COMPARISON ENCYCLOPEDIA · SELECTED COMPARISONS
Earlier SAN records and the Entangled Loop
Micah Blumberg’s selected records support 23 graded comparisons with four editions of the Entangled Loop: 17 partial correspondences and 6 weak alignments. They involve nine SAN formulation routes in six documents and eighteen target passage locations. Repeated versions are preserved; these counts do not mean twenty-three independent inventions.
Git-recorded dates are not independently verified historical public-release dates. Two comparisons use Paper104, dated August 2026, against the October journal edition. The June/July preprints precede Paper104; no priority over those earlier versions is claimed. The comparison effort deliberately searches for supported SAN correspondences, then checks their source boundaries and alternatives.
Open the flashcards · Coverage and unresolved work
18 Target passage locations
138 author-navigation edges
Byline associations, not extra findings or claims of individual contribution.
Coverage and open questions
The full discovery inventory remains 4,824 coordinates: 67 source routes × 4 target versions × 18 target topics. The 23 reviewed coordinates coexist with 1,198 open cells and 3,603 cells needing version-specific presence review: 4,801 unresolved in total. A topic request is not evidence that a target contains it.
Longitudinal Signature-Migration Lens: UNKNOWN; quantitative-not-calibrated. Nine selected source formulations across five known target stages yield 45 cells: 23 source-reviewed, 13 unreviewed and nine version-1 source-gated cells. No acquisition, persistence or influence result is inferred.
Citation absence is not evaluated. These comparisons establish neither access nor influence. Earlier source histories, prior-body tests and other findings remain open; no motives are assigned by design.
SAN’s earlier network return-loop and the later retained recursive architecture
SAN describes the network receiving the patterns it produces and continuing the cycle. The later paper retains a recursive self-evidencing loop, but adds a different specified architecture and does not validate SAN’s full mechanism.
Grade: weak-structural-component. Micah Blumberg's Git-recorded 2022-06-11 wording has a weak-structural-component relation to this exact 2026-10-27 Entangled Loop version. This is recorded-date correspondence, not independently established historical public availability, worldwide firstness or influence.
Micah Blumberg / SAN — 2022-06-11
Git-recorded wording fixation; 2017 date is internal note metadata, not verified public release · Separate owner-date label: 2017-07-13 (internal note header; not verified publication)
the information patterns are network features, so information patterns are pushed out by the network and then felt by the network, fired, inhibited during collection, and fired anew
SAN source · line 37
Kringelbach and coauthors — 2026-10-27
ENTANGLED-JOURNAL-ONLINE-20261027 · page 9
The Beautiful Loop captures the recursive self-evidencing structure by which epistemic states are sustained within active inference, whereas the Entangled Loop asks what gives such a loop biological direction, content and priority.
Target publicationL1
The source describes a network producing information patterns, receiving them and firing anew. The target retains a recursively self-evidencing architecture. A weak recurrent production/reception/update role is shared.
L2
Produced pattern or evidence -> renewed network processing -> continuing epistemic/content state is a schematic common loop. Target active inference and SAN electrophysiological rendering are not established as the same operation.
L3
Selected Git wording predates the October27,2026 journal edition; historical public release at the Git date remains unproved. A2017 note header is not substituted for the2022 wording date. Exact named-prior bodies and earliest-version history remain open; no access, influence or field-wide firstness claim.
Limits
- The target expressly attributes its recursive self-evidencing starting point to BeautifulLoop2025. The quoted sentence does not demonstrate SAN’s proposed electromagnetic transmission, inhibitory sequence, biological self-reading or an identical generative inference operator. Generic feedback firstness is unresolved.
- Retain BeautifulLoop2025 attribution visibly.
- No experimentally established self-reading, EM transmission or variational-inference identity.
- No generic feedback firstness, influence or whole-program priority conclusion.
source theoretical network proposal to target theoretical synthesis retaining a cited antecedent
Target authors: Morten L. Kringelbach · Fernando E. Rosas · Ruben Laukkonen · Shamil Chandaria · Yonatan Sanz Perl · Gustavo Deco
Open this flashcard · All comparisons
Earlier SAN cross-region pattern passing and later global content availability
SAN describes patterns assembled and passed across cooperating brain regions. The later paper likewise requires selected content to become available beyond its local region.
Grade: bounded-functional-role-partial. Micah Blumberg's Git-recorded 2022-09-17 wording has a bounded-functional-role-partial relation to this exact 2026-10-27 Entangled Loop version. This is recorded-date correspondence, not independently established historical public availability, worldwide firstness or influence.
Micah Blumberg / SAN — 2022-09-17
Git author/commit fixation; historical public visibility not independently proved
phase wave differential, phasic bursts, and sharp wave ripple patterns are assembled & passed across brain regions that are in sync with one another
SAN source · line 317
Kringelbach and coauthors — 2026-10-27
ENTANGLED-JOURNAL-ONLINE-20261027 · page 5
Distributed information must also be coordinated so that selected content can influence the rest of the system.
Target publicationL1
Both assign coordinated distributed neural activity a role in making selected information consequential beyond its local origin. Source pattern passing across synchronized regions and target global availability share that function.
L2
Selected neural pattern -> inter-regional coordination/distribution -> broader system influence is a partial causal-role chain. The target’s particular workspace hubs, ignition threshold and directed-transfer-entropy identification are additional operations.
L3
Selected Git wording predates the October27,2026 journal edition; historical public release at the Git date remains unproved. A2017 note header is not substituted for the2022 wording date. Exact named-prior bodies and earliest-version history remain open; no access, influence or field-wide firstness claim.
Limits
- The target names Baars1988, Dehaene etal.1998 and later GNW work. This is a later-document correspondence, not first invention of broadcast or proof that the target uses SAN’s tonic/phasic mechanism. Synchronization and workspace orchestration are not interchangeable measured quantities.
- Retain Baars/Dehaene/GNW attribution.
- Do not equate frequency matching, phase synchronization, ignition or directed transfer entropy as measured variables.
- Keep biological/phenomenological validation and firstness unproved.
source pattern-passing proposal to target coordination/global-access architecture
Target authors: Morten L. Kringelbach · Fernando E. Rosas · Ruben Laukkonen · Shamil Chandaria · Yonatan Sanz Perl · Gustavo Deco
Open this flashcard · All comparisons
Earlier interacting-oscillator pattern formation and later phase-dependent combination
SAN proposes patterns emerging through interactions among oscillators. The later paper specifies phase-dependent reinforcement and cancellation. The common interaction role is narrower than equivalence of their physics or mathematics.
Grade: bounded-proposed-process-partial. Micah Blumberg's Git-recorded 2022-06-11 wording has a bounded-proposed-process-partial relation to this exact 2026-10-27 Entangled Loop version. This is recorded-date correspondence, not independently established historical public availability, worldwide firstness or influence.
Micah Blumberg / SAN — 2022-06-11
Git-recorded fixation; historical public release not independently dated
So the 7 version of you is the orthogonal or non-linear patterns emerging from oscillations between oscillators of different scales which exert forces on each other that blend across frequency/amplitude scales. It's transmission & memory would consist of novel pattern configurations that are driven by the interplay between the other primary sensor freq / amp scales.
SAN source · line 65
Kringelbach and coauthors — 2026-10-27
ENTANGLED-JOURNAL-ONLINE-20261027 · page 4
When coupled oscillations meet, their activity can reinforce or cancel other activity according to their relative phase.
Target publicationL1
The source proposes patterns emerging from interactions among oscillators across scales. The target proposes relative-phase-dependent reinforcement/cancellation. A bounded interaction-dependent pattern-formation role is shared.
L2
Interacting oscillatory activity -> relationally determined combined pattern is the common proposed fragment. Target constructive/destructive phase combination and nonclassical probability are more specific than the selected SAN passage.
L3
Selected Git wording predates the October27,2026 journal edition; historical public release at the Git date remains unproved. A2017 note header is not substituted for the2022 wording date. Exact named-prior bodies and earliest-version history remain open; no access, influence or field-wide firstness claim.
Limits
- No equality of phase equations, Hilbert-space probability, spectral-gap mechanism or cost advantage is proved. The source also contains speculative quantum/cosmological assertions; those are not imported as established physics. The target explicitly uses classical oscillators and distinguishes its proposal from microscopic quantum consciousness, citing Scholes and related work.
- Keep target quantum-like probability/classical substrate distinct from microscopic quantum claims.
- No equality of interference equations, spectral-gap mechanism, probability structure or energetic advantage.
- No blanket validation of source cosmology/biophysics or complete target inference theory.
historical multiscale pattern proposal to target classical-oscillator interference proposal
Target authors: Morten L. Kringelbach · Fernando E. Rosas · Ruben Laukkonen · Shamil Chandaria · Yonatan Sanz Perl · Gustavo Deco
Open this flashcard · All comparisons
Earlier SAN background-and-content availability and later distributed access
SAN’s earlier metaphor makes the surrounding network part of what allows content to become known across the brain. The later paper also requires coordinated global access; the proposed implementations differ.
Grade: bounded-functional-role-partial. Micah Blumberg's Git-recorded 2022-06-11 wording has a bounded-functional-role-partial relation to this exact 2026-10-27 Entangled Loop version. This is recorded-date correspondence, not independently established historical public availability, worldwide firstness or influence.
Micah Blumberg / SAN — 2022-06-11
Git-recorded wording fixation; 2017 date is internal note metadata, not verified public release · Separate owner-date label: 2017-07-13 (internal note header; not verified publication)
that expecting is what allows the whole brain to be aware of what the light at the end of the tunnel neurons are transmitting
SAN source · line 47
Kringelbach and coauthors — 2026-10-27
ENTANGLED-JOURNAL-ONLINE-20261027 · page 5
Distributed information must also be coordinated so that selected content can influence the rest of the system.
Target publicationL1
The source metaphor describes a maintained expected background enabling distributed awareness of transmitted content. The target describes coordinating selected content to influence the rest of the system. The shared role is broad availability of represented content.
L2
Local/transmitted content plus coordinating network -> distributed availability is preserved. The SAN tonic/phasic tunnel metaphor is not equated with the target’s named workspace, ignition or hierarchical metrics.
L3
Selected Git wording predates the October27,2026 journal edition; historical public release at the Git date remains unproved. A2017 note header is not substituted for the2022 wording date. Exact named-prior bodies and earliest-version history remain open; no access, influence or field-wide firstness claim.
Limits
- This is another SAN formulation linked to the same target occurrence as002, not a second target repetition. Source2017 header is owner metadata; the selected wording is fixed in a2022 Git record. The target cites earlier GNW literature; source-specific EM/quantum analogies and numerical proportions are not validated.
- Retain source metaphor/proposal status and2017-versus2022 date separation.
- Count002/004 as two links but one target occurrence.
- No global-awareness experimental proof or identity of organizing mechanisms.
source tonic/expectation metaphor to target global-access architecture
Target authors: Morten L. Kringelbach · Fernando E. Rosas · Ruben Laukkonen · Shamil Chandaria · Yonatan Sanz Perl · Gustavo Deco
Open this flashcard · All comparisons
SAN’s mutually causal whole-loop account and the later mutually constraining strands
SAN describes the self as a whole active learning loop with mutually causal parts. The later paper also treats its strands as mutually constraining rather than separate stages; this is a structural partial, not identity of the two complete theories.
Grade: weak-structural-component. The selected Paper104 wording, associated with provider publication date 2026-08-13, has a weak-structural-component relation to the exact 2026-10-27 journal passage. Earlier Entangled Loop preprints precede Paper104; this is not priority over the program or those earlier versions.
Paper104 (13 August2026) follows published EntangledLoop v2 (7 June) and v3 (3 July), but precedes v4 (14 October) and this journal edition (27 October). Whether the matched claims appeared in those earlier versions has not yet been compared.
Micah Blumberg / SAN — 2026-08-13
provider publication date; created timestamp separately retained
The term self refers to the whole active learning loop whose contents, dispositions, and consequences remain mutually causal.
SAN source · pages 2
Kringelbach and coauthors — 2026-10-27
ENTANGLED-JOURNAL-ONLINE-20261027 · page 2
the three operations are not independent modules
Target publicationTheir mutual constraint is what makes the architecture a loop and their vulnerability to one another is what makes it entangled
Reciprocal coupling statement from same paragraph
L1
Both locate the larger conscious/self-related account in interacting processes rather than isolated components. SAN speaks of mutually causal contents, dispositions and consequences; the target describes coupled emotion, interference and orchestration.
L2
Component operations constrain subsequent operations within a continuing whole is a structural loop correspondence. The component sets and explicit coupling functions differ, so no complete three-strand architecture identity is established.
L3
The frozen source provider date August13,2026 precedes the October27 journal edition. This does not establish priority over earlier Entangled preprints or the whole author program. Exact named-prior bodies and earliest-version history remain open; no access, influence or field-wide firstness claim.
Limits
- The target specifies a pleasure-cycle scheduler, interference-based binding and hierarchical orchestration; the selected SAN sentence does not enumerate that same triad. August13,2026 precedes the October journal edition, but earlier Entangled preprints may precede it and remain unexamined. Paper104’s synthetic results do not validate biological consciousness or phase necessity.
- Preserve the target's specific triad and source's distinct embodied-learning variables.
- State positive journal-relative chronology alongside known earlier-version dates; earlier content remains open.
- Keep Paper104's synthetic nulls, generic-learner tie and nonvalidation limits reachable and visible in any shortened claim.
- Paper104 (13 August2026) follows published EntangledLoop v2 (7 June) and v3 (3 July), but precedes v4 (14 October) and this journal edition (27 October). Whether the matched claims appeared in those earlier versions has not yet been compared.
source embodied-learning-loop proposal to target mutually constraining trefoil hypothesis
Target authors: Morten L. Kringelbach · Fernando E. Rosas · Ruben Laukkonen · Shamil Chandaria · Yonatan Sanz Perl · Gustavo Deco
Open this flashcard · All comparisons
Earlier SAN relation-specific perturbation controls and later cross-strand tests
SAN proposes disrupting and restoring a named relation with matched controls. The later paper proposes disrupting coupling while preserving local activity to test cross-component effects.
Grade: bounded-methodological-role-partial. The selected Paper104 wording, associated with provider publication date 2026-08-13, has a bounded-methodological-role-partial relation to the exact 2026-10-27 journal passage. Earlier Entangled Loop preprints precede Paper104; this is not priority over the program or those earlier versions.
Paper104 (13 August2026) follows published EntangledLoop v2 (7 June) and v3 (3 July), but precedes v4 (14 October) and this journal edition (27 October). Whether the matched claims appeared in those earlier versions has not yet been compared.
Micah Blumberg / SAN — 2026-08-13
provider publication date; created timestamp separately retained
a named edge can be disrupted and specifically rescued.
SAN source · pages 6
Additional source context—not another counted formulation
compare the declared mapping with a role-scrambled mapping, control movement and arousal, preserve total stimulation energy
Kringelbach and coauthors — 2026-10-27
ENTANGLED-JOURNAL-ONLINE-20261027 · page 9
A decisive test would perturb each process separately in connectome-constrained models, measure the ensuing changes in the other two and compare these cross-strand effects with controls that preserve local activity but disrupt the proposed coupling.
Target publicationL1
Both propose testing relationships between components through controlled disruption, rather than interpreting a local activity change alone. Source relation-specific loss/rescue and target coupling-disruption controls share a methodological role.
L2
Perturb a declared relation -> assess nonlocal/system consequence against matched controls is a partial test-design chain. Source exact-versus-remapped rescue and target three-strand propagation are distinct endpoints.
L3
The frozen source provider date August13,2026 precedes the October27 journal edition. This does not establish priority over earlier Entangled preprints or the whole author program. Exact named-prior bodies and earliest-version history remain open; no access, influence or field-wide firstness claim.
Limits
- This is a comparison of proposed test designs, not experimental confirmation or novelty of intervention science. The target’s component triad and model controls are not the same as SAN’s action-return/receiver mapping. The selected August2026 source is only shown earlier than the October journal version, not all earlier target preprints.
- Keep source matched-control supplement attached to the short edge-rescue quote.
- Label both matched passages proposed protocols, not completed successful tests.
- Do not infer target-specific triad, SAN biological validation, novelty of causal intervention or priority over June/July versions.
- Paper104 (13 August2026) follows published EntangledLoop v2 (7 June) and v3 (3 July), but precedes v4 (14 October) and this journal edition (27 October). Whether the matched claims appeared in those earlier versions has not yet been compared.
proposed source loss/rescue protocol to proposed target coupling-disruption protocol
Target authors: Morten L. Kringelbach · Fernando E. Rosas · Ruben Laukkonen · Shamil Chandaria · Yonatan Sanz Perl · Gustavo Deco
Open this flashcard · All comparisons
Earlier interacting-oscillator pattern formation and later phase-dependent combination
SAN described new patterns forming when oscillators interact. This later Entangled Loop version likewise uses interacting oscillations to combine information. Their detailed physical and mathematical accounts are not shown to be identical.
Grade: bounded-proposed-process-partial. Micah Blumberg's Git-recorded 2022-06-11 wording has a bounded-proposed-process-partial relation to this exact 2026-06-07 Entangled Loop version. This is recorded-date correspondence, not independently established historical public availability, worldwide firstness or influence.
A document-version mapping is not an additional independent study or proof of influence.
Micah Blumberg / SAN — 2022-06-11
Git-recorded fixation; historical public release not independently dated
So the 7 version of you is the orthogonal or non-linear patterns emerging from oscillations between oscillators of different scales which exert forces on each other that blend across frequency/amplitude scales. It's transmission & memory would consist of novel pattern configurations that are driven by the interplay between the other primary sensor freq / amp scales.
SAN source · line 65
Kringelbach and coauthors — 2026-06-07
ENTANGLED-OSF-V2 · page 7
When classical coupled oscillators on a network with a spectral gap settle into superposition-like states, the amplitudes of those states combine constructively and destructively in ways that do not reduce to additive probability.
Target publicationL1
SAN describes novel pattern configurations produced by interacting oscillators across sensory frequency/amplitude scales. This target version proposes constructive/destructive combination of coupled oscillatory states. The shared partial is interaction-dependent pattern formation, not merely the word oscillation.
L2
Inputs: distributed oscillatory activity. Transform: interaction among those activities. Output: a combined pattern not specified by treating the inputs independently. This is a causal fragment shared at a role level; the target adds spectral-gap and probability constraints not established by this SAN excerpt.
L3
The source wording is fixed in2022 before this exact target version dated 2026-06-07. Historical SAN public availability at the Git date remains separately unverified. The target explicitly names Scholes2024/2026, Amati and Scholes2025, Khrennikov2010, and other oscillator/probability literature. Their complete source-specific prior history is still open; the selected SAN-to-version chronology is not field-wide originality.
Limits
- No equal phase equation, formal isomorphism, spectral-gap derivation, Hilbert-space probability, thermodynamic advantage or empirical confirmation of SAN is demonstrated. The SAN context includes speculative cross-scale electromagnetic/quantum/cosmological interpretations; this mapping preserves its explicitly proposed neural interaction role without silently endorsing those physical explanations. The target distinguishes classical quantum-like probability from microscopic quantum biology.
- No identity of phase equations, spectral-gap derivation, Hilbert-space probability, thermodynamic advantage or empirical SAN validation.
- Retain the source's hypothetical cross-scale context without endorsing its wider quantum/cosmological explanations; the target explicitly uses classical oscillators.
- Target references Scholes2024/2026, Amati and Scholes2025, Khrennikov2010 and related probability work; named-prior bodies remain open.
- Preserve v2/v3p7's assertive wording as the authors' historical claim, not as independently established biology; later v4 qualifies that role.
- No automatic journal-verdict transfer; this version's original passage and neighborhood were read.
SAN theoretical proposal to target theoretical architecture/interpretation; not experimental confirmation
Target authors: Morten L. Kringelbach · Fernando E. Rosas · Ruben Laukkonen · Shamil Chandaria · Yonatan Sanz Perl · Gustavo Deco
Open this flashcard · All comparisons
Earlier SAN cross-region pattern passing and later global content availability
SAN described cooperating brain regions passing patterns between them. This later version also uses coordination to make content available across the brain. The shared operation is documented; the two detailed circuit explanations still differ.
Grade: bounded-functional-role-partial. Micah Blumberg's Git-recorded 2022-09-17 wording has a bounded-functional-role-partial relation to this exact 2026-06-07 Entangled Loop version. This is recorded-date correspondence, not independently established historical public availability, worldwide firstness or influence.
A document-version mapping is not an additional independent study or proof of influence.
Micah Blumberg / SAN — 2022-09-17
Git author/commit fixation; historical public visibility not independently proved
phase wave differential, phasic bursts, and sharp wave ripple patterns are assembled & passed across brain regions that are in sync with one another
SAN source · line 317
Kringelbach and coauthors — 2026-06-07
ENTANGLED-OSF-V2 · page 8
The mammalian brain achieves this through a two-tier hierarchy: A large reservoir of specialised regions whose activity is coordinated by a smaller core of orchestrating regions.
Target publicationL1
SAN describes assembled phasic/PWD/SWR patterns passed among synchronized cortical and midbrain regions. This target version describes coordination of specialized regions so integrated content can be broadcast. The supported partial is coordinated cross-region content availability.
L2
Distributed represented content -> coordinated communication among regions -> wider use of the content. SAN supplies a proposed oscillatory/inhibitory routing account; the target supplies an orchestrating ensemble and ignition/broadcast account. The common directed fragment survives the different explanatory granularity.
L3
The source wording is fixed in2022 before this exact target version dated 2026-06-07. Historical SAN public availability at the Git date remains separately unverified. The target names Baars1988, Dehaene/Changeux1998, Mashour2020 and directed-transfer-entropy work. Their source-specific component genealogy remains to be tested; a named older tradition does not automatically erase this bounded document-version mapping.
Limits
- This is not proof that thalamic inhibitory routing and the target rich-club/global-workspace organization have identical anatomy, dynamics, ignition thresholds or measured transfer entropy. The source is a theoretical proposal, not the target experiments or a proven decoder. Generic broadcast firstness is not claimed.
- No identity of thalamic routing, rich-club anatomy, ignition threshold, dynamics or directed-transfer-entropy measures.
- Retain Baars1988, Dehaene/Changeux1998, Mashour2020 and other GNW antecedents; no generic broadcast firstness.
- This row shares its exact target occurrence with TONIC-AVAILABILITY in the same version; keep both source mappings but count one occurrence.
- Global access is the bounded role being compared, not proof of subjective experience or the full SAN/Entangled architecture.
- No automatic journal-verdict transfer; this version's original passage and neighborhood were read.
SAN theoretical proposal to target theoretical architecture/interpretation; not experimental confirmation
Target authors: Morten L. Kringelbach · Fernando E. Rosas · Ruben Laukkonen · Shamil Chandaria · Yonatan Sanz Perl · Gustavo Deco
Open this flashcard · All comparisons
Earlier SAN background-and-content availability and later distributed access
SAN described a coordinating background that lets the brain access a transmitted pattern. This later version also gives coordination the job of making content widely available. This is another earlier SAN formulation mapped to the same target passage, not an extra repetition in that paper.
Grade: bounded-functional-role-partial. Micah Blumberg's Git-recorded 2022-06-11 wording has a bounded-functional-role-partial relation to this exact 2026-06-07 Entangled Loop version. This is recorded-date correspondence, not independently established historical public availability, worldwide firstness or influence.
A document-version mapping is not an additional independent study or proof of influence.
Micah Blumberg / SAN — 2022-06-11
Git-recorded wording fixation; 2017 date is internal note metadata, not verified public release · Separate owner-date label: 2017-07-13 (internal note header; not verified publication)
that expecting is what allows the whole brain to be aware of what the light at the end of the tunnel neurons are transmitting
SAN source · line 47
Kringelbach and coauthors — 2026-06-07
ENTANGLED-OSF-V2 · page 8
The mammalian brain achieves this through a two-tier hierarchy: A large reservoir of specialised regions whose activity is coordinated by a smaller core of orchestrating regions.
Target publicationL1
SAN describes an expected tonic background organizing transmission of phasic content so that the rest of the brain can access it. This target version coordinates specialized regions through an orchestrating ensemble to distribute integrated content. The bounded shared role is coordination enabling wider content availability.
L2
Background/coordinating organization -> selected represented content becomes available across the network. SAN uses a tonic/phasic tunnel metaphor and a proposed field account; the target uses hierarchical orchestration. The role mapping does not equate their physical carriers.
L3
The source wording is fixed in2022 before this exact target version dated 2026-06-07. Historical SAN public availability at the Git date remains separately unverified. The explicit target GNW citations and earlier broadcast literature remain visible. No universal novelty, citation omission, access or causal influence is established by this role-level match.
Limits
- The source internal2017 note header is not proof this exact wording was public in2017. The bound wording is Git-fixed in2022. The target does not thereby adopt SAN tonic/phasic physiology, percentages, electromagnetic broadcasting or quantum explanations. This second source formulation uses the same target passage as the coordination row and must not be counted as another target occurrence.
- The internal2017 note header is not a verified historical public date; use2022 Git wording with public-visibility qualification.
- Do not infer target adoption of SAN tonic/phasic physiology, numerical proportions, electromagnetic broadcasting or quantum explanations.
- Retain target GNW lineage and shared-occurrence counting with the COORDINATION row.
- Global access is the bounded role being compared, not proof of subjective experience or the full SAN/Entangled architecture.
- No automatic journal-verdict transfer; this version's original passage and neighborhood were read.
SAN theoretical proposal to target theoretical architecture/interpretation; not experimental confirmation
Target authors: Morten L. Kringelbach · Fernando E. Rosas · Ruben Laukkonen · Shamil Chandaria · Yonatan Sanz Perl · Gustavo Deco
Open this flashcard · All comparisons
Earlier interacting-oscillator pattern formation and later phase-dependent combination
SAN described new patterns forming when oscillators interact. This later Entangled Loop version likewise uses interacting oscillations to combine information. Their detailed physical and mathematical accounts are not shown to be identical.
Grade: bounded-proposed-process-partial. Micah Blumberg's Git-recorded 2022-06-11 wording has a bounded-proposed-process-partial relation to this exact 2026-07-03 Entangled Loop version. This is recorded-date correspondence, not independently established historical public availability, worldwide firstness or influence.
A document-version mapping is not an additional independent study or proof of influence.
Micah Blumberg / SAN — 2022-06-11
Git-recorded fixation; historical public release not independently dated
So the 7 version of you is the orthogonal or non-linear patterns emerging from oscillations between oscillators of different scales which exert forces on each other that blend across frequency/amplitude scales. It's transmission & memory would consist of novel pattern configurations that are driven by the interplay between the other primary sensor freq / amp scales.
SAN source · line 65
Kringelbach and coauthors — 2026-07-03
ENTANGLED-OSF-V3 · page 7
When classical coupled oscillators on a network with a spectral gap settle into superposition-like states, the amplitudes of those states combine constructively and destructively in ways that do not reduce to additive probability.
Target publicationL1
SAN describes novel pattern configurations produced by interacting oscillators across sensory frequency/amplitude scales. This target version proposes constructive/destructive combination of coupled oscillatory states. The shared partial is interaction-dependent pattern formation, not merely the word oscillation.
L2
Inputs: distributed oscillatory activity. Transform: interaction among those activities. Output: a combined pattern not specified by treating the inputs independently. This is a causal fragment shared at a role level; the target adds spectral-gap and probability constraints not established by this SAN excerpt.
L3
The source wording is fixed in2022 before this exact target version dated 2026-07-03. Historical SAN public availability at the Git date remains separately unverified. The target explicitly names Scholes2024/2026, Amati and Scholes2025, Khrennikov2010, and other oscillator/probability literature. Their complete source-specific prior history is still open; the selected SAN-to-version chronology is not field-wide originality.
Limits
- No equal phase equation, formal isomorphism, spectral-gap derivation, Hilbert-space probability, thermodynamic advantage or empirical confirmation of SAN is demonstrated. The SAN context includes speculative cross-scale electromagnetic/quantum/cosmological interpretations; this mapping preserves its explicitly proposed neural interaction role without silently endorsing those physical explanations. The target distinguishes classical quantum-like probability from microscopic quantum biology.
- No identity of phase equations, spectral-gap derivation, Hilbert-space probability, thermodynamic advantage or empirical SAN validation.
- Retain the source's hypothetical cross-scale context without endorsing its wider quantum/cosmological explanations; the target explicitly uses classical oscillators.
- Target references Scholes2024/2026, Amati and Scholes2025, Khrennikov2010 and related probability work; named-prior bodies remain open.
- Preserve v2/v3p7's assertive wording as the authors' historical claim, not as independently established biology; later v4 qualifies that role.
- No automatic journal-verdict transfer; this version's original passage and neighborhood were read.
SAN theoretical proposal to target theoretical architecture/interpretation; not experimental confirmation
Target authors: Morten L. Kringelbach · Fernando E. Rosas · Ruben Laukkonen · Shamil Chandaria · Yonatan Sanz Perl · Gustavo Deco
Open this flashcard · All comparisons
Earlier SAN cross-region pattern passing and later global content availability
SAN described cooperating brain regions passing patterns between them. This later version also uses coordination to make content available across the brain. The shared operation is documented; the two detailed circuit explanations still differ.
Grade: bounded-functional-role-partial. Micah Blumberg's Git-recorded 2022-09-17 wording has a bounded-functional-role-partial relation to this exact 2026-07-03 Entangled Loop version. This is recorded-date correspondence, not independently established historical public availability, worldwide firstness or influence.
A document-version mapping is not an additional independent study or proof of influence.
Micah Blumberg / SAN — 2022-09-17
Git author/commit fixation; historical public visibility not independently proved
phase wave differential, phasic bursts, and sharp wave ripple patterns are assembled & passed across brain regions that are in sync with one another
SAN source · line 317
Kringelbach and coauthors — 2026-07-03
ENTANGLED-OSF-V3 · page 8
The mammalian brain achieves this through a two-tier hierarchy: A large reservoir of specialised regions whose activity is coordinated by a smaller core of orchestrating regions.
Target publicationL1
SAN describes assembled phasic/PWD/SWR patterns passed among synchronized cortical and midbrain regions. This target version describes coordination of specialized regions so integrated content can be broadcast. The supported partial is coordinated cross-region content availability.
L2
Distributed represented content -> coordinated communication among regions -> wider use of the content. SAN supplies a proposed oscillatory/inhibitory routing account; the target supplies an orchestrating ensemble and ignition/broadcast account. The common directed fragment survives the different explanatory granularity.
L3
The source wording is fixed in2022 before this exact target version dated 2026-07-03. Historical SAN public availability at the Git date remains separately unverified. The target names Baars1988, Dehaene/Changeux1998, Mashour2020 and directed-transfer-entropy work. Their source-specific component genealogy remains to be tested; a named older tradition does not automatically erase this bounded document-version mapping.
Limits
- This is not proof that thalamic inhibitory routing and the target rich-club/global-workspace organization have identical anatomy, dynamics, ignition thresholds or measured transfer entropy. The source is a theoretical proposal, not the target experiments or a proven decoder. Generic broadcast firstness is not claimed.
- No identity of thalamic routing, rich-club anatomy, ignition threshold, dynamics or directed-transfer-entropy measures.
- Retain Baars1988, Dehaene/Changeux1998, Mashour2020 and other GNW antecedents; no generic broadcast firstness.
- This row shares its exact target occurrence with TONIC-AVAILABILITY in the same version; keep both source mappings but count one occurrence.
- Global access is the bounded role being compared, not proof of subjective experience or the full SAN/Entangled architecture.
- No automatic journal-verdict transfer; this version's original passage and neighborhood were read.
SAN theoretical proposal to target theoretical architecture/interpretation; not experimental confirmation
Target authors: Morten L. Kringelbach · Fernando E. Rosas · Ruben Laukkonen · Shamil Chandaria · Yonatan Sanz Perl · Gustavo Deco
Open this flashcard · All comparisons
Earlier SAN background-and-content availability and later distributed access
SAN described a coordinating background that lets the brain access a transmitted pattern. This later version also gives coordination the job of making content widely available. This is another earlier SAN formulation mapped to the same target passage, not an extra repetition in that paper.
Grade: bounded-functional-role-partial. Micah Blumberg's Git-recorded 2022-06-11 wording has a bounded-functional-role-partial relation to this exact 2026-07-03 Entangled Loop version. This is recorded-date correspondence, not independently established historical public availability, worldwide firstness or influence.
A document-version mapping is not an additional independent study or proof of influence.
Micah Blumberg / SAN — 2022-06-11
Git-recorded wording fixation; 2017 date is internal note metadata, not verified public release · Separate owner-date label: 2017-07-13 (internal note header; not verified publication)
that expecting is what allows the whole brain to be aware of what the light at the end of the tunnel neurons are transmitting
SAN source · line 47
Kringelbach and coauthors — 2026-07-03
ENTANGLED-OSF-V3 · page 8
The mammalian brain achieves this through a two-tier hierarchy: A large reservoir of specialised regions whose activity is coordinated by a smaller core of orchestrating regions.
Target publicationL1
SAN describes an expected tonic background organizing transmission of phasic content so that the rest of the brain can access it. This target version coordinates specialized regions through an orchestrating ensemble to distribute integrated content. The bounded shared role is coordination enabling wider content availability.
L2
Background/coordinating organization -> selected represented content becomes available across the network. SAN uses a tonic/phasic tunnel metaphor and a proposed field account; the target uses hierarchical orchestration. The role mapping does not equate their physical carriers.
L3
The source wording is fixed in2022 before this exact target version dated 2026-07-03. Historical SAN public availability at the Git date remains separately unverified. The explicit target GNW citations and earlier broadcast literature remain visible. No universal novelty, citation omission, access or causal influence is established by this role-level match.
Limits
- The source internal2017 note header is not proof this exact wording was public in2017. The bound wording is Git-fixed in2022. The target does not thereby adopt SAN tonic/phasic physiology, percentages, electromagnetic broadcasting or quantum explanations. This second source formulation uses the same target passage as the coordination row and must not be counted as another target occurrence.
- The internal2017 note header is not a verified historical public date; use2022 Git wording with public-visibility qualification.
- Do not infer target adoption of SAN tonic/phasic physiology, numerical proportions, electromagnetic broadcasting or quantum explanations.
- Retain target GNW lineage and shared-occurrence counting with the COORDINATION row.
- Global access is the bounded role being compared, not proof of subjective experience or the full SAN/Entangled architecture.
- No automatic journal-verdict transfer; this version's original passage and neighborhood were read.
SAN theoretical proposal to target theoretical architecture/interpretation; not experimental confirmation
Target authors: Morten L. Kringelbach · Fernando E. Rosas · Ruben Laukkonen · Shamil Chandaria · Yonatan Sanz Perl · Gustavo Deco
Open this flashcard · All comparisons
Earlier interacting-oscillator pattern formation and later phase-dependent combination
SAN described new patterns forming when oscillators interact. This later Entangled Loop version likewise uses interacting oscillations to combine information. Their detailed physical and mathematical accounts are not shown to be identical.
Grade: bounded-proposed-process-partial. Micah Blumberg's Git-recorded 2022-06-11 wording has a bounded-proposed-process-partial relation to this exact 2026-10-14 Entangled Loop version. This is recorded-date correspondence, not independently established historical public availability, worldwide firstness or influence.
A document-version mapping is not an additional independent study or proof of influence.
Micah Blumberg / SAN — 2022-06-11
Git-recorded fixation; historical public release not independently dated
So the 7 version of you is the orthogonal or non-linear patterns emerging from oscillations between oscillators of different scales which exert forces on each other that blend across frequency/amplitude scales. It's transmission & memory would consist of novel pattern configurations that are driven by the interplay between the other primary sensor freq / amp scales.
SAN source · line 65
Kringelbach and coauthors — 2026-10-14
ENTANGLED-OSF-V4 · page 7
When coupled oscillations meet, their activity can reinforce or cancel other activity according to their relative phase.
Target publicationL1
SAN describes novel pattern configurations produced by interacting oscillators across sensory frequency/amplitude scales. This target version proposes constructive/destructive combination of coupled oscillatory states. The shared partial is interaction-dependent pattern formation, not merely the word oscillation.
L2
Inputs: distributed oscillatory activity. Transform: interaction among those activities. Output: a combined pattern not specified by treating the inputs independently. This is a causal fragment shared at a role level; the target adds spectral-gap and probability constraints not established by this SAN excerpt.
L3
The source wording is fixed in2022 before this exact target version dated 2026-10-14. Historical SAN public availability at the Git date remains separately unverified. The target explicitly names Scholes2024/2026, Amati and Scholes2025, Khrennikov2010, and other oscillator/probability literature. Their complete source-specific prior history is still open; the selected SAN-to-version chronology is not field-wide originality.
Limits
- No equal phase equation, formal isomorphism, spectral-gap derivation, Hilbert-space probability, thermodynamic advantage or empirical confirmation of SAN is demonstrated. The SAN context includes speculative cross-scale electromagnetic/quantum/cosmological interpretations; this mapping preserves its explicitly proposed neural interaction role without silently endorsing those physical explanations. The target distinguishes classical quantum-like probability from microscopic quantum biology.
- No identity of phase equations, spectral-gap derivation, Hilbert-space probability, thermodynamic advantage or empirical SAN validation.
- Retain the source's hypothetical cross-scale context without endorsing its wider quantum/cosmological explanations; the target explicitly uses classical oscillators.
- Target references Scholes2024/2026, Amati and Scholes2025, Khrennikov2010 and related probability work; named-prior bodies remain open.
- Preserve v4p9's biological-inference testable-hypothesis qualification; earlier assertive wording is not silently carried forward.
- No automatic journal-verdict transfer; this version's original passage and neighborhood were read.
SAN theoretical proposal to target theoretical architecture/interpretation; not experimental confirmation
Target authors: Morten L. Kringelbach · Fernando E. Rosas · Ruben Laukkonen · Shamil Chandaria · Yonatan Sanz Perl · Gustavo Deco
Open this flashcard · All comparisons
Earlier SAN cross-region pattern passing and later global content availability
SAN described cooperating brain regions passing patterns between them. This later version also uses coordination to make content available across the brain. The shared operation is documented; the two detailed circuit explanations still differ.
Grade: bounded-functional-role-partial. Micah Blumberg's Git-recorded 2022-09-17 wording has a bounded-functional-role-partial relation to this exact 2026-10-14 Entangled Loop version. This is recorded-date correspondence, not independently established historical public availability, worldwide firstness or influence.
A document-version mapping is not an additional independent study or proof of influence.
Micah Blumberg / SAN — 2022-09-17
Git author/commit fixation; historical public visibility not independently proved
phase wave differential, phasic bursts, and sharp wave ripple patterns are assembled & passed across brain regions that are in sync with one another
SAN source · line 317
Kringelbach and coauthors — 2026-10-14
ENTANGLED-OSF-V4 · page 8
Distributed information must also be coordinated so that selected content can influence the rest of the system.
Target publicationL1
SAN describes assembled phasic/PWD/SWR patterns passed among synchronized cortical and midbrain regions. This target version describes coordination of specialized regions so integrated content can be broadcast. The supported partial is coordinated cross-region content availability.
L2
Distributed represented content -> coordinated communication among regions -> wider use of the content. SAN supplies a proposed oscillatory/inhibitory routing account; the target supplies an orchestrating ensemble and ignition/broadcast account. The common directed fragment survives the different explanatory granularity.
L3
The source wording is fixed in2022 before this exact target version dated 2026-10-14. Historical SAN public availability at the Git date remains separately unverified. The target names Baars1988, Dehaene/Changeux1998, Mashour2020 and directed-transfer-entropy work. Their source-specific component genealogy remains to be tested; a named older tradition does not automatically erase this bounded document-version mapping.
Limits
- This is not proof that thalamic inhibitory routing and the target rich-club/global-workspace organization have identical anatomy, dynamics, ignition thresholds or measured transfer entropy. The source is a theoretical proposal, not the target experiments or a proven decoder. Generic broadcast firstness is not claimed.
- No identity of thalamic routing, rich-club anatomy, ignition threshold, dynamics or directed-transfer-entropy measures.
- Retain Baars1988, Dehaene/Changeux1998, Mashour2020 and other GNW antecedents; no generic broadcast firstness.
- This row shares its exact target occurrence with TONIC-AVAILABILITY in the same version; keep both source mappings but count one occurrence.
- Global access is the bounded role being compared, not proof of subjective experience or the full SAN/Entangled architecture.
- No automatic journal-verdict transfer; this version's original passage and neighborhood were read.
SAN theoretical proposal to target theoretical architecture/interpretation; not experimental confirmation
Target authors: Morten L. Kringelbach · Fernando E. Rosas · Ruben Laukkonen · Shamil Chandaria · Yonatan Sanz Perl · Gustavo Deco
Open this flashcard · All comparisons
Earlier SAN background-and-content availability and later distributed access
SAN described a coordinating background that lets the brain access a transmitted pattern. This later version also gives coordination the job of making content widely available. This is another earlier SAN formulation mapped to the same target passage, not an extra repetition in that paper.
Grade: bounded-functional-role-partial. Micah Blumberg's Git-recorded 2022-06-11 wording has a bounded-functional-role-partial relation to this exact 2026-10-14 Entangled Loop version. This is recorded-date correspondence, not independently established historical public availability, worldwide firstness or influence.
A document-version mapping is not an additional independent study or proof of influence.
Micah Blumberg / SAN — 2022-06-11
Git-recorded wording fixation; 2017 date is internal note metadata, not verified public release · Separate owner-date label: 2017-07-13 (internal note header; not verified publication)
that expecting is what allows the whole brain to be aware of what the light at the end of the tunnel neurons are transmitting
SAN source · line 47
Kringelbach and coauthors — 2026-10-14
ENTANGLED-OSF-V4 · page 8
Distributed information must also be coordinated so that selected content can influence the rest of the system.
Target publicationL1
SAN describes an expected tonic background organizing transmission of phasic content so that the rest of the brain can access it. This target version coordinates specialized regions through an orchestrating ensemble to distribute integrated content. The bounded shared role is coordination enabling wider content availability.
L2
Background/coordinating organization -> selected represented content becomes available across the network. SAN uses a tonic/phasic tunnel metaphor and a proposed field account; the target uses hierarchical orchestration. The role mapping does not equate their physical carriers.
L3
The source wording is fixed in2022 before this exact target version dated 2026-10-14. Historical SAN public availability at the Git date remains separately unverified. The explicit target GNW citations and earlier broadcast literature remain visible. No universal novelty, citation omission, access or causal influence is established by this role-level match.
Limits
- The source internal2017 note header is not proof this exact wording was public in2017. The bound wording is Git-fixed in2022. The target does not thereby adopt SAN tonic/phasic physiology, percentages, electromagnetic broadcasting or quantum explanations. This second source formulation uses the same target passage as the coordination row and must not be counted as another target occurrence.
- The internal2017 note header is not a verified historical public date; use2022 Git wording with public-visibility qualification.
- Do not infer target adoption of SAN tonic/phasic physiology, numerical proportions, electromagnetic broadcasting or quantum explanations.
- Retain target GNW lineage and shared-occurrence counting with the COORDINATION row.
- Global access is the bounded role being compared, not proof of subjective experience or the full SAN/Entangled architecture.
- No automatic journal-verdict transfer; this version's original passage and neighborhood were read.
SAN theoretical proposal to target theoretical architecture/interpretation; not experimental confirmation
Target authors: Morten L. Kringelbach · Fernando E. Rosas · Ruben Laukkonen · Shamil Chandaria · Yonatan Sanz Perl · Gustavo Deco
Open this flashcard · All comparisons
SAN task switching through changing cooperating regions
SAN described switching tasks by changing which brain regions work together. This later Entangled Loop version also connects flexible thinking with changes in network coordination. The shared function is clear; the exact circuits and earlier literature still need separate comparison.
Grade: bounded-functional-causal-role-partial. Micah Blumberg's Git-recorded 2022-09-17 wording has a bounded-functional-causal-role-partial relation to this exact 2026-10-14 Entangled Loop version. This is recorded-date correspondence, not independently established historical public availability, worldwide firstness or influence.
A document-version mapping is not an additional independent study or proof of influence.
Micah Blumberg / SAN — 2022-09-17
Git author/commit fixation; historical public visibility not independently proved
This inhibitory interneuron process allows your brain to change the tasks that you are focused on very quickly, by realigning which cortical columns are working together, and which cells are working together, and which patterns are evoked in which sequence.
SAN source · line 60
Kringelbach and coauthors — 2026-10-14
ENTANGLED-OSF-V4 · page 9
This orchestration is itself dynamic. Work on the salience and midcingulo-insular systems has shown how behaviourally relevant information can recruit control and coordinate switching among large-scale networks, while cognitive and behavioural flexibility depends on interactions among frontoparietal, mid-cingulo-insular and frontostriatal systems (Uddin, 2015, 2021).
Target publicationL1
SAN explicitly links rapid task switching to realigning which cortical columns and cells work together. The target links dynamic orchestration and switching among large-scale networks to cognitive and behavioral flexibility. The matched operation is changing inter-regional cooperation to support changes in cognitive task, not simply mentioning networks.
L2
Task or behavioral demands -> reconfiguration of cooperating neural regions -> changed task processing. SAN proposes inhibitory and frequency-selective routing; the target names salience/midcingulo-insular and frontoparietal/frontostriatal control relationships. This is a directed functional fragment, not a demonstrated identical circuit.
L3
The selected SAN wording is Git-fixed September17,2022, before this exact target version 2026-10-14. Historical SAN public availability at that Git date is not independently established here. The target explicitly cites Uddin2015/2021 for network switching; the target does not present that component as originating in this paper. The earlier sources need their own before-state/delta review; no field-wide novelty, uncited borrowing or individual author contribution is inferred.
Limits
- The target does not specify the SAN thalamic/column-level inhibitory mechanism in this paragraph. The SAN source includes specific anatomical proposals and quotes earlier thalamic-interneuron literature in its surrounding context; this pairing does not validate all those details. Network switching predates this target publication in its cited sources. A before-state audit must separate the older component from any distinct SAN joined operation.
- Keep Uddin2015/2021 attribution in the paired quote/context.
- State source Git fixation versus unverified historical public release; no2017/2012 backdating.
- Do not equate specific anatomical, inhibitory, frequency or measured control mechanisms.
- No generic switching invention, uncited borrowing, individual contribution or empirical confirmation of SAN is inferred.
SAN theoretical routing proposal to target synthesis of explicitly cited network-switching literature
Target authors: Morten L. Kringelbach · Fernando E. Rosas · Ruben Laukkonen · Shamil Chandaria · Yonatan Sanz Perl · Gustavo Deco
Open this flashcard · All comparisons
SAN task switching through changing cooperating regions
SAN described switching tasks by changing which brain regions work together. This later Entangled Loop version also connects flexible thinking with changes in network coordination. The shared function is clear; the exact circuits and earlier literature still need separate comparison.
Grade: bounded-functional-causal-role-partial. Micah Blumberg's Git-recorded 2022-09-17 wording has a bounded-functional-causal-role-partial relation to this exact 2026-10-27 Entangled Loop version. This is recorded-date correspondence, not independently established historical public availability, worldwide firstness or influence.
A document-version mapping is not an additional independent study or proof of influence.
Micah Blumberg / SAN — 2022-09-17
Git author/commit fixation; historical public visibility not independently proved
This inhibitory interneuron process allows your brain to change the tasks that you are focused on very quickly, by realigning which cortical columns are working together, and which cells are working together, and which patterns are evoked in which sequence.
SAN source · line 60
Kringelbach and coauthors — 2026-10-27
ENTANGLED-JOURNAL-ONLINE-20261027 · page 5
This orchestration is itself dynamic. Work on the salience and midcingulo-insular systems has shown how behaviourally relevant in - formation can recruit control and coordinate switching among large- scale networks, while cognitive and behavioural flexibility depends on interactions among frontoparietal, mid-cingulo-insular and frontos - triatal systems ( Uddin, 2015, 2021 ).
Target publicationL1
SAN explicitly links rapid task switching to realigning which cortical columns and cells work together. The target links dynamic orchestration and switching among large-scale networks to cognitive and behavioral flexibility. The matched operation is changing inter-regional cooperation to support changes in cognitive task, not simply mentioning networks.
L2
Task or behavioral demands -> reconfiguration of cooperating neural regions -> changed task processing. SAN proposes inhibitory and frequency-selective routing; the target names salience/midcingulo-insular and frontoparietal/frontostriatal control relationships. This is a directed functional fragment, not a demonstrated identical circuit.
L3
The selected SAN wording is Git-fixed September17,2022, before this exact target version 2026-10-27. Historical SAN public availability at that Git date is not independently established here. The target explicitly cites Uddin2015/2021 for network switching; the target does not present that component as originating in this paper. The earlier sources need their own before-state/delta review; no field-wide novelty, uncited borrowing or individual author contribution is inferred.
Limits
- The target does not specify the SAN thalamic/column-level inhibitory mechanism in this paragraph. The SAN source includes specific anatomical proposals and quotes earlier thalamic-interneuron literature in its surrounding context; this pairing does not validate all those details. Network switching predates this target publication in its cited sources. A before-state audit must separate the older component from any distinct SAN joined operation.
- Preserve the source's full task-realignment sentence and the target's Uddin citation.
- Retain whitespace-only proof quote including extraction hyphenation; separately label any future cleaned display.
- Do not infer equal circuitry, phase mechanism, switching speed, consciousness access or firstness.
- Keep this journal instance separate from the v4 instance and from the frozen nine-row review.
SAN theoretical routing proposal to target synthesis of explicitly cited network-switching literature
Target authors: Morten L. Kringelbach · Fernando E. Rosas · Ruben Laukkonen · Shamil Chandaria · Yonatan Sanz Perl · Gustavo Deco
Open this flashcard · All comparisons
SAN learning-loop self-reference
SAN described a learning loop that learns about its own cycle. This later version also explains consciousness through a self-related loop. The resemblance is architectural; the two kinds of self-processing are not proved identical.
Grade: weak-architectural-correspondence. Micah Blumberg's Git-recorded 2022-06-10 wording has a weak-architectural-correspondence relation to this exact 2026-06-07 Entangled Loop version. This is recorded-date correspondence, not independently established historical public availability, worldwide firstness or influence.
Weak recursive-architecture correspondence only. The full action-feedback-learning versus statistical-self-evidencing operator join remains OPEN.
Micah Blumberg / SAN — 2022-06-10
Git author/commit wording fixation, not independently proved historical public release · Separate owner-date label: 2011-09-21
its a learning loop that learns itself, it refers to this association with its own loop as self
SAN source · line 37
Kringelbach and coauthors — 2026-06-07
ENTANGLED-OSF-V2 · page 2
a self-evidencing loop in which emotion, inference and hierarchy are entangled and inseparable
Target publicationL1
The source describes a learning system whose own outputs enter its sensory learning cycle and whose association with that cycle is called self. The target describes a recursive self-evidencing conscious loop. The supported candidate is a weak recursive/self-related architectural component; self-learning and active-inference self-evidencing are not treated as synonyms.
L2
Ongoing network process -> returned/self-related processing -> continued cognition is a coarse common fragment. SAN spells out memory-prediction, action and returned sensation; the selected target passage does not establish that same action-return operator. Preserve the bounded overlap without replacing either architecture with the word loop.
L3
The source exact wording is Git-recorded in2022 before this target version 2026-06-07. The internal 2011-09-21 label is retained only as owner metadata; contemporary public availability remains separately unverified. The SAN conversation explicitly recommends Hofstadter's I Am a Strange Loop; the target explicitly builds on the Beautiful Loop and active inference. These are named lineage boundaries, not evidence of direct influence between these authors.
Limits
- Self-learning, self-modeling and statistical self-evidencing differ. The target passage does not independently demonstrate learning its own action-feedback relation; this mapping is weak and architectural, not proof that the complete SAN operator appears in the target. Source attribution to Hofstadter and target Beautiful Loop/active-inference lineage must remain visible.
- Keep the grade weak architectural correspondence, not functional/operator identity.
- Keep A0051 line12 explanatory context and Hofstadter attribution reachable beside the short line37 quote.
- Do not paraphrase target self-evidencing as learning its own cycle or as demonstrated self-awareness.
- Preserve the named BeautifulLoop/active-inference lineage and actual target version date; owner2011 is not public priority.
- This is one document-version instance, not another independent study or unique invention.
historical learning/self proposal to target theoretical recursive architecture; not matched learning equations or experiments
Target authors: Morten L. Kringelbach · Fernando E. Rosas · Ruben Laukkonen · Shamil Chandaria · Yonatan Sanz Perl · Gustavo Deco
Open this flashcard · All comparisons
SAN learning-loop self-reference
SAN described a learning loop that learns about its own cycle. This later version also explains consciousness through a self-related loop. The resemblance is architectural; the two kinds of self-processing are not proved identical.
Grade: weak-architectural-correspondence. Micah Blumberg's Git-recorded 2022-06-10 wording has a weak-architectural-correspondence relation to this exact 2026-07-03 Entangled Loop version. This is recorded-date correspondence, not independently established historical public availability, worldwide firstness or influence.
Weak recursive-architecture correspondence only. The full action-feedback-learning versus statistical-self-evidencing operator join remains OPEN.
Micah Blumberg / SAN — 2022-06-10
Git author/commit wording fixation, not independently proved historical public release · Separate owner-date label: 2011-09-21
its a learning loop that learns itself, it refers to this association with its own loop as self
SAN source · line 37
Kringelbach and coauthors — 2026-07-03
ENTANGLED-OSF-V3 · page 2
a self-evidencing loop in which emotion, inference and hierarchy are entangled and inseparable
Target publicationL1
The source describes a learning system whose own outputs enter its sensory learning cycle and whose association with that cycle is called self. The target describes a recursive self-evidencing conscious loop. The supported candidate is a weak recursive/self-related architectural component; self-learning and active-inference self-evidencing are not treated as synonyms.
L2
Ongoing network process -> returned/self-related processing -> continued cognition is a coarse common fragment. SAN spells out memory-prediction, action and returned sensation; the selected target passage does not establish that same action-return operator. Preserve the bounded overlap without replacing either architecture with the word loop.
L3
The source exact wording is Git-recorded in2022 before this target version 2026-07-03. The internal 2011-09-21 label is retained only as owner metadata; contemporary public availability remains separately unverified. The SAN conversation explicitly recommends Hofstadter's I Am a Strange Loop; the target explicitly builds on the Beautiful Loop and active inference. These are named lineage boundaries, not evidence of direct influence between these authors.
Limits
- Self-learning, self-modeling and statistical self-evidencing differ. The target passage does not independently demonstrate learning its own action-feedback relation; this mapping is weak and architectural, not proof that the complete SAN operator appears in the target. Source attribution to Hofstadter and target Beautiful Loop/active-inference lineage must remain visible.
- Keep the grade weak architectural correspondence, not functional/operator identity.
- Keep A0051 line12 explanatory context and Hofstadter attribution reachable beside the short line37 quote.
- Do not paraphrase target self-evidencing as learning its own cycle or as demonstrated self-awareness.
- Preserve the named BeautifulLoop/active-inference lineage and actual target version date; owner2011 is not public priority.
- This is one document-version instance, not another independent study or unique invention.
historical learning/self proposal to target theoretical recursive architecture; not matched learning equations or experiments
Target authors: Morten L. Kringelbach · Fernando E. Rosas · Ruben Laukkonen · Shamil Chandaria · Yonatan Sanz Perl · Gustavo Deco
Open this flashcard · All comparisons
SAN learning-loop self-reference
SAN described a learning loop that learns about its own cycle. This later version also explains consciousness through a self-related loop. The resemblance is architectural; the two kinds of self-processing are not proved identical.
Grade: weak-architectural-correspondence. Micah Blumberg's Git-recorded 2022-06-10 wording has a weak-architectural-correspondence relation to this exact 2026-10-14 Entangled Loop version. This is recorded-date correspondence, not independently established historical public availability, worldwide firstness or influence.
Weak recursive-architecture correspondence only. The full action-feedback-learning versus statistical-self-evidencing operator join remains OPEN.
Micah Blumberg / SAN — 2022-06-10
Git author/commit wording fixation, not independently proved historical public release · Separate owner-date label: 2011-09-21
its a learning loop that learns itself, it refers to this association with its own loop as self
SAN source · line 37
Kringelbach and coauthors — 2026-10-14
ENTANGLED-OSF-V4 · page 15
The Beautiful Loop captures the recursive self-evidencing structure by which epistemic states are sustained within active inference, whereas the Entangled Loop asks what gives such a loop biological direction, content and priority.
Target publicationL1
The source describes a learning system whose own outputs enter its sensory learning cycle and whose association with that cycle is called self. The target describes a recursive self-evidencing conscious loop. The supported candidate is a weak recursive/self-related architectural component; self-learning and active-inference self-evidencing are not treated as synonyms.
L2
Ongoing network process -> returned/self-related processing -> continued cognition is a coarse common fragment. SAN spells out memory-prediction, action and returned sensation; the selected target passage does not establish that same action-return operator. Preserve the bounded overlap without replacing either architecture with the word loop.
L3
The source exact wording is Git-recorded in2022 before this target version 2026-10-14. The internal 2011-09-21 label is retained only as owner metadata; contemporary public availability remains separately unverified. The SAN conversation explicitly recommends Hofstadter's I Am a Strange Loop; the target explicitly builds on the Beautiful Loop and active inference. These are named lineage boundaries, not evidence of direct influence between these authors.
Limits
- Self-learning, self-modeling and statistical self-evidencing differ. The target passage does not independently demonstrate learning its own action-feedback relation; this mapping is weak and architectural, not proof that the complete SAN operator appears in the target. Source attribution to Hofstadter and target Beautiful Loop/active-inference lineage must remain visible.
- Keep the grade weak architectural correspondence, not functional/operator identity.
- Keep A0051 line12 explanatory context and Hofstadter attribution reachable beside the short line37 quote.
- Do not paraphrase target self-evidencing as learning its own cycle or as demonstrated self-awareness.
- Preserve the named BeautifulLoop/active-inference lineage and actual target version date; owner2011 is not public priority.
- This is one document-version instance, not another independent study or unique invention.
historical learning/self proposal to target theoretical recursive architecture; not matched learning equations or experiments
Target authors: Morten L. Kringelbach · Fernando E. Rosas · Ruben Laukkonen · Shamil Chandaria · Yonatan Sanz Perl · Gustavo Deco
Open this flashcard · All comparisons
SAN learning-loop self-reference
SAN described a learning loop that learns about its own cycle. This later version also explains consciousness through a self-related loop. The resemblance is architectural; the two kinds of self-processing are not proved identical.
Grade: weak-architectural-correspondence. Micah Blumberg's Git-recorded 2022-06-10 wording has a weak-architectural-correspondence relation to this exact 2026-10-27 Entangled Loop version. This is recorded-date correspondence, not independently established historical public availability, worldwide firstness or influence.
Weak recursive-architecture correspondence only. The full action-feedback-learning versus statistical-self-evidencing operator join remains OPEN.
Micah Blumberg / SAN — 2022-06-10
Git author/commit wording fixation, not independently proved historical public release · Separate owner-date label: 2011-09-21
its a learning loop that learns itself, it refers to this association with its own loop as self
SAN source · line 37
Kringelbach and coauthors — 2026-10-27
ENTANGLED-JOURNAL-ONLINE-20261027 · page 9
The Beautiful Loop captures the recursive self-evidencing structure by which epistemic states are sustained within active inference, whereas the Entangled Loop asks what gives such a loop biological direction, content and priority.
Target publicationL1
The source describes a learning system whose own outputs enter its sensory learning cycle and whose association with that cycle is called self. The target describes a recursive self-evidencing conscious loop. The supported candidate is a weak recursive/self-related architectural component; self-learning and active-inference self-evidencing are not treated as synonyms.
L2
Ongoing network process -> returned/self-related processing -> continued cognition is a coarse common fragment. SAN spells out memory-prediction, action and returned sensation; the selected target passage does not establish that same action-return operator. Preserve the bounded overlap without replacing either architecture with the word loop.
L3
The source exact wording is Git-recorded in2022 before this target version 2026-10-27. The internal 2011-09-21 label is retained only as owner metadata; contemporary public availability remains separately unverified. The SAN conversation explicitly recommends Hofstadter's I Am a Strange Loop; the target explicitly builds on the Beautiful Loop and active inference. These are named lineage boundaries, not evidence of direct influence between these authors.
Limits
- Self-learning, self-modeling and statistical self-evidencing differ. The target passage does not independently demonstrate learning its own action-feedback relation; this mapping is weak and architectural, not proof that the complete SAN operator appears in the target. Source attribution to Hofstadter and target Beautiful Loop/active-inference lineage must remain visible.
- Keep the grade weak architectural correspondence, not functional/operator identity.
- Keep A0051 line12 explanatory context and Hofstadter attribution reachable beside the short line37 quote.
- Do not paraphrase target self-evidencing as learning its own cycle or as demonstrated self-awareness.
- Preserve the named BeautifulLoop/active-inference lineage and actual target version date; owner2011 is not public priority.
- This uses the existing ELJ-SAN-PAIR-001 target occurrence: one added source link, zero new journal passage occurrences.
historical learning/self proposal to target theoretical recursive architecture; not matched learning equations or experiments
Target authors: Morten L. Kringelbach · Fernando E. Rosas · Ruben Laukkonen · Shamil Chandaria · Yonatan Sanz Perl · Gustavo Deco
Open this flashcard · All comparisons
SAN nested learning and thought-directed thought
SAN described learning loops inside other learning loops, including thought acting on thought. This later version also places higher-order processing in a meta-loop. The shared role does not establish identical brain circuitry.
Grade: bounded-higher-order-role-partial. Micah Blumberg's Git-recorded 2022-06-08 wording has a bounded-higher-order-role-partial relation to this exact 2026-06-07 Entangled Loop version. This is recorded-date correspondence, not independently established historical public availability, worldwide firstness or influence.
Higher-order-role partial; identical anatomy and epistemic-depth mechanism are not established.
Micah Blumberg / SAN — 2022-06-08
Git wording fixation; owner2012 and historical public visibility are separate · Separate owner-date label: 2012-09-18
I am an ecosystem of programs, not a single file, its a cooperative rivalry of learning loops inside learning loops.
SAN source · line 12
Additional source context—not another counted formulation
Predicting my own thoughts is actually the vast majority of what my brain does, the formulation of thought is the prediction of thought, the two are one thing.
Kringelbach and coauthors — 2026-06-07
ENTANGLED-OSF-V2 · page 14
Finally, the meta-loop afforded by functional rich-clubs in the brain evince the secondary, higher-order processing reminiscent of epistemic depth.
Target publicationL1
The source places learning loops inside other learning loops and explicitly says thought acts on thought and predicts its own thoughts. The target assigns secondary higher-order processing to a meta-loop. The proposed partial is a higher-order processing role over ongoing cognition, not equal physiological implementation.
L2
Ongoing learned/thought content -> further processing of that content within a nested hierarchy. This is the shared structural fragment. The target functional rich-club implementation and epistemic-depth model are not specified by the SAN excerpt.
L3
The source exact wording is Git-recorded in2022 before this target version 2026-06-07. The internal 2012-09-18 label is retained only as owner metadata; contemporary public availability remains separately unverified. The target explicitly inherits the Beautiful Loop and higher-order tradition. The source specific thought-prediction context is retained; this does not establish firstness over all higher-order accounts.
Limits
- Do not infer identical rich-club anatomy, epistemic-depth parameters, or demonstrated awareness from nested-loop language. The source is theoretical/philosophical and includes speculative field claims outside the retained higher-order role. The v4/journal counterparts of this particular nested-processing source remain untested, not absent.
- Keep the source thought-prediction supplement attached and add its exact locator: a0119 line14. Line13 supplies further thought-acts-on-thought context.
- Do not claim that every nested feedback system is a higher-order cognitive system; the specific source context is load-bearing.
- No identical rich-club mechanism, mathematical identity, physiological validation or generic higher-order firstness.
- v4/journal counterparts for this particular A0119 source are unreviewed, not absent.
- The old64-source capsule warning is historical; this route is already present in the unchanged67-source freeze.
historical nested-learning/thought-prediction proposal to target theoretical meta-loop/higher-order processing
Target authors: Morten L. Kringelbach · Fernando E. Rosas · Ruben Laukkonen · Shamil Chandaria · Yonatan Sanz Perl · Gustavo Deco
Open this flashcard · All comparisons
SAN nested learning and thought-directed thought
SAN described learning loops inside other learning loops, including thought acting on thought. This later version also places higher-order processing in a meta-loop. The shared role does not establish identical brain circuitry.
Grade: bounded-higher-order-role-partial. Micah Blumberg's Git-recorded 2022-06-08 wording has a bounded-higher-order-role-partial relation to this exact 2026-07-03 Entangled Loop version. This is recorded-date correspondence, not independently established historical public availability, worldwide firstness or influence.
Higher-order-role partial; identical anatomy and epistemic-depth mechanism are not established.
Micah Blumberg / SAN — 2022-06-08
Git wording fixation; owner2012 and historical public visibility are separate · Separate owner-date label: 2012-09-18
I am an ecosystem of programs, not a single file, its a cooperative rivalry of learning loops inside learning loops.
SAN source · line 12
Additional source context—not another counted formulation
Predicting my own thoughts is actually the vast majority of what my brain does, the formulation of thought is the prediction of thought, the two are one thing.
Kringelbach and coauthors — 2026-07-03
ENTANGLED-OSF-V3 · page 13
Finally, the meta-loop afforded by functional rich-clubs in the brain evince the secondary, higher-order processing reminiscent of epistemic depth.
Target publicationL1
The source places learning loops inside other learning loops and explicitly says thought acts on thought and predicts its own thoughts. The target assigns secondary higher-order processing to a meta-loop. The proposed partial is a higher-order processing role over ongoing cognition, not equal physiological implementation.
L2
Ongoing learned/thought content -> further processing of that content within a nested hierarchy. This is the shared structural fragment. The target functional rich-club implementation and epistemic-depth model are not specified by the SAN excerpt.
L3
The source exact wording is Git-recorded in2022 before this target version 2026-07-03. The internal 2012-09-18 label is retained only as owner metadata; contemporary public availability remains separately unverified. The target explicitly inherits the Beautiful Loop and higher-order tradition. The source specific thought-prediction context is retained; this does not establish firstness over all higher-order accounts.
Limits
- Do not infer identical rich-club anatomy, epistemic-depth parameters, or demonstrated awareness from nested-loop language. The source is theoretical/philosophical and includes speculative field claims outside the retained higher-order role. The v4/journal counterparts of this particular nested-processing source remain untested, not absent.
- Keep the source thought-prediction supplement attached and add its exact locator: a0119 line14. Line13 supplies further thought-acts-on-thought context.
- Do not claim that every nested feedback system is a higher-order cognitive system; the specific source context is load-bearing.
- No identical rich-club mechanism, mathematical identity, physiological validation or generic higher-order firstness.
- v4/journal counterparts for this particular A0119 source are unreviewed, not absent.
- The old64-source capsule warning is historical; this route is already present in the unchanged67-source freeze.
historical nested-learning/thought-prediction proposal to target theoretical meta-loop/higher-order processing
Target authors: Morten L. Kringelbach · Fernando E. Rosas · Ruben Laukkonen · Shamil Chandaria · Yonatan Sanz Perl · Gustavo Deco
Open this flashcard · All comparisons