z.md",
        "sha256": "FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "Beyond the electro-chemical dynamics, oscillatory physics is what binds our minds together, and the simulation of oscillatory physics is what can bind artificial minds together."
        ],
        "locators": [
          73,
          83,
          85,
          87,
          95,
          102,
          108
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-MCH-A16",
        "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-CIMC-A16"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Bach"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-8FD2FED8A41DC59750DC",
      "title": "The self is represented inside its own loop",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Computational Phenomenological Consciousness",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/4e0cf1ee0975c01dc57182368497d3f0cd864030/a0319z.md",
        "sha256": "FD658E976304F5DDEF12326F0D434D1E042F4B2A6464920A9BA8E8E3B1ECDAF0",
        "date": "2022-11-28",
        "date_type": "git-recorded historical fixation",
        "date_boundary": "The exact wording is in a public immutable commit with the stated Git dates. First-public-push date has not been independently archived in this review.",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": null,
        "quotes": [
          "conciousness is context referencing context, self referencing self, where self is a rendered pattern that is a distinct information/energy configuration, that oscillates inside a feedback loop that is made up of brain state elements that alternately render & detect renderings,"
        ],
        "locators": [
          11,
          21,
          25,
          27,
          65,
          91,
          102,
          108
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-MCH-A12",
        "bach-initial:BACH-DOCWIN-2022NOVCP-CIMC-A12"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Bach"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-9D867D97BDDD91B25558",
      "title": "Building objects inside a spatial representation",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Neural Lace monologue · Building objects inside a spatial representation",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/214c640ba35e81350eaef71635a255f00d18ad75/nlp1.md",
        "sha256": "A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
        "date": "2025-06-21",
        "date_type": "Git wording record; first public release not independently dated",
        "date_boundary": "Source labels OpenAI Whisper transcription; audio accuracy not independently checked here",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": "April 2017 (attributed; original audio/upload not verified)",
        "quotes": [
          "And we're going to call this the concept of a car.",
          "And not only do we have this concept of a car, which is all these lines, but we can also predict which way the car is moving."
        ],
        "locators": [
          [
            61,
            81
          ],
          [
            151,
            189
          ]
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "bach-neural-lace:BACH-DOCWIN-2017-MCH-A03"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Bach"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-0A04381C2FE72327FD2B",
      "title": "Combining partial information into an experienced world",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Neural Lace monologue · Combining partial information into an experienced world",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/214c640ba35e81350eaef71635a255f00d18ad75/nlp1.md",
        "sha256": "A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
        "date": "2025-06-21",
        "date_type": "Git wording record; first public release not independently dated",
        "date_boundary": "Source labels OpenAI Whisper transcription; audio accuracy not independently checked here",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": "April 2017 (attributed; original audio/upload not verified)",
        "quotes": [
          "These are all, um, supporting concepts that are taking a little bit of information coming from your senses and bolstering that into your complete experience."
        ],
        "locators": [
          [
            103,
            131
          ],
          [
            151,
            189
          ]
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "bach-neural-lace:BACH-DOCWIN-2017-CIMC-A03"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Bach"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-47F1940534AF8F975047",
      "title": "Experienced content need not reproduce the outside scene",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Neural Lace monologue · Experienced content need not reproduce the outside scene",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/214c640ba35e81350eaef71635a255f00d18ad75/nlp1.md",
        "sha256": "A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
        "date": "2025-06-21",
        "date_type": "Git wording record; first public release not independently dated",
        "date_boundary": "Source labels OpenAI Whisper transcription; audio accuracy not independently checked here",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": "April 2017 (attributed; original audio/upload not verified)",
        "quotes": [
          "And then you send the difference between those two patterns so that the pattern that received just allows you to have steak into your reality where there was none before.",
          "So once we can do that, that means that you're going to have things in your reality that are not actually there"
        ],
        "locators": [
          [
            497,
            519
          ]
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "bach-neural-lace:BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-MCH-A14"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Bach"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-07AB827DEC5D5348F7C4",
      "title": "Feedback and confirmation in distributed communication",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Neural Lace monologue · Feedback and confirmation in distributed communication",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/214c640ba35e81350eaef71635a255f00d18ad75/nlp1.md",
        "sha256": "A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
        "date": "2025-06-21",
        "date_type": "Git wording record; first public release not independently dated",
        "date_boundary": "Source labels OpenAI Whisper transcription; audio accuracy not independently checked here",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": "April 2017 (attributed; original audio/upload not verified)",
        "quotes": [
          "because the connection means there's, there's actually a feedback loop of information.",
          "you're able to send a whole and complete message and you're able to verify that it was sent"
        ],
        "locators": [
          [
            277,
            305
          ],
          [
            335,
            379
          ],
          [
            491,
            507
          ]
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "bach-neural-lace:BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-CIMC-A15"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Bach"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-E9C6DDFC5573F3250A57",
      "title": "From understanding biological operations to artificial implementations",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Neural Lace monologue · From understanding biological operations to artificial implementations",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/214c640ba35e81350eaef71635a255f00d18ad75/nlp1.md",
        "sha256": "A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
        "date": "2025-06-21",
        "date_type": "Git wording record; first public release not independently dated",
        "date_boundary": "Source labels OpenAI Whisper transcription; audio accuracy not independently checked here",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": "April 2017 (attributed; original audio/upload not verified)",
        "quotes": [
          "But after we build neural lace, the idea is to, um, uh, build artificial neocortex and then artificial brains."
        ],
        "locators": [
          [
            61,
            81
          ],
          [
            491,
            527
          ]
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "bach-neural-lace:BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-MCH-A16"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Bach"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-0B193AFFEA6224D652F7",
      "title": "Related functions across biological and artificial systems",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Neural Lace monologue · Related functions across biological and artificial systems",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/214c640ba35e81350eaef71635a255f00d18ad75/nlp1.md",
        "sha256": "A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
        "date": "2025-06-21",
        "date_type": "Git wording record; first public release not independently dated",
        "date_boundary": "Source labels OpenAI Whisper transcription; audio accuracy not independently checked here",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": "April 2017 (attributed; original audio/upload not verified)",
        "quotes": [
          "And the self-driving car is doing the same thing.",
          "It's predicting there is a concept, which is a unification of a bunch of lines and edges and spatial computing and cars doing it and humans are doing it."
        ],
        "locators": [
          [
            61,
            81
          ],
          [
            491,
            527
          ]
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "bach-neural-lace:BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-CIMC-A16"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Bach"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-BC830DE62BEC176601DB",
      "title": "Representations participate in changing mental states",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Neural Lace monologue · Representations participate in changing mental states",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/214c640ba35e81350eaef71635a255f00d18ad75/nlp1.md",
        "sha256": "A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
        "date": "2025-06-21",
        "date_type": "Git wording record; first public release not independently dated",
        "date_boundary": "Source labels OpenAI Whisper transcription; audio accuracy not independently checked here",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": "April 2017 (attributed; original audio/upload not verified)",
        "quotes": [
          "But what you would do then is figure out the difference between the pattern that's there and the pattern that should be there if steak was there.",
          "And then you send the difference between those two patterns so that the pattern that received just allows you to have steak into your reality where there was none before."
        ],
        "locators": [
          [
            491,
            519
          ]
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "bach-neural-lace:BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-MCH-A13",
        "bach-neural-lace:BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-CIMC-A13",
        "bach-neural-lace:BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-MCH-A15"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:79308E09995AA00A6EFF0EE9DF0718BE101C8083286A34F5A5453016C956A46B",
        "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Bach"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "passage-77883A03590C93103733",
      "title": "The experienced world is an internally maintained representation",
      "source_work_id": "sha256:A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
      "source": {
        "name": "Micah Blumberg / SAN",
        "title": "Neural Lace monologue · The experienced world is an internally maintained representation",
        "url": "https://github.com/v5ma/selfawarenetworks/blob/214c640ba35e81350eaef71635a255f00d18ad75/nlp1.md",
        "sha256": "A1138D2B2324987EB96E1595D622165E13EE6B2CD9E978B32B1A753ABDE783BB",
        "date": "2025-06-21",
        "date_type": "Git wording record; first public release not independently dated",
        "date_boundary": "Source labels OpenAI Whisper transcription; audio accuracy not independently checked here",
        "public_wording_by": null,
        "attributed_recording_date": "April 2017 (attributed; original audio/upload not verified)",
        "quotes": [
          "These are all, um, supporting concepts that are taking a little bit of information coming from your senses and bolstering that into your complete experience.",
          "And then you send the difference between those two patterns so that the pattern that received just allows you to have steak into your reality where there was none before."
        ],
        "locators": [
          [
            103,
            131
          ],
          [
            497,
            519
          ]
        ]
      },
      "record_ids": [
        "bach-neural-lace:BACH-DOCWIN-2017D-CIMC-A14"
      ],
      "target_work_ids": [
        "sha256:B472B40F89780EAB1BDA83C1935B58849D6F0C52D6078BB5319BE86B60F8CA9D"
      ],
      "programs": [
        "Bach"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "source_check_revision": {
    "edition_checks_pass": 6,
    "selected_records": 86,
    "miller_check": "PASS-SOURCE-RELEASE-SCOPED-V2",
    "graziano_check": "SOURCE-CERTIFIED-32-ROW-BOUNDED-EDITION",
    "legacy_global_status": "FAIL-PRESERVED_WITH_SCOPED_DEPENDENCY_REVIEWS",
    "full_map_certification": false,
    "public_upload_authorized": false
  },
  "integration_boundary": {
    "parent_selected_projection_records": 54,
    "appended_source_qualified_records": 32,
    "parent_rows_unchanged": true,
    "new_scientific_findings": 0,
    "new_global_wins": 0,
    "shared_source_document_is_not_shared_whole_theory": true,
    "author_labels_are_exact_listed_names_not_necessarily_distinct_people": true
  },
  "presentation_routes": {
    "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUN-MCH-A04": "../joscha-bach/paired-passages/index.html?card=BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUN-MCH-A04",
    "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUN-CIMC-A04": "../joscha-bach/paired-passages/index.html?card=BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUN-CIMC-A04",
    "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUL-MCH-A05": "../joscha-bach/paired-passages/index.html?card=BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUL-MCH-A05",
    "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUL-CIMC-A05": "../joscha-bach/paired-passages/index.html?card=BACH-DOCWIN-2022JUL-CIMC-A05",
    "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022SEP-MCH-A06": "../joscha-bach/paired-passages/index.html?card=BACH-DOCWIN-2022SEP-MCH-A06",
    "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022SEP-CIMC-A06": "../joscha-bach/paired-passages/index.html?card=BACH-DOCWIN-2022SEP-CIMC-A06",
    "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-MCH-A07": "../joscha-bach/paired-passages/index.html?card=BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-MCH-A07",
    "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-CIMC-A07": "../joscha-bach/paired-passages/index.html?card=BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-CIMC-A07",
    "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-MCH-A08": "../joscha-bach/paired-passages/index.html?card=BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-MCH-A08",
    "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-CIMC-A08": "../joscha-bach/paired-passages/index.html?card=BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-CIMC-A08",
    "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-MCH-A09": "../joscha-bach/paired-passages/index.html?card=BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-MCH-A09",
    "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-CIMC-A09": "../joscha-bach/paired-passages/index.html?card=BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-CIMC-A09",
    "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-MCH-A10": "../joscha-bach/paired-passages/index.html?card=BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-MCH-A10",
    "bach-extension:BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-CIMC-A10": "../joscha-bach/paired-passages/index.html?card=BACH-DOCWIN-2022AN-CIMC-A10"
  },
  "presentation_boundary": "Fourteen existing Bach records also have a paired-passage view. Four gain additional complete target-sentence displays; ten retain reviewed summaries. Extra presentation passages do not add comparison records, source editions, author edges or canonical excerpt groups.",
  "integration_revision": "R6_BACH_PAIRED_PASSAGE_NAVIGATION"
}
