Self Aware NetworksComparison Encyclopedia
SAN compared with Joscha Bach and coauthors · review controls
Full source dossier

Blumberg’s earlier source record → two later Joscha Bach/coauthor versions: ten partial comparison links across five examined framings. Dates distinguish the attributed 2017 recording from the 2025 Git wording record; historical first public release remains unverified.

Building objects inside a spatial representation

Blumberg's earlier source record already joins spatial features, object categories and predicted movement; Bach and Sorensen's later text also builds and tracks objects within a represented world.

Micah Blumberg / SAN

2025-06-21 · Git wording record

Git wording record; first public release not independently dated.

April 2017 (attributed; original audio/upload not verified)

And we're going to call this the concept of a car.

And not only do we have this concept of a car, which is all these lines, but we can also predict which way the car is moving.

Exact transcript and surrounding passage

Joscha Bach and coauthors

2026-01-15 · selected version

Selected PDF version date, not initial article date.

The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis · PDF page 20

Consciousness sorts things and animals into different kinds, identifies and tracks individuals, and gives each their names.

Read the target passage in context

Same operation after translation?

Both descriptions organize perceptual features into represented objects and use more than a bare label: the SAN passage predicts movement; the later passage identifies and tracks individuals in an internally constructed space.

Grade: partial.

See the difference that remains

The SAN passage does not here present MCH's second-order-perception genesis mechanism. MCH does not here give SAN's joint external-scene/neural-measurement BCI procedure. Shared categorization alone is historically broad.

See the dated formulation ladder

April 2017: attributed recording date, still needing audio/platform verification.

June 21, 2025: exact source wording fixed in the reviewed Git record.

2026-01-15: the selected later target version.

Other early and mature SAN formulations remain in the wider genealogy; this card does not claim to exhaust that history.

Check all three lenses, dates, authors and source boundaries