Self Aware NetworksComparison Encyclopedia
SAN’s earlier record: fourteen supported partial matches

SAN’s 2022 source records precede the mapped operations in two later Joscha Bach papers. This edition makes each supported partial match visible, alongside its exact limits.

These are source-record-dated comparisons, not fourteen separate inventions, target repetitions or experimental confirmations. This is an additional edition, not completion of the whole Bach comparison.

Expert evidence dossier · Structured comparison data

Micah Blumberg / SAN vs Joscha Bach and coauthors · MCH · 1 / 14

Keep information distinct while joining it together

Micah's June 2022 Git-recorded note separates binding from the distinctions needed for information. Bach and Sorensen's reviewed MCH version likewise coordinates differentiated models and builds represented structure through contrast; the shared function does not equate physical synchrony with model consistency.

Micah / SAN · 2022-06-08
Git-recorded wording
Joscha Bach and coauthors · 2026-01-15
MCH · selected version

Micah Blumberg / SAN

2022-06-08 · Git source record

the problem is that synchronization or coherence is non-informative, its a solution for binding, for convergence, coupling of patterns, but not for distinction making, decoherence, deconvergence, decoupling of of ideas & concepts

Exact excerpt; original wording retained.

Joining signals is not enough: their differences must remain readable. SAN describes a receiving oscillator detecting changes against its own ongoing pattern.

Read the dated source and context

Joscha Bach and coauthors

2026-01-15 · MCH version

The later paper coordinates different models and uses contrast to build represented structure. This shares the need for both coordination and differences.

Plain-language paraphrase, not a quotation.

Read The Machine Consciousness Hypothesis · pages 17, 18, 20

Exact locators and short quotation anchors

What matches, what differs, and how it was checked

Shared operation: Keep distinguishable patterns available within coordinated activity; compare or select contributions rather than erase all differences through undifferentiated binding.

Difference kept visible: No June definition of semantic constraint violation or MCH implementation of this oscillator mechanism; no identity between physical coherence and representational consistency. Neither document proves the neuroscience.

The 2022 dates are verified Git source-record dates. Current public access to the exact bytes was checked; first public availability on those dates is not independently established.

All three comparison lenses and the separate longitudinal lens →